New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Explanation of misnamed stiction

Posts

Explanation of misnamed stiction

#1

Explanation of misnamed stiction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Explanation of misnamed stiction

This discussion will test your curiosity.......

First, stiction is the resistance to getting something moving that is stuck. I think the word was invented in the modern electronics field for I see the term applied to the problem of sticking heads on disk drives and other situations of smooth silica stuck to anything else that is smooth. The unexpectedly large force required to push a flat tool like a plane blade across a fine stone is not stiction as described in the previous literature on the topic. In the former case we are concerned with getting something moving that is stationary and once moving it moves easily. In the latter case we are annoyed by the large force to keep the plane blade moving across the stone while sharpening. We need a new name. For now we will call the phenomena “stuction” .

Stuction is the excessively high resistance we experience trying to push a flat tool across a relatively smooth, flat abrasive surface that is lubricated with sharpening fluid of some sort.

I questioned my daughter on this topic as she was synthesizing synthetic lubricants and was becoming familiar with the topic of lubrication and friction. She provided a Tribology book that I think explains stuction.

The force(Fm) to push a flat plate (plane blade) across another flat plate(fine stone) equals the force(FN ) pushing down on the plate(plane blade) times the coefficient of friction(u).

Equation 1 Fm = u times FN

What we experience in stuction is that the force to push the blade across the stone suddenly, maybe even unexpectedly, becomes excessive to the point where the blade can become stuck. Either the force pushing down on the blade or the coefficient of friction has become suddenly very large. In fact both have become large.

The force pushing down has become large as a result of adhesion. Any liquid placed between two flat plates that wets these plates will become an adhesive and stick the plates together (stiction) with substantial force if the area of contact is large. (Think two glass plates with water in between). This force can become so large that the liquid is largely squeezed out from between the plates and they become intimately close together. In this cozy state the roughness of the surfaces begins to physically engage at the high spots and abrasive particles are now rubbing on metal with no liquid in between. The finer the stone the more points are engaging over the total contact surface. This is good or there would be no sharpening action. As a result the coefficient of friction increases dramatically beyond the case where there is liquid everywhere between the surfaces.


The Stribeck curve describes what happens to the coefficient of friction under sharpening conditions. ZN/P, the x axis, is the speed (N) of the plane blade sliding across the stone times the viscosity of the liquid (Z) divided by the pressure pushing on the plane blade (P). It is critical to note that the pressure on the blade is greatly more that the pressure you are pushing on the blade because of the adhesion of blade to stone. In a sharpening situation we are at the left side of this curve in the region labeled low speed, low viscosity, high load. In sharpening we have a low viscosity sharpening lubricant, low speed of pushing the blade across the stone and a high pressure from the adhesive force pulling the blade to the stone.

To summarize the situation:

From Equation 1

Fm = u times FN

The force(Fm) to push a flat plate (plane blade) across another flat plate(fine stone) equals the force(FN ) pushing down on the plate(plane blade) times the coefficient of friction(u).

The force pushing the blade to stone, FN ,is much greater than the force we are applying to hold the blade on the stone because of the additional force from adhesion. The coefficient of friction, u, is at its maximum as shown on the Stribeck Curve. The result is an unexpected large force required to move the blade across the smooth sharpening stone.

A coarse stone prevents the smooth blade surface from getting close enough to the stone surface to enable good adhesion. As a result the adhesive force pushing the blade to stone is greatly less, or even zero. Also, we are at the low part of the Stribeck curve in mixed film lubrication. Hence, both u times FN are smaller and the force to push the blade across the coarse stone is smaller.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#2

Why stuction is less on cast iron than stone

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Cast iron is naturally lubricated by the graphite phase in the case iron. We know that graphite is an excellent solid lubricant. Things slide easier on graphite then aluminum oxide or silica rock. As a result flat tool surfaces are sucked to the cast iron surface by adhesion but the coefficient of friction remains small. Hence, the force to push or pull the metal across the surface of the cast iron remains small. The result is that stuction is not a problem when sharpening with loose diamond on cast iron. It is a big problem on acrylic and copper(from experience).

