New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

ADVERTISE HERE - FREE TRIAL

The reward for making your own tools...

Posts

The reward for making your own tools...

#1

The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

Is using them. I desperately want to make just planes. No kitchen cabinets, no nothing else, but my econo bench with a 1.25" thick top and thin legs has served me for almost ten years now, but parts of it are starting to fail.

P1080235

I've been waiting for hardwoods to be inexpensive, and no truck. West Penn lumber had or has a sale going on for domestic lumber, and ash was relatively inexpensive, and free freight. So for just a hair over $400, I got 155 bf of 8/4 ash, they pick, so that 155 BF is going to turn out to be just about the right amount to make a bench (they pick means not the widths I'd have picked). It'll leave me with long narrow scrap that I can always use in teh garden, anyway.

The real treat in all of this, given that I'm not interested in making a bench, is that I get to use my planes as much as I want, and on something a little harder than cherry. That said, the ash works easy and the shavings that come from edge jointing are fantastic. An easy 7-8 thousandths. The action of the plane is so much better than the LN 7 that I had, and the other metal planes, I wish I would've switched to wooden planes much earlier, but wouldn't have known how to make them properly, I guess. There's a world of difference between a plane just made or tight from use and older ones, too.

Fantastic continuous shavings spring from it.

P1080236

The japanese stone that is just barely capable of cutting the hardest chisels I have is totally in love with vintage steel, too. The iron in the try plane is a vintage butcher that Jim Andrews on SMC sold to me for a song, and it's not particularly soft for an old iron, but nothing in hardness compared to ouchi and kiyotada stuff. I think I've found a new finish stone to play with for a while, just not on the tools I expected to use it on.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#2

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

RK near Boston

Where you able to specify the length for those boards?

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#3

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

No, though I think when you order you can (you can specify width, too, but there's an upcharge at least for width and probably for length). I had intended on making something more like a bowling alley top, but have enough boards that are long enough to make the finished length (just under 7 feet with caps)

I don't have enough room for a bigger bench, and if I have to move, I don't think I'll take it with me.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#4

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

RK near Boston

Thanks for the info. I checked out their website and they seemed to have a good deal on 12/4 Ash. Maybe I will get some since your wood looked good. I also need just about 7 feet length. I need to replace my bench's top and already got some nice tight grain fir for that, but this Ash looks tempting. I might mix it up and leave the back of the top in Fir.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#5

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

Some of the boards I got were perfect, some have some swirling grain in them. This one's probably in the middle. I didn't notice the 12/4 when I ordered this, or I'd have gotten that instead. It would've been a bit more problematic to joint with no power jointer, I guess.

2/3rds of the boards I got were 8 feet, the others range from 5 to 6 feet.

It's pretty easy to get to 100 feet and get free freight, though.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#6

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

Brian Holcombe

Nice, I think ash is a hidden gem, it's cheap and works beautifully. I've used it to build a few tables and my saw bench.

Coming along well, I think you'll find you've built a keeper once it's complete.

Ash, at my local yard, is 1/3 the price of AAA walnut and the ash lumber I have access to is gorgeous. It's easy to find straight, nearly twist free boards that are relatively thick for their specified sizes and straight grained. That's impossible from walnut without paying a super premium, maple is hit or miss, and while I love white oak....I hate working it.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#7

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

RK near Boston

I am slowly convincing myself to get that Ash and maybe some cherry as well. Their prices seem better then my local place that is hour of drive away and since I have two little kids hour of drive means I never get there. Did they deliver to your home?

BTW. I watched some of your videos, great stuff. I have started using my Norton India/Washita combo stone and results are very satisfying and fast.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#8

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

They did deliver to my door, hand unload from the back of the truck. There's a $45 fee from the carrier for residential addresses, so the base freight fee is waived, but you do have to pay the residential fee unless you're going to go to the terminal to pick up the wood.

When the carrier dropped off the wood, they confirmed that they add that fee as the carrier, and in that amount.

