Re: Different approaches
steve voigt
So Brian wrote:
"I will take and read [the] cut and then adjust the chip breaker with a hammer, blindly, until the chip reacts exactly as I want. I want the chip to go up and over the blade without curling. I want the shaving to look like it's coming up and out of a ticker tape machine." I also put a tiny microbevel on the edge of my chip breaker, usually about 60 degrees, though frankly I do not measure this I simply go by feel and feedback from the end result. If I can't get that type of shaving without setting my chip breaker to the furthest extreme then I will raise the angle further."
I found this a very interesting comment. It reminds me of watching the KK video, where they demonstrate that blunting the CB angle (80 vs 50 in the vid) allows you to get the same effect at a further distance. In the vid, I think an 80° CB angle set back .008" produced about the same effect as a 50° CB angle set back .004". Or something like that; I don't remember exactly.
Anyway, it's interesting to me because I usually take the opposite approach: I try to use the lowest CB angle that still gives me the necessary tearout-beating effect; for me that angle is around 45°. I find the lower angle is easier to push through. But, I'm using a Western plane and setting the CB with the irons out; I can see how with a Japanese plane, given the greater complexity of setting the CB distance, a blunter angle would make things easier to set up. Just goes to show that the "right" answer depends on tools and working methods. Thanks for the interesting perspective, Brian.





