New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Save Your Pennies

Posts

Save Your Pennies

#1

Save Your Pennies

david weaver

I'm going to make a try/long plane for auction in the benefit auctions, and if still OK and needed, it will be for the benefit of Stephen Shepherd.

Same basic plane that Brian Holcombe shows the straight chips coming out of, and it'll have some sort of mainline sheffield maker's double iron in it (butcher, greaves, ward...just haven't settled on which iron and cap yet).

I will make the plane ex handle, and then after the auction, make the handle based on the hand size of the winner so that nobody can end up with an uncomfortable plane.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#2

Speaking of handles

Paul in NJ

Speaking of handles, I have seen vintage ones where the handle is off-set to one side of the plane body. I have never used a plane with the off-set handle. It would be interesting (at least to me) to hear the reasoning behind that and also of anyone's experience using one.

As far as size goes, I have never had a problem with smallish plane or saw handles. Most often I use an light open grip with most of my fingers outside the tote, pushing from the web between my index finger and thumb. I do not have small hands.

Regards,

Paul Dzioba

Re: Save Your Pennies

#4

Re: Speaking of handles

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Paul, David, and all,

Very, very generous of David--hope the bids will match!

On the question of offset handles....I have handled planes made by Clark & Williams (now Old Street). Bill Clark, who made the bench planes at that time, always asked the customer if they wanted an offset handle. The offset was small, typically 1/8 to 1/4", depending on plane width.

What Bill said was that the user's lead hand on a long plane would tend to rest on or have a bias toward the near side of the plane, since you are reaching somewhat across your body; therefore the handle was offset slightly toward the far side, so that the user's handle hand and lead hand tended to balance the rotational pressure on the plane. These considerations would only pertain to edge jointing, I think, where the plane is balanced on an edge.

He wasn't adamant about the offset though, and always asked if you wanted it, or if you preferred the handle centered. I have C&W long planes done both ways (offset and centered), and don't notice the difference, say, on edge jointing. But someone with a more refined touch might notice....

Wiley

Re: Save Your Pennies

#5

Re: Offset

david weaver

Hopefully, I won't squash the information George Wilson has told me into an unrecognizable pile of incorrectness.

Older planes had offset handles, and sometimes the closed handles were lower. As wiley says, it more or less makes planing more of a two handed affair.

According to George, an offset handled plane makes it harder for you to close your grip (especially if the grip is short) and makes it harder to develop repetitive stress or grip injuries.

I have made two planes with offset grips. One is a panel raiser (which you have two hands on at one time, anyway - but that was probably a dumb idea), and the other is a jack plane. The panel raiser also has a very short handle, which I don't favor and my jack plane's handle is admittedly a little too large (the ideal handle height is different for open handles than it is for closed handles). I could take or leave the offset handle (I prefer it to be centered if I really have a choice), but it does make you realize how you get a little extra out of a plane in terms of removing material heavily if you get both hands on it and skew it a little bit.

My offset is about 1/4" on both planes. I've been using the jack a lot, and am getting used to it. Whatever you use, offset or not, you'll get used to it and learn to work well with it.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#6

Re: ooops..

david weaver

i responded below about the offset. Having a somewhat open grip is a good thing, less fatigue.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#7

Re: if someone would want an offset..

david weaver

..I won't be sinking the handle until after the auction is over, so I can do whatever is requested in terms of handle location.

It'll take several weekends for me to put together a plane body, but I'll make a big deal when I do it to try to generate some interest.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#10

GENEROUS, THANK YOU 


Re: Save Your Pennies

#11

Re: Speaking of handles

William Duffield

You might notice it a bit more if you tried one offset for a left hander. At least I notice it (adversely) if I try to use one that is offset to the far side (for a right hander).

Thank you, David. I'm sure Stephen's needs are ongoing, and he will continue to appreciate the help.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#12

Re: No electrons

david weaver

Given the reason the plane is being made, and that this is a hand tool related item, I have used no power tools. Not for billet sizing, resawing or opening the mouth or anything. I'll continue to use only hand tools until this one is finished.

http://s22.postimg.org/fba5rlum9/20160206_205928.jpg

http://s18.postimg.org/5hlngbysp/20160206_205948.jpg

http://s27.postimg.org/p97vpp9kj/20160206_205958.jpg

(you can make out which shavings are jack and which are try plane shavings in that pile. The jack shavings are over 2 hundredths thick in the flatsawn face of beech - it takes some humping to work them through the jack plane).

