New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Adjusting tenon thickness

Posts

Adjusting tenon thickness

#1

Adjusting tenon thickness

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What tool is preferred to adjust the thickness of a tenon that needs thinning a bit. I have been using a shoulder plane....because I have one. Someone earlier suggested a router plane. I had not considered that possibility and I am not sure it is a good choice.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#2

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

John in NM

I too have always used a shoulder plane of one variety or another, like you because it was a tool I had on hand.

These days I would probably try a rasp, because I have one of those expensive French ones, and it really does work well for such tasks as this when sufficiently sharp (I've acid dunked it once so far, that really did bring it back). Unfortunately I haven't made many tenons lately, at least since I got that rasp! :D

The conventional wisdom is of course to simply make your tenons perfectly from the start. Though I don't find it to be realistic personally, I'm sure someone will give you that advice :D

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#3

Re: Production wise...

TomD

I did this one little piece and it didn't seem to be a big deal. Started to calculate it out and there were dozens of M&Ts. So production can be a factor.

Router table, or overarm router. You have an index on the whole piece, which is great if it is flat. You adjust a fence so that you can't reach the shoulder. I do a production/custom approach where I use the router to cut 90% but stay back from the shoulder since it would grab. I get that last fraction out with a chisel. I really don't like routers, but in this case it works OK because the material being removed is slight.

I mention this here because I know you use a HCM, so why not this. My production/custom approach is HCM/bandsaw/router table. But hand skills are also important once one leaves the sphere of small furniture mortises, and rectilinearity.

For a hand tool method the router plane is the nearest thing to the above, whether mounted in a table or used over top of the stock. Mounted in a table the router plane is so close in function to a router there is no skills difference, and it even works right into the shoulder.

Of course, the better method whether with hand or power tools is to go direct to the dimension. With power tools that takes too much set-up for the way I work. With hand tools, to be honest, I can't pull it off in all/most situations. I can on say a guitar joint, right size, material, practice range.

There are also large MTs. I love to put together table with stretchers and wedges, and the tenon faces can be like 8x6 inches. Just standard had plane fits. Or with power, you can cut them direct off the jointer and use a slick to the shoulder.

In my shop the key is often which tools I can get to depending on what else is going on in the shop.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#4

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

Personally I prefer a big paring chisel. The router plane method takes too long and isn't accurate on long tenons.

If you have marks on the tenon, then you can use a chisel without issue.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#5

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

Ron in Sterling, CT

Hi Bill,

I don't make a lot of tenons, but when I need to adjust one I find that personally I have better control with a sharp, wide paring chisel than I do with a shoulder plane. Both work, but I prefer the chisel. My 2 cents.

Ron

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#6

Chisel details?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't see how to use a chisel? Does one start from a front edge and try to lift a shaving all across the tenon cross grain, or with the grain? That way would be hard to control the starting shaving thickness. It is hard for me to start a chisel on vertical surface. Start in the middle and pare both ways? Nothing I can imagine seems as obvious as using a plane.

I have wide chisel ready to try as soon as I know what to try.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#7

It depends ...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

... on the waste to be removed from the cheeks.

If it is a smedgeon to remove, because the fit is a little too tight, look for the shiny spots and use either a rasp or a joinery float (LN makes one).

If one has sawn off parallel, it is essential to return to parallel as well as thicknessing. A router plane does a good job of doing this with reduced stress levels. With a little more care, marking the high spots and paring with a wide chisel is a little riskier but equally doable.

I tend to avoid using any plane on cheeks, since they are difficult to steer over high spots only. If it is just a matter of reducing thickness evenly, sometimes a skew block or rabbet block plane can be used. I never use a shoulder plane as they are too tippy.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#8

Re: Chisel details?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Here is Peter Nicholson's description of sawing a tenon from 1812. I do the same except I cut the shoulders last and I just use a chisel, no rabbet (rebate) plane.


I put the rail on a sawing board or side hook and pare across the grain with a sharp one inch chisel. I think someone mentioned earlier that the original gauge lines on the tenon are a help. Any method of adjusting is tedious work so it pays to saw carefully and avoid having to adjust. I have taught teenagers and retirees to saw to the line.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#9

Re: Chisel details?

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Just a point on starting the chisel cut. Cross grain, as others have said. What I suggest to start the cut: Place the second joint of the forefinger of your off hand up against the vertical wall, making a fence on which to steady the chisel and locate the start of the cut.

Wiley

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#10

Hand Router

David Charlesworth

Routing with a sharp cutter has the advantage of keeping the cheek parallel to the surface of the rail.

Chisel and shoulder plane do not necessarily do this.

David

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#11

Re: Chisel details?

Brian Holcombe

Bill,

If your knife marks are still there, and they would be if you missed your mark off the saw, then you just put the chisel into the knife mark to start it.

On the odd change that I need to adjust then I watch my gauge marks on the end of the tenon as I'm making a shaving. I posted a video on one of my recent blog posts entitled something to the effect of paring...etc. In that I adjust the side of one of the stub tenons.

It likely goes so fast that no one can see what I'm doing unless they're keenly aware.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#12

Re: Hand Router

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Routing with a sharp cutter has the advantage of keeping the cheek parallel to the surface of the rail.

Chisel and shoulder plane do not necessarily do this.

