New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

Posts

3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#1

3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

Brian Holcombe

Good morning! In addition to competing in the event, I was able to cover the event with a blog post. I know many were curious about the event since I posted a bit on my preparations and so I thought you guys might like to check it out.

https://brianholcombewoodworker.com/2016/09/09/mokuchis-3rd-annual-nyc-kez-2016/

Cheers

Brian

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#2

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

That was great Brian. Very impressive performances. It did not appear that there was much in it.

Many thanks for the detailed report!

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#3

Thank you!


Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#4

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Brian and all,

Thank you very much! The photos and commentary bring the event to life. Nice to see our old friend Wilbur Pan (Dr. Pan) also!

You mentioned prominently the amount of tuning and instruction that went on pretty much continuously through the event. Are there any particular or unexpected tips or hints that you can pass on to us? Something that really gives the flavor of what is meant by 'tuning'.

Thanks again,

Wiley

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#5

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

My pleasure! Absolutely, the dai had traveled from distances or air conditioned shops and so when they arrived to meet with the current conditions they moved. Everyone had spent some time tuning them. Flattening the sole then working the hollow.

Sharpness at this level requires constant attention, I could literally take 4-5 passes and need to knock the plane apart and re-sharpen. When I resharpened it was important to completely remove the wear. Even a small glimmer of wear meant I wouldnt able to take a very thin shaving.

One plane I shrink wrapped for the commute and that helped keep it perfectly flat.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#6

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

JDK

Thanks for the report, Brian. Your passion for Japanese tools is infectious. I also enjoy your deep-dive into sharpening technique, a subject which, if one were to count the number of threads in this forum in which it's discussed, never loses its appeal.

What did Oliver ask in the beginning of Oliver Twist? "More please."

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#7

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

Thanks David! Glad to hear that you are enjoying! It is also really interesting that sharpening threads remain so popular.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#8

Question for Brian

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Brian,

Do you know of anyone currently offering saw sharpening for Japanese saws? I haven't been in touch with Mark Grable for better than 10 years, so don't know if he still does it. Could probably ship to So, but he is always very busy, and it would likely be a nuisance for him.

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#9

Re: Question for Brian

Brian Holcombe

Wiley,

I know Mark Grable is still at it. I spoke to a fellow at the event that has recently been in contact with Mark, including a visit to his shop.

This is his information listed on Daiku Dojo, and as far as I know it is still accurate.

Mark Grable

607 Highland Rd.

Springfield VT 05156

802-885-3376

noko.metate.ya '@' gmail.com

So can probably point you to a source in Japan, if not then Stan Covington could certainly point you to a metate in Japan.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#10

Thank you very much!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

I really Mark's work.

Wiley

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#11

Re: Thank you very much!

Brian Holcombe

Anytime!

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#12

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

wilbur

A little bird told me my ears were burning. Or I’m mixing my metaphors again. ;)

I have a bit of a different takeaway from this year’s NYC KEZ. Because of work craziness and keeping the kids busy, I’ve not been able to do very much woodworking since the late spring. The only project I was able to work on this summer was a bowl that I turned, which clearly did not require my Japanese tools. The Japanese plane I brought for the NYC KEZ was one that had been sitting on my bench since I gave a talk on Japanese tools back in June, and I had not touched it since.

As far as tune up went, I gave it a decent, but not extensive sharpening, and spent a rudimentary amount of time adjusting the dai. Even with that, I was able to get a shaving that was 16 microns thick. That’s not kezurou-kai competition winning form at all. Other folks there were getting shavings in the single digit range.

Then I realized that with a minimal amount of effort, I was getting a Japanese plane that had sat untouched for 2-1/2 months to take a shaving that was less than 1/1000 of an inch, which is certainly good enough for most woodworking projects.

For a long time now, I’ve been working with the thesis that Japanese tools are actually a lot easier to work with than what conventional wisdom says, based on the idea that there’s no reason to believe that Japanese woodworkers would have less interest in efficiency than western woodworkers. My experience at the NYC KEZ this year leads me to believe that I’m onto something.

Granted, I would have needed to do more work with my plane to get a better result with the plane shavings (after more work, I got an 8 micron shaving once). And it does take a lot of work and attention to detail to set up a Japanese plane to take a thin shaving that can win a kezurou-kai planing contest. But to take this amount of work and say that Japanese planes always require this amount of effort is like looking at a Holtey plane and assuming that a Stanley plane can’t do useful woodworking because it’s not finished to the same degree.


img

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#13

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

TomD

Very nice report.

I know for my race planes I prefer a pretty short dai, some might say I use a spokeshave. :)

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#14

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom!

That is a slick idea, How short is your race plane?

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#15

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Brian Holcombe

I tend to agree, once Japanese tools are up and running I find them fairly easy to maintain and continue to use.

I went to Japanese tools and 18th century type western tools because they're very well worked out and easy to maintain.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#16

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Wilbur and all,

i love the surface created by a Japanese plane. However, I have a problem that led me away from them. And it's this....On favorable grain, they're great. But on high-figure wood, like with reversing grain or curl, I need the close chipbreaker to avoid tearout, because they're low-angle planes. But I've never developed a really reliable way to make this close subblade setting.

