New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Find a woodworking club near you

Lee Valley cover plane question

Posts

Lee Valley cover plane question

#1

Lee Valley cover plane question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The Spring micro-catalog has planes on its cover. I have never seen anything like them. I am flummoxed about what to ask......what do they do? why are they different? How are they used? There is a violin in the background. Are they for planing violins and if so what about planing a violin is different from planing anything else that these most different planes are advantageous?

Maybe if you have to ask you don't need to know. :(

And yes I fell victim to yet another free shipping offer. Ever since I saw the brad point drills being ground at the Veritas factory I have lusted for a set. Damn those free shipping lures.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#2

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

roger lance

I don't have that mini catalog.....and probably don't know anything of substance about those planes anyway.

But, I do know if LV can get its hook into an ole steelhead like you.....those free shipping promotions aren't going away.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#3

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

William Duffield

The guy who made the planes also made the espresso machine shown on Lee-Valley's June 2014 catalog cover.

http://www.leevalley.com/US/home/OnlineCatalog.aspx?id=612113a7

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Finger_plane

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#4

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

Brian Roberts

Planes are planes.....generally....

The back and belly of a violin is carved with gouges and planes.

There are areas that need smaller radius planes...the small "finger planes" fill that need.

The planes can be fitted with toothed blades also....to reduce tear out while roughing out the highly figured maple that is used for the backs......and necks.

The planes on the catalog cover are a bit "higher class" than those I have used....but I doubt they work any better.....which is not to say I don't lust after them....

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#5

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Don't know about the planes, Bill, but I have the brad point bits from LV and I guarantee you won't be disappointed. They're wonderful and very, very sharp.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#6

more questions

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I gather from your response that these planes are indeed used for making stringed instruments. That said I have never seen anything like them in the local stringed instrument shop. And, that the planes with the "pusher" on the end are for scooping out small concave parts. What function does the surface in front of the Allen head screw serve? Curious that it is a different shape on two of the planes and that an Allen head screw would be used on an otherwise elegant plane.

What specialized function does the long plane on the right serve? Ditto for the one with wood. It looks like it was built backwards. Are these planes reproductions of something to be found in the typical 1720 Italian stringed instrument makers shop?

There is a shop in town that sells world-wide which leads me to think the shop makes good instruments. The owner gave a program to our club. He commented that he doesn't know how the instrument is going to sound until it ages and has been played for some time. He is often surprised by an instrument he has made that he encounters some years later. I suppose the sound quality can go both ways.?.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#7

I bought a set from Woodworkers Supply.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

.....and I was most certainly disappointed. They were useless. Some drills were poorly ground and hence misshapen and dull. the spurs were too shallow to be useful and they fuzzed up the hole edges as bad as a twist drill. I returned them.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#8

I think you'll like the LV set.....

John in NM

I have a couple I bought for their shelf pin sleeves years ago, I finally had to sharpen one of them last year :D Granted they don't get tons of use compared to a regular twist drill, but they are great quality bits in my book.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#9

Re: more questions

Warren in Lancaster, PA

On the cover, the planes on the lower left are designed to have the knob in your palm and your forefinger in a depression at the front of the plane. The two on the right are scraper planes with blades at an extreme angle.

More typical violin planes are like the ones illustrated 250 years ago in Diderot, hardly changed in centuries.


Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#10

Re: more questions

TomD

You place the pusher against your palm, and the very forward section of the plane near the wood surface is radiused for your finger tip, upon which you bear down with some force. The pieces you refer to look like a support for the underside of the finger

Where these planes differ from other planes is they are like jointing a 7 foot table board with, well, one of these planes. The planes are small to get into the curvatures, and to allow gradual voicing of the plates. In the early part of the instrument making revival, it seemed some people didn't get the memo about the full range of woodworking tools, and undertook to hollow say a cello, with these pipsqueaks alone. Even used properly there is a lot of tendon stressing work to be done, so it is understandable someone would make something like this for fun, and to customize the plane to their hand and their hand strains.

There seem to be 3 sets of planes.

- Top left are hollowing and shaping

- bottom left look to me to be bow planes

top right are scraping planes. Like the 112. Not sure what he uses those for. I use mine to make fly rods. Assuming instruments it might be for jointing the fingerboard, which would explain why the lower one is long and lean. It will only contact the board at one point of tangency, so it doesn't need to wide, but a little bit of length will help keeping the playing surfaces straight, or even concave over the length, not sure what they want.

These days rouging on CNC would make sense, but many shops are all hand tools, so you can generalize as to what is necessary in any given shop.

The process you are referring to Bill, can be called opening up. You leave the instrument a little tight and it gains voice with playing. This has been lab studied, and there are even machines you can buy to sonically shake the instrument. I used to have a guitar that needed a bunch of loud strumming prior to playing it finger style, or it sounded a little boring. While not all instruments are the same or as good, it is like breaking in shoes, they loosen up, but don't fall apart if you picked the right point to put them out there. This is one of the arguments against Strads: they are great, and the greats play them, and what makes them great is that the get played by the greats. Somewhat circular logic, but there could be some truth to it.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#11

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

Paul M

That catalog stopped me in my tracks. Such drool worthy little planes on the cover! I joked with my wife that I could ditch the victoria secret ads after only a cursory glance, but I could look at this picture for hours.

These are indeed small instrument planes used to carve out the curves of the plates on violins, cellos, and arch-top guitars. Since I make flat-top guitars, I have no need for these. But that doesn't mean I don't want them.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#12

thanks all

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My curiosity has been satisfied. If I ever encounter one I will know what it is now.

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#13

Re: thanks all

TomD

You can see the bow type planes, and others, here.

http://www.stjamesbaytoolco.com/luthier.html

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#14

Re: Questions for John Aniano

William Duffield

Maybe John Aniano will offer insight into which planes and scrapers he would use for making bows.

www.jbabows.com

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#15

Re: Questions for John Aniano - response    *LINK*

John Aniano in Central NJ

Hello Sir William,

I've taken your advice and made up a tutorial on the planes I use for bow making.

John


http://www.woodcentral.com/woodworking/forum/handtools.pl/md/read/id/476813/sbj/planes-for-making-musical-instrument-bows/

Re: Lee Valley cover plane question

#16

Re: Questions for John Aniano - response

William Duffield

Thank you, John. That tutorial was well above and beyond the call of duty. We'll see if Ellis can find a volunteer to convert it into a Wood Central article, so it won't get lost.

Based on your tutorial, can we surmise that the two bottom planes in the LV cover photo are probably violin makers planes, but could easily be modified for bow making?