True David. The router plane has the least risk. On the other hand, working with hand tools involves an acceptance for risk - the degree to which is the decision of the individual. I have seen you paring joinery with a chisel with great dexterity, so clearly you have confidence in your technique.

In order of risk, I do not consider a chisel to be the tool of greatest risk; I consider a plane to be so as it obscures the area that needs work, and it is easy to mis-cut. My sawing is decent and, consequently, when I need to make a corrections to a cheek it is usually to a slight taper. A chisel, float or rasp is enough to level to the line. More than this - if the cheek is too thick across the face - and I would use a router plane.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#13

How I as taught

ian neuhaus

clamp the rail to your bench.

engage about 1/8" of a wide chisel in the [side grain] gauge line at the end of the tenon and push the chisel across the tenon guiding the chisel with the [end grain] gauge line. Done "properly" you should be able to just see the polished surface left by the cutting gauge in the end grain.

The second and subsequent passes are done similarly, with the back of the chisel riding on the shelf left by the first paring cut.

There should be no need to skew the chisel.

If more than about 1/32" needs removing, work down to the gauge line in stages.

It goes without saying that your chisel needs to be properly tuned -- flat back, crisp edges, and very sharp.

I like a sharpening angle of 25° or less for paring duties.

BTW

I find the above technique the best method when working with very small

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#15

Sorry, meant to reply to Bill's post


Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#16

I made a movie for you, Bill

Brian Holcombe

I had to trim down a fat tenon, so I filmed it;

https://youtu.be/gK7F2OuQT5E

Trimming the tenon is about half way in.

The bridle joints are purposefully made with the tenon short of the exterior edge. You'll see why in two weeks.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#17

Re: Hand Router

David Charlesworth

I usually select methods which will be safest for my beginning students.

Hence the choice of router plane.

I find chisel good for adjusting width of tennon.

David

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#18

Comment/question on Hand Router

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe I am missing an opportunity from lack of understanding.....?

I have one sitting at arms length from the bench. I have considered it, thought of what seem to me serious disadvantages, and dismissed it as a possibility. What I see as reasons not to consider the router.

1. I don't find mine quick to adjust.

2. I don't find mine easy to refine an adjustment (change depths a few thousandths).

3. If both sides of the tenon need adjustment the router will need to be adjusted (tediously in my hands) twice.

4. The router is limited to a thin shaving. Mine stalls if the shaving is very thick. So if more than a few thou. need to be removed there will be two or more router adjustments.

Advocating that the router is an advantage for keeping the tenon in the same plane as the rail seems odd advantage to be significant to people with far greater hand skills than I have. This problem is the least of my worries in tenon fitting.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#19

Thank you for the movie

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am not sold on a chisel.....see separate note.

I am interested in what is holding the stick with the tenon on its end. Anything more than a simple bench hook?

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#20

Thank you and a decision

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

First, thank you all for taking the time to comment. I'm sticking with the shoulder plane.

I don't like the fiddly adjusting of the router. I wind up with rounded tenons if I file. I don't see a chisel used free hand better than a "chisel" held in a plane body. I would chisel otherwise and may try it anyway the next time I need an adjustment.

I used to be able to buy LN stuff wholesale and for some forgotten reason bought a large shoulder plane. I might have reached a different conclusion if I didn't already own one.

For how I mostly use a plane I regard it as a precise chisel holder with depth stop. So, for example, if I have a tenon that is 0.006" too thick the fastest, most accurate way I have at hand to thin it is with two passes with the shoulder plane. No adjusting of any tool required I would think that anyone that joints lumber with a hand plane would find planing a tenon to adjust thickness the vastly easier task to master. Which is to say anyone should be able to do it successfully. But, given that nobody else uses the shoulder plane I must be missing something.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#21

Re: Thank you and a decision

David Charlesworth

Bill,

Large shoulder plane is a great tool and I'm sure I used to recommend it.

So is the rebate block plane.

Shallow slopes chiseled up from existing gauge lines, and scribbled on, help to inform stopping point.

Anything which ensures accuracy and consistency in frame joints is a good thing. Truing up innacurate frames is a PITA, and slow..

David

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#22

Re: Thank you for the movie

Brian Holcombe

Anytime.

It's a shooting board with a bench hook, I use it as a multi purpose backstop.

The chisel is super easy, I own a shoulder plane and while I use it for odd tasks this isn't really a good one. You'd think it would be easier but in my opinion it winds up being like using a jointer plane on a small wooden box IE way too large for the task at hand.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#23

Re: Comment/question on Hand Router

Brian Holcombe

Quite honestly the only reason I own a router is for blind dados, even then I'm happier doing most of the work with a chisel.

I hate cutting blind dados, but manage to spec them out regularly for my own work...

I found the router plane to be a nuisance when adjusting tenons.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#24

Ditto

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Quite honestly the only reason I own a router is for blind dados, even then I'm happier doing most of the work with a chisel.

I hate cutting blind dados, but manage to spec them out regularly for my own work... "

Agree on all counts..............I guess I might add the occasional hinge and lock mortise benefit from the router but mostly I can get by with chiseling here too.

Re: Adjusting tenon thickness

#25

Re: Thank you and a decision

William Duffield

I use a L-N large shoulder plane for fitting tenons. Before I had it, I used a L-N skew rabbet block plane or an old Stanley #10.