New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

THE WOODRAT IS BACK!

New Tools for Measuring and Layout

Posts

New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#1

New Tools for Measuring and Layout

William Duffield

I'm not quite sure what to say about these recent developments. They're both intended to do the same, or at least similar, jobs. Their approaches to design are, however, quite different.

http://www.woodpeck.com/storystickpro.html#

http://www.leevalley.com/US/wood/page.aspx?p=72921&cat=51&ap=1


Woodpeckers' inside/outside measuring heads are a rather interesting feature, as is Veritas' reversible head, but I'm not sure how often I would find an application that would make either one of them essential.

I'm not planning on buying either one of them, although the concept is intriguing, so I'm afraid I won't be able to provide a useful review. I think I'll stick with a traditional story stick. When necessary, I'll augment it with a small machinist's double square, or of course a pair or few pairs of dividers.

One warning I think is worth mentioning is the real danger with the regular heads of the Woodpeckers' tool of making your marks an inch shy or an inch over, not a problem you would ever have with the Veritas tool. There are several other functional (and aesthetic) differences, but I will leave them as exercises for the interested student.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#2

a "solution" in search of a need

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Maybe it is a solution in search of a customer that has yet to figure out a simple cheap alternative.

These are the kinds of tools that can seem useful unless you already are doing the kind of work these tools apply to. And then, compared to the already established alternatives, they seem silly. A scribe or pencil mark on a stick does the job nicely and you can write information on the stick to boot. For complex lathe spindles I make a notch in a stick to accommodate a pencil tip.

I am embarrasses to say that I have too many of these kinds of tools literally hanging around, unused.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#3

Re: Oh, Shiny!

William Duffield

Me too. Some of them, I enjoy just because they are unique or well designed or just interesting, even though there are easier ways, or at least much less expensive ways, to do the job.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#4

Guilty as well

John in NM

Especially when it comes to the "nifty mechanism" aspect.

Years ago I used to sell fishing flies that I tied. I quickly learned to tie those patterns that caught fishermen. No idea if the fish found them equally appealing. Tool marketing has many aspects in common with selling fishing gear. :D

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#5

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

roger lance

I actually thought the LV offering was this years April Fools tool. Both companies will probably sell enough to make it worth their while.

We've all bought things we really didn't need.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#6

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

david weaver

It doesn't look like those are sharpening stones, so I'm out.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#7

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

TomD

I used to say that I never bought a measuring tool that I didn't find useful, so for instance the load cells I was talking about. Rock Exotica sells them for 800 dollars so you can test climbing gear, which isn't necessary but might be interested. I just bought a bar tacker sewing machine and it would be interesting to know what happens there.

But yeah, some of these things are useless, for amateurs anyway. I think you could pretty quickly buy a CNC machine and make accurate templates (or cut parts) for what a lot of this stuff costs, and you can't really complain about the tech, since that is how this stuff is made.

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

#8

Re: New Tools for Measuring and Layout

North of the Border

Same feeling here. I was surprised that Lee Valley spent that kind of development resource on a gadget like that.