Cast iron provides that desirable state where the tool sucks to the cast iron surface to provide secure registration of tool bevel to abrasive, without annoying stuction. This situation makes free hand sharpening on cast iron easy.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#3

Re: Why stuction is less on cast iron than stone

Warren in Lancaster, PA

In fifty some years of frequent sharpening on bench stones, I have never had a problem with the tool sticking too much. If sticking were a problem, I would consider the stone to be of poor quality. Are there stones which you have tried which were ineffective because of sticking?

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#4

Why are you asking me?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In what may be a first I used the search function to prepare a reply, something that you typically excel at. I direct you to a previous post 4/25/2016 where the topic of "stiction" was brought up. There was disagreement as to the cause. Apparently it is something observed with some abrasive media and something I have observed with loose diamond on copper and fine loose diamond on acrylic. I like to understand stuff so I researched the topic and reported above. The curious may find the information interesting, if not useful. On the other hand maybe nobody found the information interesting or useful and it was a waste of time posting.

I would have thought that those that never encountered it, or had anything positive to add, would have no interest in reading the post or replying.

I will leave it to others to reply to your assessment of sharpening stone technology.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#5

Re: Why are you asking me?

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thank you. It was unclear what you meant by "aluminum oxide or silica rock", just what it was you were contrasting to cast iron.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#6

Re: Why stuction is less on cast iron than stone

TomD

I find the conclusion somewhat hard to buy. Is it conjecture or some research report finding? When sharpening on cast iron, the tool is not in contact with the surface of the plate but above it on top of the diamonds. I don't really see how the slipage is supposed to be working with the graphite in the cast plate. The point of cast other than machine shop availability is that it is softer than tool steel and therefore the abrassive is registered in it and tool steel gets dragged over the arassive. On a soft plate the diamonds might hook up moreso than on a hard plate, like glass, with the result that the diamonds engage the surfaof the tool more agressively. On really hard surfaces the diamond engage more on the tool and wear the plate. There are a lot of variables. The idea that graphite lubricates seem unlikely. Even cast on cast where one has unmediated contact does nto slip very well, one needs to flake the surface to ensure resevoirs of oil are distributed over the contact surface, the graphite is in no way sufficient.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#7

Re: Why are you asking me?

TomD

Possibly because of the lack of quotation marks, though the part where the quote starts is clear enough I thought you were summarizing most of it in your own words. I'm not picky about the use of quotes, but you often handle technical subjects so I thought you were probably in there somewhere.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#8

Clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The point I was making, perhaps not clearly, was that the "dry" coefficient of friction of anything a sharpening stone could be made from, as well as steel which I didn't mention, will be greater than cast iron. Hence, if a situation arises where a plane blades adheres to the sharpening surface the sliding friction will be less with cast iron. That is to say one can live with adhesion with cast iron and maybe not with something else. The fact that woodworkers have borrowed the word "stiction" from the electronics industry suggests it is not unknown with some abrasive formats and procedures.

To get a significant attractive force from adhesion the following requirements must be met. The surfaces must be flat to enable close contact over a large area, the surfaces must be smooth to get close contact, and there must be a liquid between the surfaces that wet them. These requirements could be met with very fine stones, cast iron or steel when flattening plane blade backs with a lubricant that wets the surfaces.

I find adhesion to be an advantage when sharpening bevels. Sucking the bevel to abrasive aids maintaining registration of bevel to abrasive and mitigates rounding.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#9

Stuction is is an occasional irritant

Chuck Nickerson

with my Shapton 8k Pro stone. Since the 8k is my final stone, and most frequently used, I'd enjoy finding a similar stone without the stuction issue.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#10

Try this ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Chuck, just spritz water with a little liquid soap mixed in. That will keep the stone and your hands clean, and prevent any stiction.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#11

Skeptical....

John in NM

In part because of the broad misuse of the term "stiction", both here and in the thread last month. It is the force required to overcome static friction, nothing more. Once the object is moving, stiction is absolutely the wrong term to apply to the force required to overcome kinetic friction and keep the object in motion. Whenever I see "stiction" used it seems as though it is intended to mean "sticky" more so than "static friction" - often the sentence makes less sense if one substitutes the longer specific meaning.

I believe the phenomenon you are trying to quantify has more to do with fluid dynamics and films than it does friction - though at some level its all related. Friction on surfaces, whether static or kinetic, is fairly straightforward.

