New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

flattening Spyderco bench stones

Posts

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#26

Re: It worked?

Bruce Mack

Yes it did, with one light application of 60 micron powder and multiple squirts of soapy water as you had suggested. It took about 20-30 minutes in addition to the time I had put in on the metal plate and the diamond stones. The larger acrylic surface made it physically easier. I'm new to abrasive flattening and don't know if it would have been better to reapply the diamond dust in mid course or to use 30 micron powder instead. 60 was still crunchy but less noisy as I proceeded, perhaps because the slurry spread out. The Spyderco surface was smooth to touch, but I could see the striations, so I briefly went back to the fine and then ultra fine diamond plates for cosmetic purposes. I used a 6 x 12 area of one side of the acrylic which itself is no longer flat.

Flattening with all media was a bear. The Spyderco wins the laurels.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#27

The crunchy gets less

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

" 60 was still crunchy but less noisy as I proceeded"

It takes a while for the rocks to get forced into the substrate. A gem cutter (they should be called grinders for they grind facets) explained to me how he uses a rounded vary hard stone to assist in embedding the diamond into the lapping plate before use.

Diamond is not only hard, it is extremely tough, so it does not fracture easily. Hence, it is unlikely you broke up the rocks, but rather just forced them into the plastic. To keep them from being forced uselessly into the substrate it needs to be hard itself. Acrylic is a good choice in this regard for it is harder than most other plastic.

Copper is also good but it gets sticky and annoying to use.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#28

One thing to note....

John in NM

The practice of using a hard material to embed grit in a lap is best suited for much more fine abrasive than 60 micron. IIRC, that technique is more commonly used for the <5 micron abrasive sizes.

I used to use 325 grit (50 micron roughly) and 600 grit (20 micron) on copper laps for rough cutting. My method was to make an oil slurry and roll it into the lap with an old sealed bearing on a dowel. One could use a new bearing too, it doesn't matter. I never tried the other method with coarse diamond, I would imagine it would work ok too, but I liked the rollers better.

I knew a guy who had two 24" cast iron laps - he made petrographic thin sections for a living. His diamond grit was in big shaker bottles, to be used liberally :D I had the impression from watching him work once that the diamond didn't become embedded in cast iron, but having never used a cast iron lap, I wouldn't know. Perhaps it did but just cut too slow for his tastes.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#29

If it isn't embedded it isn't abrading

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The abrasive particle must be stationary relative to what is desired to be abraded or nothing useful happens. It is well established that the finer diamond particles embed in diamond. This format has been used for faceting diamonds for centuries, according to the source of the diamond information I obtained from a supplier when searching diamond abrasive for sharpening.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#30

Re: If it isn't embedded it isn't abrading

John in NM

It is likely that diamond grit does embed to some degree in cast iron. I'm always somewhat amazed by the amounts of grit typically used on cast iron laps however, and can only assume that degree of embedding is pretty minimal compared to softer materials.

Of course, I'm not speaking in reference to sharpening steel, or even cutting diamonds, just the cutting of softer stones like sapphires or quartz.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#31

correction

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

should read embed in cast iron