New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

How to sharpen a hatchet

Posts

How to sharpen a hatchet

#1

How to sharpen a hatchet

Joe in a Cleveland suburb

I know I could simply Google this question, but I am more interested in what you guys have to offer/say. I already tried the search here (+ax +sharpen) and didn't get much.

I have a small Boy Scout hatchet that I think was my dads. So, I guess maybe it's from the 40's. It's nothing fancy, but I'd like to use it now and then. The cutting edge was in pretty bad shape (lots of nicks) so I tried to clean it up a little on my slow speed grinder and white wheel of some sort. I probably made it worse...

Anyway, how do you guys like to sharpen hatchets/axes?

Files? Stones? Sandpaper? Angles?

Thanks in advance!

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#2

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

david weaver

From experience - very heavy bulk work (reprofiling an old axe that has a blunt end - with a slower speed belt sander and a coarse belt, but slowly so that the result is desirable and relatively symmetrical. Check often. It may take 15 minutes to do this.

If the damage is less, draw filing across the axe with a *good* mill bastard file is preferable. Finishing the edge with file strokes straight in from the edge as the finish is better than draw filing. If there is a wire edge remaining, or if you want to do it for aesthetics, you can use an axe stone or any other india or fine carborundum stone to do that (with oil), and then go further than that if it pleases you.

For practical use, you can get quite a fine hatchet or axe edge with a file, especially considering axes and hatches usually work with easy-cutting green wood.

If you have a large amount of damage or you don't like the shape of the axe edge, you can file the edge itself at a 90 degree angle until you get the profile you like.

Beware doing heavy drawfiling on an axe that has even a half decent edge - making a bolster on a handled file and wearing gloves is a good idea. No matter how much you pay attention to what you're doing, eventually you'll cut a finger if you don't do those things (but if you are doing only one hatchet, you may be able to pay attention long enough).

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#3

A good display of filing - the axe man

david weaver

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc0mdjknbPM

At 14 minutes in this video, an operator sticks a double bit axe in a stump and files it just as I was describing.

This is an excellent excellent video in general. It shows the mechanics of physical work done by men who know how to do it (the swings look easy, well paced and accurate), as opposed to the wranglerstars and other video sellers of now who pose as experts without being very competent.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#4

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

John in NM

Can't help with angles, since I've never had to do more than touch up the edge on the axes I have. Should be easy enough to find though. I would try googling hatchet bevel angles - look under images and you should find lots of graphics. You could also find lots of info on Bladeforums ax subforum I bet. (and as David says, avoid wranglerstar youtube videos).

I most often use an angle grinder with about an 80 grit flap wheel for this. Puts on a nice convex bevel and is relatively fine. I also have some scotchbrite pads that go in a Foredom tool or die grinder. Those work great if you want a polished edge.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#5

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I use an ax a lot. I use a hatchet, which I consider hazardous, seldom. But sharpening would be the same.

If it can be filed, clamp the handle in a vise and file it till the nicks are gone. If its worse than filing can recover, then an angle grinder will get it started. Stay away from the edge with the grinder. Just use it to thin some the blade back from the edge, then file.

For most, filing will be sufficient. If you like to limb firewood with well placed one armed swings of a double bitted ax then some refining of the filed edge with a coarse/ fine India stone lubed with oil is what I do.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#6

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet *LINK*

JDK

Here is Wranglerstar's take on axe and hatchet sharpening. It is excellent.


Wranglerstar Sharpens an Axe

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#7

Re: USFS Instruction Also

david weaver

This is probably the video that I referred to to learn to sharpen an ax, i can't remember.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=22tBYD-HMtA

But it is excellent. Sharpening occurs starting around minute 18. As I stressed earlier, despite transferred suburbanites like wranglerstar garnering a lot of views, I have no idea why anyone would use them as a reliable source when there are professional sources all over youtube like the one above.