Maybe you folks can help. I was told (have never had person-to-person hands-on instruction) to look down the throat of the plane from above, as I tapped the subblade lower, and watch the shadow move down the blade. Then stop just before a complete ecliipse occurs. This led to enough frustration that I stopped using kanna, except for specialty things like trimming dovetail pins, where the low angle and long registration is very helpful.

So. How do you aficionados do the subblade setting? More specifically, how do you see the setting effectively enough that you can repeat it with any precision?

Wiley

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#17

Received from Brian Holcombe this morning

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Brian contacted me offline due to some technical mishap. His reply is so good, I asked his permission to post for benefit of all:

"Wiley,

I’m getting an error message on wood central when I attempt to reply to that thread this morning. So I thought I’d just email you instead.

I do use that method, but with one amendment. I like to have a good light shining off of the blade so that I can see, very clearly, when the chip breaker is getting close.

So I normally hold my plane up with the bottom facing an overhead light and tap with a light brass hammer until the chip breaker is close and I can see just a tiny sliver of light....to almost nothing.

After that is complete I'm close. I will take and read cut and then adjust the chip breaker with a hammer, blindly, until the chip reacts exactly as I want. I want the chip to go up and over the blade without curling. I want the shaving to look like it's coming up and out of a ticker tape machine.

A couple notes;

I also put a tiny microbevel on the edge of my chip breaker, usually about 60 degrees, though frankly I do not measure this I simply go by feel and feedback from the end result. If I can't get that type of shaving without setting my chip breaker to the furthest extreme then I will raise the angle further.

I want ZERO gap between the chip breaker and blade, so check to see that both parts mate exactly and when the chip breaker is ontop of the blade in a dry assembly (outside of the plane) then it cannot click clack if you tap one corner with your finger. If it does, then it needs adjusting.

The chip breaker should move with light hammer taps, I use a tiny brass hammer and it moves the chip breaker with ease. Anything more than that and it may cause inaccurate settings.

Cheers

Brian

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#18

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

wilbur

Hi Wiley,

I was getting that error this morning as well. Here’s another try.

I’ve heard of the “look at just the right angle and set the subblade” method, and I can’t seem to get the right combination of angle and light to do this efficiently. What I do instead is to get a scrap piece of wood that’s the same as the workpiece (like a cutoff) and tap the subblade as close as I can, and take a test shaving. If I’m still getting tearout, I’ll tap it closer and try again, until I get the right setting.

This sounds a lot more fussy than it is. If you can adjust the main blade of a wooden plane, western or Japanese, to take a thin shaving, you can do this as well. Can I reliably get the subblade to exactly 1/96” from the edge? No. But I can get the subblade to a position that prevents tearout.

One other method is to have a Japanese plane with a 45º bed angle. You can order Japanese planes with higher bed angles than the typical ~40º that they usually come with. I’ve got one plane that has a 45º bed angle, and it works great on figured wood, and I don’t have to rely as much on the subblade.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#19

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Broo

Howard Pollack

I cut a dai out of purpleheart (of all things!) that sets the blade at 50 degrees. It works pretty darn well.

-Howard

P.S. the purpleheart seems very stable and needs very little adjustment.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#20

Re: Breaking news

TomD

Which is how we know, as I have often said, that the chipbreaker effect was widely known in western circles, since this type of tune can be seen in US pictures going back to the 70s I would guess.

The Japanese breaker is quite visible when set so you can make minor scribe marks, or sharpie marks to control it's position. Not something I do, but if the freeness of it is bothersome, it can be done.

I would be interested to know what value the breaker has in this use. When shavings get really fine, they pile up on themselves, and look like a pile of crumbs until you draw out the diaphanous result. If you have a shaving valet, well fine. But my way of looking at it is the shaving gets so fine that the breaker can't do all that much in this kind of case where uniform softwoods are being handled. My results which are entirely more casually attempted, for one thing only King stones at the time I was trying this stuff, have always been without a breaker in classic Japanese style.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#21

Re: Race Plane Measurements

TomD

6.375 x 3.375 x 1.5. Infeed is 3.75. It could be a little longer.

The idea is the opposite of a jointer. Reduce the spacing between the contact points and eliminate the rear contact points so that plane follows the surface and produces the optimal shaving planform. It won't hurt or help thickness of shaving much. Might have a theoretical speed advantage.

It gets complicated though under different rule sets about how you get to the initial surface to be followed. If you use only one plane is there no advantage, or a disadvantage. If you could level with one plane and cut with the race plane, I think that is a clear advantage, but it is complex.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#22

Re: Breaking news

Brian Holcombe

Tom, I find them useful outside of perfect grain, so it helps to reduce time spent cutting pieces to perfectly align the grain. I do that whenever possible but on certain pieces that is just not feasible.

Also, it's especially helpful when working larger shavings.

I removed it for the competition.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#23

Re: Race Plane Measurements

Brian Holcombe

Wow, that is incredibly short! I would think it a significant advantage when going over a board previously worked by a jointer.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#24

Re: Race Plane Measurements

TomD

It is a 70 mm blade, sorta like one of those beam planes on a regular length dai in shape, but the blade is way up there.

Re: 3rd Annual Kezurou-kai Mini at Mokuchi in Brooklyn

#25

Re: Breaking news

TomD

OK, got it, I thought they were being used for the comp, for some reason. Yeah sure, it is a tool and might be useful at any time, but I don't normally use them on thin shavings since I don't think they get a grip on the shaving.