I'd say something about no sanding, too, but I will lap the bottom on a sanded lap because I always end up with a better working plane that way - call it lack of skill on planing and scraping a sole flat in every way. I don't usually sand anything else on a plane, anyway.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#13

Re: No electrons

david weaver

And the shine...

As I was finishing sizing and squaring the billet, one side of it has a whole lot of sheen.

As we've come to know, when the plane is set and not tearing out the quartered face of these billets, thick shavings come shooting out straight up. The shine is an indication of the finish on the prior pass across the board with the try plane.

http://s22.postimg.org/9nhn5xuf5/P1080510.jpg

The plane doing the planing is the last plane I made, it's been a few months now, and I made it for myself to replace a plane I had made earlier. It's the first one I'm really happy with, I'd say. If, for some reason, I bungle "stephen's" plane, I will just auction it instead.

More of the billet of the current plane.

http://s27.postimg.org/naepedf3n/P1080513.jpg

(of course, one side is like this, and the other side looks more plain)

Re: Save Your Pennies

#14

Re: No electrons

Brian Holcombe

Gorgeous! The plane is coming out nicely and I see the Kiyotada is being put to work :D

That shaving is awesome, those beech billets must be really enjoyable to work.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#15

Re: No electrons

david weaver

Good eye on the kiyotada! This is the first job that it's really gotten real use. I didn't realize at first that it was set up primary only (I thought I had used it for something), and I immediately went to beating it into the billet and it shed a few carbides, shall we say.

I stepped the bevel up a little bit with it on a washita by lightly rounding it up another 3 or 4 degrees (don't tell anyone, chisels this hard take a highly polished edge off of a washita, but you wouldn't want to remove much material with it). It went through the rest of the job without shedding anything else and I could still ride the bevel in the mortise. It's way early in its lifetime to tell what the edge holding will be, but it's already fine. One of those things where it's a shame not to use it if you have it, even though you can mortise a plane body fine with a construction grade chisel.

Beech is a wonderful wood to work when you're working the quartered face. It's just a hair harder than I'd like on the flatsawn face - most or all stuff works easier on a quartered face, but on beech, the difference is probably 2 to 1. The quartered face feels like cherry, and the flat face feels like maple. On the quartered face, the shavings come off one after the other just like that once you've got the surface flat and are just working to the mark. You could take those and make a bouquet of them. Very satisfying.

The thicker jack shavings on the flatsawn face of the board are a two handed affair - the discussion above about the offset (and two handing the plane) gets some relevance with them!! Continental smoothers are also good that type of thing, just lacking in sole length a little. But you can really crank on them with two hands.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#16

Re: Speaking of handles

david weaver

Offset being on the wrong side would be a pretty rough affair. I noticed on the first middle handle plane I made (where I had just prior switched from a metal jointer), the handle height made it so that I had to think a little to keep edges square. The offset would've helped in that case because it would've been biased in the right direction, but it would've compounded the problem if it wasn't.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#17

Re: No electrons

Brian Holcombe

With the bevel dialled in I wonder how long it will go between sharpenings, or even stone stropping. Probably quite a significant amount of time, as my kikuhiromaru go quite a while between sharpening and probably give them a quick once over every time I use them for a significant project.

I'm always very careful about using the plane on it's side for that same reason, that the quarter sawn surfaces are softer, making sure it's properly waxed up if I do. It's so much easier to shoot with a try plane of this size than it is to use a 7 plane or a metal Jack, so much so that it's hard to avoid using it to shoot long grain.

My limited experiences with beech have been identical, the quarter sawn grain shavings could be used as pillow stuffing.

Those shavings from the Jack plane are awesome. The first time I ran the Jack long grain and it took a heavy shaving that was about the thickness of modern veneer.....and still left a shiny scallop I believe I spent a few long moments in amazement.

These planes have changed my experience from 'ugh, I have to flatten a panel' to 'yay, I get to flatten a panel!'.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#18

Curious about the beech...

John in NM

I use a fair amount of it - though what I can get around here is steamed European beech - and I've not noticed a big difference in hardness one direction to the other. I wonder if that is the steaming process?

