Spyderco stones question
Howard Pollack
I'm thinking of changing my sharpening to Spyderco stones. I think I remember that there was/is a problem with them not being truly flat. Is this the case? And if so, how does one flatten them? Thanks.
-Howard
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Spyderco stones question
Howard Pollack
I'm thinking of changing my sharpening to Spyderco stones. I think I remember that there was/is a problem with them not being truly flat. Is this the case? And if so, how does one flatten them? Thanks.
-Howard
Re: Spyderco stones question
Michael Brady
......With great difficulty. They would probably ruin any diamond plate that was applied to them. They also load quicker than any stone I have used; which means you spend time cleaning them after every use instead of flattening them. I wouldn't by them as replacements for stones I already have, but would consider recommending them for a first set.
That's my take after borrowing all three grades from a friend. I'm sure you will now get a torrent of comment from the true believers.
Re: Spyderco stones question
david weaver
They can be a little out of flat. The UFs are pretty well finished, though, and you can disregard it and just use them.
I've, in the past, had the 8x3 UF (don't favor it for freehanding), the 2" UF, and the 2" medium. The latter two were plenty flat enough to use out of the box, and the mild mill marks left on the UF were no problem.
The 8x3 had a radial pattern on it (from a lapping machine, maybe) and it was slightly low in the center.
They are ceramic, including the binder (the only type of "ceramic" stone that's truly ceramic). To flatten them, you need something that can cut ceramic, which is diamond hones or loose diamonds on a lap. you will only have to do it once, and if you do it, you'll be glad of that. Even diamonds don't cut the ceramic quickly, they just don't penetrate deeply.
it's possible that silicon carbide might be ever so slightly harder on the mohs scale, but I think the ceramic in the stones will just wear it down.
I eventually sold all of mine (don't tell George) as I favor novaculite stones more, and anything the novaculite won't cut, I'd rather use an Ezelap to establish a bevel and then pretty much anything to finish it off.
there are some similarities between them and oilstones, but where the oilstones will cut (steel 62 hardness or less, I guess, something like that), I find the oilstones to be faster and require less care/cleaning.
Re: Spyderco stones question
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia) That's my take after borrowing all three grades from a friend. I'm sure you will now get a torrent of comment from the true believers
......With great difficulty. They would probably ruin any diamond plate that was applied to them. They also load quicker than any stone I have used; which means you spend time cleaning them after every use instead of flattening them. I wouldn't by them as replacements for stones I already have, but would consider recommending them for a first set.
I have the Medium and Ultra Fine stones, which is all that are required - you do not also need the Fine. these come in 2" x 6" and are protected by a nice plastic case. I remove the lid and use them in the container.
The stones are not flat when they arrive. Most find, as I did, that they have a slight hollow in the centre. I used 250- and 600 grit Eze-lap diamond stones, and it took 15 minutes in all for each stone. After this you are home free. They remain flat. They also cut every steel I have thrown at them.
While some complain the stones load up, I suspect it is because they may use them dry. ALL stones/media require some liquid to remove swarf. I spritz with a little soapy water. No loading up.
Spyderco do not state the grit these stones are. I estimate the brown Medium is around 3000-4000, and the white Ultra Fine is about 6000-8000. I pair the stones with a worn Eze-lap Fine (600 grit), to start.It is possibleto finish on the UF, however I use green compound on hardwood. This creates a very sharp edge, and it does so quickly as I work with hollow ground blades.
Regards from Perth
Derek
Re: grit
david weaver
Either spyderco or coors (coors ceramics is the actual maker) stated that the particles are 3-5 microns, but they can't be compared to friable stones except for the very first cut, as the density of the particles determines the fineness.
If you never cleaned or abraded a spyderco again after the first lap, it would become a burnisher (at least mine did) once the entire surface was devoid of lap marks.
The medium stone has pores in it, and the particles are bound by ceramic, so a group of particles at the edge of a pore can act like a large particle.
I don't know for sure that the particles in the brown/black stone are the same size, but I suspect they're not too much different - the pores make the difference.
In both of those respects, they're very much like oilstones, just the abrasive and the binder are harder than oilstones - something not very common.
Re: Spyderco stones question
TomD
Certainly not the best thing to use exclusively. What I use them for is in the knife sharpening set-up for knives and scissors, and I use the stones now and again for sharpening very fine tools where the support the hard stone offers, without the need for oil or water is appreciated.
I think the fact you would use diamond to flatten them is a tip in the right direction. Oh, I think some people have actually added diamond to these stones to enhance cutting, though whether that is a net gain or not, I don't know.
Re: Spyderco stones question- thank you
Howard Pollack
Thanks for all of your varied input!