New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

flattening Spyderco bench stones

Posts

flattening Spyderco bench stones

#1

flattening Spyderco bench stones

Bruce Mack

As noted by David Weaver and others, the stones are often not flat end to end. I have the medium and fine which I use for free-hand sharpening of chisels. I like the side to side method and can see the very edge become shiny as I lift the chisel handle. The edge becomes working sharp with just a few swipes on CrO2 on hardboard. The ceramic repels edge dig-in like a Romulan torpedo shield.

I use the Shapton professional stones for my plane irons, usual sequence 1000-5000-15000 (ouch). It would be fun to try the 2 Spydercos on plane irons as well. I have been able to flatten the medium, but the fine stone has resisted a coarse DMT diamond stone as well as 30u loose diamonds on a Veritas honing plate. I have about 4-5 inches flat on a 2x8 stone. Next attempt with 100-150u diamonds if I can find them. Any other methods you might suggest? I don't want to spend the bucks on a super coarse diamond stone I might not use again.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#2

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I about ruined a coarse DMT flattening a hard Arkansas stone. I bet a Spyderco would be just as difficult.

JR

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#3

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

TomD

I flattened mine a little with a DMT. Mine are pretty old stones, and were quite bad really, not sure what they are supposed to be good for, or why they let them out like that. The same is true of the Spiderco triangle sharpener. That's a great tool for knives and scissors in particular, but I guess it would be better still if the parts were straight. Ceramic wise the white is nice because it does really bring up a sharp edge I rarely use the stones, but I do used them on tools like gravers, and narrow chisels, etc...

My overall experience is that DMT stones are not long for the world when used to flatten other stones. I hear lots of people are having different results, but I have given it a go with new DMTs several times over the years. Finally I just don't care to try it again. The diamond is tough enough, but the vitreous bond is softer than alumina ceramic, or other stones. If I was going to flatten, them today, I would try lapping with lapidary diamonds. That is right up David's alley, is that what he is doing?

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#4

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bruce

I have a Medium and an Ultra Fine Spydercos. Both needed to be flattened, and about the same amount. It required about 30 minutes each on, firstly, 275 grit and then 600 grit Eze-lap plates. These were new at the time and used the flattening process to break them in.

A few notes:

The Medium has remained flat over the past year. The Ultra Fine has required re-flattening a smidgeon - only faintly noticeable when running the 600 grit across it. I do try and use the whole surface, but the center still gets a touch more wear.

I have a Coarse and Extra Coarse DMT combination plate. I thought that this was on its last legs about 5 years ago after 5 years of heavy use. They are still cutting. Not as bad as I expected.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#5

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

Bruce Mack

Thanks Derek. I used a DMT duo-sharp coarse/extra coarse which I had bought to flatten my waterstones (works very well). The flattening of the Spyderco went more slowly than I hoped and the diamond plate looked "subdued". I stopped, fearing loss of the DMT for its original purpose.

I do have 8x3" coarse and fine Eze-Lap plates as well. I use them to adjust my bevels when they become convex or damaged (I have no grinder). I could try them on the Spyderco fine, but am concerned that the ceramic could damage them. Though you had no damage, I'm still a wimp and would prefer a go with 100-150 loose grit if I can get a small amount at a reasonable price, reserving the Eze-Lap if this fails.

Addendum: I have found 80 and 140 grit, 10 gm. for $14 each shipped. Will arrive Saturday. I'll report early next week. Expecting Spyderco to be the victor.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#6

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

Peter Evans

My Medium stone needed to be flattened, and I used a worn out 8x3 Extra Coarse DMT (the one without the holes). Did not take too long (I only did one side). The Ultra Fine was perfectly flat (well as flat as my Academy straightedge) - on one side. The other side was unflat. I understand the Ultra is a Fine stone that has been properly flattened. Take some getting used to, and have only used free hand on chisels so far.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#7

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

TomD

You got diamond grit? Be interested to hear how that works. With a proper lapping surface it should win over the spyderco.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#8

this is what happened....

Bruce Mack

First, I want to affirm that Derek and David are correct in recommending the diamond plate for flattening the Spyderco fine/extra fine. My experience with loose diamonds can be termed a detour which I pursued because I could get them for a reasonable price.

