New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

How to sharpen a hatchet

Posts

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#26

Re: wranglerbungle

JDK

You're too incoherent to carry this on further.

You obviously never have seen a single on of Cody's axe videos, you know nothing about his YouTube page, and are obviously unaware that he is a professional wildland firefighter who is known worldwide for his expertise about axes and forest preservation and maintenance, is native to the Oregon forests, and is a third-generation lumberjack.

Why I bother wasting my time responding to your nonsense is a mystery.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#27

Re: I have to agree with David...

david weaver

One last one, I couldn't resist. Here's the sharpening of an ax after gushing of the virtues of it.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8Pa_A4e9U_8

The preparation of the edge happens at the end. It's difficult to watch.

No clue why he didn't insert the metal wedge on the diagonal, either. I've seen little recommending otherwise.

If he'd have draw filed the edge on that ax (it certainly would've taken longer and taken more skill), it would've had a chance with the geometry. The sager double bits are beautiful axes, as are the kelly perfects and flint edges. It's a shame to see one get done like that.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#28

Re: wranglerbungle

david weaver

I posted a couple of his ax videos. John is familiar with his "work", too.

He is a volunteer (not a professional), from what he said, who moved out of the burbs after he spent himself into a mound of debt and had a mid-life crisis. Now he chastises people (like those who provide him with a free lunch as a firefighter volunteer - he is unhappy that they put ham in his lunch bag, and it's not fresh or from whole foods or whatever) on his videos and pretends to have the moral high ground.

He recommends $300 work pants to subscribers (of course, he provides a link to buy them so that he gets an affiliate cut), takes anything he can get for free - gushes about how great it is to his viewers, and sells all kinds of "reviewed" items on amazon to make a cut.

He is a professional video maker, nothing more. Youtube is full of them, and they certainly don't resemble professional anythings other than video makers.

In honor of Todd Hughes, and what he would say, "he sees his subscribers coming from a mile away".

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#29

Did he really say that.   

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I didn't want to waste my precious monthly allotment of internet on the too long video. Did he really advocate burning the wood out of an ax head?!? If so, one can dismiss anything else for this is just the most ignorant thing I could imagine doing to an ax.

I am well past breaking ax handles but I have put a good many in for others. It is trivial to drill a few holes to relieve pressure in the eye and then just punch the remaining wood out.

If he has a UTube making chips the size of the ones in this picture I will be more inclined to believe he knows what he is doing. I'm not a "homesteader" whatever that means but I do spend some time in the woods. The picture is clearing blowdown off Abrams Falls Trail, Washington County, VA.


Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#30

Re: Did he really say that.   *LINK*

JDK

Yes, he did, but only as a means to replace a handle if you're in the woods and have no alternative.

Watch the video before you make a judgment.

He also takes great care to protect the temper on the edges of the axe.


Cody Crone Burns Out an Axe Handle

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#31

Re: Did he really say that.

david weaver

He didn't just say it, he showed it. You don't need to waste your time watching it. Somehow, he gets stuck out in the bush with a superduty pickup, but he couldn't drill the wood out of the eye like anyone else would. I guess a cordless drill wouldn't fit in a knaack box.

It was filled with the other things that come with glurge (he showed himself making tea and taking a nap while the axe head was burning away in the fire).

In terms of ability to make chips, he does show himself in another video with a just-sharpen sager felling axe working on fresh softwood, and he manages to go back and forth between breaking off some chips by blunt force and watching the axe bounce instead of sinking into the cut. The end of the axe is blunt because he's beveled about 1/2 inch of it to a steep angle instead of filing or reprofiling the axe to a proper pattern.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#32

Re: Did he really say that.

david weaver

At the end of the video, you see material smoking and burning as it sits on the bit of the axe that has already been pulled out of the fire. Putting an axe in the middle of a large fire and sprinkling dirt on the bit will just make for a hot axe with hot dirt on it instead of a hot axe alone.

He's ruined it. I guess he may have at least made it soft enough that he could file a decent profile on it.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#33

Re: homesteader...

david weaver

..is mostly a buzzword on youtube for a circle of people. A select few of them actually live a minimalist life without using youtube to subsidize an otherwise not-very-credible environment.

Most of the rest of them can a little bit and do "reviews" and try to generate ad revenue.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#34

Clint Searl

Files and oil stones


Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#35

Absurd...

