New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Super Resolution Thermal Imaging Camera

Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

Posts

Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#1

Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I have a lot of tenons to tweak and fit - 32 cheeks in all. Hopefully most will need just the smallest of tuning. One of my preferred methods is the router plane (I think it was David Charlesworth who first suggested this). I tend to use the 1/2" straight iron in the widest router plane, which is the Veritas. It occurred to me that I might use the V-iron this time around.

Mine was dull from use. I have always honed it my freehanding the bevel faces on my stones. This has not been as satisfactory as I would have liked since over time the bevels have become a little rounded. It occurred to me that I could use a technique in sharpening them that I use with the Chris Vesper marking knife, which also has a V-blade ..


What I do is hollow grind the bevels, and this makes it a 2 second process to hone the iron. Done once, the hollow grind should last years. I use a Tormek, but the principle could be transferred to any other grinder - just watch for heat. I have not come across this method elsewhere. Let me know if you have method of your own.

The V-iron is similar for both the Veritas and the Stanley (and no doubt Record) models in that the V- blade head screws to the shaft, and may be separated. Veritas supply a handle that will screw onto the head to hold it while sharpening. For the purposes of clearance when grinding, the head was screwed to the reverse side of the handle, and then locked into the blade holder of the Tormek ...


Square the diagonal of the V iron ...


... and then set the bevel angle to 30 degrees ...


Grind the one side, and then reverse the blade and set it up exactly the same way as before ...


The resulting hollow makes it very easy to hone the edge. One stroke on a worn 600 grit Eze-lap, and then a stroke or two on a Spyderco Medium and Ultra Fine, polish the back, and we are done ..



Here is the side view with the relief angle ..


I found that it is important that the V is centred to achieve an even shaving. If not centred, it just dug in on one side.

In use, the V iron works well ... but I do not see it replacing the straight iron, which is less complicated in use. One advantage of the V iron, however, is that it can get into corners more easily. Maybe with a bit more practice. This edge is so sharp that fine shavings are a must. Deeper and the point digs in.

Here is the shaving as it occurs ..


And here is the result: a smooth surface across the grain ...


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#2

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

David Charlesworth

Derek,

I got that method, which works extremely well ;-)#, from Robert Wearings book "The Essential Woodworker", now republished by Lost Art Press. Chris Schwartz USA.

My Stanley router plane sat on the shelf for many years, before I discovered its great value for this demanding task!

best wishes,

David

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#3

Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Why is the router plane a better alternative to refining a tenon thickness than any of the various planes that can plane to an edge?

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#4

Re: Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Why is the router plane a better alternative to refining a tenon thickness than any of the various planes that can plane to an edge?

Hi Bill

Simply because it will remove shavings from the cheek that ensure it remains parallel to the stretcher.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#5

A side question.....

roger lance

Derek.....

Not to get off track, but I've been trying to recall the word you have for adjusting....tinkering.....refining.....tools etc.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#6

Fiddly

Warren in Lancaster, PA

"Excessively fiddly" or "anoyingly fiddly". This method sure beats all for fiddly. Sawing to the line is somewhat easier.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#7

Re: Fiddly

David Charlesworth

Tell that to the beginner who has not learned to saw perfectly.

And then deal with the frustration, (and poor result) which abuse of other tools and methods will produce.

i.e. joints which don't fit at all.

David

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#9

Re: A side question.....

roger lance

Derek.....

My question didn't have anything to do with this thread topic.....its just that I've been doing a lot of tweaking lately and while doing it, I think now what was that word Derek used to describe this line of activity.....

Its one of those words not used much in USA but used in the UK.....

It will come around again.....

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#10

Re: Fiddly

Brian Holcombe

Having done both I find that when I miss my mark off the saw it's quicker and easier to use a big paring chisel.

All the same I do appreciate the jigging posts.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#11

Re: Fiddly

David Charlesworth

Brian,

A plane jigs its blade.

Your chisel may be jigged by a gauge line? Or perhaps by magical powers... That gauge line was jigged by a gauge.

Just teasing.

David

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#12

Re: Question

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ther are many ways to skin a cat.

This weekend I am back to the Lingerie Chest, and have 34 mortices and 68 cheeks to cut. I am hopeful that a goodly percentage will go in off the saw. However, should the gods not be kind, I have a few choices ...

If the cheek is just a smidgeon too thick on one side, I will use a rasp or float. There is rarely much to remove, so a plane, such as a block rebate or skew rebate is overkill. I do not use a shoulder plane on a cheek as it is tippy.

If the cheek tapers a little - after all we do have the disadvantage of sawing upside down here in Oz - then out comes the router plane, since this will get the cheek back on track. I also may use a chisel if it is just a small area, such as a corner, that needs leveling.

Anyone have another suggestion?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#13

Re: Fiddly

Brian Holcombe

Howdy David, Thanks for the humor.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#14

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A router plane is something I don't consider as often as I should. If I ever get a tenon out of parallel :) I will try to remember to break out the router plane.