I actually like beech a lot (the stuff I get anyway). It is fairly well behaved, and quite attractive in it's plain sort of way.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#19

Re: Curious about the beech...

david weaver

I'm not sure if it's the steaming or if it's just that it's a different tree. I can't remember what the steaming sets out to accomplish, but it definitely looks more uniform than american beech. American beech sap is less dense and less hard than the heart. The heart reminds me of the heart in an apple tree.

I ususally have planes that have heart and sap, because that's just what's available from horizon.

As long as it's sawn with the pith on center, whether it's rift or quartered, it seems to be well behaved. If the pith is off center, it twists, even if it's already dry.

I have a tiny amount of european steamed beech that george wilson gave me, and all i've made of it so far is a saw handle. It's nice wood (I only have quartersawn).

Re: Save Your Pennies

#20

Re: No electrons

david weaver

I think the kiyotada will probably be a low maintenance chisel. It's destined to mortise large plane bodies in my shop (and maybe small ones), with all kinds of stones nearby, so life will be easy.

It's not like I can send it back to the maker!!

I haven't had anything that would need an edge shot since making planes, but one thing that comes to mind is that most of my planes aren't square after lapping!! They're only square at the outset when making the billet, and then I don't check again.

Close enough, I guess. Your bench is clean enough that I doubt the side of the plane will get a scratch, even though it's soft.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#21

Re: Speaking of handles

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Sir Wm and all,

Great point, and one that might be missed by a left-hander buying without actually getting their hands on the plane!

One other thing occurs....when edge jointing, I find that hands work together (as they will), but the job done by each hand is different. For me (maybe not others), control of plumb is done just about entirely by the lead hand--it's got direct control. The handle hand is mainly pushing the plane, though it joins in steadying the plumb which is set by the lead hand.

Your point is an excellent caution for left handers buying vintage try planes.

Wiley

Wiley

Re: Save Your Pennies

#22

Not too long yet before finish

david weaver

http://s14.postimg.org/57a6u8h0h/P1080535.jpg

Doesn't look like much has happened since the prior picture, but the iron is prepared and bedded, the escapement opened up, eyes cut and the wear moved to zero mouth before lapping the sole.

Another weekend should see it ready to be auctioned off.

Usually, the only three things I'll use that are powered are a cordless drill, bandsaw and sometimes an old us made powered miter saw. In keeping with the spirit of this plane and who it is for the benefit of, I didn't do any of that, just a miter box to keep the ends square. I often cut them freehand then then plane the endgrain with a stanley 4 until it's smooth. when I do that, they're nowhere close to square. I guess I can't say too much yet as I haven't planed the endgrain on the ends of this one, but it should be closer to square than my usual efforts (I have no idea why that would matter, though!!)

Re: Save Your Pennies

#23

Re: No electrons

Brian Holcombe

Yeah I have a feeling it will serve well!

They must not have moved much if at all, though I have not checked. I check the edges after shooting and they're right on square.

Hah, and that one side of my bench has like a strip of wax now as well.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#24

Re: No electrons

david weaver

Results by work is far more reliable than putting a square to the plane!

That billet you have was the hardest billet to plane that I have ever had in beech, so I probably made some extra passes on it, making it out of square one way or another over its height/width, which is far longer a span than the things you'll strike with it.

If you look at it and find it's out of square, you might not trust it then, even if it does well :) (it shouldn't move/twist, if it's out of square, it's my doing)

The lure of the low friction is strong, and I forgot to make a comment about your mention of dimensioning being a pleasant thing - it is straight up on the mark. Nobody can get a good feel for dimensioning and how hard it is or isn't until they have the chance to use good saws and the right planes for pre-smoother work. It's a pleasure that I'm not willing to forgo.

Re: Save Your Pennies

#25

Re: No electrons

Brian Holcombe

Hah, exactly, if I start checking things I'll be tempted to tune them :D

Anything larger than 3/4" I usually turn upright and square in the normal fashion, so if it is slightly out of square it's so small an amount that it doesn't show up in 1/2"-3/4".

Low friction was key for me! It has a large effect on how the blades are treated as well. I won't sharpen the edge of this blade until I can literally see the edge looking straight on. On a metal plane the same edge would not even attempt to make a shaving, on this I'm usually still turning those nice straight shavings but it will start to get difficult at the beginning of the cut, or the finish will become slightly rougher.