New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Marking knives

Posts

Marking knives

#1

Marking knives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Well the forum is really slow. We cannot go into Christmas without something to read ... and more so, to tempt you to post a picture or two. This one is easy .. the marking knives/tools that you use and find indispensible .. not the prettiest necessarily, but the most useful, and why.

Here are the ones that live on the wall behind my bench ...


From left to right:

1. A wide Damascas kiridashi. This is a single bevel, but wide enough to flip and strike on both sides. It is a medium heavy blade that will take some pressure. I must admit that I bought it because the steel is so gorgeous, but it works as well as it looks.

2. Skinny kiridaski, with a double bevel, used for sliding against deep and/or narrow walls, such as when transferring 2" deep dovetails.

3. Shopmade heavy duty kiridashi, for use when high downforce is needed, used to strike deeper lines.

4. Glen Drake kerf starter - this is fantastic for scoring the tail lines before sawing. It ensures that the saw blade will follow a line perfectly (when sawing dovetails, all hinges on this line being perfectly square). The "blade" is steel the thickness of the saw plate, and ends in a fine scraper hook.

5. Swann-Morton scalpel. This little brass knife was resurrected a while ago when I finally managed to find blades (now I have a lifetimes worth!). It belonged to my grandfather, who passed away 50 years ago. I acquired a new version recently, when purchasing the blades, and the inscription is different. This is the type of blade made popular by Paul Sellers. Indeed, it is a nice knife to use, but one must remember to angle the tiny bevel so it registers in the vertical.

6, 7 and 8. Three "Cohen" knives (OK, the first is a scratch awl) made by Chris Vesper, but designed by yours truly. Years ago I was making this design for limited sale but mostly as gifts. Chris was looking for a detail knife and asked to use the design. He does a better job than I. I have no financial part in this, so can recommend them to anyone wanting something special. They are really comfortable in the hand, held like a pencil. There are two models, one a standard width (same as a saw blade), which is good for most dovetail transfering or detail marking, and the other is super thin, which is the only knife blade that will get into single kerf "London" dovetails. The scratch awl is the tool to use when marking a measured line. A "dot" is more accurate to align than a slight knife line, which is unlikely to be perpendicular to the rule.

9. Chris Vesper heavy duty knife - this is a double bevel knife that can also be used as a (skew) chisel for cleaning out dovetail sockets. It snuggles into the palm. Very powerful.

10. Lee Valley "Woodworker's Knife". I modified the blade from a hook to straight edge, and honed wide bevels on each side to make it work on both hands. The straight blade enables more than just the tip to enter the wood. The thick blade doubles for riving blanks for draw bore pegs. This is the knife I take to demonstrations.

I hope some of this is helpful. Interested in what you use, and why.

Best wishes for the festive season from Perth, Australia ...

Derek

Re: Marking knives

#2

Re: Marking knives

roger lance

This is my group.....the two Pfeil knives were made from blades they sell.....


The wood shavings aren't as dramatic this time.....

Re: Marking knives

#4

Re: No scratch awl, Roger?!

roger lance

The awls I have are mainly used to locate holes for drilling.....rarely use one to scratch a line.....the middle one was made by a turner friend of mine who appreciated that spalted beech wood I gave him.....


I appreciate his thoughtful gift.....

Re: Marking knives

#5

Re: No scratch awl, Roger?!

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Roger

Yes. Those awls have long blades and the handles are really designed for pushing down, rather than being held like a shorter pencil for more delicate control. I would add 3- or 4-sided edges to use them as birdcage awls for screw holes.

Build a small scratch awl using a 1/8" HSS drill bit (drill it into the handle, and sharpen up the other end).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Marking knives

#6

I have an excuse.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have been in Bavaria the past two weeks.


Those kings had nice places to spend their summers. But the furniture, which I was not allowed to photograph , was not much to look at. interestingly all the screws in the hinges were clocked. Tidy Germans!

Violin shop in Mittenwald.


Re: Marking knives

#7

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I had breakfast one morning with a couple from Perth. They didn't know you...and I thought you were famous :)

They were pleased you were using reclaimed Jarah.

Re: Marking knives

#8

Re: I have an excuse.....

Kevin French

Nice pics

I love to spend some time hiking around Schloss Hohenschwangau. I've been to Neuschwanstein twice but just for the tour.

Re: Marking knives

#9

No pictures!  Blame the conservators...

John in NM

My sister once explained how much sense it made to prevent all that UV from millions of tourists' flashes (I remain skeptical though).

Re: Marking knives

#10

Re: Marking knives

Brian Holcombe

Hoping gauges can join in as well :D


Kiridashi that I use for bonsai (grafting) and occasional marking out. The other is blue spruce.

The gauges are Matsui, Kinshiro and Blue Spruce.

Re: Marking knives

#11

Re: Marking knives

Ron Harper

I have a hock knife, a Veritas spear point knife, and the Stanley knife that Paul Sellers uses. I saw him using it in a video a few years ago,I tried it,and it has been my go to knife since then.

