Re: wranglerbungle
david weaver
I've seen all of the current axes, too. Most of them are not the equal in the middle of the woods to a kelly perfect. Either too soft, never finish profiled, or too hard to file on location. The swedish axes that many people often rave about are missing the third dimension of the profile that's prevalent on every kelly, plumb, etc. axe - the bulge from top to bottom that causes the axe to be released in a progressive stroke pattern. Boutique tools that don't make sense in the context of work...well, they don't make sense.
Your "expert" (back when I subscribed) was advocating sending a multi-hundred dollar work of art back to eastern europe simply because the handle had shrunk. In fact, he spent so much time complaining about something that should have been a routine fix for anyone who has even basic competency with axes that you'd have to wonder what he was doing in the first place. That work of art axe was also made too hard to file - very artistic, but not very practical in the woods.
These days, practical in the woods appears to be "will it hold an edge long enough to make a test cut for a youtube review video".
I didn't even get into the ridiculous video series of him a manufacturer about the quality of a $15 or $20 axe. I'd like to see him try to make a functional axe for that.
He's got you snowed, though. Just don't put any of your axe heads in a fire, just because he did.
(most importantly of all of this, I wouldn't send another respectable forum member like Joe to someone like w-bungle for advice when there are several professional tutorials available. The same would go for any log saw sharpening videos, or pretty much anything else - though I'm sure the homesteader of the minute could probably advise on what's good for making videos and how to set up a web page to get your video subscribers to buy things so that you can make money off of selling them the things you "Review".
the forum members here deserve better than that)