New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

Saw Vise - one solution

Posts

Saw Vise - one solution

#1

Saw Vise - one solution

Bob Entwisle in NJ

In last night’s Hand Tool Chat, the subject of saw vises came up, so I thought I’d post a couple of pictures of a saw vise that I made .

This vise should more properly be called an appliance as it is meant to work in conjunction with a bench vise to hold a saw plate for filing. It’s by no means elegant and has several shortcomings, but the objective at the time I made it, was to learn how to file a saw, not to build a magnificent saw vise.

So here is my vise, and I’d be interested to see and hear about others solutions to this work holding task.

The vise is ½ inch Baltic birch plywood, maple jaws glued to the plywood, and a leftover piece of piano hinge.




Bob in NJ

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#2

Great idea

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I would not find your invention any less convenient than the 30 pound cast iron monster I used for this task. Had I thought of what you did I would not have bought the cast iron affair, which is unhandy fastening to anything I have in the shop to hold it. And, a cumbersome pain to store.

Suggest submitting to Popular Woodworking "Tips".

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#4

Small variation......

roger lance

Bob.....I made a similar saw vise......but, didn't have a suitable hinge.....so I made separate sides that rest on the guide rods of my bench vise.....



a simple and economical design that can be hung for storage in the floor joists above the bench.....

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#5

Re: Small variation......

Paul M

Mine looks very much like yours Roger.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#6

Re: Small variation......

Sgian Dubh

I don't have a picture of it, but my saw vise is essentially like yours, Roger. The difference is in the construction. I made a rectangular section tube with two pieces of 6 mm plywood and two pieces of solid wood - can't recall the species, probably pine. I simply glued the four parts together and flushed any unevenness at the joins with a plane. Next, I marked a line with a marking gauge along the length of one of the pieces of solid wood and ran the saw through it to create a kerf to hold the blade during sharpening jobs. In use it looks essentially the same as yours, but it's a single piece vise rather than two pieces. I guess the only real advantage is I can't lose half a saw vise - I either lose all of it, or find all of it, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#7

Re: Small variation......

Neal in San Jose

I wish I had thought of that. It would have saved me a trip to the borg for a piano hinge!

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#8

Re: Small variation......

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

Why not a couple of pieces of leather nailed across the base of the two pieces to ensure that, like Richard, you lose the whole thing at once? I could mail you some leather for the purpose if you don't have any old shoes or suchlike to cut up.

If you have kids, you should label it. "Handsaw sharpening vise" or something like. Otherwise, they'll wonder what it is. Unless, of course, you're educating them about these things.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#9

Re: Small variation......

AlanWS

Mine is very much like Roger's. I was building one as described by Tage Frid in his book (still one of the best, if not as well illustrated as many), but the vise worked well enough without the hinge that I never added it.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#10

Re: Small variation......

TomD

Yeah, I made mine from Frid's book also, must be around 30 years ago. I have something similar for sewing leather also. Krenov has an even simpler version, just two strips of wood sandwiched in your vise. For extremely fine saws he would position them so the file would score the strips of wood. Parallel sets of score lines of even depth clearly show consistency in filing the very fiddly saws, for a long time it was the only instruction I had seen for sharpening a dozuki.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#11

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

Steve Voigt

Looks familiar…



One small modification that really helps is the ledger strip screwed to the front of the saw vise. This keeps it at the height you want, and it doesn't slip when you open the leg (or face) vise.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#12

Re: Small variation......

Steve Voigt

I believe Tom Lie-Nielsen makes them with leather hinges. Somewhere I found a description of his and based mine off it, but I had some hinges handy and no leather. I'm sure either works fine.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#13

The simplest solution of all ..

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Paul Sellers posted this idea for a saw vise on his blog. It is so simple that it puts my Disston #3 to shame :)

It is simply a slip of wood that is sawn most of the way. The saw plate slides down the kerf and then may be clamped in a vise.



Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#14

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

don stephan

The August 2015 issue of Popular Woodworking has an article describing how to build much more complex saw vise.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#15

Re: The simplest solution of all ..

Paul in NJ

The problem with this solution and some of the other vises shown is that it limits how much of the file you can use. The jaws must be tall enough to provide clearance for your hand and file handle. It helps if the jaws are chamfered, especially when using files appropriate for fine tooth saws.