If I tried to make furniture part time without using these handy tips I would be spending all my time making practice joints and never get any furniture made.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#15

Ditto on the paring chisel

david weaver

..and for small tenons, I've also had excellent luck thinning them just a little using a plane bed float.

Hands and eyes...that's what we trust after a good mark is made. The more we do, the less hassle it is to work.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#16

Re: A side question.....

TomD

Tweak? Apparently you are not sufficiently deep in drug culture...

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#17

Re: Question

TomD

"Anyone have another suggestion?"

If one doesn't have a router plane put two level blocks on either side of the tenon and work down with a hacksaw blade. This is a lot faster than it sounds, hacksaws blades are commonly used to level flat and curved surfaces in composite boat building. Make the blocks UHMW plastic, or just large enough to skid the blade compared to the tenon. The best technique seems to be a diagonal cut, and one can cant the blade to get various degrees of bite. Works on things like glue lines where you want something to take out the glue but not cut adjacent surfaces.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#18

Dumbing Down

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Tell that to the beginner who has not learned to saw perfectly.

And then deal with the frustration, (and poor result) which abuse of other tools and methods will produce.

I certainly do tell beginners to learn to saw. There is no shame in having one's level of experience show in his work. I think teaching alternate "training wheels" techniques designed for beginners will delay the acquisition of real skills. And skill development, whether with chisel or gouge or plane, feeds on itself and pays dividends, saving time and boosting quality. Learning one skill makes one better at learning other skills.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#19

Re: A side question.....

roger lance

No deeper than the occasional aspirin......and, of course, Jack Daniels.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#20

Re: Ditto on the paring chisel

Brian Holcombe

Absolutely. I have been actively trying to minimize reliance upon jigs, so that when I'm in circumstances where they are impractical I can work without them confidently (and quickly).

This thread stems from sharpening, I setup a 6mm Ichou-gata chisel tonight that arrived from the maker with a near 45 degree bevel....making it practically useless for paring. There is no way to jig these without some specialized tooling. The edge I ended up creating landed around 32 degrees and a slight Hamaguri shape, but flat across the width. With more practice I should be able to get these to a perfectly flat bevel. 4-5 years ago I probably would have not had success.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#21

Dumbing Down has it merits

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Some do woodworking for the challenge of building skills associated with some time period or another, while others build for a place to store their socks. In the latter case the only way to successfully proceed is to dumb down the design and construction process to match the skills at hand and get the job done.

Incrementally, the designs get more complex over time and the skills get more refined. For each new project one decides what new design element to tackle and what new skill to learn. Maybe for the next project it is decided to continue making M&T joints with machines and/or crutches and instead spend the time learning to do a cock beaded drawer (for example).


Shown is the first piece of furniture I ever made. It is in the shop for refinishing and repair after decades of useful service and several paint color changes. Newly married we needed a place to set a lamp. Telling me that I should learn to make this end table according to the procedures of an 18th century professional cabinet maker would have been misguidance.

On the other hand if the goal in life is to acquire some of the skills of an 18th century cabinet maker then it would be well to not waste time learning skills or leaning on crutches that are not period correct.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#22

Re: Fiddly

Steve Voigt

I'll third Brian and David on using a chisel. Watch Phil Lowe, starting at about 1:15 in this clip:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=73Neq8EoQdY

As the video shows, no magical powers are required, but the technique is heavily dependent on having the mortise gauge set accurately. I made a couple of fixed mortise gauges this summer and that was a nice improvement. I orient the bevels on the cutters to the outsides of the tenon (the opposite of what the Japanese gauges like the Kinshiro do), so that the width of the tenon will not be affected by how deep I gauge the line.

I don't really think the question here is right or wrong, but rather the extent to which you want to trade speed for certainty. The router method looks the slowest, but also the most easily mastered and least error-prone. For someone who makes only the occasional tenon, it looks like a good route. Sawing is obviously the fastest, but if you don't cut tenons on a regular basis, this method might make your burn pile a little bigger than you want it to be. I like the chisel method as a good compromise.

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#23

Choices

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Is this not a good example of why we use hand tools? :)

There are choices. Decide which one is best for you or best in the circumstances. You may just prefer to use one. I do not decide beforehand, except to ensure that the blades for each option are sharp and ready to go.

It reminds me when I used to watch Norm all those years ago. I smile when I think of the mortice and tenon joint in plywood. He would make the tenons look so simple with his tablesaw jig. Saw, flip, saw, and a perfect fit.

We aim for the same tolerances. I do not recall what Norm did when he had a smidgeon to remove from a cheek. Did he have a choice other than another pass with the tablesaw?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sharpening the V iron for the router plane

#24

Re: Choices

roger lance

What that show did not show was all the fettling that went into the correct table saw set-up. There was the occasional use of scrap to show some of the process of getting an accurate thickness off the saw.....hey, that's what hand tool guys like to say about their joint work....fit right off the saw. :D

He did make tenon thickness adjustment with a rasp/file and also a block plane.