New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

Posts

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#26

Re: question

Brian Holcombe

I'm even less convinced now when a stopped groove is considered. A ploughed groove is painless and does not create short grain which readily breaks off at inopportune times. I used stopped grooves plenty in my work but not when short grain is a result. At that juncture a front slip starts to look entirely reasonable and much more practical.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#27

Weighed options

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Wiley! I appreciate your having noticed that bit of decision making.

While I agree on the whole that the grooved drawer front is probably the best solution, there is a lot being made of a relatively simple choice on my part to increase the volume of the drawer.

Formulaic building gets very tedious for me. While I'm approaching that in drawer building, I much prefer on the fly decision making and living with the consequences of those decisions. In this case the front slip was one of those decisions.

I have a drawer I built using a milling machine on my first piece of furniture, it's entirely constructed of sliding dovetails and likely it will outlive me. I used absolutely no research in building it and did not have the mental catalog of reference that I do currently. Optimized western construction is excellent, but its not the only thing.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#28

Re: question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

A ploughed groove is painless and does not create short grain which readily breaks off at inopportune times. I used stopped grooves plenty in my work but not when short grain is a result.

Hi Brian

One of the purposes of a front groove is to strengthen the construction. Another purpose is to align the sides and make them coplanar.

A stopped groove was barely more work than a through groove would have been on my bowed drawer front. You could not use a plough to form the groove, and also you could not glue a slip to it.

Short grain is not an issue here. The groove ends with sufficient support, and the drawer bottom placed no stress in that area.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#29

Loving the pile up

Brian Holcombe

I may not change my evil ways, but I do appreciate the pile-up. This is alot of fun for me and the quality of this discussion is inspiring.

Tom, thanks for the comment as always, but I dont mind the commentary with regard to somewhat of a minor detail. It's actually interesting to me to see what takes off into a larger discussion and usually it is something I didn't think much about.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#30

Re: question

Brian Holcombe

I think the way that you went about it was very reasonable considering the task at hand. There would be short grain in my case.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#31

Other benefits

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Long ago I realized that there is a silent audience following, and we hope learning from, these discussions. I am optimistic that the discussion taught a few people about drawer building options and/or helped them choose among options. Indeed this may be the main benefit of these discussions.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#32

Re: Other benefits

Brian Holcombe

Indeed, it is really good to see the information made available online in an easily searchable format.

That was my main driver behind blogging, seeing something like Chris Hall's the carpentry way and Derek's In the Woodshop inspired me to catalog my builds in a centralized location.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#33

Re: Other benefits

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Yes. It seems that a few of the same voices answer time and again. I do invite others to voice their opinions. We all learn that way.

My responses in this thread (as in many others) are written not just as a direct reply, but also to those reading alongside. Brian, I do hope that you do not feel I was having a go at you at any time regarding technique - your joinery is sometimes quite "Brian" :), and while it obviously works, is not traditional, and this needs to be made clear for those who do not know the difference.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#35

Re: Other benefits

Brian Holcombe

Hah :D I know that is true.

WRT to opinions, I dont mind becuase some early unflattering opinions saved me some serious headaches. The most memorable was a bed that I had designed some years ago (not the one from last year). I was showing my work to Ru Amagasu who suggested I might find out where the flaws were in a most embarrassing and untimely fashion. Ru is hilarious, so I could hardly get upset, but I did spend a good deal of time redesigning it.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#36

Retraction and rethink

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I need to withdraw the incorrect concept and math of my previous post, to which you've replied.

Here is a rethink...Suppose the lower pins are at 3/8" elev. Make a 1/8" to 3/16" groove across the drawer front (inside) at that elevation, before doing any pin sawing. Just to be definite, make it 3/16", so that the groove top is at 9/16". Now make side slips 9/16" tall, with a short extension at the front topside, which is 3/16" thick, to serve as a locator pin--this pin goes into the groove you just made.

The two side slips are grooved in their length, with say a 1/8" groove located 3/16" from the top.

The drawer bottom is made 5/16" thick, with a 3/16" front tongue and 1/8" side tongues. The front tongue is at the top surface; the side tongues are at the bottom surface. When the drawer bottom is slid into the slips, the front tongue will fit the groove in the drawer front; the side tongues will fit the groove in the side slips; the slips are flush with the drawer bottom; the drawer bottom will clear the ground by 1/4"; the drawer bottom comes 9/16" up the side wall of the drawer.

NOTE: These dimensions suggestive only. The 1/8" side tongues would have good strength, being cross grain, but could be made thicker if the drawer purpose and size called for it, or if your plough iron is 5/32" as a favorite one of mine is.

Apologies.

Wiley

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#37

The unnecessary "locator pin"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I like your new math. It would be fine for a small drawer but I, and most others, would go with 1/4" grooves for a large dresser.

I was at a tour in the Philadelphia museum some years ago and in one part they have a semicircle of furniture through the ages, starting in the 1600's, and ending I don't remember where, with the signature Fox and Grapes piece in the middle. I asked a question about the internal framing of an early piece with frame and panel side construction. Out came a drawer and we poked inside. A comment was made about the nailed on drawer bottom, which led to a discussion of drawers through the ages, using this collection as examples. Somewhere in the 1700's drawer construction evolved to it's final destination and hasn't changed since. I figured it unlikely I was going to add any useful improvement and copied what they did.

The English went a different direction as a result of their use of thin abrasive oak sides, which led to slips to provide a bearing surface. Some, in utilizing slips, mill a locating pin/tongue on the end that goes in the groove in the drawer front.

For those with more drawers to build than time to build them (8 on my current schedule), this feature is unnecessary. Use the temporary locating guide I described earlier in this discussion.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#38

Re: miters

Sgian Dubh

"Perhaps David Charlesworth or Richard Jones will respond."

Derek, it's kind of you to add my tuppenceworth, but to be honest, I think plenty has been said already, and the information I provided in a link you made earlier in the discussion pretty much summarised my approach to drawer building.

I suppose the only things I feel useful to mention are that I've never seen any point in a slip added to the back of a drawer front - it's redundant given there's always enough meat in the drawer front for the groove, as well as plenty of room to execute outer half-pins and the like to hide that groove. Secondly, the term I generally give for slips with a quarter round upper profile facing the interior of the drawer box is a 'quadrant slip'. It's just a name I use, and I don't think there's anything 'official' or 'approved' by cognoscenti about the nomenclature. And, of course, those slips upstanding into the interior of the drawer box can have all sorts of upper profiles worked into them. Slainte.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#39

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

don stephan

Chiming in late, I find flush slips with a scratch bead add significant visual detail and interest to a drawer interior compared to a "quadrant" slip. (And I still have a printed copy of Richard's first presentation here on drawer slips.) Nothing right or wrong about a plain or fancy interior for a simple sock drawer, just different looks.

Besides increasing the width of the bearing surface on the drawer support, slips allow a thinner drawer side than otherwise possible which is a more graceful look. Again, aesthetics for what may be "just" a sock drawer.

Individual preference and working practices make peeking inside drawers more rewarding because they are not all the same.

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

#40

Re: The Butler's Desk - Drawer Building

Brian Holcombe

Thank you Don, I appreciation your opinion/comment.