Not sure if they use the same carrier everywhere, but i live in a development and they used con-way who only has semis. I called ahead of time and they put the load on the shortest semi trailer they had (28 feet instead of 48 or 53) and the driver had no trouble.

So, short answer is yes, right at my driveway. No truck rental or travel needed. Order a little extra, though, in case they give you a board or two with a knot in the middle. Out of the probably 15 boards I got, one's got a knot right in the middle. The rest don't.

Thanks for the nice comments on the videos, by the way. Washitas are nice stones to use, I think more people would like using them if they gave them a shot and let them break in.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#9

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

TomD

Can you avoid the fee if you take it off the truck yourself? I have several lifts so they are actually making an easier delivery than to a dock as all the do is come up parallel to the house and off it comes. Sometimes just something you can push up to tailgate height is all you need.

As one gets older I would argue we all need one of these. Best 25 dollars I ever spent, and it functions as an adjustable height work surface also.


Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#10

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

Unfortunately, you can't avoid the fee - it's not for liftgate or unloading, but rather a fee that they charge for sending their drivers to a residential area (I guess it takes longer than running up and down the street and unloading at docks).

The liftgate fee would be more, but I never pay it, anyway, unless the item that I'm getting is so big I can't move it. I'd move anything chest height that's not awkward and 200 pounds or less, I guess...though the only thing that would fit that would be an anvil.

At any rate, when the drivers show up with a lift gate, they always use it even though i didn't pay for it (they say nobody does). I always give them a good tip, because sometimes the same guy shows up twice.

I had to hand unload this time, though, because the pallet the lumber was on was actually too long to fit on the liftgate. Dude driving the truck handed the boards down to me, though.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#11

Re:Agree on the lift, by the way...

david weaver

...or even a mid height bench.

When I worked in the cabinet factory, the last year I was there, they put in a bunch of stuff like that where materials were often handled, and sometimes repetitively taken off of the ground.

Even the scissor tables are helpful (albeit light duty in a lot of cases).

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#12

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

Dan Rode

I've been mulling a bench build for some time. My bench still in good condition but I think it's very similar to David's (IIRC). I have a pretty clear idea what I want and oddly enough I also settled on 7' length. I doubt I'll build it for another couple years but that doesn't stop me from doing a little planning.

Ash seems like the way to go in may respects. What worries me is the open grain. I've never used ash in any prior project but it seems close to oak.

I'm curious to hear impressions from anyone working on a ash bench.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#13

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

Michael Brady

Dave, when I built my bench, I used 8/4 ash and got to pick it. I bought 110 board feet for a six foot bench and had a few useful scraps left over. I think I paid $4 bd ft to Kirkland (Illinois) saw mill, which is in the town that just had that just had that terrible tornado.

I experience a lot of tear-out when planing the white ash. It has interlocking grain that wants to chunk out. I finally ended up with a toothed blade in a 5-1/2 and still use that to flatten the top occasionally. My bench is the best tool I ever built.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#14

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

The main reason I'm building another bench is that the board that the vise fits in has split. I drove screws through it, it's probably OK, but at some point it will break.

And the bottom of the shelf isn't strong enough to hold the ballast I have in it. It held up well for a while, though!

The thing that kills the front vise, which certainly is light duty, but is all I ever needed for 99% of what I do, is clamping boards in it tight enough to resaw them. That's what caused me to split the wood where the vise is.

Well see how the next vise apparatus works. This is going to be a functional bench, but I am by no means going to spend any more time or money on it than I need to, with the exception of getting decent vise hardware.

I'm pleased with how much stuff I was able to do with the sjobergs bench before it broke. Years ago when I got it, they were on sale with a free cabinet and free shipping for $399. I can't much complain about it.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#15

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

If you click on the picture of the shavings, you can actually see where the tearout is - I have the cap backed off some but not too much, but so that I can take bigger shavings. The tearout will disappear with the cap set closer, though I know lots of folks don't love using the cap iron for that as much as I do.