The packets came yesterday, 50 carats (10 gm) each of 80-100 mesh (180-150 u) and 140-170 mesh (106-90 u). These are 80 and 140 grit respectively, according to charts.

I used a Veritas steel honing plate as the grinding template, placing the Spyderco underneath, as the weight of the metal plate helped the process. The coarser diamond grit felt like gravel as had been cautioned by David. The finer diamonds felt better to touch and were my flattening medium. WD-40 proved better than mineral oil and 3-IN-ONE, both of which quickly thickened with black swarf. The WD did also, but more slowly. About the swarf? It came from the steel plate which was abraded more than the Spyderco.

While I did not use a feeler gauge to measure, the Spyderco stone initially dipped at both ends with a usable central flat of about 4 1/2 inches. After about 1 1/2 -2 hours of interrupted lapping I got tired and stopped with 7 flat inches on one edge and 7 1/2 inches on the other, by straight edge. It took very little diamond powder to achieve this. I refined the surface with 30 to 6 to 2 micron paste resulting in a stone which felt quite smooth to touch.

Testing with the Veritas PM-V 11 iron for my block plane, I got a really nice edge in a total of one minute using the Spyderco medium and then the fine stone. It was not as sharp as I get with my full sequence of water stones, but is the equal of my Shapton 5000.

I don't know whether this will replace the waterstones, but think that it could. The Spyderco may become finer with use. The blade edge presently needs CrO2 refinement.

Incidentally the Veritas honing plate lost its milling striations and became slightly hollowed in this long process. Clearly the diamonds attacked the more vulnerable surface. The Eze-Lap or DMT plates would have been faster/better, but I got the best arm work out in years and satisfied my need to reinvent the wheel.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#9

Re: this is what happened....

TomD

If you are going to us a lap, it need to be well embedded. If the granules are too large that will hurt also. I don't know what grit to use, a coarse diamond stone does not have grit that feels like sand on it.

I also wouldn't invert the lap, seems like that would affect the embedding. We know diamond stones work, and we know laps are used to flatten stuff, so the correct combo must be out there. There is probably

I have often thought that for some activities casting some diamond grit over an epoxy wetter surface might be worth a try.

There are always all kinds of manual on the net, this one seemed interesting, but was near the top the list, there are probably many others.

http://www.grstools.com/PDF/LIT-322_CastIron.pdf

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#10

Re: this is what happened....

TomD

Step 6 in there on embedding the granules with a carbide tool is interesting.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#11

Re: this is what happened....

Bruce Mack

Thanks for the reference Tom.

I erred in my report by not stating that I had first used Spyderco over lap. When I tired I placed the steel plate over the ceramic. The smaller grit I used did seem to grind, not roll like the larger grit.

I would have preferred cast iron and have in the past thought of using a discarded hand plane, like Derek, or reclaiming something like a table saw wing.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#12

A flaw in the approach

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Loose diamond works when the particles embed in the substrate and don't move, while the thing to be abraded does. The traditional material (for the past 200 or more years) to use with loose diamond is cast iron. Why LV chose not to offer this choice is a mystery to me. But even cast iron won't trap the large rocks you are using. A sheet of hard plastic is better for coarse diamond. Plexiglas works well and Corian might as well. Soapy water or antifreeze is a good lubricant for the plastic. One needs something slippery that doesn't soften the plastic. This information applies to abrading hard tools steel with loose diamonds. I have no experience with abrading a sharpening stone.

It does strike me as odd that people employ the best material available for abrading hard steel to abrade a sharpening stone and not the steel itself.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#13

A question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is so good about this means of abrading metal that it is worth the expense to buy it and the time to flatten it, given all the other effective means there are of sharpening a plane or chisel blade? I would think that spending hours and $$ getting such a stone ready to use will never be recouped actually using it.

I am amazed at the variety of means by which professional and serious hobby woodworkers sharpen their tools. But they share some characteristics. They are quick and cheap, and their user has devoted the time to learn how to efficiently use what ever was chosen. Given so many means to an effective end why pick one that seems to begin with a problem to be solved?

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#14

Re: A question

Bruce Mack

You are right. I have a fine set of water stones that give me a good edge with little effort.

