Explanation of misnamed stiction
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Explanation of misnamed stiction
This discussion will test your curiosity.......
First, stiction is the resistance to getting something moving that is stuck. I think the word was invented in the modern electronics field for I see the term applied to the problem of sticking heads on disk drives and other situations of smooth silica stuck to anything else that is smooth. The unexpectedly large force required to push a flat tool like a plane blade across a fine stone is not stiction as described in the previous literature on the topic. In the former case we are concerned with getting something moving that is stationary and once moving it moves easily. In the latter case we are annoyed by the large force to keep the plane blade moving across the stone while sharpening. We need a new name. For now we will call the phenomena “stuction” .
Stuction is the excessively high resistance we experience trying to push a flat tool across a relatively smooth, flat abrasive surface that is lubricated with sharpening fluid of some sort.
I questioned my daughter on this topic as she was synthesizing synthetic lubricants and was becoming familiar with the topic of lubrication and friction. She provided a Tribology book that I think explains stuction.
The force(Fm) to push a flat plate (plane blade) across another flat plate(fine stone) equals the force(FN ) pushing down on the plate(plane blade) times the coefficient of friction(u).
Equation 1 Fm = u times FN
What we experience in stuction is that the force to push the blade across the stone suddenly, maybe even unexpectedly, becomes excessive to the point where the blade can become stuck. Either the force pushing down on the blade or the coefficient of friction has become suddenly very large. In fact both have become large.
The force pushing down has become large as a result of adhesion. Any liquid placed between two flat plates that wets these plates will become an adhesive and stick the plates together (stiction) with substantial force if the area of contact is large. (Think two glass plates with water in between). This force can become so large that the liquid is largely squeezed out from between the plates and they become intimately close together. In this cozy state the roughness of the surfaces begins to physically engage at the high spots and abrasive particles are now rubbing on metal with no liquid in between. The finer the stone the more points are engaging over the total contact surface. This is good or there would be no sharpening action. As a result the coefficient of friction increases dramatically beyond the case where there is liquid everywhere between the surfaces.

The Stribeck curve describes what happens to the coefficient of friction under sharpening conditions. ZN/P, the x axis, is the speed (N) of the plane blade sliding across the stone times the viscosity of the liquid (Z) divided by the pressure pushing on the plane blade (P). It is critical to note that the pressure on the blade is greatly more that the pressure you are pushing on the blade because of the adhesion of blade to stone. In a sharpening situation we are at the left side of this curve in the region labeled low speed, low viscosity, high load. In sharpening we have a low viscosity sharpening lubricant, low speed of pushing the blade across the stone and a high pressure from the adhesive force pulling the blade to the stone.
To summarize the situation:
From Equation 1
Fm = u times FN
The force(Fm) to push a flat plate (plane blade) across another flat plate(fine stone) equals the force(FN ) pushing down on the plate(plane blade) times the coefficient of friction(u).
The force pushing the blade to stone, FN ,is much greater than the force we are applying to hold the blade on the stone because of the additional force from adhesion. The coefficient of friction, u, is at its maximum as shown on the Stribeck Curve. The result is an unexpected large force required to move the blade across the smooth sharpening stone.
A coarse stone prevents the smooth blade surface from getting close enough to the stone surface to enable good adhesion. As a result the adhesive force pushing the blade to stone is greatly less, or even zero. Also, we are at the low part of the Stribeck curve in mixed film lubrication. Hence, both u times FN are smaller and the force to push the blade across the coarse stone is smaller.