John in NM

Covering the edges with a little dirt will do exactly squat to protect the edges. Might help for a few minutes, but that is a big "might". Spend some time heating the body of your favorite chisel and you'll see what I mean.

I doubt anyone would bother doing this "out in the woods" - because no one would be carrying a spare handle, rasp, mallet, and wedge. In such an "emergency" the wiser course would be to head home or use an alternate if less effective tool.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#36

Re: Absurd...

JDK

As he said in the video, the method was employed only because there was no alternative. It was a theoretical situation in which he had no other means to remove the old handle fragment, and the axe was vital to his survival.

Even if the temper was destroyed, the axe would function well enough to cut wood once a replacement handle was fashioned in the wild.

The video was produced in order to demonstrate a survival technique in the wild. It wasn't produced to show the best way to remove a broken axe handle when other means were available.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#37

So.... in such a hypothetical situation...

John in NM

Where does he come up with another handle? Why would a felling axe be crucial to his survival? Now if he had done this with a hatchet head, and then demonstrated fashioning a serviceable handle from a branch, I would buy the explanation. As the video stands it is just foolish, bad, bad advice.

And though you (now) recognize that the temper would be ruined, nowhere in that video does he acknowledge it - instead he puts forth the spurious idea that the head will be fine afterwards, thanks to a quarter inch of dirt over the edges.

Your ship is sinking, I invite you to step into the nice dry lifeboat of reason :D

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#38

Re: So.... in such a hypothetical situation...

JDK

Oh please. First of all, Cody made clear the entire exercise was theoretical, under survival conditions, and not to be done when there were alternatives. Weaver implied otherwise, and thus Weaver is a liar. You can certainly criticize Cody's hypothetical situation, how unrealistic it might be, etc., etc., but you cannot say that Cody advised the technique be employed under any different conditions than he postulated.

Cody pretended he was in the wilderness with a broken axe handle and no means to properly replace it. The purpose of the video was to show how to burn out the fragment with fire if your survival is at stake. It was also done tongue-in-cheek, as any person can see, given the nap scenes, making the tea, etc.

As far as the temper of the axe goes, no one knows how much its temper was degraded. Even so, in a survival situation, it isn't at all difficult to imagine fashioning a handle that will allow the axe to become functional, even if the temper was completely destroyed. An axe without a temper can still bring down a tree, split logs into firewood, and keep a man alive who otherwise would not survive under extreme conditions.

Weaver is a crank who has some kind of infantile resentment against people like Cody who have achieved success. We've all seen it before. Why you defend him is your business, but you are wasting your time. Cody Crone is an honorable man with hundreds of thousands of people to whom he educates and entertains on self-sufficiency, respect for the natural world, craftsmanship, and self-respect. The fact that Weaver hates him says a lot about Weaver, but not much about Cody Crone.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#39

Great Video

Gary B.

That video takes me back. I got my bachelors in Wood Engineering at SUNY ESF, an environmental science school. We had a woodsman's team.

It was amazing watching those guys in competition. They could fell a telephone pole faster with their competition ax then I probably could with a chainsaw. Seriously it seemed like 6 or 8 whacks and it was over.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#40

Now ya done it!  *LINK*

John in NM

I had to watch that dopey video all over again! :D

1. Nowhere did he say anything about survival conditions and all that drama you that you imagined.

His exact words were "So what would you do if you were out in the middle of nowhere, you broke your axe handle, you need to make a new one" (in the first 25 seconds). I do not call that "your survival at stake" as you put it.

2. He refers repeatedly to how this won't damage the temper, the most egregious example is at 6:35 when he says "Don't worry about taking the temper out of that axe head the cutting edges are buried in the dirt and those ashes are a real good insulator". Given the hour+ he gives it in the fire, there is plenty of time for the head to equilibrate and ruin the temper.

3. You can see how hot the edges are when he takes it out - smoking pine needles under the edges themselves at 8:30 and the complete, burned outline when he flips it over at 8:50. Based on the NIST study in the link below, I will conclude that the edges reached a temperature in excess of 300 C (572 F), quite enough to ruin the temper.

4. At 9:40 he says "That is a quick and easy way to do it" -- no mention of last resort, survival tactics - that is in your imagination.

5. At 10:10 he again says "Don't have to worry about taking the hardness out of it" and mistakes the difference in discoloration around the eye vs the edges as evidence of the effectiveness of his efforts to protect the edges. In fact what it demonstrates is that the area of the eye was in a more oxidizing area of the fire, and while such an area might be hotter, it says nothing about the temperature at the edges.