Still I'm drawn to the grail of a sharpening medium requiring no water or oil, one that stays flat, can be accessed easily and can sharpen 1/8" chisels as well as 2" irons. I've had the Spydercos since the 90s but found them useless with a rolling jig because of their surface irregularities. Since I've switched to freehand sharpening I can better maintain a sharp edge on any sharpening medium. After partially flattening the Spyderco to a 4 1/2 flat", I found it excellent for chisels, especially the narrower ones which sometimes dug into my waterstones.

My recent Monty Pythonesque misadventure stems from this observation. I have the time to putter in my shop, with the hope that a fully flat ceramic will do everything (of course it won't). I'm almost there and have 5 other sides of my otherwise unused Veritas steel plate set to use.

Bill - my reply is largely whimsical. I've learned a lot from you. I may try to find the plexiglass.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#15

I understand the lure of the "Quest"

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

All the sharpening procedures I have tried would make a long list. Only my cheapness has limited the number.

I am down to a one "stone" procedure that works for anything and free handing is easy on the slick surface.

Hollow grind on a grinding wheel (every professional shop I have become acquainted with begins with this step for it makes what ever follows trivial). Then free hand on diamond charged cast iron lubed with WD40. Still experimenting with optimum grit size here. Something in the range of 5-15 micron seems about right. Finish with a few strokes on chromium oxide charged leather.

Let us know if you can grind a stone on a diamond charged acrylic or other hard plastic. It embeds the coarse "rocks" well for doing steel, but I have no need for this advantage any more.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#16

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

RK near Boston

My 8x3 spyderco UF has uniform dip in the middle in the direction of the long axes, perfect for cambering if used with the honing guide:)

Spyderco said I could send it back for warranty exchange or something like that, but would have to pay for shipping. Maybe I will just leave it as is or sell it on ebay as camber polishing stone:)

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#17

Re: A question

TomD

Many people do own the ceramic stones so it would be good if the optimal method to deal with them could be worked out. I do think they have some net advantages for small tools. The other thing is that people selling this stuff don't tell you it is wonky in the sales literature, it looked perfect in the pictures. It's not that I set out to buy something that was a project.

I know you like to rely on what folks in the biz do, the makers generally do not hollow grind tools on the kind of machine we use, their hollow grinds are nearer flat, and most people do not have access to those machines. Many tools are not designed for hollow grinds, one can argue about chisels, I doubt any are truly designed for hollow grinds of 3 inch radius, but that aside, there are many tools designed for convex grinds. There are a lot of variables, and sharpening is one area where new stuff is on offer all the time, so the fact people over time end up with a lot of methods is not all that perplexing.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#18

Why Spydercos? .....

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

The reason I purchased a couple of Spyderco stones was for their convenience. The promise they offer is a stone with similar resilience to an oil stone with regard dishing, which means very slowly and unlike waterstones. Even ceramic waterstones such as Shapton require frequent flattening (just less so than most). Further, they may be used dry, unlike waterstones and oilstones, both of which require lubrication. I needed something that I could take to Wood Shows, where this would make life easier. It also has a benefit in my workshop, where there is the luxury of running water, but I experience cracking hands from the process. At home I often use a tad of soapy water, which is mainly to ensure that the surface remains clean.

There are only three Spyderco grits available: Medium (roughly 2000 grit), Fine (said to be the same as Ultra Fine, but less well prepared), and Ultra Fine (roughly 5000-10000). The reason for the vagueness about the grits is that Spyderco do not (and will not) say what they are, and the estimations come from the Knife websites.

There is also an issue with size. Only the Ultra Fine comes in an 8" x 3" while all the others come in 8" x 2". The latter come in a protective plastic case, and the large one in a suede envelope. So I elected for the smaller stone. The narrower width does not bother me size I freehand and use a side sharpening method.

My full sharpening system adds a coarse medium to start. This is a small 600 grit Eze-lap diamond stone. I could finish on 0.5 or 0.1 micron diamond mesh, however I have found the edge off the Ultra Fine to be perfectly satisfactory for everything.


The Spyderco stones arrive very slightly hollowed. I used a Extra Coarse Eze-lap, followed by a Coarse Eze-lap to achive a perfectly flat surface. Each stone was the same in regard to having a hollow and the time it took to flatten. Over several months of weekend use, the Medium has remained flat, while the Ultra Fine needed a very slight touch up.

