New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Strop question

Posts

Re: Strop question

#26

Re: a question of data and conclusions

TomD

Your cordovan is presumably chrome tanned. There are some nasty substances in there that are not accounted for by whatever happened in the living tissue.

Re: Strop question

#27

horse hide and silica

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are two routes to silica in hide. Horses are known for rolling. I suppose it is possible that dirt gets embedded in the hide and some particles could survive tanning. Or the leather simply becomes contaminated in route from horse to user. It would seem that this source would be a source of rogue scratches and not uniform polishing.

Silica has a tiny solubility in water. Jungle trees that grow in wet siliceous soils transport vast quantities of silica saturated water up their stems. Along the way some water evaporates and deposits tiny crystals of silica. In some work of Kato and Kawai these crystals appear in photomicrographs of the planed wood. Granted horses drink water and some is undoubtedly evaporated through the hide. But I would be surprised if significant silica deposited in the hide by this mechanism. If it did the amount would be highly variable depending on the water source for the horse, just as the amount of silica in trees differs widely. I am sure hide has some amount of silica but I doubt it is there in enough concentration and crystal form to be a meaningful abrasive.

If the dulling mechanism for a razor is edge deformation, something that some knife people advocate, the leather simply straightens the edge after each shave. No metal removal to effect sharpening is necessary.

Re: Strop question

#28

Re: horse hide and silica

david weaver

I believe that it (the silica) would be deposited or incorporated into the leather from a source external to the horse. Of course, I don't know that it's silica for sure, just that whatever it is, it's hard enough to scratch steel for a while, but then not. Much like novaculite and silica particles in a natural stone.

Yes on the shaving damage - the actual wear on the edge exists, and eventually you need to go to a linen instead of the leather, but the wear rate is so slow (and even the linen barely gets black - less black in five years than you'd get in a single chisels sharpening with a finish stone), that linen and leather for me is good for a year of shaving before a touch up with a hone that is again, a fraction of what would be done with a tool on a finish stone.

It is popular for new shavers to hone their razors all the time, and there were old stones that were marketed for razors that were aggressive, but they are substandard just as sharpening all the time is (and they wear down a razor quickly). The edge that's been worked on linen and leather is better than the edge off of the stones (at least as sharp, but with less tooth so that it doesn't catch skin and bumps as it goes along), and old texts and old hone instructions are specific about not removing the very edge when stoning.

There are natural abrasives that will still provide a good shave if the edge is removed, but there is a decrease in sharpness with them.

I would suspect that with a proper regimen of linen and leather, and sparing honing, a single razor could last at least 50 years of shaves. I've never seen any visual wear in any of mine, despite a couple of years worth of use on one. The bigger danger to a razor is accidental dropping or bumping into a sink.

Re: Strop question

#29

Re: a question of data and conclusions

david weaver

This is horse butt, veg. tanned. (from the butt strips, on the outside of the horse)

The only cordovan I have is horween, and I'd imagine that's full of chemicals. I kind of wish I hadn't bought the horween, it cost me a lot of money to get a shell and make a strop, and I only recovered a little bit of money selling off the scraps.

Re: Strop question

#30

Re: horse hide and silica

david weaver

By the way, I have seen no silica or anything similar in the two shell strops I've had (new ones, I've never found a vintage shell strop that wasn't dried out), but the shell is not outer skin. That's another thing that makes me think the source is external (rubbing and rolling....my mother is "horse people", by the way. I can do without them myself!)

Re: Strop question

#31

Re: The best strop for plane and chisel blades

Gary B.

Derek,

For years in a production setting I had to keep my chisels relatively sharp, quickly. I could go from a grinder with a finer wheel, to piece of scrap MDF with the green compound on it and have a pretty sharp edge in less than a minute. I love the LV green compound!

Re: Strop question

#32

Re: The best strop for plane and chisel blades

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Gary, it actually comes down to the point you make - the green compound on a hard surface aids in maintaining an edge. Whether the compound is 0.5 or 1.0 microns ... well, I just do not care. The edge is excellent, and an excellent edge makes chisels and plane blades a thing of pleasure. Importantly, this excellence comes at a minimal cost, both to the pocket and in time and effort. Just a big win all round.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Strop question

#33

Ellis Walentine

What has worked for me...

Ellis Walentine

I've had some leather strops in the past and never really became proficient with them, so I can't presume to address the original post. But, I thought I'd mention that my favorite strop is a hard-maple block impregnated with a slurry produced by a wet nagura stone, like the Japanese use on their fine-grit waterstones to create a polishing paste. The hard maple doesn't deflect like leather does, so there's little or no perceptible dubbing of the edge. The result is a clean, flat and mirror surface with just a couple strokes.

