New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Posts

Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#1

Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Anyone familiar with a source for riven walnut and oak in this area? I'd like to source riven stock for furniture parts (table legs, framing members, drawer sides, ect).

It can be green, I dont mind drying it, but getting tired or processing 8/4 kiln dried into something respectable.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#2

Clint Searl

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Clint Searl

Try Willard Bros. They may be able to help.

I have an old black walnut (24+ diameter) that I had cut back to around 20 feet tall with the intent to have it milled some day. You can have it if you fell it and take it away. Of course, cleanup is a prerequisite.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#3

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Clint, that is incredibly generous of you, but I'm not capable of harvesting the lumber, looking for a source already down to a size that I can handle with my tools.

I'm a regular at Willard, they do not have any that I'm aware of.

This may be a pipe dream, but I thought it worth asking.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#4

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What problem are you trying to solve? There may be another solution.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#5

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Paying for VG 8/4 walnut, then throwing away the sap (or setting it aside and never using it) and still there is some slight movement in the grain I would prefer not to have.

Most table legs are 28.5" for me, that should be a length capable of being riven.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#6

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You might try searching in Woodfinder, linky below, and maybe contacting likely prospects. Riving is an inefficient way to process wood, so there aren't likely many retailers doing it; but you're in a part of the country where there might be enough people willing to pay the premium that someone's willing to do the work.


http://www.woodfinder.com/

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#7

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

TomD

Best means is to cut it yourself. Baring that, then you go looking for firewood dealers, or tree surgeons.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#8

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for the suggestions, I'll keep an eye out for those types.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#9

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

steve voigt

Brian, find a sawmill that will sell you a log. They will almost certainly crosscut it into dimensions you can deal with. The tools needed to split and rive can be had very inexpensively, and doing it yourself is very rewarding. One place to check out is Alderfer lumber in PA.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#10

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Steve! I was hoping to avoid all that but like many things I expect this is one area where doing it yourself is probably the best method, the big holdup with that being that I have very little capability of dealing with logs.

I'm only able to deal with long slabs because I can slide them in through a basement window.

Log halves or quarters would possibly fit.

I was thinking of building a storage rack above the garage door for the splits to dry.

I expect that buying veneer grade logs is significantly less expensive than kiln dried 8/4 VG stock.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#11

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

steve voigt

Brian,

I suggested splitting a log because you referred to riven stock, but if VG or QS is what you're after, another option would be to have a place like Alderfer saw the log to your specs. They've done this for a friend of mine. If you are buying a whole log, they'll probably cut it however you want. Or you can try other mills. The key is to find a small place, or at least a place with small scale sawing equipment. The bigger and more production-oriented mills will be less flexible.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#12

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Ahh I see, my preference is for riven stock, but short of that having more control over specifics might be what is needed.

I also seem to be unique in my preference for walnut without figure :D So finding a mill who will saw up a veneer grade log to my spec might do the trick.

This is only for parts and legs, I dont mind figure in some panels and table tops.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#13

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Some figured wood can really enhance a piece of furniture, but there are many times when straight grained wood is much to be desired. An example is in carving. Figured wood not only adds to the labor in carving, it detracts from the carving itself. The carving should be the focus, not the figure. It can be like a fellow wearing a paisley tie with a striped shirt and plaid jacket, too many competing sensations. We often like straight grain for mouldings as well, likewise both for ease of execution and lack of distraction. A figured panel often looks good with a plain frame. Make the panel look special.

For making walnut table legs, we have several options for getting the grain straight. First choose a plank that is straight. Second, make saw cuts in the plank parallel to the grain.Then a small amount of adjustment can be made while truing and planing to thickness if it is done by hand. And last choose which sides to taper based on any small remaining grain run out.

It is nice to have a truck for hauling and a property with a yard to work lumber or to make stacks, and a large shed or barn for storage. However even with all of these I don't think riving walnut is particularly productive.


Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#14

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

TomD

Riving is just a very efficient means to an end, when it is that. Sawing is just as good or better. With the modern builders using veneer grade logs you can see how precious riving has become. There is no need for a grade of wood in the arrow range, several orders of magnitude better than aircraft grade, in a chair.

In a lot of the best cabinetmaking the straight grained wood is the majority of the project. There are only so many places where you can put a piece of chaotic burl. Of course you can veneer the whole project, if you have some kind of cruel lookout for future generations. Really selecting the straight grain wood is in a lot of ways more difficult that the fancy stuff. depends how serious you are about either. But it is very easy to wreak the look of a project with straight grain that either isn't all that nice, or actually kills the lines of the project. Meanwhile, something like a bookmatched panel is going to look good in a lot of ways, and normally draws interest. It has to be part of the overall look also, which is basically the same issue you get with straight grained wood, no more or less.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#15

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for your comments on this Warren, much appreciated! It sounds like my current process (the process you describe) is possibly better than I give it credit for.

I almost never have trouble finding white oak, cherry or ash that meet my requirements, but my area's love of figured walnut poses difficulty for me so I've resorted to buying basically straight as I can find when I can find it.

This is a typical result;


Oddly enough I have a specific sawyer near me who likes to keep stock of mildly figured, flat and wide 4/4 walnut, but not really much in that way in 8/4 or larger.

