New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Line and Berry practice

Posts

Line and Berry practice

#1

Line and Berry practice

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.



It is hard to get shop time in the Spring. So much farm work to do and wildflower hikes.

I have been practicing the door pattern for the Spice Boxes. I have tried two berry sizes. I thought the large berries were best but I took the panel to the club meeting and everyone chose the smaller berries. What do you all think?

It is hard getting the intersections crisp but I am getting close to declaring good enough.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#2

Re: Line and Berry practice

david weaver

Small berries look better. I don't know anything about line and berry, but all of the berries being perfect makes it look like the picture they're making was drawn by machine.

I'll defer to the experts about how much variation is allowable. I see that you have a little bit of variation in orientation of the berries, is there room for more?

The third berry is a bit dark, maybe it's just the picture. It's hard for the eye to pick it up.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#3

Re: Line and Berry practice

William Duffield

Is the panel in the picture the one with the large berries or the small berries? I wouldn't make them any larger than those, but might prefer them just a little smaller. That is not so much an aesthetic decision as it is based on the sizes of berries I've seen on other Chester County spice chests.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#4

I have to agree with David.

Bob Hackett

I saw the pic and asked myself, "why not use a CNC router to do that"?

I think work like this is done more to make an impact on other makers in that it speaks more to the challenges of skill and expertise in technique and execution.

If you want to produce work that speaks, at least in part, to the "nature" of things then for me it requires more variation. More voice in regard to art rather than than skill. I have found that`s why most of the folks in the crowd will choose hand carved over mass produced if they are looking at more than the price point. Too much precision says "Machine" rather than artisan. You`ve talked about this very thing when showing us examples of historic pieces in past posts Bill.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#5

Re: Line and Berry practice

Michael Brady

If you overlap the berries; that is, drill one --inlay the berry--drill another, overlapping just a little--inlay that berry; you can introduce some randomness. You can even use differing inlay species to create a shadowed effect. Don't let naysayers discourage you. Line and berry is beautiful and traditional. You will get way more raves than nayes from a piece done with it. You have great start.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#6

the 3rd berry is supposed to be dark

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

it is cedar, not holly.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#7

some are smaller than others

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

they are 6 mm and 1/4"

Re: Line and Berry practice

#8

Re: What's Wrong With This Picture?

William Duffield

You're a very tricky fellow!

I didn't notice, but now it's obvious. I like the smaller ones (6 mm) better, even though there's on 0.35 difference between them.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#9

Re: the 3rd berry is supposed to be dark

david weaver

I gather that, but for some reason the combination makes it very hard to see in the picture.

I see various examples of that pattern on google image looking up line and berry and noticing that the third berry is a lot easier to pick up on some of them.

http://www.wood-w.com/lessonsguides/line-and-berry-inlay.html

It might be a circumstance that isn't worth worrying about, I'm certainly no expert on anything furniture. It would seem to me with a critical but uneducated eye, that you've got 99% of what you need already, and we're left to pick at the small things like randomness of berries and the colors.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#10

I yield....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Every one who has offered an opinion chose the smaller berries. Now if I can get the fences done it will be back to scratching troughs and drilling berry holes.

I had a neighbor bore the post holes along the creek. I am not adverse to hand tool work (post hole digger ;) ) but in this case there are pockets of gravel which makes hand tools impractically slow to impossible. So, I had the holes drilled, posts laid beside the holes, and an unexpected flood arrived. Posts washed away, holes filled with muck and I am back to excavating the soggy heavy muck from the holes with hand tools. Slow and back breaking and it seriously interferes with woodworking.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#11

It's the camera....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

or the person running it. This new Cannon seems to overexpose pictures. I returned the first one and its replacement does the same as the first. I need yet another camera but the choices are boggling. I have no idea why there are dozens of models to choose form with nonobvious differences among them.

Traditionally cedar is used for the dark berries, as was the case with the test panel. On the chest of drawers I used southern (and hence very red) cherry. The cherry is more lusterous and shows up better. I will likely use cherry for the door panel too.

The pattern is geometric combination of arcs with a mathematical relation to one another, not an abstract art project. Geometry executed imprecisely can easily wind up looking sloppy instead of arty. Given that I have no artistic talent I'll err on the precise side of pattern execution. I spent a day studying this kind of decoration at the Chester Co museum and found the makers of the day laid out these patterns geometrically, not artily. Given that the patterns are most easily scratched out with compass cutters the geometric result is to be expected.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#12

Re: It's the camera....

david weaver

I guess it's somewhat subjective, but the level of lack of duplication doesn't have to be an intentional departure from geometry in a sloppy free-wheeling abstract art way.

https://www.liveauctioneers.com/item/20745460_pennsylvania-walnut-line-and-berry-inlaid-chest

The pictures of this chest show (though it's a little hard to see) that the berries have varying orientation, and the close up of the drawer shows the right profile not being 100% symmetrical to the left.

I'd imagine the person executing it could have made both sides absolutely identical if they wanted by using a pattern or laying out as deliberately as possible, but they made a choice not to. Whether it was design, or economic, I don't know.

all of the junctions are clean, though, which I think would be more indicative of sloppy work if they were not done, but the curves themselves on the pictures shown are nice despite not being identical left and right. The imperfections are small, but it makes a huge difference in making the piece look other than CNC made.

Just my opinion, but a lot of the stuff I see shown in magazines and in instructional DVDs don't inspire me to want to make it, too much of it looks like it's made by a computer or could be easily duplicated as such. It takes the right amount of imperfection, but without violating design rules, to make something look legitimate.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#13

Re: I yield....

Bruce McCrory

Gave up on the fence too? Yield? You have my empathy.

While waiting for forest fires, fire crews would do menial jobs. Ours was building a wood fence on a river bed. We were levering up boulders every inch of the way. The pits had sloped sides nearly touching each other.

Re: Line and Berry practice

#14

Ellis Walentine

Re: It's the camera....probably not

Ellis Walentine

If your camera isn't taking proper exposures, it's most likely because the meter is being fooled by the range and placement of the light and dark areas of the composition. Meters may be programmed to take spot readings or center-weighted readings or average readings, and probably others. Most cameras have some kind of over/under function. When you get a bad exposure, the solution is to over or under expose the next one to compensate.

Ellis

Re: Line and Berry practice

#15

Thanks David

Bob Hackett

You expanded upon what I was trying to say and communicated it far better than my attempt.

As I believe you said, there is a line between being skilled enough to let the work showcase your skills and making an object so precisely laid out and executed that it looks like something other than the human hand and eye did the work.