New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

Save Your Pennies

Posts

Re: Save Your Pennies

#26

Re: No electrons

Steve Voigt

Looking good, Dave! Nice to see you back in the saddle again.

And, I'll concur with the remarks about the flatsawn side being noticeably tougher to push through than the QS side. On the other hand, the FS side is less tearout prone. If I have to fiddle with the cap iron, it's always on the QS side.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#27

Re: Curious about the beech...

John in NM

As I understand it, the steaming mitigates some of the instability in beech - and when you mentioned the pronounced anisotropy in hardness, I wondered if there was a correlation in other properties vs. dimensions.... The mind makes connections, some silly, some not :D

The trouble is, I mostly shape that steamed beech with a belt sander and spindle sander. I wouldn't notice hardness differences the way you would planing it, so I was wondering if you'd tried some. I can save you a bit next time I buy it. I have scraps on hand, but nothing big enough for a plane of any size.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#28

results of steaming

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I was friends with the owner of a furniture factory (now closed like most of them in these parts) that worked a lot of walnut, all of which they steamed. Joe claimed that steamed walnut was a "different species" meaning that it worked different.

No doubt someone has studied the changes but I have never seen a report. One can smell furfural around the steamer which means some cellulose molecules are being reduced in size. May or may not be significant.

Steam will extract lignin, the glue that holds the tree parts together. There is not a lot of water that runs out of a steamer so I would not think lignin removal is significant.

Steaming will temporarily soften the wood allowing any stress to relax but as far as I know this effect is temporary.

Bottom line- I don't know what steaming does. I'll see if I can find out. In the case of beech it enables it to dry straighter, which implies some change in the tree's cells.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#29

Re: results of steaming

david weaver

The several steamed beech billets I got felt more dry than other beech that I've gotten. I haven't had air dried beech yet, but I suspect for a hand tooler, it would be the best to work.

I'm rectifying that soon, not in large quantities, just in a few sticks. I'm sure it moves more than KD or steamed, but if it's sawn quartered with pith properly centered, that won't matter.

It's difficult to be historically accurate on anything, anyway, as old planes were sap almost entirely (if reading old texts is to be believed - and by the density of a lot of the older planes, I'd say it seems accurate).

One side comment, I think I read somewhere that the beech is steamed also to even color. Maybe I said that already.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#30

Re: Curious about the beech...

david weaver

I do have a billet of it left. The billet I have is big enough for a couple of moulding planes, but not for anything else. George Wilson gave it to me to make saw handles, and I did that thus far, but there isn't enough planing in a saw handle to remember how it planes. I'll just plane the billet I have - I'd imagine the density difference in early to late wood is probably a big factor in why it planes so easily quartered, but that's just a guess.

The color is definitely a lot more even in the steamed euro beech that I have. Since my billets of american beech are non steamed and mostly a mix of heart and sap, it takes a while for their color to even out after a plane is made.

thanks for the offer, though, on the sticks. I should have enough on hand to make a good guess.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#31

Re: results of steaming

TomD

Steaming accelerated drying, evens out colour in walnut so the sapwood changes to a dark wood. As far as work ability, most commercial wood feels different than air dried and has worse colour, but I don't know why, it could just be storage conditions. Worse meaning feels less resilient. Wood looses tensile strength above and below certain levels, and it seems to be something you can cycle thousands of times. For instance bows will get worse as they are out for the day, then they get stored in dry conditions and come back. The bows can last years and go through that cycle every day of use. That is measurable in stuff like flight shooting.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#32

Re: results of steaming

TomD

A lot of wood is steamed as part of the kiln drying process. I don't know if it evens beech wood out or not though, because for one thing I don't know if German plane makers kiln dry their wood.

I have worked both beech I cut and beech someone else cut and presumably kiln dried. Both were nice wood to work. I think air dried wood is always a little more plastic, but then wood varies a bit at the best of times. Also when working personally cut wood one often uses different tools. I made a lot of slabs with the chainsaw, but also split out balks of the beech, so one ends up axing and spiting and drawn knifing, and a lot of that work gets done while the wood is still wet. So it is hard to be objective about it all.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#33

Question for Warren....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think I read somewhere that beech plane blanks were boiled before drying by some makers, presumably to stabilize the beech. Any truth to this recollection?

Re: Save Your Pennies

#34

Boiling

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Yes apparently plane makers boiled the blanks for several hours and than air dried the blanks for several years. I believe there is documentation of this for the late 19th century, early 20th. I would be surprised if this were done 200 years ago, just my instincts.

As to what is accomplished I don't know. Beech is susceptible to fungal attack. It has a bit of a sugary sap like maple so boiling would tend to remove sugar and any salts or other soluble nutrients. It might kill bacteria and fungus present in the wood. I guess it is possible it interferes with structure of the wood or the chemistry of the "bound" water. Some have suggested the the boiled beech is more stable or dries faster.

With American beech, I have only worked air dried material, not boiled and not kiln dried. In my experience, beech that has been air dried for several years is reasonably stable, though it might have shrunk or twisted while drying.

I have worked European beech (presumably steamed), but not enough to notice definite differences.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#35

One last update

david weaver

Normally I start oiling planes after the handle is sunk.

However, with the temperature at or slightly below zero overnight here, just in one day after lapping the bottom of the plane, I started to get some cosmetic checking on the sole of the plane.

Too late to scrap it at this point, after about ten or a dozen hours of work. I'll give it a week to see if the color evens out as the checking isn't even enough to get a fingernail to catch, just a very slight line, but when you oil the sole of a plane, it really highlights anything that takes in oil faster than the rest of the wood.

I do have a plane that I've made that does have a minor *open* check, but it, too is confined to the bottom of the plane.

Some of the bits and pieces that look funny colored (like behind the mouth) are just from wax on the sole as I was troubleshooting feeding around the wear (sometimes wax helps). that kind of stuff on the bottom of the plane (coloration) doesn't really matter too much. All of it will get a lot more oil before it's done, but I will have to scrape some of it off on the top to be able to get a pencil mark to make the handle mortise.

http://s28.postimg.org/a85bbn3gd/P1080536.jpg

http://s24.postimg.org/7iga7v16t/P1080537.jpg

http://s8.postimg.org/87xz0vh45/P1080541.jpg

http://s24.postimg.org/prn22666d/P1080544.jpg

Just the perils of working with beech in such low humidity. The wood as sawn is fine, no problem, if the plane is oiled or waxed even just a little, no problem. But that short period of time while making and if there's no humidity source nearby and there's stuff to deal with.

Of course, we can always do the same thing again this summer if the auction disappoints.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#36

Re: One last update

TomD

That sucks. I don't know what the deal is with this beech. I haven't had any problems yet, you are scaring me.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#37

Re: One last update

David weaver

It's just circumstances this time, I think. This is the only two week period that it has been cold and dry, and it just happened to be at a time when rhe wood in the plane is freshly planed.

Most of the rest of the year, I'd have had no problem.