New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

Posts

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#26

Re: Different approaches

steve voigt

So Brian wrote:

"I will take and read [the] cut and then adjust the chip breaker with a hammer, blindly, until the chip reacts exactly as I want. I want the chip to go up and over the blade without curling. I want the shaving to look like it's coming up and out of a ticker tape machine."

I also put a tiny microbevel on the edge of my chip breaker, usually about 60 degrees, though frankly I do not measure this I simply go by feel and feedback from the end result. If I can't get that type of shaving without setting my chip breaker to the furthest extreme then I will raise the angle further."

I found this a very interesting comment. It reminds me of watching the KK video, where they demonstrate that blunting the CB angle (80 vs 50 in the vid) allows you to get the same effect at a further distance. In the vid, I think an 80° CB angle set back .008" produced about the same effect as a 50° CB angle set back .004". Or something like that; I don't remember exactly.

Anyway, it's interesting to me because I usually take the opposite approach: I try to use the lowest CB angle that still gives me the necessary tearout-beating effect; for me that angle is around 45°. I find the lower angle is easier to push through. But, I'm using a Western plane and setting the CB with the irons out; I can see how with a Japanese plane, given the greater complexity of setting the CB distance, a blunter angle would make things easier to set up. Just goes to show that the "right" answer depends on tools and working methods. Thanks for the interesting perspective, Brian.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#28

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

TomD

That was a bit disappointing, I came across the picture of the maebiki and figured I would get some good shots of how the log is set up. Then I got to that teeter totter photo a few shots below... That is the biggest hassle I have with mine that getting a piece well enough secured I can work on it has not been easy. I have some blow down oaks that might work out since they are cantied.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#29

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

TomD

OK, this may be worth a read. I will get right on it:

http://lumberjocks.com/fissionchips/blog/36555


Planing is actually pretty easy, relative to any practical level of even extreme results for finishes. Now that criss cross sawing looks like a real contest.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#30

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

Tom, you may want to contact Yann and ask his insights on setup for sawing. I'm sure there is a lot to it.

Hah, yes that does look like quite a contest.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#31

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

TomD

As with every time one returns with a search there is a lot more out there now. Basic strategy seems to be the log is a giant teeter totter, and once you saw down one side, in leaves, you cause it to flip to the other side. Though how some of these massive logs are elevated in the first place is another mater. I wonder if for some of these heroic logs all they did was walk over after the struts were removed causing the log to majestically reverse working orientation. That would be something to see.

There is also horizontal placement, and I was wrong, they are not racing in that pic they are sawing the same kerf in turns so that one plunges as the other withdraws. Still a pairs sawing contest is interesting.

And then some logs are sawn in the vertical, like stumps.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#32

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

Tom,

I'm fairly certain they're sawing two different kerfs. I see a few boards marked out, I think the fellow on the right is sawing the top board and the one on the left is sawing the next one down.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#33

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi

wilbur

There used to be a YouTube video showing how a two man team with maebikis sawed a log, but that video went away.

Here’s a picture made with bad Photoshop technique showing how this works.


In this picture, we’re looking down on top of the “log”, there’s a sawyer on either side of the log, each with his own maebiki. They are cutting from the top of the picture, working their way down.

What happens is that one sawyer pushes and pulls his saw back and forth. Then the other one does the same on his side. The straight line edge at the front of the saw allows the toothline of the other saw to go past.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#34

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi

Brian Holcombe

Ah-ha, Thanks Wilbur, I see it now.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#35

Interesting

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

While not personally smitten by engaging in Oriental woodworking I find it interesting to observe. The tools and techniques employed are so different. It is hard to imagine a greater difference than what you illustrate compared to a colonial pit saw. There has been trade between the regions for centuries so one side was certainly not ignorant of the techniques of the other. Are these differences a result of the culture or the materials available to work the wood or the wood itself?

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#36

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi

david weaver

This may not be the same video, but it's one I've seen before. I also saw one that looked like it was taken around WWII with two thin guys sawing quickly, but not with a lot of force (they probably weren't that well fed back then, and they certainly didn't fit the description that odate provided of the men who ate quarts and quarts of rice to fuel their profession of cutting lumber from logs).