I share your opinion of keeping the figured wood to specific uses, which makes both the making and the result better.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#16

Riven won't solve one of those problems

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Say I am a logger and have a walnut log for sale. I can sell it to a mill for XX$$ and they will saw it, it will be dried and sold to the place where you buy lumber. Sapwood is not considered a defect in walnut grading (more on that later) so there will be sapwood in what you buy that you don't use.

Or, I can sell the log to you for XX$$, you will discard the sapwood when you rive it. In both cases you paid for the sapwood you didn't use. You will save the expense of the middle man and drying(which is nearly costless to a mill burning wood waste). However, the log will have #2and #3 common lumber that you won't have a use for, whereas the mill that sawed the log will have a market for.

Anyone considering going into the Riven log business faces the same economics. Bottom line is that doing it yourself or finding a business that does(highly unlikely) is not going to save the cost of the sap waste. One way or another you will pay for it.

Personally, I don't have any sap waste. It gets used for internal framing- drawer bottoms and anything else that doesn't show.

A better solution to your problem is to buy a large clean log from a mill and have them saw it to your specifications. You could even arrange for them to keep the lower grades of lumber as partial payment. One large log will keep you in wood for many years.

I use this solution. I saw the logs to yield largely rift cut planks, at 2 1/2" thick. I can then make legs from this size or resaw to yield book matched panels.


For example, shown is a frame for a figured panel made from this rift cut lumber.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#17

Riven may not solve another problem

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Legs are best made from rift grain planks. If the grain is more or less 45 degrees to the faces each face will be rift and therefore similar. Quartered lumber will yield two faces that are flat grain which will clash mightily. The best place to get leg material is off the edges of wide flat sawed planks or rift cut a log to begin with.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#18

An finally some walnut economics

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Currently the walnut market is strong. Logs smaller than 12" are being sawed and 14" logs are being bought for veneer. This is a difficult market to find wide sap-free lumber. In contrast when the market crashed a few years ago I saw packs of walnut with boards 12 to 18" wide and little sap because the veneer market had collapsed. Something called a veneer log is not going to ensure the kind of lumber you are looking for.

I have bought walnut for some 4 decades now for personal use or resale. My advice for those that like working it is to buy as much as you can store and afford when you find some that is the quality you like.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#19

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Tom, I can certainly appreciate the difficulty of finding straight grained walnut. It's not so bad in cabinet projects as I really only need it for certain parts, but it is difficult in tables where I'm attempting a decent yield out of the stock I purchase.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#20

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA *LINK*

Joanne in Point Pleasant, PA

Check with John Kirlew at Bucks County Hardwoods in Doylestown, PA (Bucks Cty.)


http:/http://www.buckscountyhardwoods.com/

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#21

Re: An finally some walnut economics

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for your comments Bill.

The typical sawing program here seems to be flat, so that leaves me digging through to find the rift sawn material for legs.

Here is a set for the next project;


It does seem that these theoretically could be improved upon, but as you, Warren and Steve suggested it's likely found through selection of sawn material rather than hunting down riven material.

I've been stocking up on material as time goes by but finding myself increasingly more particular the more I build. The only trouble with buying and keeping material is that, if I'm fond of the material, I find it incredibly hard to saw up for a project, hah.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#22

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

Brian Holcombe

Thank you Joanne!

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#23

Re: An finally some walnut economics

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Unless it is a boutique mill custom sawing, hardwood lumber is always flat sawn for the market. Logs are sawn to yield the most value which is obtained by sawing the clearest lumber from the outside of the log and concentrating the defects into what is left. With the clearest lumber on the outside of the log it follows that trees with prominent sapwood will have this sapwood in the clearest lumber. It will be a substantial portion of this lumber if the log is small.

I have an article in the Articles Section on commercially sawing logs.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#24

Re: An finally some walnut economics

Brian Holcombe

Thanks for pointing out your articles Bill they are a good read.

From the sound of it, I will just continue collecting walnut as I come across good material, quarter and rift sawn that I desire.

I suppose, realistically, I'm not likely to get completely straight and clear grain from walnut for a 30-40" run, looking at a pair of chairs that I own, likely made from some of the best walnut available to anyone, and they have grain movement I would otherwise want to avoid in many of their parts that are majority straight grain.

Re: Riven walnut/oak NJ/PA

#25

not necessarily

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"I expect that buying veneer grade logs is significantly less expensive than kiln dried 8/4 VG stock. " Not necessarily so when you consider the lower grade lumber you may have to deal with in some way.

A "veneer grade" log doesn't tell you much by itself. An experienced sawer can look at the bark and anticipate what lies within. Your best bet would be to find a trustworthy sawyer to pick and saw the log. But most of all you would want as large a log as you could afford, and it won't be cheap. I try to find a log that isn't a veneer grade log but that will yield sufficient clear sections to make the stuff I make. A large log that is partially hollow can be especially good value for the center will be useless to you anyway. And a partially hollow log is severely downgraded and I have never figured out why. It is common for a logger to trim all the butt hollow from a log, throwing away all this clear wood. Makes no sense to me.

The 10/4 lumber on the top of this walnut pile is from logs I bought and rift cut. None were veneer logs but all were good value for my purposes.