New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

planes for making musical instrument bows...

Posts

planes for making musical instrument bows...

#1

planes for making musical instrument bows...

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello All,

William D. asked that I chime in and post some pictures of the planes I use to make stringed instrument (violin, viola, cello, bass) bows...

Almost all are sharpened with relatively high bevel angles of between 35 and 45 degrees. This is due to the fact that wood for making bows is hard and dense, all the species above 1.0 gram/cubic cm. Thus, all the planes are scraping tools. Due to the strong nature of the wood, (some of the hardest and highest Young's modulus species known) the scraping blades do create a shaving, although sometimes a fragile one. Most are set to take a very fine cut, except for the roughing planes, which I'll cover first.



The roughing planes begin with a Stanley 102 with a CPM3 blade made for me by Stephen Shepherd (of "loopy plane fame"). I've got the blade strongly cambered and ~35 degree bevel. This plane is set bevel up, as are almost all of the bow planes described here. I use it for roughing out a square pernambuco bow stick blank to a rough tapered form. Sometimes I use this plane for rough shaping of the ebony frog.

2nd roughing plane - a Stanley #9 adjustable mouth block plane. Other than the ~35 degree bevel, a tight mouth and the sole lapped, nothing special going on here. I use this for the final frog dimensional shaping. It has a straight across ground blade - no camber here.

3rd roughing plane - a new one - a little chariot plane - a gift from a bow making friend. I tuned it up recently by shimming up the bottom of the rosewood wedge and doing the "candle soot" method for getting the final fit to keep the bed, blade and wedge all fitting nicely. The blade is also ~35 degrees, straight across. Will probably wind up using it much the same as the #9 plane, but more fun!



Another larger one, but not for roughing - this brass plane is ~4" long, and is from St. James Bay. It was sold as a bow making plane. Bevel up, ~40 degrees, straight across. I soft soldered a little steel piece into the throat to close it up. Took some time to get the blade, bed and wedge to fit really well to prevent chattering. The tight throat and "long" length allows the plane to take a nice clean cut where straightness is important. I use it for final fitting of frog to the stick.



The two other little brass planes shown above were originally purchased from Woodcraft or Garret Wade ~30 years ago - these are Ernie Conover planes sold as a set of three - one convex, one concave, one flat. I modified them for bow work by adding a steel throat insert, setting the ~35 degree blade bevel up, and rounding the bottom of one to a ~12-14" radius convex curve. The other was lapped flat. I mostly use the flat one for it's use as a truing tool for cleaning up the stick facets. (The 3rd Conover plane sits idle...).

Now for the really fun tools. In 1982-83 I worked for William Salchow, a world famous bow maker in New York City. Naturally, we learned from Bill, and we emulated his tools and techniques. These three aluminum planes are of Bill's design. All have HSS blades ~3/32" thick made from power hacksaw blades. Blade adjustments are using little setscrews to hold and/or advance the blade.



The black anodized one Bill had commercially made and he sold for bow making classes he taught in NH at the time. It has a strongly curved bottom and I use it only for making bass bows and then, only at the most curved portion of the stick behind the head. This plane is bevel down, or at least "bevel back" and had a ~90 degree total blade angle due to the ~90 degree bedding angle. A true scraping plane. Ground straight across, the blade bevel is ~40 degrees.

The other two aluminum planes are ones I made in ~1980 when I first met Bill. Made from bar stock and slotted with a milling machine, they operate much the same as the little anodized example. These differ in that the ~45 degree bevel blades are bedded at ~45 degrees, but are bevel up, so they are ~90 total angle scraping planes. The longer one is flat; the shorter is convex. I use both a lot. Being aluminum,, you have to true up the soles every few years as they wear at the center. I made some similar planes with steel instead of the aluminum bodies, but I prefer the lighter weight ones.



More little brass planes! These four are true violin maker's planes that I modified for making bows. All are commercially available and range from ~12mm to 24mm long and have blades from ~1/4" to 3/8" or so wide. To convert to bow making, I removed the metal lever caps (they looked like those on the Conover planes), made wooden wedges, flipped the blades to be bevel up, and flattened the soles. Some have blades made from old high carbon steel files. No attempt was made to close up the throats. I honestly prefer the open throat - you can see where you are taking a shaving when truing up a stick facet. The high total cutting angle prevents tearout so a tight throat is not needed. These tiny planes can be used for planing slightly concave surfaces by skewing them to one side - presenting an even shorter effective sole length to the work.


Lastly are the "file planes" - short sections of mill and 2nd cut files used as one would use a plane. These are basically a miniature version of a gunsmithing tool used to drawfile the barrel. They have a low center of gravity which prevents them from tipping when being pushed along with one's fingers. Also, their short nature tends to allow them to self-level, again, maintaining a flat surface. I use these when I make a fully octagonal bow stick - they tend to make a more trued up octagon. At least in my hands.