I have no idea what grit the nagura powder is, nor how it compares with LV green compound or anything else. On another note, I've always wondered how cerium oxide might work as a honing powder.

Ellis

Re: Strop question

#34

Re: What has worked for me...

Ron Harper

Just today got a piece of scrap cherry, used a smoother get it slick anfd rubbed the green stuff on it. Works great.

Re: Strop question

#35

Re: cerium oxide..

david weaver

...cerium oxide is well regarded in the razor community. I've never used it, but some of the razor folks like to play with it.

Re: Strop question

#36

. For David

Ron Harper

I have a small jar of very fine 'diamond powder". It is green wood id work well on hardwood?

Re: Strop question

#37

Re: . For David

david weaver

The diamond powder is green? It sounds like it's got chromium oxide, but chromium oxide works fine on hardwood, mdf, leather, or whatever.

Diamond works fine on all of those things, too.

Re: Strop question

#38

A reminder about waste

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There are cases where one wants an abrasive format that conforms to the shape of what is being sharpened. For example, I think that every carver I have seen carving sharpens on abrasive charged leather. In other cases, for example plane blades and chisels, sharpening on something that isn't deformable seems preferred. To that end MDF, wood etc. charged with some abrasive is recommended. Why this approach is preferred over a similarly sized abrasive stone is unclear to me.

While more or less hard and flat, all of these substrate suggestions are porous and suffer two disadvantages. Most of the grit that is added becomes uselessly embedded within the substrate. Additionally, there is no way to remove the abrasion products, presuming getting rid of the ground up metal and worn abrasive particles is advantageous.

There is a superior alternative that I have mentioned a time or two. Charge the abrasive particles, ideally diamond powder, on cast iron. A near lifetime supply of diamond powder is $15, none is wasted by embedding uselessly into the substrate, the plates stay flat and they are readily cleaned of ground up metal. Plus, diamond is the fastest abrasive to use and it is effective on any metal used for tools, including high alloy abrasion resistant steel.

Don't have a cast iron plate? Buy a cheap plane on ebay which will do fine upside down.

Re: Strop question

#39

Re: The best strop for plane and chisel blades

Dan Rode

"Whether the compound is 0.5 or 1.0 microns ... well, I just do not care. The edge is excellent, and an excellent edge makes chisels and plane blades a thing of pleasure."

I finish on a 15k Shapton today but the feel off of the green compound is different. Someone described it as silky. I often find myself taking a couple of strokes on the strop after the 15k. Doing both is probably a complete waste of time. I'm not sure that it's the BEST edge possible but I enjoy the feel. I'm drawn to the sypderco stones and a hardwood + compound stone/strop because it's simple and the end result is an edge I enjoy using.

It's also simple, cheap and durable; just like me :)

Re: Strop question

#40

Re: A reminder about waste

TomD

"While more or less hard and flat, all of these substrate suggestions are porous and suffer two disadvantages. Most of the grit that is added becomes uselessly embedded within the substrate. Additionally, there is no way to remove the abrasion products, presuming getting rid of the ground up metal and worn abrasive particles is advantageous."

Technically leather is porous, but the hard leather used on strops is an excellent medium. I guess one could ask that if cast iron is so good, why didn't barbers sharpen on that instead. I have all the media/and substrates in my shop and use the cast iron when I need a lap, but most stropping maintenance is such that so little material is removed the actual shape of the lap is not a problem. I added a few dabs of diamond (as a result of your research I think) Several years back and haven't had to do anything with it, so neither the surface absorption or the galling have been of any concern. Since it is so cold up here, I do a lot of inclement sharpening where I avoid water or oil based (you need water to clean) methods. So for a good run of time every year I have been using my one leather strop for everything. No problems.

One problem I have both for sharpening, but more pertinently with my products, is that the leather I get today is spongy compared to the leather of 20 years ago. My strop is made of old leather (and it was about 6 oz or less to start with, so there is little give after it is bonded to wood. Cordovan would be better but is about 100+ a square foot.

Re: Strop question

#41

Want to try it?

John in NM

I have plenty, it's about the only thing that will polish quartz :D

Re: Strop question

#42

Re: A reminder about waste

david weaver

8-9 ounce horse butt strips that I've bought in the US have been hard enough that you get a knocking sound when you put it on wood and knock your knuckle on the leather.

The expensive shell cordovan from horween is less hard, but still hard. The shell from foreign sources that I have used has been soft, almost like veg tanned cowhide.