We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
There are two ways to build it (with lots of variations). The original, and much less efficient, way is to attach the knobs securely to the threaded rods, and build one nut per rod into the back jaw.
The second, and preferred way is to attach the rods to the rear jaw with two nuts each and also thread the knobs. These knobs spin freely, but need to be much more massive than the original knobs would be. Excellent plans for building one of these are found on the Benchcrafted website. The Benchcrafted hardware is the best there is, so hold onto your wallet when you visit them. Joel at TFWW also published plans for a Moxon vise with a small benchtop attached to the rear jaw.
I've build and used both types. My knobs have been turned from dense hardwoods, and a nut mortised into the knobs, instead of the threads being machined into the knobs.
Go to YouTube and type in Moxon vise in the header and up will come a video showing a guy making one using ordinary pipeclamps.....it does work very nicely.
I'm not impressed, for several reasons. Note that this is a quick analysis. I may have missed a few points. Also, I already had a meta-bench, which I already use for several purposes, onto which I installed the Moxon vise.
First, it doesn't work, because he didn't extend the holes in the front jaw sideways to allow the jaw to rack. Granted, that's an easy fix. Also, he didn't bevel the front edge of the top of the front jaw, which is a major disadvantage when sawing half blind dovetails.
Second, it's way too complicated to build, with all the pocket hole screws, glue-ups and sawing up, gluing, clamping and trimming plywood.
Third, his not cheap. I built mine from one board (4 bf) of 8/4 hardwood and $11 of hardware. Even in quarter sawn hard maple that's about $37, much less than a 4x8 sheet of 3/4" Baltic Birch plywood. I'm not sure that's what he used, so his cost may be less than my estimate.
My hardware was much less expensive than his 1/2" pipe clamps and black pipe, a bottle of yellow glue, and about a hundred Kreg screws. Using half inch instead of 3/4" hardware, not to mention the mechanism to slide the rear jaw (made from 5/16" hardware) makes it much less robust than the 3/4" Acme thread hardware in mine.
Fourth, the pipe clamp heads hanging out the front are a snag and bruise hazard. My hardwood handles handles only project 2" from the front jaw, have no snag points, and are a lot easier to operate.
Still, my recommendation is to save a lot of labor. Don't build mine, and especially don't build his kludge. Build a vise that works superbly: Buy the Benchcrafted kit from Jameel Abraham.
You did not disturb me. I took the time to watch the video, which I do not think was time wasted, and to write what I think is a fair critique of it, based on my own experiences with my own Moxon vises, which, by the way, I have rebuilt or enhanced at least three times, and I'm still not satisfied. I'm sure I can do better if I make further improvements to it, but I won't have time to do them before the next time I haul it off to a demo.
In any case, thank you for finding the video and sharing it with us. If you have all the materials already laying around the shop, you are familiar with the techniques, and you are a long way from a Home Depot, you can use his methods to cheaply (in the sense of worth more than its cost) build a viable dovetailing vise.
The methods I use, which result in a less expensive (but not cheaper in the sense of lower quality) vise, do require some lathe and hand tool skills and tools, but I already have them laying around my shop. For the next upgrade (which a lot of people might think is a conceit) I have acquired some machinist tools and am learning some machinist techniques.
I used the laminated plywood method to build the base of my main workbench, almost a score of years ago, and it works as well today as when I built it, and as well as one made from solid hardwoods. Depending on your tool set and skill set, it might be the right way to get from no bench to one that will serve you well for many years.