New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Top of the world to you!

Posts

Top of the world to you!

#1

Top of the world to you!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well, my wife is partly Irish, and we are getting close to completing her Lingerie Chest.

My last post completed the drawers, and now attention is turned to the top of the chest ...


This was a saga. I built and rejected three tops before settling on the one below. There were a variety of mouldings, and none fitted in, even the subtle ones. In the end it was a case of less is more. Book matched Makore (as with the carcase) ...


As seen here, the panel is reinforced by breadboard ends. The breadboards line up with the side frames.

So here is the completed carcase. I apologise for the inaccurate colour - it should be a little more red. New camera and still trying to sort out the lighting. Trying to learn to take better photographs!


Here's the obligatory dovetail picture, which most have seen already. The bowed drawers (figured Jarrah) are difficult to judge in this photo, but the curves will show up in the top shortly ..


So, let's see what happens when we lift the top ...


The chest is just 48" high, and the mirror allows it to double as a dressing bureau. This will be covered in dark blue leather.


The hinges for the top are heavy-duty Brusso butt hinges that have a built-in stop at 95 degrees. Holding up the top and mirror is not a problem - my concern was to ensure the lid did not fall down! I searched for months for a suitable brass stay, but could not find one anywhere. The problem was that it needed to fit into a narrow space, and all the ones I looked at needed more room than I had. In the end I designed and built my own.


A brass bits-and-pieces, reshaped, fitted together ...


The stay and catch are french fit into the top. There is a finger hole to access the head, then swing it over and into the catch. It works really well.


And one last photo. Apologies for the gruesome person in the background :)


I am now working on the last part of the Lingerie Chest: sliding jewellery trays in the top drawer.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Top of the world to you!

#2

Re: Top of the world to you!

Anji12305

Glorious.

What isn't obvious is the multiple compound curves in every plane. It's an original take on a classic form.

Kudos

Re: Top of the world to you!

#3

Re: Top of the world to you!

Howard Pollack

Derek, you do nice work!

-Howard

Re: Top of the world to you!

#4

Re: Top of the world to you!

TomD

Beautiful job there Derek.

Not sure what a mirror on a lingerie chest is for, but I live a sheltered life. Many people never pass a mirror so it is complementary to provide one I guess.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#5

Re: Top of the world to you!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

The name "Lingerie Chest" is just a joke. This is a chest of drawers that is also used as a standing dressing bureau, hence the mirror.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Top of the world to you!

#6

Re: Top of the world to you!

roger lance

Derek.....this is yet another magnificent example of where all that skill development, thinking, planning, and hand tool use can get a guy.

Your woodworking is approaching top of the world levels.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#8

Re: Top of the world to you!

philip f Duffy

AMAZING accomplishment! P.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#9

Re: Top of the world to you!

roger lance

"As always, you are too kind....."

Now , we both know that I've played the villain on occasion.....

Re: Top of the world to you!

#10

Re: Top of the world to you!

Brian Holcombe

In addition to my comments on SMC, I wanted to say I'm really loving that mitered plain molding in the top of the case, I had been wondering what you have planned for that and I'm glad to see the result.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#11

Mitres

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Thanks Brian.

That mitering was a deliberate part of the design to avoid any edge grain showing (to fit in with the clean lines of the whole piece). The lid was planned to replicate this, using the same dimensions and layout.

Here is a frame-and-panel lid I discarded. I loved the front curved lip (to act as a grip), but once it was done it just seemed too busy and too heavy ...


Here is a close up of the lip (apologies for the poor photo) ..


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Top of the world to you!

#12

The brass stay.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

There were a few comments about the brass stay.

I probably have the largest range of brass stays in the history of mankind, collected in the course of research ... Oh, I think that will do it! Cha-ching (sound of me paying for another stay) .... Damn, too large to fit!

Originally, I had planned to situate the stay to the right side and inside the tray. This has a depth of about 1 1/2". It was this that was too shallow for all the stays I came across. Here is what I came up with ...

I was wandering around the local hardware store looking for inspiration when an idea formed around these door closers (front) and (at the rear) box hinges ..