The stones cut quite quickly. Not as speedily as Shaptons, but they do have an advantage in being able to abraid any type of steel. You can push M2 or M4 across them.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#19

apology

Bruce Mack

To those who on this forum or by e-mail advised using diamond stones rather than loose diamonds or who found fault with my methods, you were right. Today I again used the straight edge on the Spyderco and realize I had far less than a 7" flat. Perhaps the thick slurry had burnished the penumbra or perhaps I just screwed up in my measurement.

I used my Eze-Lap coarse 3x8 and got considerable white slurry with some improvement in the flat, now truly 6". Further lapping got me nowhere so I quit after 20 minutes. The feeler gauge measures .0015" dip at each end of the stone (not checked before I began this exercise). I smoothed the flat with a fine and then an extra fine diamond stone. The surface feels smooth and looks shiny. I used it to refresh the edge of a 3/4 " chisel which then passed my test of easily slicing a file card and a modified Derek Cohen test of paring end grain pine.

I'll test the Spyderco on my plane irons when they need sharpening. Because I'm free-handing, I should be able to sharpen on this limited flat. I may get the plexiglass as Bill suggested and see if my diamond "rocks" can finish the job.

Finally, I wish the manufacturer of this potentially great product had done the proper flattening.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#20

Acme Corporation

Bruce Mack

I identify with Wile E Coyote. I'm obsessed with the Spyderco stone. I want it flat. In the pipeline are a sheet of 12 x 12 acrylic and 10 gm of 250 grit loose diamonds. I recommend Bill Tindall's excellent report "status of loose diamond sharpening" WC Forums: Messages Archive 2006.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#21

Re: apology

TomD

"Finally, I wish the manufacturer of this potentially great product had done the proper flattening. "

That is perplexing. It seems the way it is with some of this stuff. My stones probably go back to around 1980, or whenever they started on this product. The world of quality has revolutionized since then and yet apparently not much change here. Seems to be part of the material, the sticks are often off. Or it may be the way knives are sharpened, where there is a run along a tiny patch on an edge not normally a large flat in contact with an equally flat stone.

I think these stones are limited by the fact they clog so easily, not a big deal with knives or gravers, but to keep a stone working on some larger surfaces might end up quite tedious, but then I normally use them dry.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#22

Re: Acme Corporation

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Beep, Beep-I think you got an "Acme" sharpening stone! I loved those cartoons.

My curiosity perked I looked for information on these stones and was unable to find any technical description beyond "ceramic" which I interpret as a "ceramic" or "seeded gel" aluminum oxide particle like what is popular for grinding wheels which have the attribute of fast cool cutting, yet wear resistant.

If these stones are this material the concept is an obvious application of this technology and I would presume other companies have copied it.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#23

Re: A flaw in the approach

Bruce Mack

Bill - I got the acrylic 12 x 12, 1/4" thick sheet and 60 micron loose diamonds. This regimen almost completely flattened the Spyderco (just 3/8" shy on each end). I now use both stones for routine chisel, drawknife, and gouge sharpening. No plane irons yet. Like Derek, I'm pleased with the ease of use and the good results. Thanks to everyone who shared their experiences.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#24

It worked?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

To clarify.....the 60 micron on acrylic worked satisfactorily for flattening an abrasive stone? If so that is new information on using diamonds. I found that it worked for steel but was unsure what would happen with a stone. Did you lubricate and with what?

Writing up what you did for an article in the Articles Section would be useful to others.

Re: flattening Spyderco bench stones

#25

Re: Lee Valley Corporation

TomD

Bill have you ever used Crock Sticks? That is what these are not like any wheel I have seen, but they might use a similar tech at a different level of granularity. They are brilliant for touching up small knives and broadheads. I just bought another Lansky sharpener, because I found it so cheaply.

I had thought someone back in the Diamond rodeo days said they had used one of these charged with diamonds to good effect...

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=46363&cat=1,43072,43079

http://www.ortechceramics.com/

Alumina ceramics seem to be the ones for sharpening.

http://www.spyderco.com/catalog/list.php?category=7