Based on all this, I sure wouldn't call David a liar or a crank if I were you.... Honestly, you're kinda coming off as a jerk in my view of it. I do not mean to insult you, just pointing out that you may not be presenting a face that you'd want the world to see. I've sure done that now and then myself.


Ignition temperature study

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#41

Re: So.... in such a hypothetical situation...

david weaver

I think to some extent, I have achieved success. I'm a professional during the day and at least thus far, my wife hasn't had to go back to work.

Sure, I'm a crank. I have an aversion for salespeople and gimmicks. Wranglerbumble's channel is a gimmick channel. It's like a collection of old wive's tales, figuratively, or a good illustration that a con only needs to be one step more experienced or clever than the mark.

When he sharpens saws (someone came to my channel and said I should look for his video to sharpen saws, I find that worth a chuckle). Then he bought crosscut saws, and, oh God, now we have to see him do that. There is a five part video from the Forest Service showing a true professional doing the same thing. Someone splits wood in a tire? Oh boy, wranglerdoodle is going to show it, too. And then we get the "reviews" to sell people things, or the display of comped products.

It's fake, it has no credibility, and neither does he. Who knows what he did in the lifetime where he describes overspending and getting into pile of debt. A plastic life, I guess. His comment section is filled with marks, looking for an escape, I guess. They are watching videos with a lampshade on their head, so to speak, making sure to avoid thinking - "does it make sense when a guy using an axe he supposedly just sharpened has it bouncing off of a direct hit on softwood?". No, it doesn't.

There's a whole world of authentic out there. the guy from the USFS sharpening the axe, he's authentic. He doesn't want to sell you $300 work pants or the notion that to lead a minimalist lifestyle, you have to have custom made boots, scads of tools that you don't really need, expensive appliances in your "cabin", a bulldozer, all of that stuff. No glurge. Same with the men swinging axes in the ax man video, or the guys making axes in the oakland maine video on youtube. By my measure of success, they are far beyond wranglerbimble....they have credibility and they are authentic.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#42

Re: found a picture

david weaver

Nicely done on the bevels with the shoulder filed off.

What you describe is probably a lot like what's shown in the ax man videos. They show a guy limbing, discuss what he's doing, but in a subtle way a craftsman would pickup (it's not paint by number is what I mean by that).

And then they show one of the workmen clipping off saplings with single upstroking swipes (to avoid dirt and rock).

It is not by any means effortless looking work, but they do it very naturally and competently.

I like often to see how people work rather than have them tell me about how they do it. I learn a lot more by seeing what they do.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#43

Re: at any rate

david weaver

That's enough of that overall for me, I spot the guy a mile away. Lots of people do, lots don't apparently - i don't need to argue about it after this point, I'm on the hunt for more videos of guys like the ones in the USFS stuff.

Since we've been talking about this guy today, and I've dug up a few of his videos, now I have more than ever in my video recommendations. Here's a screen capture from today's video. Who thinks this is a good idea? Half the tree is left in the hinge and he says in the video he's trying to use this jack with a leaner that's also got the wind blowing in the direction of the lean. He really should stick to reviewing things he can buy on amazon. If he finds success with this, is he going to convince other people that it's a good idea?


If I hadn't seen a bunch of his stuff before, I would've thought the video was an intentional spoof. But he's serious, and that's dangerous.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#44

Re: Did he really say that.

TomD

I know it sounds crazy Bill... But "our farm" was sold during the depression when they figured city work would pay better, and it did so they were able to buy it back for a vacation place later. During that interval the place was owned by a lumber guy who used the house as a camp and logged off everything else. We have these old axe heads, never really thought much about it, but one year we needed some gravel off the beech and while digging came across lots more. I guess others had found them earlier too. They were exactly where you would expect to find a campfire. I think they burned the handles off, but that doesn't make a lot of sense either, because it should kill the temper, and anyway, so many were lost.

A few year ago I arrived at the farm in the middle of the night, and faced a blowdown like the one in your post, and no chainsaw ready to use. Pulled out a japanese switch blade 300mm saw, and had my way cleared in minutes, it was super fast, not as dangerous. Where a CS might have jammed the pieces jusy slid past the saw, and I was able to keep using it, no damage.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#45

Re: homesteader...

