We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
I have the below Richardson Brothers back saw. It was given to me by a (92 year old) friend along with a bunch of other old tools that were his grandfathers.
I've been reading up on horn repairing and thought I'd give it a go with this saw.
I believe the handle is Apple. Do you agree?
I've been looking on eBay at apple lumber to try and buy a small piece to use. It seems most of it is mostly sap wood. These handles would have been from the heart wood though, correct?
I've also been watching eBay for an old beat up Richardson Brothers saw similar to this for parts. I need a slit nut too. If I do find an old beat up one I might be able to use its handle for some of the wood also.
Saw nuts are available for $5-6 from several sources. That is probably a 1/2".
Try TGIAG saw works. They will have it. I may have a small piece of apple for you.
That is a very nice saw a definitely worthy of your time and the minimal expense. Horn repairs can be made to be almost invisible. I would strip that handle completely, but you may choose not to do that and just have a visible repair.
It's hard to tell when a saw handle is covered that much, there's a small chance it could also be beech.
Apple trees have changed since that saw was made, and now they are short narrow stems with apples at low heights, and there is no big wood available.
If you're going to use apple, it needs to be quartersawn or close to it. You never know what the stem stock of a tree is when it's apple (since something else will be grafted to the stem to ensure the quality of the apple flavor rather than letting a seed grow and just checking). I've had billets of apple, one from an abandoned tree, and another one that is probably modern. The former was wet when I got it, the latter was kiln dried. The coloration and the workability was different night and day (I worked the wet wood after it dried).
If you can't find quartersawn apple, I would try the following:
* Quartersawn beech
* quartersawn pear (that will come from europe most likely)
and there's not much else I can think of. I'd bet back in the day when disston used apple, they probably threw away five times as much apple as they used. Maybe ten times (but they also had a supply coming, probably from orchards in south central PA where there are many, and any others where lumber hawks came up with wild apple tree logs).
Rick Hearne told me that there are still a lot of large fruit trees in europe (he's got some large boards, but they cost the moon - $20 a board foot or so for a large board and only part of it will be close enough to quartered if it's a slab - no clue what you'd do with the rest of a $500 slab).
You want a board that will let you orient the handle so the grain runs straight from the top of the handle to the point of the cheeks.
I agree with David that the handle is more likely to be beach, particularly as yellow as it appears. For such a small repair I don't think you would have trouble finding suitable grain in a thick board. You can always quarter-saw a chunk out of it yourself, since beech is often cut into billets for planes and turnings. I have air-dried beech from Michigan, in billets.
I am the proud owner of (4) Richardson Bros. saws - two steel backed saws, one brass-backed saw and one crosscut panel saw. My saws have different saw nuts and differing wood handles. Two of mine have split saw nuts, like your example, and I would guess they are earlier than the other two which have domed saw nut hardware (think Disston), which I assume are later. The two earlier saws with the split nuts have birch handles. The later backsaw has a beech handle and the later panel saw has an apple handle.
Birch is quite distinctive in that it has a medium/fine pore structure on the handle sides. More coarse than maple, less coarse than, say mahogany. The pores look like little black lines on my saws. Beech is also distinctive in having the characteristic medulary ray flecks when quartersawn. Beech would also show the medulary rays prominently when looking at the endgrain. Apple is very fine grained, especially when looking at the endgrain, sort of like boxwood without the density of boxwood.
FWIW - from your photographs, your handle's squarish protrusion on the spine of the saw is like my earlier examples, so again, with the split nuts, I feel yours is earlier. The later backsaws have a protrusion rounded at the bottom edge, at least on my example.
Birch is not too common in woodworking tools. Yes, there are early examples of molding planes and some all-wood handscrews made from birch, but it is not common.
That said, when I think of Richardson saws, I think birch handles. I would guess that your saw's handle very well might be birch. Apple second choice, beech third...
I missed that you were just repairing the horn and not making an entire handle.
The handle looks like beech to me, looking closely at it. My email address is above. If you don't have some suitable beech, let me know. I'll send you some offcuts that would keep you busy in saw repairs for quite some time.
I would repair it with beech but cutting the break back to clean wood.