They are straightforward and have no incentive to put out trash unlike the glom of ad revenue generating video bloggers.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#8

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

TomD

If you have a metal cutting belt sander (1x42 or 36 is fine with a good belt, or the brown belts if sharp), and I don't know how people live without 2, then it is a few seconds job to sharpen one, if the edge has big chips it needs to be ground back square and even, and then sharpened, which depending on the situation can take more or less time.

For most people the problem they have with sharpening is not enough time on task before moving on to another grit. Axes are probably the largest thing, many people sharpen. Taken together, a bail out to electrons make more sense than usual. In that Wranglerstars (?) video you can plainly see the belt grinder marks, or maybe CNC grinder marks on the tool.

All the grinders I am familiar with are similar in that they have some slack area in the belt that one can exploit where one end is fairly stiff and the other can be induced to droop. Normally where it leaves the platen and then takes up on a wheel. Supper fancy are system that use a rubber belt mounted like a tank track that can be adjusted for droop, over which the abrasive belt runs. But any way, you find a place where you can introduce the edge section of the axe to the grit side and let the belt slide perfectly over the axe's convexity until the required reduction is achieved.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#9

Re: USFS Instruction Also

TomD

Yeah, that is a good presentation if you happen to have a government shop in your yard. Modern times, cheap chinese imports, different ways of doing things. You could probably find a 1x42 for the cost of one specialty axe sharpening tool. Pretty much all of my axing starts from the back of the pick-up, or the house, not in the woods, though I would pay to get a crack at a really large redwood with my 090. I can run the 1x42 off the inverter in my truck.

At least 50% of woodworkers are like a squirrel on crack who hears of Fentanyl when it comes to their sober consideration of acquiring new tools. No point in pretending commercial are a burden, the whole forum is a giant commercial. American life is basically a commercial.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#10

Re: USFS Instruction Also

david weaver

In that film, the guy uses a vise, a mill file and a round stone.

Filing an axe is far more sensible than using a belt grinder, and just as fast. There's no specialty tool needed, except a vise maybe for a single bitted axe, but that can be filed just clamping the axe to a flat surface.

My favorite stone to stone an axe is the $1 stone sold here at dollar tree. It's aggressive aluminum oxide, and literally a dollar.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#11

Re: A good display of filing - the axe man

Brian Holcombe

That voice over would be a fantastic lead into a heavy metal song.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#12

Re: USFS Instruction Also

TomD

Files make sense in their place, but will not get the same edge as you get from grinding; you will not be able to make as perfect a convex shape simultaneous with sharpening the edge; not able to handle the range of hardnesses. It simply isn't true that it will be as fast, that is a joke, unless external factors like the walk back to a shop are taken into account, which is real if you are in the field. There are grinders that would swallow that axe whole.

The USFS dates back to 1876, a vibrant point in factory production, and a time when the people were living the hand wrought frontier life, but using the products of machines to do it.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#13

Re: USFS Instruction Also

david weaver

touching up with a file is part of the process during the day. Sort of like working with carving tools, you never let what you're working on get really dull. You can get any geometry you want really easily with a file, too.

If we're talking about maintaining an axe in use, a file is more ideal. If we're talking about reprofiling a new one, I suppose the fastest way you could do that is an industrial silicon carbide wheel or a 7000 feet a minute belt grinder.

I have the baldor 1x42 - it may work marginally faster than a good file in the hands of someone who knows how to draw file, but then you have to file to finish before stoning, anyway, unless you want too run through a progression of grits (definitely something I wouldn't want to do).

For what joe is doing (a hatchet), a good file would be fine.

In terms of capability difference, there should be none, probably near nobody of modern use has an axe working as well as the kelly perfect that the fellow is using in this video. Half of the bit has been filed - I see few modern axes that have been given as much attention.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fc0mdjknbPM

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#14

Nice video. Thank you.


Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#15

Re: USFS Instruction Also

John in NM

I never would have thought to look for anything useful in Dollar Tree! :D (around here the dollar stores are such a mess I have trouble finding anything that isn't refrigerated - and that is only because the fridge space is so limited!)

