New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Explanation of misnamed stiction

Posts

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#26

when the slurry behaves like a solid

ian neuhaus

I should have written more above about the slurry

as an analogy I was thinking about wet concrete where additional water increases the slump and hence the ability of concrete to flow.

with sharpening media, especially water stones, I'm surmising that at a low water content surface tension within the slurry begins to bind the particles of the slurry to each other, the item being sharpened and the sharpening media and that these forces are many times the frictional force attributable to the particles moving against each other or the two flat surfaces relative to each other.

I'm suggesting that the observed effect that adding a wetting agent to the slurry -- which significantly decreases the surface tension and hence lowers the shear resistance of the slurry -- supports this supposition that stiction is a phenomena related to surface tension within the lubricating fluid (water) rather than friction between adjacent surfaces or particles.

I'm further suggesting that the absence (or near absence) of stiction when oil is used as the lubricant -- oil having a much lower surface tension than water -- further supports my supposition.

Noting that I have direct no experience with diamonds and cast iron

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#27

Graphite

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Andre Felibien, writing in Paris in 1667, noted that woodworkers used either graphite or chalk to mark boards, depending on the color of the timber. A century later Andre Roubo mentioned using graphite or some "red stone" to mark boards and that chalk rubbed off too easily. Graphite was mined in England. So woodworkers had graphite in their workshops. I have not read that they used it for sharpening.

I have graphite in my shop also, but have not seen a need for it in sharpening tools. In fact, one of the things I like about 19th century steel is the way it engages the stone and makes abrasion easy. Abrasion, after all, is what we are after in sharpening, and it doesn't happen without friction. In contrast, stainless steels or other high chrome steels feel gummy on the stone, and resist abrasion, making them difficult to sharpen. Even old fashioned 20th century steels with only about 1% chrome are noticeably more difficult to abrade than cleaner steels.

For the record, I tried putting graphite on some of my stones while sharpening yesterday. Anyone else try this? I must report that I did not notice a difference.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#28

Circuit boards as diamond substrate

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I thought I had found the ideal substrate for loose diamond- copper plated fiberglass-resin circuit boards. They are flat, cheap and the diamond would embed readily into the copper. They were a failure in practice. The resistance to sliding a tool across the surface was too great to be practical.

Copper, diamond, WD-40 and tool steel results in unacceptable resistance to moving the steel across the plate (aluminum isn't satisfactory either for hand powered application)

Cast iron, diamond, WD-40 and tool steel results in little resistance to moving the steel across the plate in spite of the fact that it is easy to experience the adhesion of flat steel to the cast iron surface.

This hands on information and published coefficients of friction for cast iron vs other materials support all I have said on this topic.

Conclusions:

With some sharpening formats adhesion will contribute a significant component to the force pressing steel to abrasive. It then follows from adhesion and friction theory that lowering the surface tension of the lubricating fluid, lowering the coefficient of friction of the abrasive surface and lowering contact area by any means will lessen the force required to push steel across abrasive.

As a practical matter it is worth the effort to find suitable cast iron for the diamond substrate, something discovered centuries ago. You will never encounter unacceptable "stuction" and all steel used for tools can be rapidly sharpened as good as necessary.

(What seems to have been lost in the rebuttals is the dependence of coefficient of friction on the steel to abrasive distance(Stribeck curve), which in turn is dependent on force pressing steel to abrasive, which in turn can depend on adhesive force. )

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#29

Re: Circuit boards as diamond substrate

John in NM

I would mostly agree with your synopsis. But what has been lost in the numerous rebuttals is that on a wetted surface you will be unable to distinguish the component of adhesive force between two surfaces and the (correctly) cohesive force within the liquid lubricant - this force is most familiarly summed up as "surface tension".

The adhesive force between two solid surfaces is most familiar in everyday life as the difficulty in separating two panes of glass. While it may be possible to get a plane blade back that flat and rub it on a iron surface that flat, I can't see it being a problem when sharpening a bevel - the surface area is too small and the force is easily overcome by rocking the blade against the bevel.

The reason for all of this is that adhesive force is only significant on the nanometer scale - 10's to 100's of nanometers. Much as we would like our plane blades to be that flat, it is next to impossible to do by hand lapping metals.

So the easy way to check this is lay that plane blade flat on a piece of cast iron, dry, and see if there is significant resistance to picking it up. There likely will not be. Do the same with a piece of glass and there will likely be quite a lot. Do it with two pieces of glass and you probably can't pick one up at all without sliding them apart first. This is the adhesive force you are talking about.

Add a liquid to the mix and surface tension becomes the dominant force besides gravity - that is where the formula and charts you posted come in, and from there on out, the discussion is more or less correct.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#30

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

TomD

David, I don't seen any practical purpose to these discussions, yet. But there is interest and it brings out people with the required backgrounds to discuss this. No harm in understanding things. Though so far the model does not seem that credible.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#31

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

david weaver

Like I said, I went on many a bender on here talking about all kinds of stuff that wouldn't help anyone do any woodworking in anyway.

I agree with warren's comments about steel.

I've got a couple of chisels that on anything other than diamonds, they feel like you're rubbing two pieces of ice together when you sharpen. I don't particularly love diamonds so it's not convenient to keep anything handy to sharpen those chisels.

(to add another useless comment, I have noticed that careful care to not abuse white steel chisels makes maintenance possible indefinitely on a washita stone, and the results are similar to less hard steel on a hard arkansas)