Where I get most skeptical is in the assignment of a significant portion of downward force to adhesion in order to make the math of kinetic friction work out. More likely it is the coefficient of friction that is varying widely, due to the varying effectiveness of the lubricating fluid with rapidly changing variables like speed and pressure, amount of slurry in the fluid, etc.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#12

Re: Clarification

Warren in Lancaster, PA

the "dry" coefficient of friction of anything a sharpening stone could be made from, as well as steel which I didn't mention, will be greater than cast iron.

Are you talking about cast iron here, or cast iron with diamonds embedded? Do you have data for any of this? It seems like speculation and it doesn't seem to fit with experience.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#13

Data to support the statement

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The sliding coefficient of friction of steel on cast iron is 1/5 that of steel on aluminum oxide. Stuff slides easily on cast iron. It is why slidy machine parts are made from it.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#14

reply

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. I think in sharpening both the force to get a plane blade moving across the abrasive surface as well as the force to keep it moving can be annoying. I suspect since this force is proportional to contact area the problem is more significant with back flattening than bevel sharpening.

2.The Stribeck curve answers your issues of fluid dynamics vs coefficient of friction. Sharpening is way to the left on that curve. It all depends on the fluid thickness. If the fluid thickness is so thick that fluid viscosity is the main resistance you aren't close enough to be sharpening.

3. An estimate using the adhesion equation I sent you will reveal that for a 2 x 2 inches of flat blade back on flat glass there is about 30 pounds of adhesive force. An equivalent from fingers will lead to cramps. Combine the calculated adhesive force with a 1.1 coefficient of friction of steel on aluminum oxide and one can see that if the plane blade back and rock are very smooth such as to get intimate contact, and water lubricant, substantial force is necessary to get a plane blade moving or keep it moving.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#15

Re: Data to support the statement

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is a big difference between rubbing steel on cast iron and rubbing steel on diamonds embedded in cast iron that you cannot seem to notice. The data on clean cast iron is irrelevant.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#16

#3 is the crux of it...

John in NM

I do not agree that there is a significant adhesive force at work here (though I will have to read the material you sent again). The reason is that the distances in consideration are too large for adhesion to be a significant force - don't forget you are dividing by the cube of that distance.

The balance of adhesive force and surface energy is what gives a fluid droplet it's shape on a specific surface - that is why the distance is so important, the adhesive force drops rapidly a short distance from the interface and the droplet becomes curved as the surface tension force becomes dominant.

I believe you are misapplying the adhesive force in the case of sharpening, leading to a false conclusion in your point #2 as well.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#17

I know that Wikipedia is often unreliable but ...

ian neuhaus

in my experience of stiction (stuction) can be overcome through the use of a wetting agent, which would correlate with the phenomena being related to what Wikipedia ascribes as capillary forces due to the surface tension of the lubricating fluid -- wetting agents being so called because they reduce surface tension -- rather than friction between the surfaces.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#18

Spot on Ian

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

From adhesive theory:

The adhesive force holding two glass plates together with a liquid in between, or a plane blade back to a very smooth flat stone or cast iron, is given by

F = 2AYcos T/ d (don't know how to make greek letters in Woodcentral font)

where F is the force, A is the contact area, Y is the surface tension, cosine of the contact angle, and d, distance the plates are apart.

Force is proportional to surface tension of the liquid between the plates.

This is the same force that sucks two boards together when edge gluing. When prepared accurately they stick even before the glue sets .

Combine this information with the Equation for coefficient of friction where the downward force of steel to rock is the sum of finger pressure and adhesive pressure, along with the variation of coefficient of friction with distance from the Stribeck curve and the forces we encounter when sharpening are explained in terms of physical variables and constants. No black magic involved.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#19

Half on....

John in NM

Again, adhesive force is being misapplied regarding the stone vs steel, but Ian does have it correct with the lubricant.

If you want an accurate estimate of that downward force on, say a plane sole being flattened, it is the sum of gravity, the adhesive force between the stone and fluid, and the adhesive force between the plane and fluid. This is just the simple downward force at rest that must be overcome to pick it up. The sliding force is more complicated because the force vectors are going in several directions.