A medium size belt grinder is going to be far faster than a file, but I don't agree with Tom that there is necessarily any difference in the edge produced by either. When removing metal I can achieve the same result by different means, just need to modify technique a bit.

I do think that the more aggressive methods are best left to those with a light touch - its easy to overheat and edge with an angle grinder, or to come up with one of the oddest edge profiles I've ever seen like that wranglerstar guy did in one of his videos - put an appalling curve on a narrow double bit. Probably seemed nifty at the time, but I have to wonder that he left the video up after trying to use that thing! Perhaps he never tried to use it :D

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#16

found a picture

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


I recalled that I took a picture while sharpening a while ago. There is a lot to be said for securely fixing the ax somehow for the sharpening process.

This ax was bought by my father in about 1954 and used for trail maintenance to the fire tower he manned on Kempshall Mt, near Long Lake, NY. I inherited it and have used it for trail maintenance and for limbing trees for firewood. For trail work I prefer it to a saw most times for it works well for small stems up to trees 6-8" diameter (bigger than that and I haul in a chain saw). People that work with me are typically amazed at what a sharp ax will do.

The profile seems to be about right and has not been materially changed since purchase.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#17

Re: wranglerbungle

david weaver

...in an effort to make videos to do two things:

* sell ads and get ad revenue

* get viewers to do things like buy $300 work pants through amazon affiliate links, as if that would have been something a homesteader would've done...

...races to make videos like, showing people how to throw an axe head in an open fire and burn the handle out of the eye (and, of course, obliterate the temper in the bits).

I understand that's the kind of glurge that draws views on youtube.

Reminds me of what George Wilson told me. Beware of the guy who learns something, does it wants and writes a book every time. Youtube glurgers have taken it a step further, deciding to make a video first and then grasping at anything after that.

Agree on the file (in terms of edge fineness). With good geometry, I doubt anyone gains anything even by stoning - filing toward the edge leaves little wire edge on a decent hard axe.

If you've got a dollar tree, you can nail down one of their gray and blue al-ox stones for a buck. It sheds particles when it's new for a bit, which is pretty annoying if it's on your bench, but that kind of stuff is no problem at all for rub stone work. If you drop it, you won't cry, either.

https://www.dollartree.com/Tool-Bench-Hardware-Sharpening-Stones-6-in-/p346429/index.pro

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#18

glurge...

John in NM

That is the perfect word! :D Never heard it before (I'm old and out of the loop on stuff like this :D )

Did he really advocate tossing an ax head in the fire? Wow. Talk about stoopid.... I've heard of that one from old books that were the equivalent of youtube back in the day - quick published, shallow, unprofessional works that imitated "homespun" wisdom to make a quick buck. The bucks fly quicker on youtube though.

Youtube does have some good stuff - like the films you linked, or an Allan Batty video I recently watched - but its just so hard to sort through all the wranglerscrable style noise on there. I often come away with the impression that its a colossal waste of time in the balance.

I've got to head into town today or tomorrow, I'll keep an eye out for a Dollar Tree, I think there's one in Albuquerque. Everything in the rural towns here is Family Dollar.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#20

Wow... the mind boggles...

John in NM

Yeah, put dirt on the edges... that'll help.

Given that steel has pretty good thermal conductivity, I would say the temper was gone in about 10 minutes - about the time he got his tea water over the fire.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#21

Re: wranglerbungle

JDK

My guess is that Cody knows more about maintaining axes than you do or ever will, and I'd advise anyone reading your infantile posts generalizing about YouTube videos to take them with a grain of salt.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#22

Re: wranglerbungle

david weaver

If he knows more about them than I do, you'd think it would show up in video somewhere - not whining about inexpensive modern axes or running the temper out of a perfectly good axe. He definitely knows more about making mediocre comments about modern mediocre tools so that he can link them for people to buy (and make a commission). If I ever bothered to make a video about axes, something that doesn't need to be made in the first place, you'd not find me trying to convince people to buy modern axes when there are unlimited numbers of old kelly, plumb, mann, etc, axes around that need nothing more than file work and a new handle.