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=c4o_zi7l8DY

Regardless, even if this later one looks like it's just for fun, it's the same process.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#37

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi

Brian Holcombe

Wow, that is a good sized slab to be sawing by hand!

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#38

Re: Interesting

Brian Holcombe

It's interesting, I really dont consider it that drastically different from western woodworking in say....the 18th century.

So Yamashita explained the logic behind a pull stroke being so that slender people could use their largest muscles (thighs and lats) to when planing (and sawing too it would seem). I find it a heck of alot easier to pull very wide shavings (without camber) with a kanna than anything else. You see really incredibly strong looking carpenters in Japan now (judging by Facebook), but I bet at the time they were much thinner and probably not as well fed as people are currently.

FWIW the term Oriental is a bit dated, for instance my wife is Chinese and if I use that word I better be referring to a rug.....or plan to sleep in my study for a day or three.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#39

Re: Interesting

TomD

I can see it both ways, I was initially taken by how different Japanese woodworking is, as a working type, and I guess it is about as different as it gets. But aside from the pulling on saws, which we do in pits in the West; and pulling on planes that we also do, but admittedly only about as often as they push on them; most of the rest of it is pretty similar. They have their own style which is significantly different, though there is a belief in Germany that the similarities are greater than the differences, and I have one book on that subject, that compare architectural similarities. There are lots of differences within the west also.

Questions have an interesting status in Buddhist tradition, so one thing you don't get is a whole log of rationales as to why certain things are done the way they are done, so knowing why they do things a certain way is harder to piece together. Not that there is all that much of a backstory for us either. On forums there are a million ways of doing things, and we have only a few books from our past often written by writers not workers. So if someone says they did it this way, or they did it this way because, other than the most obvious instances, I don't really trust it.

If you consider that in Japan they sit directly on the floor, if you need to mortise in that position, nothing needs to change. But if you need to saw, or plane, without something supporting your back, you can clasp something to your chest more easily than you can push it away. That may have something to do with the pulling, but most of their greater labours are not done seated.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#40

Re: Interesting

TomD

"FWIW the term Oriental is a bit dated, for instance my wife is Chinese and if I use that word I better be referring to a rug.....or plan to sleep in my study for a day or three."

And in any case there are some quite different approaches throughout the region.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#41

Re: Interesting

TomD

"So Yamashita explained the logic behind a pull stroke being so that slender people could use their largest muscles (thighs and lats) to when planing (and sawing too it would seem). I find it a heck of alot easier to pull very wide shavings (without camber) with a kanna than anything else."

I don't buy that, you can use your legs when pushing, indeed, I am not a physiotherapist, but that pretty much describes what we are doing just to stand up. If the samurai where restricted to moving in the direction their eyes were not pointing in order to use their biggest muscles, their reputation for retreat would have been formidable.

I think there are two flaws in the logic in this answer. One is that every thing that exists in a culture, (even when the opposite of what exists in another culture) is there for a functional reason. That way of working the mind is pretty much what we got when the world turned towards science in the enlightenment. It would have happened a lot earlier if that had been the focus. I grew up with a lot of people born in the 1890s, some of whom went through the startlingly pragmatic experience of surviving WWI, one of whom fought in WWII also, and they did not behave like that. Jobs they had included water department engineer, pharmacist, accountant, and salesman of industrial scales. Not exactly non-technical people. SO when all this got rolling a thousand years ago, or whatever, I don't think they thought as we do about technical subjects. Buddism itself seems to discourage the asking of questions and encourages doing.

The other issue is the one I bring up a lot but always passes without comment, and that is the idea that pros do not care if something is hard. They rise to that level. Dilettantes like ourselves, we care. I don't doubt some carpenters didn't eat that well. Maybe the society was set up to ensure the working classes never ate that well, so they would never relent, which takes the issue in a circular direction (no matter how efficient they were, they would never get ahead). One motivation that many crafts have, I have been in on this myself, is ensuring that difficult means are the norm as that retains the status of the craft. I was involved in upgrading educational standards for the securities industry at the precise moment they were moving to packaged products where all they were was relationship managers. The focus was the competitor, not the client's needs.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#42

Re: Interesting

Brian Holcombe

Ookanna would seem to make that point when you consider they're 6"~ wide and you can actually plane with them, where trying to push a 6" wide plane would likely require a man built like a giant.