I'm already looking forward to it being done. I wish someone else wanted to make it for me for free!! :b

What kind of vises did you put on your bench?

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#16

planing ash

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have planed (power planer) a lot of ash. Some chunks out and most doesn't. I have never seen ash with interlocking grain. Occasionally I have seen curly ash and in a rift cut it is gorgeous.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#17

Ash lumber lengths

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The longest "standard" length for hardwood lumber is 16'. The shortest length allowed in the top grade is 8'. The labor and machinery involved in harvesting timber and sawing boards is essentially identical for logs of any length. So obviously logs are going to be cut 16' if the tree will yield 16' logs for the production cost per bdft will be least.

Poorer timber is more likely to best cut 12' logs and boards. Anything else, by in large, is trimmed from these primary lengths to improve the grade of the trimmed board.

Furniture factories hate the short lengths so packs of 8', 9 and 10' lumber are common to find in retail yards, a market that doesn't object to these shorter lengths.

We usually had little problem finding packs of 12' lumber, or mixed packs of 10's and 12's (with a small amount of 9, and 11 included). . 12 foot is the length I most like to buy for routine use. It is easy to handle and store and there is much less cutting waste than on say 8' lumber.

If a 7' cutting is desired try to find a pack of 14'. Packs of 14' lumber are not rare. A 7' board would be 1/10000.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#18

Re: Ash lumber lengths

david weaver

I was going purely on price in this case. Anyone else would've probably charged me freight, and more than $2.70 a ft. I can get ash locally for $2.70 a ft, but I'd have to call the local mills ahead of time and arrange to pick through stock, and then I'd have to rent a truck and do a couple of hours of driving.

West Penn is a retailer, so I expected that a couple of the boards would be shorts. It's much better than the sale stuff we usually see a rockler, though (which is the closest place for me to get wood), and I don't recall seeing 8/4 anything there on sale.

At the same time, I'm not that particular about the lumber for this bench, either. It just needs to be a bench that works. Other than having wedged stretchers and legs joined to the top, there won't be anything elaborate about the bench and certainly not attractive.

Anyway, for the rest of us buying wood retail, it's fine to make suggestions but the reality is that we can't be that picky about material when the price is low.

(I couldn't have gotten this lumber at 14 though, I'd have a trimmed bench end after taking the ends off, and I'd have been in a bind with any cracked board ends. 8 to 9 foot boards is ideal for me, and they've surface planed the stuff to exactly 2" thick, so I haven't had to work anything other than the edges, and then run the stuff through a surface planer).

A while back, a friend told me that he has a line on several trees worth of red oak that's just shy of 4" thick, but he's not moving fast enough in getting it accessible. I don't know what he would've wanted for it, but buying stuff from friends sometimes puts you in a bind, most of the time my friends or other people who offer me stuff have not had much sense in what they think things are worth.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#19

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

RK near Boston

Allright, I ordered bunch of wood from them! Minimum free shipping requires 150 board feet of domestic lumber so I mixed it up, some Ash for the bench top as well as cherry, walnut and soft maple. Prices seem to be much better then locally near Boston. I got almost 250 board feet so $45 residential fee adds less than 20 cents per boardfoot. I now need to scramble and clean out the mess in my garage.

Does kiln dried wood still needs stickering or is it optional?

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#20

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

david weaver

It doesn't need to be stickered, just if it's stacked under weight, it needs to be stored straight and flat or it will take on the flex where it's stored (as in, stack it on something flat and stable).

The ash that I've been working is pretty dry, though that doesn't mean what you get will be the same.

It looks like the requirement for free freight has gone up, it was 100 bf when I got mine, but they're probably getting weary of eating a $100+ freight charge on orders that cost $400.

I've been following them for a long time. It's unusual for them to have a sale like this on domestic stuff, they usually have something like ebony scraps for 30% off, or some other such thing you me and everyone else wouldn't have any use for.

Re: The reward for making your own tools...

#21

no

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Does kiln dried wood still needs stickering " It is dead packed when brought out of the kiln and stays that way until used.