New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Marking gauges.....

Posts

Marking gauges.....

#1

Marking gauges.....

roger lance

Derek started a series on hand tools we actually use and I thought I might add to that theme by looking at marking gauges.

I've got three that I built and a LV classic which is no longer offered.....


So what are you using ??

Re: Marking gauges.....

#2

Re: Marking gauges.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well Roger, they say that you cannot have enough marking gauges .... well, that's my story! Here are a few of the ones that get used most of the time.

My all-time favourite is a Kinshiro mortice gauge (on the right), for two reasons: firstly, it was a gift some years ago from Wiley, and secondly it cuts the cleanest lines, either singly or in pairs. The Kinshiro make is no longer produced, although there are a number of very similar ones available. I purchased a couple of cheapies, and then modified them, converting them to single cutter designs.


One of the advantages of gauges that have the cutter at the very end of the arm is that you can set it up very easily for dovetails ..


You can do this also with wheel gauges. I have a few of these as well. I especially like the anniversary stainless steel ones that LV brought out a few years ago. These have an offset head (for longer registration), plus more heft. They feel very solid in the hand. Tough if you did mot get them when you could!


I do have one of the micro adjustable Tite-Marks. It is a super gauge, but micro adjustability is not necessary, if someone wants to know.

The one problem I find with the Kinshiro is setting it for mortices that are offset. A gauge with fixed cutters would be better. Consequently, I built a mortice cutting gauge that uses fixed blades. These are held in a "cartridge" and changed for the size required ..


I have recently added a Veritas wheel gauge that can be set in a similar manner - the advantage of this one is that the wheel cutters are used independently to increase downforce (the dual wheel cutters I have used are difficult to achieve sufficient downforce with). This shows much promise.


Lastly, another favourite is a wheel gauge I built. It started as a dual cutter mortice gauge, but has been in use as a single cutter.


Regards from London

Derek

Re: Marking gauges.....

#3

Re: Marking gauges.....

roger lance

Derek.....hope you don't mind my extending your topic idea.....please continue this theme.

My marking gauges got to their ergonomic form with your help here on this forum.

Thanks again.

With you in London, I've been thinking about a movie I liked.....Quigley Down Under......featuring the English actor, Alan Rickman.....what a villain he was !!

Re: Marking gauges.....

#4

Re: Marking gauges.....

Brian Holcombe


From left to right is Matsui, Kinshiro, then Blue Spruce.

I also have a LN panel gauge which does the job well.

Matsui is a great replacement for the now unavailable Kinshiro.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#5

Re: Marking gauges.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Derek.....hope you don't mind my extending your topic idea.....please continue this theme.

My marking gauges got to their ergonomic form with your help here on this forum.

Thanks again.

With you in London, I've been thinking about a movie I liked.....Quigley Down Under......featuring the English actor, Alan Rickman.....what a villain he was !!

Hi Roger

Great idea to pick up on the theme. I started it to get some involvement of the forum by other members - hoping that it would inspire some to eventually move beyond tools to builds. The idea of 'tools that we use' (as opposed to tools that we own) is really very useful in separating out those that are workers.

So come on guys, let's see or hear about the tools you find useful, made or bought.

Regards from London (returning to Perth tomorrow)

Derek

Re: Marking gauges.....

#6

Re: Marking gauges.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Brian

The cutter on the Matsui looks different from the Kinshiro. Comment?

The Blue Spruce gauge looks like it was made by Hamilton Toolworks for BP. Do you think?

Regards from London

Derek

Re: Marking gauges.....

#7

Re: Marking gauges.....

Brian Holcombe

Derek, different in which way? They are shaped very similarly.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#8

Re: Marking gauges.....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Brian, the Matsui has a larger V as a result of the increase relief grind. The Kinshiro has a minimal relief grind. The size of the Matsui makes it look like it could be used both directions (I know this is not intended). What I asked was whether this made any difference in use (since the balance may be altered).

Regards from London (back to Perth tomorrow)

Derek

Re: Marking gauges.....

#9

Re: Marking gauges.....

Tony

The Marking Gauges sold by Dave are in fact made by Hamilton.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#10

I'll play

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Here's mine:


left to right:

Gauge, the first, is one I just plain lifted from Roger's design that he posted a couple years ago. He even sent me a pic of the blade so I could copy that. Second most used in the shop.

#2 is the first tool I ever made. Blade from an Xacto knife.

#3 is the Veritas wheel gauge, most used.

#4 is an old Stanley gauge that I found amongst my grandfather's stuff. Presumably he used it. He was a Swedish cabinet builder/carpenter who emigrated from Sweden in 1915.

#5 is a Stanley #98, given to me by Paddy O'Deen, and really useful when you have a whole bunch of mortises to mark.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#11

Re: Marking gauges.....

Brian Holcombe

Still about the same, thought it's hard to tell since they're different sizes. Both seem to work best slightly tilted forward and being pulled in the right hand.

They'r relatively cheap, it's worthy addition to your collection, I'd grab one...I thought it would be second to my Kinshiro and it's really the other way around.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#12

I'll play too

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Although I have somehow inadvertently acquired 18 marking and mortise gauges (19 if you count the butt mortise gauge), I have two frequent fliers and one I wanted to show:



Front to back:

1) A Stanley 90, one of my two frequent fliers. This is nice when marking thin stock, and stock with, say, a rabbet when you have to mark from the inner wall of the rabbet. The beam can be flipped over in the fence so that the thin side's registering against the stock (picture below makes this clearer).

2) A Stanley 64-1/2, the other frequent flier. Stanley's 64 and 65 (and fractional variants) gauges, and the less common 164/165, retain the pin in a slot clamped shut with a screw. The pin is easily removed for sharpening by just loosening the screw. You can also easily set it with more or less projection, nice if you have to jump over a low projection on the edge of the stock, as I needed to do recently. The 64-1/2 is distinct for its oval head/fence, very comfortable in the hand. The 164/165 series gauges have a cast brass fence on one face of the fence that can be used to gauge around mild inside and outside curves (there were gauges designed for gauging around curves; Goodell-Pratt, at least, made one, an example of which made its way to my herd).

3) I bought this later Stanley 65 because the shape of the beam should permit great visibility of the pin, so you can start/stop the line exactly where you need it. I am so fond of the 64-1/2 that I've consistently forgotten to try it out. I show it here because I think it's a better design than the older 65, which has a rectangular head, not as comfy in the hand.

Showing the faces:



You can see the reversible fence on the 90, the comfy oval head on the 64-1/2, and the (at least in theory, but, again, I haven't tested it) nifty design of the beam on the later-model 65.

Although I keep intending to do all that sophisticated filing that turns a round point on the pin into a pointed oval shape, I've been soldiering along for years with a plain old sharp pin; it's worked so far.

These all have rules built into the beam, useful for rough work, although I always test the measurement against the fence for anything precise.

Not shown here is my version of Bruce's grandfather's gauge, a Disston gauge that came to me from my father's father, by way of Dad's garage when we cleaned it out. It's a demonstration that Disston made great saws, but didn't necessarily pick the best vendors when stamping the Disston name on other products. I don't use it, but of course I keep it.

Re: Marking gauges.....

#13

Re: I'll play too

Patrick Gibbons

Bill, the 65 you show is one of the best designs Stanley developed. I have an old boxwood one that the pin broke out and was replaced with a larger size. This is that design's main flaw. Recently I bought a NOS maple one. I've been meaning to build one without a thumb screw, but a wedge instead. That, along with an improvement to the pin, takes away the design's major weaknesses. My criticisms aside, I prefer it above other general markers.