I managed to find brass pipes with a 5mm hole and 5mm brass thread. The brass thread fitted the pipe to create a strong brass rod.

The "catch" (female) was modified: the wings with screw lugs were removed (needed to reduced the width and make a neater fitting), a screw hole was drilled in the centre, the springs were removed and shortened (re reduce tension), and the case ground back by about 2mm each side.

The "lug" (male) was also modified: shortened and rounded (as it needed to fit at an angle. The existing square shape only permitted entry if all parts were square with one another). The brass thread was tapped into the lug ....


Here is the end with the box hinge ...


This was also 5mm diameter .... see how it was meant to be?

Once the lower section was epoxied together, the lid was morticed for the catch (to prevent it moving on the single screw) ...



Once this was done, the stay was attached (clicked in), and the position for the pivot could be marked for drilling ...


And the rest (drilling, grooving and morticing for the stay) is, as they say, history.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Top of the world to you!

#14

Re: Mitres

Brian Holcombe

I think you made the right choice. Hard to discard a finished top, but the second take is a nice result.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#15

Re: Top of the world to you!

TomD

Close up the chest sucks to be you. But with the perspective of a little more time you will get closer and closer to seeing it the way other people see it.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#16

Re: Top of the world to you!

Gary Balcom

Derek,

Excellent work! I hope to see it in a magazine sometime...It really does make me think of something I read a while back from one of the popular authors (CS?) That the craft will be pushed forward not by professionals, but by serious amateurs.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#17

Re: Top of the world to you!

TomD

Krenov used to say that, then he went pro, and concerned himself with pros. I doubt that is true that amateurs will push things along moreso than pros, but they still can do things at a professional level. It isn't even that difficult. It doesn't take that long to teach a person with some aptitude professional skills, if they work at it over a long period of time they will develop other things like speed, or design ability, etc... Apprenticeships really aren't full time there is a lot of work time in there. It is just a mater of why people do craft and what goals they set.

I think it is another question as to what would constitute an advance, and how often we see that.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#18

Re: Top of the world to you!

Brian Holcombe

Alternatively I think it's the internet that pushes the craft forward. Without the internet people who are otherwise isolated from each other do not get to see what is being made and by whom.

They become your peers much in the way that artist communities have pushed forward greats along the way.

Professionals have the advantage of having clients who ask them to build things outside of their normal range. Maloof attributed much of his design creativity to client requests.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#19

Re: Top of the world to you!

Gary B.

I've spent my entire career thus far as a professional woodworker. I'm not too old yet, but it's been 20 years. What I take Krenov's quote to mean is that most professional woodworkers don't get to build such furniture. To clarify, when I say "professional", I mean someone who holds a legitimate and legal full time business, and counts on it to provide food for his or her family

Realistically, who would pay for it? Not many that's for sure. I'd hate to think of what Derek's beautiful piece would cost if he had to charge a realistic shop rate for his time. Most professional woodworkers eventually become a starving artist or end up gravitating towards the kind of work that actually pays well, such as custom cabinetry. Jim Tolpin also mentions this in one of his books also, lamenting that he would find himself subsidizing the client's project with his "free" time to produce a piece better than they could afford. (Which he advised to be careful of, or you'll be the next starving artist).

Indeed, the internet plays a large role...but without the serious amateurs, who knows if this ancient craft would survive, let alone be furthered. In all the time I've spent in shops, my hand tools have come out of the box very rarely, and many of my co-workers had never used any...It's sad really.

But, Technology being what it is, I'm sure if the true professionals 150 years ago had access to a CNC router, they'd use it too. Afterall, for many it was about putting food on the table, and making money.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#20

Amateurs, professionals, and prices

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I did wonder why Krenov did not charge more for the pieces he made. From accounts, he sold them very cheaply. Perhaps this was a nod to the "amateur" status he conveyed upon himself. In my eyes he was a professional woodworker since his income came from woodwork ... as with many other furnituremakers around the world, who supplement their furniture work with teaching. In his case it was the other way around.

Generally professionals build what will sell, or what they are comissioned to build. I do not know many professional woodworkers who enjoy the luxury of being able to sell their fancy, or charge a fee that reflects the time they spent on the build. There are not many Maloofs in the world. I think that this was what Krenov was getting at.