Well, that's all folks!

John

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#2

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

Bob Hackett

Thanks for posting these John.

Always nice to see what others are actually using in the work they do. Especially nice to see how others have made or modified these tools and explanations of the thinking behind them. When the folks such as yourself. who always do an exceptional job on specialized work, take the time to make in depth posts like this we all learn from them. I know I do.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#4

Comment and a questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Let me add to the thank you for the informative post. It took a lot of effort to assemble and I appreciate the effort. I enjoyed studying it. Where but WC can one get this information!

At the pre-performance discussion the conductor injected a comment to please don't get the soloist going about making bows. I gathered from the comment that the soloist made bows and this conversation had dominated the discussion before the per-performance conversation of conductor and soloist. That comment was akin to revealing a dead carcass beneath a circling vulture(to add variety to the typical cliché) I descended on the topic with enthusiasm. I am sure the non-woodworker audience was disappointed in the direction the pre-program discussion then took when I asked the first question. The answers raised more questions than I got answered.

The bow maker said that he used some wood from South America? that I had never heard of. Why this wood? What properties does it have that a bow requires?

The soloist commented on "period" (if that is the correct term) vs modern bow design and lamented that he would have liked to demonstrate the difference if only he had a period bow. One was promptly produced by someone (presumably an orchestra member for the audience would unlikely carry a bow around in case one was needed). The demonstration lead to yet another unanswered question, the physics of what is going on.

When the bow is pushed or pulled, is it designed to store and then release at some desirable rate the stored energy to the string? The "modern" bow looked to me like it might store more energy, if indeed that is what is going on.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#5

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

Hi John! Loved the photos and information about the hand planes. Wasn't it Steve Thomas that built your plane blade? I'm sure with the recent posts about Stephen Shepherd health fresh in your mind it just rolled off the fingers onto the keyboard. :)

Joe

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#6

Re: Comment and a questions

William Duffield

Probably the wood that the violinist mentioned was pernambuco, Caesalpinia echinata. It is an endangered species.

Explanation of the tree and its habitat are here:

http://ipci-usa.org/pernam.html

Explanations of why it makes the best wood for bows are here:

http://ipci-usa.org/pernam2.html

I know John has also built bows from unfigured snakewood (Piratinera guianensis) and other species that might be a bit surprising. However, how he finds species that are suitable for bows may be a trade secret, and anyway, I don't understand it well enough to explain it.

http://www.fpl.fs.fed.us/documnts/TechSheets/Chudnoff/TropAmerican/pdf_files/pirati1new.pdf

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#7

Re: Comment and a questions

Bruce, a MN Galoot

I was a bit disappointed to learn that Anne Akiko Meyers uses carbon fiber bows on her Strad. Isn't there something wrong with that?

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#8

Re: Comment and a questions

William Duffield

Maybe she paid too much for the Strads? ;)

More seriously, maybe she is supporting the work of the IPCI? (see the link in my previous post.)

Perhaps, the most important question is, "How does it sound?"

I think it's time for us to start a campaign to convince her to use one of John's bows. instead.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#9

Re: Comment and a questions

Paul M

I recently found a chunk of pernambuco in of all places a Rockler store. It was only 14" long, so useless for bows. But it could make a few guitar bridges, and is nicely quartersawn. I could not believe it was sitting in their miscellaneous wood cutoff pile, but it followed me home.

Thanks for the show and tell on your bow making planes! You've got some cool toys there.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#10

Thank you, John!


Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#11

Re: Comment and a questions

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hi Bill, et. al.,

Thanks for the observations and questions. William already stated correctly that pernambuco is the wood of choice for making bows. Ever since the mid 1750's or so, the wood was used - first sporadically for period, or baroque bows, and later almost exclusively for "modern" bows dating from around 1790. Not much has changed since the famous French maker F.X. Tourte sort of formalized the overall dimensions, balance and weight for a modern bow.

Pernambuco has the right strength and density to make a bow, ranging from under 1 gram/cubic cm (considered mostly unusable for making modern bows) up to around 1.3 g/cc. (The most dense bow wood I've ever measured was some highly figured snakewood at ~1.45 g/cc.) The speed of sound in the material in meters/sec tends to determine the bright or dark sounding nature of the bow on any given instrument. A higher m/s value also is a great indicator for the Young's modulus or inherent material strength of the piece. One can calculate speed of sound knowing density and Young's modulus; conversely one can calculate Young's modulus knowing density and speed of sound. E-mail me directly if you really want to know the equations.