I got to watch a woodsman as a kid, my grandfather. I don't see anything credible about wranglerbumble except that you can use a lot of pt barnum type slogans when you read his commenters. His lack of credibility has him on the downswing on youtube, anyway. Years ago, I subscribed to his early channel until I figured out it was glurge. Unfortunately, youtube thinks that's a good reason to recommend his videos to me now if I read anything woodsman related, so I do get to see the titles of his current videos and his pitiful attempt to copy Casey Neistat's video naming format.

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#23

Re: wranglerbungle *LINK*

JDK

As usual, you don't know what you're talking about.

WranglerStar's YouTube channel has 427,000+ subscribers and 143+ million page views. His numbers increase weekly.

Not only that, but you are completely ignorant of his dozens of videos detailing the care, maintenance and restoration of the finest axes made today, as well as the finest vintage axes available.

You're embarrassing yourself.


WranglerStart YouTube Statistics

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#24

Re: wranglerbungle

david weaver

I've seen all of the current axes, too. Most of them are not the equal in the middle of the woods to a kelly perfect. Either too soft, never finish profiled, or too hard to file on location. The swedish axes that many people often rave about are missing the third dimension of the profile that's prevalent on every kelly, plumb, etc. axe - the bulge from top to bottom that causes the axe to be released in a progressive stroke pattern. Boutique tools that don't make sense in the context of work...well, they don't make sense.

Your "expert" (back when I subscribed) was advocating sending a multi-hundred dollar work of art back to eastern europe simply because the handle had shrunk. In fact, he spent so much time complaining about something that should have been a routine fix for anyone who has even basic competency with axes that you'd have to wonder what he was doing in the first place. That work of art axe was also made too hard to file - very artistic, but not very practical in the woods.

These days, practical in the woods appears to be "will it hold an edge long enough to make a test cut for a youtube review video".

I didn't even get into the ridiculous video series of him a manufacturer about the quality of a $15 or $20 axe. I'd like to see him try to make a functional axe for that.

He's got you snowed, though. Just don't put any of your axe heads in a fire, just because he did.

(most importantly of all of this, I wouldn't send another respectable forum member like Joe to someone like w-bungle for advice when there are several professional tutorials available. The same would go for any log saw sharpening videos, or pretty much anything else - though I'm sure the homesteader of the minute could probably advise on what's good for making videos and how to set up a web page to get your video subscribers to buy things so that you can make money off of selling them the things you "Review".

the forum members here deserve better than that)

Re: How to sharpen a hatchet

#25

I have to agree with David...

John in NM

Ok, you're a fan. We get that. But the only guy making a fool of himself is the one posting the videos we ridicule.

The too curved profile grind I referred to is around 6:45 min in his vid on restoring an axe. That grind might work fine for him, I'll admit I've never tried one with that huge curve to it. I'm pretty sure that a bit of use will teach one not to do that again - guessing it's either a stickomatic or hard to control.

Then there is tossing an axe head in the fire to burn out the old handle for an hour or more. Dumb - no other word for that. Temper is ruined around 600 F, your average campfire runs up to 1,500 F.

Then there was my personal favorite (yes I wasted some time this morning perusing the man's offerings) - failing to fell a small tree by cutting way too little and then breaking a high lift jack attempting to push it over.

I don't fault the man for doing dumb stuff - I've certainly done my share too. I'm faulting him for either never learning to do better, or leaving the videos of dumb stuff up once he has learned better. Watching another where he fells a large tree with a saw makes me think that he did learn from his errors, but the other vid is still up - if it were me I would be pretty embarrassed by that and take it down.

Honestly its a bit like watching the Red Green show and then realizing he's serious! At least trying to knock a tree over with a jack was like that.... ok, the Costco one too :D I'm sure real homesteaders would have LOVED running in to town to go to Costco!