The bottom line however, is that it is the fluid adhesion/surface tension balance resisting movement, not adhesion between the metal and stone surfaces as your previous posts have implied - if I am reading them correctly, which as always may not be the case.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#20

Well, no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"The adhesive force between the stone and fluid"- not correct

You may be confusing cohesive and adhesive, a common confusion. The adhesive force is between the two solids. It is the force pushing or pulling, depending on how one assigns the sign, the plates together.

The sliding force is simply the downward force times coefficient of friction.

The downward force is the sum of this adhesive force plus finger pressure and gravity(as you correctly pointed out). The harder the plates are pushed together the harder it will be to slide one across the other or get them moving in the first place.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#21

Actually...

John in NM

Cohesion is between similar or identical materials (which is why it is most commonly used in fluid dynamics), and adhesion is between dissimilar materials. Bonding between a fluid and stone is certainly adhesion, however.

A component of the sliding resistance between two surfaces with a fluid in between is found using the equation you quoted, but I still maintain it is misapplied at some level in this discussion. The reason is that the force required to overcome the fluid's resistance to forming new surface is minimal compared to the fluid's action in reducing dry friction (your friction equation is the dry one btw, but its so long ago now I've forgotten the lubricated one).

So what I'm saying is that the sliding resistance of the lubricated surface is going to be less than that of the dry surface. What I have noticed is that said lubricated surface can have significant resistance to changes in sliding direction, more so than a dry surface. I believe this is where your fluid equation really comes in - the resistance to forming new surface helps counteract the tendency of our imperfect motion to rock/tilt the object being lapped as direction is changed.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#22

Re: Try this ..

Bruce Mack

Useful information in a field of contention. Were I a referee I'd break up the skirmish but the combatants would likely maim me.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#23

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

david weaver

I'm not trolling when I say this, but I've forgotten most (all for practical purposes) of my physics and trig from college and high school.

I kind of liked it better when we could just say things like "works nicely with a nice smooth action" instead of getting into long drawn out bits about why there is proof (aside from the proof that occurs when you say "try it yourself and see if you disagree").

Strange that these types of topics still generate the most interest in terms of replies.

(and I'm just as guilty arguing about double irons and shaving thickness, etc).

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#24

ahh, the trickyness of force vectors

ian neuhaus

the forces you describe are not all "downwards"

surface tension effects are attractive relative to the surfaces separated by the fluid. (for now let's not get sidetracked by the "edge" boundary between the surfaces, the fluid and the atmosphere)

the net effect (if I remember the physics / engineering correctly) is that some very small value of fluid thickness, the force required to shear the fluid (and thus allow two surfaces separated by the fluid to slide relative to each other) is determined by the attraction between the molecules of the fluid, which force is very much greater than the force generated by finger pressure or gravity or dry friction. Beyond a thickness of a few molecules, the shear resistance of a fluid is represented by the bulk properties of the fluid rather than attraction between individual molecules.

my experience is that stiction is really only an issue with water stones, and that it can be partially overcome by adding additional water or a wetting agent (soap or alcohol).

From this I surmise that the phenomena is not directly related to the flatness of the surface being polished or that of the stone, but rather the properties of the slurry which forms between the two.

With a water stone this slurry is a relatively dense mix of water, abrasive, metal particles and abrasive binder, and the stiction experienced is almost wholly due to the surface tension attraction between the water molecules wetting the slurry.

If my surmising is correct, then the absence of any significant stiction when using an oil stone would be consistent with the lower density slurry that forms on an oils stone and the lower attractive force (compared to water) between oil molecules.

I have no direct experience with diamond paste and cast iron.

Re: Explanation of misnamed stiction

#25

an additional component to sliding resistance

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"my experience is that stiction is really only an issue with water stones, and that it can be partially overcome by adding additional water or a wetting agent (soap or alcohol).

From this I surmise that the phenomena is not directly related to the flatness of the surface being polished or that of the stone, but rather the properties of the slurry "

Slurries add another component to the equation. I avoided this complexity in the previous discussions. The particles provide a mechanical impediment to motion. Particles wedge between the close portions of the slicing surfaces which are in fact rough on the scale we need to consider. The result is an apparent increase in the viscosity of the fluid/slurry. Flatness is a requirement in that significant surface area must be involved at these close distances to result in a significant effect to be observed. If the surfaces are sufficiently far apart there is no adhesive force involved and the shear properties of the liquid provide resistance. However, at this distance the surfaces are so far apart there is not abrasion.