Problem is this: no one really knows how a bow actually works. I repeat - no one really knows how a bow actually works! I have met and interacted with many of the seminal researchers and thinker of bow statics and dynamics and although bows have been measured, modeled, copied, prodded, vibrationally excited, etc., the fact still remains - no one really knows how a bow actually works. Bit and pieces of how a bow works have been determined, don't get me wrong - some great scientific work has been done since the late 19th century and especially in the past 20 years. The relationship between graduation (thickness of the stick) and how it is cambered (bent with heat) is pretty well understood from the aspect of statics. When widened to the dynamic picture, the view is less clear.

Bill - you have no idea of the can of worms you opened raising your "simple question"! I can say, your observation that the difference between a period and modern bow is one of energy, is on the right track. A modern bow is more efficient at getting an instrument's strings and body to sound the way we, today, in the modern world, expect the violin should sound. I like to think that a modern bow, properly made and set up, allows the player to use the least amount of effort to make their musical expressions come out.

Playing the violin is a VERY complicated multiple nested feedback loop. There is the bow, the violin and the player. Add to this the way the player holds the violin and the bow. Factor in the skill of the player and the way the bow and violin are set up (adjusted). Adjust any aspect of the three-way loop of bow, violin and player and one affects the whole.

My criticism with most instrument/bow research falls into this latter category. Scientists like to tease out information from small parts of the picture and hope it can then describe the whole. Due to the feedback loops, bow affects violin, violin affects bow, player affects violin, violin affects player, player influences bow, bow influences player - you get the idea - it is sort of intractable - too many variables. Hard to look at any one isolated bow feature and predict how it will influence the whole tonal picture. But hey, we are only human, and our very nature is to pick apart a complicated concept and hope it can explain it in it's entirety. I am mostly confident that the answer will come out, probably in my lifetime. At least, maybe 80% of the answer! But 80% is better than nothing!

John

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#12

This should be saved somehow......

roger lance

Hopefully, both of John's posts should be keep.....the photos and his understanding of the role of a bow.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#13

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

John Aniano in Central NJ


Yes, Joe, you are correct - the CPM-M4 blade was made for me by Steven Thomas as a birthday gift when I turned 50. A wonderful present!

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#14

Re: The Bows...

david weaver

Hi John - I assumed when you talked about bows before that they'd shoot arrows!!

I went through your web page, and other than plainly stating that it's nice to look at fine work, that's really about all I could think.

A sigh of relief, with so many posts about coarse work or what to buy, it's so nice to be able to look something up and see fine eye-pleasing work!

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#15

Re: Comment and a questions

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Thanks for a thoughtful answer, John. I thought about making some remarks about the futility of analyzing bow mechanics a few days ago, but decided to wait for your answer. I would think the dynamics of some of the more exotic bowing techniques would be difficult to analyze.

Even if some analysis becomes available, I question whether a more intuitive approach would not be more successful. When people on this forum were asking for detailed instructions on how to use a double iron, I used this violin analogy:

We can calculate (roughly) where to put the finger on the A string to sound a B, but when we teach a youngster we don't say put the finger 1.XX inches from the nut (end of string), we show them about where to put it and have them adjust by ear. Making up a chart of all the fingerings to three digit accuracy is just not helpful in the real world. In the case of violin bows we might be able to put a bow on a machine and have it tell us what needs to be done (to match some other bow), but my feeling is the guy scraping off bits of wood is an important part of the equation.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#16

Re: My thoughts exactly...

david weaver

..When John explained that it's difficult to explain it scientifically when in motion, my thought of it really has more to do with asking George a question a few years ago about what he did with the "bad" violins that he made.

I asked him (this was years ago now) if the ones that turned out to be duds ended up as shop decoration, and the good ones sold to professional musicians.

He responded "what do you mean duds? I didn't make any duds. I guess you could call it good luck if you wish."

These duds exist in the world of guitars in droves because a craftsman isn't using sense and nuance at every step, even in some very expensive production guitars. I have gotten duds just because of that very thing.

My assumption that an experienced maker would have duds was based on that, but it's only because I didn't appreciate the skill that a maker brings in eliminating such things by careful selection, fitting and voicing.

If someone wrote 10 dissertations about the various aspects of bow physics and then wrote an 11th tying them all together, my money would be on the guy who made several hundred of them who couldn't explain why they worked the way they do, but who knew how to make them well, anyway.

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

#17

Re: planes for making musical instrument bows...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

I have known Stephen for nearly 20 years ( mostly through the forums with a few face to face meetings). He is a true renaissance man! His knowledge on a huge range of subjects is amazing. I am honored to have him remember my name. The gift you received from him is priceless and I hope you enjoy it to the fullest!

Joe