Re: More on that Richardson Bros. saw
david weaver
On beech, the rays are only visible on the side of stock where the grain intersects the side at 90%. On most large planes, it doesn't do that on either side and no rays, but sometimes you get it on one side.
Bright beech sap and quartersawn maple don't always look too different from 6 feet away, but up close, they do. When you put a tool to them, the difference is much more stark. Maple is just harder feeling, less dead feeling, and certainly chips out a lot easier (which is no blessing making planes).
Heart beech (like the pink piece in the middle of Joe's picture), is much easier to tell. I have exceptionally few pieces of beech that are 100% sap. I just don't think the trees that are being cut now are big enough to get a nice straight long board of that. I like the weight of a plane with the heart in it, though - a try plane made of half or more heart is about a pound heavier than a try plane made of sap. I usually oil the planes made mostly of sap.
I can identify beech by sight, even when it's 100% sap, so Joe is safe getting beech from me, but buyer beware if someone found it in a pile in a barn. Plus, I've already used parts of those boards that the scrap is from.
Not that it's important, but I have those light colored boards because mike digity was retiring a few years ago, and he asked if I wanted anything. I said I wanted soft maple for drawer sides for my kitchen, and he said he didn't have any, but he had a whole bunch of 5/4 quartersawn beech, and he sold the whole pile too me for $3 a board foot.
I bought poplar later for the drawer sides. I couldn't bear to waste that beech by planing it down and putting it in kitchen drawers (who wants heavy drawers, anyway).
I've made a couple of planes out of my quartersawn maple, and a couple of handles, too, and certainly QS maple looks a lot better than the very boring flat sawn face of maple. But for the maker, it's just not the same, and it makes for a loud plane. Even just adjusting planes made with it, it's loud, and the give at the abutments (where beech fits really well) isn't quite right. Warren uses the word musical. Reminds me of making planes of cocobolo. They're pretty, but loud and they don't wear any better than beech.