Paul Dzioba

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#16

Re: The simplest solution of all ..

roger lance

Paul.....the vise jaws on Bob's, Steve's, and mine are all chamfered. :D

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#17

Re: Simplest is not always best…

Steve Voigt

Derek,

This is no dig at you, but as usual, I find myself scratching my head at a Sellers idea.

It seems to me that a significant feature of most saw vises is that they elevate the work above the bench to an appropriate height, much as a "Moxon" vise does for dovetailing. It hurts my back to just think about using Paul's jig. One also needs clearance for one's hands below the vise, to hold the file in a comfortable and natural way. I am struggling to imagine how this works with the jig.

Perhaps I am just not getting it. But it reminds me of other quick and dirty solutions, like the "chisel router." A saw vise like the ones in this thread take an hour or two to build, and I will be shocked if I don't get at least 20 years' service out of mine. Why not take a little extra time and do it right?

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#18

Re: The simplest solution of all ..

Sgian Dubh

Paul, the top of the chops of my saw vise are flat. I've not found it a problem achieving a long enough stroke of the file in thirty or more years of use. I've used my homemade device to sharpen everything from rip saws, to panel saws, to tenon and carcase saws, right through to dovetail saws. Trying to sharpen a Gent's saw might present a challenge, but I don't use one, and never needed to sharpen one. To achieve a suitable file stroke I simply raise the saw a bit in the chops if needed.

I suppose one reason for being able to achieve a full stroke is because of the way the saw files I use are made - they come with two business ends. There's a bit in the middle, usually about 10 -12 mm long that has no teeth. I slip a wooden file handle over the one end to prevent stabbing injuries to the palm of my hand, and use the teeth available from the toothless centre section of the file to the far end. Perhaps the saw files you have are a different pattern, e.g., teeth the full length of the file, and perhaps also made with a built-in handle of some sort. I can see how that type of file might be restricted from making a full length stroke with a flat topped set of saw chops. Slainte.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#19

Re: Simplest is not always best…

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Steve

I am not tempted to make one of Sellers' saw visas as I have a couple of manufactured ones, with the Disston #3 the most used (incidentally, a lining of leather is great to reduce vibration) ...


Nevertheless, the idea that Sellers offers is terrific if you do not have a saw vise and want one quickly. Add a bevel to the top if you will.

The height thing is not a deal breaker - just sit down when filing.

With regard his many other ideas, while I may not agree with some of his methods, I applaud his inventiveness in spite of his ideas appearing motivated more by a philosophy of "keep it cheap" than "make it efficient". The router chisel idea is my least favourite. Still, overall, he has simplified many techniques for newcomers, and made it possible for them to work wood. How can you argue with that?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#20

Re: Simplest is not always best…

TomD

I am just heading off to the country where I will only have the most basic tools for a few months. Finding solutions like Sellers is great for jobsites, and seminars etc... Though any competent person should be able to come up with solutions like that pretty much stream of consciousness.

A couple of great ones, one I copies, and one I saw. The reamer for green woodworking made from a keyhole type saw. I needed one of those and had to make it with a spokeshave and other simple tools, it still worked better than any of several very fancy ones I own, which is gratifying.

Another was a horizontal boring machine that was made for a plane seminar I attended where a drill was held in a carriage with some bands, and the carriage slid on linear bearings that were just wooden rails set into coped Vs in the carriage. Worked more smoothly than a machine.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#21

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

Ray

All of the ideas in this thread are really great and I plan to build one like yours. Thanks for the photos.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#22

Re: Simplest is not always best…

North of the Border

Unfortunately, some woodworkers are not open to new ways of doing things, and they easily brush off unusual ideas Sellers comes up with. His ideas may not work for everyone but we should applaud his efforts.

Anyone who doesn't understand how Sellers' version of saw vise works should watch his video (free) first and then, only then, go about criticizing it.

When I sharpen my saws, I sit down most of the time.

Re: Saw Vise - one solution

#23

Re: Simplest is not always best…

Steve Voigt

Just because someone doesn't agree with a particular idea, it doesn't automatically follow that they are "not open to new ways of doing things." Maybe they just don't like the idea. Being open-minded is not the same thing as uncritically accepting each and every approach.

What I will never understand is why the Sellers acolytes all think it is somehow out of bounds to criticize his approach. It always seems vaguely cultish, as though one were criticizing the Supreme Leader.