My pieces are very far from those exalted heights. I have the time to correct mistakes, and the persistance to finish what I start. They end up fairly decent. What are they worth? What does they mean - to sell, to insure? I plan to enter this chest in the local furniture competition (as I did two years ago with the Wegner Chair) .... yes, I know, bloody idiot, did I not learn from that experience ... but this is to support the club and I have few illusions about my chances of winning (it is not the type of piece that is favoured). Still, what if someone offered to buy it? What would I ask? For my time? For what I perceive as a very complex build? Or a unique build, because few professionals would construct as I did - just too inefficient. It is an interesting exercise, and one that will likely shatter egos. Fortunately, I do not build to sell, and the piece therefore has no material value for me.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Top of the world to you!

#21

Re: Top of the world to you!

Brian Holcombe

I don't think it's impossible, but I think it's much much more of an unsure approach. There are guys doing it, and most of them supliment their income with teaching, or books, ect.

Proximity to people who are willing to pay for it is important and for guys like Maloof I think he was smart to limit his overhead.

Mokuchi woodworking (Yann), Miya Shoji, Chris Hall, Des King and Warren Mickley come to mind immediately. I shouldn't speak for any of them as to how, specifically, they earn their income but if I understand correctly all of these are professional woodworkers or woodworking shops building full time and doing interesting and also high quality work very often.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#22

Re: Amateurs, professionals, and prices

TomD

Derek, you had some contact with Krenov. Krenov to me is entirely the books, videos, etc... No real person.

"I did wonder why Krenov did not charge more for the pieces he made. From accounts, he sold them very cheaply. Perhaps this was a nod to the "amateur" status he conveyed upon himself. In my eyes he was a professional woodworker since his income came from woodwork ... as with many other furnituremakers around the world, who supplement their furniture work with teaching. In his case it was the other way around."

He wrote the books before the College of the Redwoods came calling, as you know. I think he was one of those guys whose wife worked, though I don't know that. But there are a lot of fine craftsmen behind whom there is definitely a good spouse with a job and benefits, etc... I once displayed at a national craft show, very prestigious, and I won't say what craft. I noticed very few of the top hands actually had families, or maybe 50% didn't, which in human terms is pretty low.

Traditionally craftsmen were not wealthy, padding out the lifestyle to include everything one wants today, takes a Goldman Sachs level business acumen, if one is doing truly great work. And I don't know if there is anyone who could add on top of that only selling to clients who really get what you are doing. If you look at the diverse and incredibly specific influences in someone like a Nakashima, and how they actually found expression in his furniture, I;m sure nobody actually understood what he was doing who was buying his work. But his work was pretty friendly, so it didn't mater that they didn't get it, but it makes for a pretty barren professional landscape, like being a great script writer in english when all you viewers are german, but they like the musical nature of your words, even though they don't understand a word of it (obviously in the real world germans know english).

Re: Top of the world to you!

#23

Re: Top of the world to you!

Gary B.

Brian,

It's not impossible.....but a very difficult row to hoe for sure....For every one of those, there are 1,000 professional woodworkers that don't build to gallery quality, or build spec pieces. There simply aren't enough people that appreciate it to sell to. If you're needing it to put food on the table, you're going to build what you KNOW you can sell in your local market.

Derek,

Sorry for the imposition. I don't mean to hijack your thread. You have built an amazing piece that anyone should be proud of.

Re: Top of the world to you!

#25

Re: Top of the world to you!

Brian Holcombe

My original point was that if you are woodworking in a situation where you have clients making requests on you of your woodwork, then you are going to find yourself problem solving more often and creating solutions much more often. That push helps certain people to create.

My larger point was that inspiration and creative development mostly happened in artist communities where each development furthers the craft of the group. Gathering online creates similar phenomenon.

I believe that was Maloof's point as well, but I'd like not to speak for him.

I respect that not everyone who wants to become a professional woodworker making gallery furniture can do so. I don't lose respect for those that do if they aren't turning a quarter million each year, I highly respect their sacrifice for the craft.