New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Tips for double or twin tenons?

Posts

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#26

Re: engineering question

Bob Lang

I'm not clear which corner of this is being discussed. Going by your earlier picture, I'm thinking that the sides, when assembled will have a front & back post, a top and bottom rail, and a panel. Many Arts & Crafts pieces will have a secondary set of stiles next to the posts if the posts are really beefy, a different scenario. In your case, the assembled sides will be equivalent to a solid panel.

My philosophy when sizing mortise and tenon joints is to make the tenon as big as possible without weakening the piece that contains the mortise. The key element to the strength of the assembled joint is how deep the tenon goes into the mortised piece. 2/3 to 3/4 of the available material is what I would aim for. One fat tenon may not have as much glue surface as two skinny ones, but it is much harder to break.

Most of the engineering challenge is turning the corner. Are you going to make the back the same as the sides? I wouldn't do that unless the piece is going in the middle of a room and the back will be visible. If that's the case, keep the tenons long and bevel back the ends so they don't interfere.

A loose back will be much easier to do as it will let you get to the inside of the case from both sides.

Here is how I see a front corner, post is 1-1/4", rail is 1", rails across front are 3/4".


Here is exploded view of the joints at that corner.


hope this helps,

Bob Lang

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#27

yes- base frame

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

similar in design as picture, as chosen by client- daughter

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#29

yes

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Intended to dovetail in top and bottom front dividers as in your excellent illustration. (how do you make such a drawing?) If I dado in the side panel that would ease my concern about the short tenon there.

there will be no side panel in the china cabinet so I expect I will double tenon that frame.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#30

Re: One More Thing

Hank Knight

One more thing I forgot: I offset the mortises a little bit toward the outboard edge rather than centering them on the post. That allowed for a little more length for the inboard mitered tenon. It also allowed for more "beef" at the inside corner of the post, which I thought was a weak place in this joint.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#31

About the drawing

Bob Lang

That came from a SketchUp model, took less time to model on the computer & export the image than it did to write the reply. It's a wonderful tool for design, engineering and problem solving as you pretend to build stuff on your computer. When you're done, you know the exact size of each and every part.

Fellow I know rather well wrote a pretty good book called "Woodworker's Guide to SketchUp".

Bob Lang

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#32

Two minute mortise gauge

Warren in Lancaster, PA

If you are still lacking in the gauge department, you can make mortise gauges for this project in about two minutes apiece.

Take a nice piece of hardwood about 1X1X8 and four brads. Mark out 1/2, 3/4, and 1 inch from an end. Drill small holes for the brads at 1/2 and 3/4, then saw down 3/8 inch at the one inch mark. That will be the fence. Then saw from the end at 3/8 from the side to complete the fence. Hammer the brads in. You can make fine adjustment to the nails with a file to fit your mortice chisel, and you can make another gauge at the other end of the rod. Precise and repeatable.

Here is a gauge from Nicholson (1812):


Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#33

What version sketchup?

BrianMonumentCO

Bob,

What version of Sketchup and what kind of host.

I am about to acquire sketchup.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#34

Re: I worried that would be the answer

TomD

You can make a marking gage a lot faster than I can borrow it.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#35

Re: I worried that would be the answer

TomD

You can make a marking gauge a lot faster than I can borrow it. I do most of my work with one gauge, the Japanese gauges are faultless at picking up lines, but still some situations demand more than one.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#36

Re: I worried that would be the answer

TomD

Since you have the mortising machine, you can just drive a mortise into a piece for the fence, take a single cut to ramp it. Insert a floating wedge, and a beam, a drywall screw. Five minutes? Not a whole lot longer to make it pretty. Japan woodworker has very nice blades for them, and you can grind blades from saw stock.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#37

Re: Two other reasons...

TomD

1) in parallel they deal with racking, and the pedestal below, is a goo example of that.

2) in series they deal with expansion issues

3) and a bonus answer... They either add strength to the tenon, or reduce weakening the mortised member.

Re: Tips for double or twin tenons?

#38

Re: What version sketchup?

Bob Lang

There are two versions of SketchUp, "Make" and "Pro". The only place I would download from is directly from SketchUp at sketchup.com. Make is free for personal use, and Pro costs about $600 for the initial license and around $100/year for maintenance and support. Either version runs on PCs and Macs and there isn't any difference between the files. I use Pro and keep up with the latest version.

When you first download, the installation is a 30-day trial of SketchUp Pro. At the end of the 30 days, it reverts back to the free version if you don't purchase a license. Functionally there isn't that much difference between the two versions, although Pro has "Solid Tools" that are very cool for joinery; tails can be used to make pins or tenons can be used to make mortises with two clicks. You can still do that sort of thing in the free version, but it takes a bit longer. The big difference is the type of files you can import and export, and Pro has a page layout program that makes printing much easier.

The good thing is you can learn on the free version and then upgrade when/if you feel the need. The free version will meet the needs of most woodworkers.

I don't want to hijack this thread and turn it into a self-serving pitch, but I teach and write about SketchUp. I'm extremely enthusiastic about it after many years experience drafting by hand and using AutoCAD. There is a bunch of information in excruciating detail on my website, readwatchdo.com.

Bob Lang