New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

Adjusting tenon thickness

Posts

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#26

Re: Hand Router

Steve Voigt

I usually select methods which will be safest for my beginning students.

Hence the choice of router plane.

That's like a bicycle instructor teaching his students to install training wheels--and never take them off.

As Derek said, there's an inherent risk factor in using hand tools.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#27

Re: I made a movie for you, Bill

Steve Voigt

I had to trim down a fat tenon, so I filmed it.

Excellent video, Brian. Anybody wanting to learn a fast, efficient method, albeit one that takes some effort to master, would do well to watch and copy.

One question: what are you doing with the coping saw?

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#28

Re: Hand Router

David Charlesworth

Who said anything about not taking them off?

It is important for learners to get a good result so that they are encouraged and not not demoralized.

David

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#29

Amen

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"It is important for learners to get a good result so that they are encouraged and not demoralized."

This statement is especially true for those of us motivated by achieving a satisfactory product from our efforts and not so much concerned how we got there. As an example, I have sharpening jigs I no longer bother with. At one time they were essential training wheels to get a job done. The same could be said about almost any of the unit operations I use to build something. If I have need to do something often enough I will become more efficient at it. If it is something less used I'm OK with crutches and training wheel if they enable me to get the job done satisfactorily.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#30

Re: I made a movie for you, Bill

Brian Holcombe

Thanks Steve!

On the coping saw, I cut the waste out from the center of the bridle joint with it. Not shown in the video, because I goofed on the camera angle, is the part where I chop to the line on the bridle joint. Took about 10 seconds and I wanted to show it but the camera angle was a bit awkward upon review, hah.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#31

Re: Comment/question on Hand Router

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

On the other hand, while I advocate a chisel as much as possible, I find the router plane a wonderfully useful tool. It does a terrific job on tenon cheeks - which is not to suggest that it is the best method, but it is one I continue to use on occasions the cheek is an uneven thickness, with one end thicker and out-of-parallel..


I also use the router place, possibly exclusively, for running grooves on areas where a plough plane cannot go. This is self-evident when working curved drawer fronts, such as below ..


It is clearly possible to do all things a router plane can do with a chisel, such as a hinge mortice, but the router plane can be used like a butt mortice plane, and provide a level finish for a perfect fit.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#32

Re: Hand Router

Steve Voigt

"Who said anything about not taking them off?"

Very well David, perhaps I have misunderstood your method. Can you tell us how the training wheels come off? Can you give us some examples? In this thread, you only mention the router plane. A quick Google search turns this up:

My method employs a simple stick, planed up to fit the mortices...Saw all the face side cheeks on my very good bandsaw...Use router or router plane to shave non face side cheeks (only) to size indicated by stick.

So, is there a point at which you teach your students to trim with a chisel? Do you teach them to saw with a backsaw?

In a similar vein, do you teach your students, once they become advanced, to sharpen without honing guides and "camber plates"?

The participants in this thread are mostly quite advanced. The OP, Bill, has built a number of quite advanced pieces. Many of the others here have decades of experience, or are professionals, or have demonstrated great technical facility. If there were ever an ideal audience for more advanced content, this is it. I think many of us will be eagerly looking forward to hearing how you enable your students to "take off the training wheels."

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#33

Re: I made a movie for you, Bill

Steve Voigt

Thanks for the reply, Brian, I should have figured that out. :\

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#34

Re: Hand Router

David Charlesworth

Steve,

I think you will probably be the only person "eagerly looking forward to" this reply.

There are usually many methods of going about a task. Often a simple jig or guide produces a more accurate and repeatable result. More advanced workers are welcome to choose to use high skilled, more risky methods.

One of the best examples is the Eclipse guide for sharpening chisels and plane blades. The results are more accurate and more repeatable, than freehand. People will stop using a guide as and when when they wish.

I have met hundreds of amateurs who have struggled with their hand planes, often for years. Immaculate sharpening can be taught in one or two days, and yes this involves a guide.

I look forward to the day when you will be doing your planing with a chisel?

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#35

Re: Amen, and more

TomD

So over the years I have emphasized methods here that allow one to combine both. So maybe not to be political, when I started doing drywall, I tried every corner with just a knife, the way the pros do. But if it didn't work, I had a corner tool to get er done. That approach, whether sharpening or drywall is faster overall. If you stick with the training wheels it slows you down two ways. It is slower and you don't learn the faster method. Also, you don't get to transfer the hand eye skills from learning the sharpening (or taping) to other things you do, you suffer twice. But having the wheels in the sop means that if your hand efforts gradually dub the edge, you can straighten out with the wheels every now and then, no downside.

A third way it hits you is this: Lets say you use training wheels all the time for sharpening, we covered that; Then the benefits of also using the hand skills that we covered; but at another level the training wheels may be superior also, like in planing competitions or repairing chipped edges (if you don't want to grind). So having them in the mix can also help you. In the drywall situation, one thing I think works better for the home guy is an approach partly based on the skill set of plasterers (ask if you care). It turns out the cornering tool while viewed as a crutch in drywall is the standard method for plastering because there isn't anything to place the outside edge of the tool on that isn't wet. So again, no skill however minor is wasted.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#36

Re: Hand Router

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I was most certainly eagerly awaiting your reply. It seems there is a movement to eliminate real skills from woodworking, and to solve problems which do not arise when one has a modest amount of experience. The old fashioned 20th century attitude is that skills are not worth learning.

I was taught freehand sharpening as a 12 year old. I was taught as if I were someday going to be a professional. No time was wasted learning baby talk. No tricks, no compromise. The fellow who taught me I cannot thank enough. The more important lesson I learned was that skills that seem daunting soon enough become routine and even trivial. He gave me the confidence that I could always overcome the clumsiness that comes with learning something new.

Learning a skill with repetition is time well spent because one skill helps with others. It is a lot easier to teach woodworking to someone who has learned the violin or how to throw a baseball. These skills are transferable, but more important is the confidence and expectation that difficulties can be overcome.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#37

Re: Hand Router

David Charlesworth

Warren,

I learned freehand sharpening at about the same age.

This does not alter the fact that a guide is a valuable aid for many amateurs.

There are many other skills for them to learn and available time is not plentiful.

David