New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

I need a drawer holding suggestion

Posts

I need a drawer holding suggestion

#1

I need a drawer holding suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

After drawer assembly the drawer size usually needs to be tidied up. It is easy to fix the drawer for doing the sides as seen in Picture 1. I keep on had scraps of plywood and other cutoffs to fit common drawer sizes I make.




Occasionally the height of the drawer must be planed to get a good fit. So far I have not discovered a good arrangement for securing a drawer for planing its top edge. My drawers are made with thin sides. Capturing the drawer between a vise dog and bench dog has been done but I always worry that the vise force and planing force might break something.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#2

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

Brian Holcombe

I use a tall wooden planing stop.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#3

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A picture would be worth a 1000 words.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#4

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

Brian Holcombe

It's multipurpose for me;


Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#5

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

Beautiful drawer!!

I like to use a plane I can hold in one hand. Either a woodie smoother, or Konrad Sauer's small No. 4. That frees up the other hand to hold the drawer against my body, as I work around the top edge with the other hand.

The reason for doing it this way is that I like to 'turn the corners', so that I'm not planing cross grain at the corners. And it's flexible--easy to swing the drawer around to get at another side/corner, with the grain in the direction I want. And you can plane one stroke and test, one more stroke and retest, without unfixturing and refixturing. No mechanical operation as you move between plane stroke and test for fit.

Wiley

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#6

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

My strategy is a combination of Wylie and Brian.

For a stop, I use the bench, either dogs situated in its centre for drawers with a coplanar bottom, or the front edge of the bench if the drawer front has a lower lip.

I will hold the drawer in place with one hand, and plane with the other.

The planes I turn to are one-handed. The choice is a common angle block plane (LN #103), small high angle smoother (HNT Gordon mini smoother, 60 degree bed, same size as a small block plane), or a shopmade BU smoother (#3 size, 60 degrees).

As Wiley pointed out, this offers the freedom to plane continuously, and follow the grain.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#7

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

roger lance

I'm assuming with the drawer bottom off, you tried to secure the drawer a side at a time in the Record and didn't like that approach.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#8

How do you do that?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If you can hand hold a drawer and plane the top edge of a 13/16" hardwood front you have discovered some way of lessening planing force than I. The reason I am asking is that the planing force I experience to scoot across the front edge and around the corner is great enough that I am worried about holding the drawer between a vise dog and bench dog. I am pushing with both hands to get across the front face.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#10

Yes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

What Derek says. Small plane or woodie used one-handed is key, thin slices, and sharp goes without saying. Pull the plane toward you.

Sometimes my own waist line is the stop, or sometimes a long stick clamped in the end vise is the stop, and pull against that. Either way, the off hand is needed to balance the forces, as well as keep the drawer from moving sideways when you grain-follow around the corner.

You could pull that No. 5 with one hand, but I like a smaller plane because that avoids having the larger plane tilt on the edge and ding the oncoming side you're planing into (DAMHIKT :( ).

I always like your drawers, Bill. Very sharp looking. Whatever you're doing is OK!

Wiley

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#11

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

david weaver

One stop, one hand and a stanley four in the other hand. If I had a 2, it would be ideal for this work, but I don't have a 2.

Cap iron set, of course, since making turns around the wood is easier if the plane stays in the cut.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#12

Re: Yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I'm missing something or you all are taking greatly more dainty shavings than I in drawer fitting. And then there is the one handed planing, and backward by Wiley's suggestion. I'm still at the struggling to plane with both hands and training wheels.

I think I can expand on Brain's suggestion and create a substantial stop to butt the drawer against. The problem with turning the corners is that the drawer has to be supported in two directions. Maybe I can invent an "L" shaped stop.

I have spent the past two days prepping the two chests of drawers for finishing. Applied the stain this afternoon and was pleased with the result. Will shoot to coats tomorrow and post a PIC if the result looks good.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#13

Workholding

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Bill, given what you have just written - about simultaneously holding the drawer in two directions - you may wish to try out this batten.

It is nothing more than a 90 degree bite out of a short board. This is set against a corner and then clamped to the bench with a hold down. It is quick to apply and remove, and then reset.



Here is a video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WNrof3cd1cA

Give it a go. It may be the answer you are searching for.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#14

Re: Yes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

'I'm missing something or you all are taking greatly more dainty shavings than I in drawer fitting. "

I went and checked. For the hand-stabilized approach, mine are 1-thou to 1.5-thou, on a drawer front thickness of 15/16" or so. My basic drawer is cockbeaded, and it is going to be very close to a fit as made, because I don't want to have to take much off the cockbeads, which are often going to be 3/32" as made.

If it's a heavier planing job than said above, I fixture it. Whatever is practical in the situation. For small drawers (not like the one you showed), sometimes one can just put the whole thing in the vise.....many different situations.

I like your idea of an L-shaped fence.

Wiley

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#15

How are you doing cockbead

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I fit the drawer, planing the top as necessary and it isn't always necessary. At this point the drawer is final fit. Then I cut off the drawer for the cockbead and install it. There is no further adjusting required.

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#16

Re: How are you doing cockbead

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

I've done it as you describe. For example, in this little table:

http://gallery.woodcentral.com/wp-content/gallery/wiley-horne/img_20150211_0011.jpg

But I didn't like how the work went. Because I had to plane the 3/32" off top and bottom (these are full width cockbeads, like you use), which seemed like a lot using the only rebate plane I had, which was a large shoulder plane, and worked the whole time not to ding the drawer side, though I still managed to when I was almost done. And had to fix/hide that ding.

So now I prefer to make the top and bottom 'pre-rebated'--I make the rebates as part of the drawer-making, and then add the cockbead strips at the end, leaving the cockbead just slightly proud and planing back to a fit (using 1-thou cuts as described above).

Here's an example:

http://gallery.woodcentral.com/wp-content/gallery/wiley-horne/img_0985.jpg

http://gallery.woodcentral.com/wp-content/themes/twentytwelve/image-popup.php?imgId=463

In this case, the drawer fronts are thick veneer (3/16"). There is a 3/4" satinwood structural drawer front, which I through-dovetailed to make the box. Then glued on the 3/16" ribbon-stripe satinwood front, with a plain but quartered surround (which is lighter); then cut in the ebony stringing; then laid on the ribbon-stripe cockbeads. The cockbeads were laid into rebates built into the work in the making. Of course, this took careful test-fitting, and very careful gluing, to make sure it all came out right.

Wiley

Re: I need a drawer holding suggestion

#17

Re: How are you doing cockbead

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Now I understand.

It goes easier with a table saw :)