New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

Posts

Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#1

Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I own a No. 20 Stanley compass plane. I haven't used it yet (not much call for it in the carpentry work that's dominated my "shop time" since retirement), but I've got some designs in my notebook that call for it, when we "finish" on the house, and I can get seriously into the shop.

A friend is moving and selling stuff off, and he's got a Stanley 113 missing its tote but otherwise OK (well, rust). I don't know what he'll be asking, but I wouldn't pay more than $25, were I to get it.

But is there any virtue of the 113 over the 20? I read one article in one of the magazines in which the author praised the 113 and faintly, but without specifics, damned the 20. I'd appreciate hearing from anyone who's used both as to whether I should think about buying this project plane, if it becomes available to me.

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#2

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

Most people like the #20 better, because you can't accidentally change the radius of the arc while you are using it. On the #113, the front hand rests on the adjusting knob and can accidentally (or intentionally) turn it while you are planing. Some people might consider tht an advantage. Also, the joint between the cast iron frog/mouth/blade holder and the front and back spring steel beds is rather frgile, and very difficult to repair. I'll need to look at mine when I get home to see if a missing tote means it is broken off or totally detached. I' don't remember whether it is cast to the frog, or mechanically joined. Mine had been dropped and broken a long time ago and expertly repaired with a curved iron mending plate and rivets.

The #113 certainly has some "gizmosity factor" that makes it more desirable, but only aesthetically or to collectors. The #20 works well, but looks kinda klunky.

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#3

Thanks

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This particular 113 is one of the later models with a split casting for the arc-adjusting knob spindle, and a screw to clamp the spindle; so accidental changes in arc seem less likely.

But it sounds like there's no real advantage to it, so I'll probably pass, unless the price drops low enough that my wallet opens on its own.

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#4

Re: Thanks

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

My #113 is a type 1, and I don't have a #20, so I don't think I'll be much help. Sorry.

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#5

Re: Thanks

Joe shelton

I like the 20, but haven't used it a lot.

Patrick Leach says the 113's flexibility can be an advantage on irregular curves, but he also contends that the 20 is the superior plane.

At the right price, you should fall on your plowshare, then report your own findings to us.

Joe

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#6

One more difference...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

Hi Bill,

I have both and they both are good planes when you need one. Just so you know, the 113 will make a tighter radii than the 20.

Cheers!

Re: Stanley compass planes: No. 113 vs. No. 20

#7

Problem solved

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

The friend who is moving sold the No. 113 during his moving sale, for the very price I was prepared to offer ($30). This is a good thing; it will now not be yet another entry on the Project List, which already rivals the 2010 (final) edition of the Encyclopædia Britannica (32 volumes, 32,640 pages), and I am freed to find a complete one for a ridiculously low price somewhere else.

Thanks, Scott, for your post about the tighter radius possible with the 113. This seems like the only major argument for getting one; but, well, if I stumble over one at the right (low) price, my resistance to a purchase is likely to be low.