Re: Marking knives

#12

Re: Marking knives

William Duffield

I'm going to have to pass on this discussion. I'm away from the shop and the tool photos for the holidays.

I think the Hand Tool Forum is slow enough that this thread won't scroll off the first page for a few days at least, so maybe you'll see some blades from me when I get home.

Of course, each of you can individually set the time threads stay on the front page, and some people are still impatient with loading time, so it might be better to start a new thread.

Re: Marking knives

#13

Re: Marking knives

John Pappas

"and the Stanley knife that Paul Sellers uses"

I also use that Stanley knife. Can all these other styles of knives really offer significantly better results? Perhaps I need a day with a highly skilled craftrsman.

Re: Marking knives

#14

Re: Marking knives

Ron Harper

John,

I have been at this for 38 years. During that time I have learned that there are several things that we get excersized about for no good reason other than that is the way we were taught. Sharpening is chief among these. But marking a line is also one. Guys will spend 150 bucks for a knife tgat will mark no better line than you can mark with your. 8 dollar Stanley knife. I call them distinctions that make no real difference.

I cannot be judgmental about this, as I have more than 20 handsaws. I really need 3. Not to mention way too many planes.

Ron

Re: Marking knives

#15

Re: Marking knives

Sgian Dubh

Do you mean Ron, that most people could manage with a collection similar to below (all I've got) for 99% of knife line needs? The middle one is for marking tails to pins, or vice-versa, when dovetailing just in case you're wondering. Slainte.


Re: Marking knives

#16

Yep! 😎


Re: Marking knives

#17

Re: Marking knives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ron and Richard, you are obviously both philistines of the first degree! :D

Everyone knows that the quality of a knife line is proportional to the cost of the blade that strikes it. You are both in grave danger of producing substandard work, Richard you especially! Your knives look like a blind beaver has gnawed them out of a nearby bog. Get thee both to Swan-Morton! :D

Best wishes for the Festive Season

Derek

Re: Marking knives

#18

😎


Re: Marking knives

#19

Maybe next week......

roger lance

start a thread with marking gauges.

Re: Marking knives

#20

A few scratch awls

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I decided to put up some of my scratch awls (don't ask how many more I have - hey, they come cheap at yard sales!). Like Roger, I use my awls mainly to locate holes or layout spots, rather than as scribers. I generally use marking gauges, knives, or pencils to scribe a layout line. I should note, though, that a high percentage of my work in recent years has been carpentry; maybe when I get shop/furniture time, I'll start using a scratch awl more.


Left to right:

*A Stanley Hurwood scratch awl. This is a nifty critter, with a lovely handle, and a shank that steps down halfway down its length. I used to see the Stanley Hurwood screwdrivers in the catalogs into the late 70s, and always thought the name had to do with the wooden handles; but learned more recently that Stanley acquired* the George E. Wood Company of Plantsville, Conn., and, in the process, the Hurwood name. I don't use this often, but like it.

*No idea what this was originally; the handle color says "sewing machine" to me. This was a standard tool for me for a while, but I've migrated toward the next two tools for shop use.

*Third and fourth tools are without maker's name. I'm particularly fond of the little one, which has a very sharp point.

*Stepping over the size indicator, the beat-up awl to its right is a Stanley awl that lives in my carpentry toolbelt. I've dropped awls and scrabbled around to find them when working outside (English ivy can eat things amazingly fast), so I wanted a tool I could lose without pain. Maybe I'll paint it safety orange.

*This handle came to me with nothing in it. I drilled out the collet to accept an ice pick shank, which can be removed and put in a drill for sharpening. When I get around to furniture-making again, if I find I could use a scratch awl, it'll be this one.

*This is an ice pick. I used to find these at about one out of three estate sales, and finally stopped buying them after I had three or four. I don't know if they're still out there, because I stopped looking at the kitchen stuff at the sales. If you find one, grab it. The steel in the shanks is very tough and, in my observation, holds a point well, and they generally come sharp enough to be scary.

---------------

*People new to hand tools may not realize that Stanley was the Microsoft of its day, gaining huge market share by purchasing competitors and companies offering tools it liked.

Re: Marking knives

#21

Re: Marking knives

Tony

I've been eyeing one of those scratch awls for quite a bit - may have to give in finally :)

How do you like the GD kerf starter? Seen it listed but not in use so I've wondered if it would be worth it.

Re: Marking knives

#22

Re: Marking knives

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

How do you like the GD kerf starter? Seen it listed but not in use so I've wondered if it would be worth it.

The kerf starter is excellent for the tails (assuming you begin with tails). It helps lock the saw perfectly square on the line. This is the most important line for mating dovetails. Get it wrong and you will have gaps. The kerf starter takes little extra time and makes it easier to get that desired level of precision in your work.

Regards from London

Derek