Jim Matthews

It's a problem generated by automated searches, where artificial 'rankings' promote vdeos based on the number of previous views, not content.

Look to the Wranglerstar 'fan' interviews to see the earnest, hopeful faces of the Beta males who have never been cold, hungry and alone in the woods.

It's a harmless form of hero worship, and from their inevitable disallsion real knowledge will arise.

Sturgeon's Revelation applies.

Keep up the good fight, DW.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#46

The jack and the wedge- professional fellers work

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


The man does not lack imagination. A dozen timber cutters could not have come up with that idea, nor 50 farmers that use this kind of jack. Apparently the simple, and effective, wedge everyone else uses in this situation didn't make good video.

For those unfamiliar with what I call a "farm jack" it levers itself up in increments the distance between the holes in the post, in a jack and hold sequence. The jack is not continuously variable; it must engage one of the holes to hold position. If one tried to use this kind of jack for the task at hand one would either force the tree over upon pulling the handle down or not be able to raise the jaw to put any significant pressure on the notch. This is not the force application required for this operation. What is needed is the continuously variable incremental force applied by a wedge illustrated in the picture taken in a timber cutting competition. The tree trunk now about to topple forward from the action of the wedge was originally leaning 10 degree back.

BTW, he will never break the hinge on this tree. It is too thick. Were he using a wedge he would alternatively drive in the wedge and thin the hinge until the wedge overcame the resistance of the wood in the hinge and started to lean away from the wedge. Can't do that with the stepwise action of a farm jack.

But, it's time to move on to other wood working. Anybody actually doing stuff soon learns truth.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#47

Re: homesteader...

david weaver

Love the beta male assessment, Jim.

I was having a conversation with George once about the difference between what's legitimate and what catches the other 90% of people who don't know what legitimate is.

His assessment was that a lot of the media that's out there (even before it really went to crap with youtube personalities) that's supposedly informative isn't meant at all to inform or instruct anyone to do something, but instead to make them feel like they could if they actually got up off of their chair (which the 90% who make that market won't do). Or in summary, it's more profitable to act dopey and avoid getting into too much detail, but instead focus on making content that will make people who will not do anything feel like at least they could if they tried.

There is nothing difficult about making planes after some repetition, but I have gotten a lot of comments on videos that I've convinced people that it's too hard to make planes!! Purely because I actually showed the whole process.

I'll bet if I'd have made one 10 minute video that didn't give anyone enough information to actually make a plane, but put music to it, showed myself drinking tea in the middle or some such thing, and edited it, I'd have more views than the 19-video process of making a plane combined. I'll choose less views and substance, even if I don't have the video talent to make it entertaining substance. I wish more people with a similar level of experience to mine in making planes would just turn the phone and and share what they are an expert at.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#48

Re: Great Video

david weaver

I know the guys you're talking about, they're still in Austrlia in droves!

I sold all of George Wilson's frictionites on ebay (vintage razor hones) and all of them went to those guys swinging 7 pound race axes in australia.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#49

Re: The jack and the wedge- professional fellers w

david weaver

In terms of what the guy's thinking, I'd imagine it's more along the lines of each video is worth a couple of hundred dollars worth of ad revenue, and he's going to post it no matter what. In the world of non-doers, there's also fascination with "let me show you a mistake I made so that you don't have to". People who don't do much love to use terms like "teachable moments".

My relatives were farmers first, before they sold livestock off and then were just row croppers, and eventually out or in the case of the other, full time woodsman after that while the crops grew.

I never saw a farm jack in the woods, and there was plenty of directional felling going on. It was chainsaw and wedges, but since farm equipment was available, my grandfather located a used cable a little over 100 feet long and used that. Eventually on large trees, he went just to cutting the hinge most of the way and then pulling them over if they were questionable.

Ditto on the hinge, I've never seen anything like it.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#50

Re: Your relatives and my dad's side

david weaver

My father's side of the family would've burned the handles out, too, if someone had showed them how to do it. There would be baling wire and sheet steel in those ashes, too, from repairs to handles. They were so poor that they couldn't afford to know better (they didn't get off of the land much to get exposed to much other what came over the radio).

One of the reasons that some of us (me especially) know a lot more now is because of what we're exposed to on the internet. It makes it harder to be ignorant unless ignorance is willful.

If the internet didn't exist, nobody would've exposed me to hand tools, and I'd have probably been a candidate to burn out axe handles, too.