New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Sayings You've Often Heard..

Posts

Sayings You've Often Heard..

#1

Sayings You've Often Heard..

david weaver

... that you think are just getting repeated because they're catchy. Or that irk because of it. I'm not picking on anyone or anything in particular, but add your own in another post.

These would be things that you see that you wrinkle your eyes at and think "that was repeated from somewhere else without trying too much"

* a plane is just a jig for a chisel (yeah, OK, and a car is just a bicycle with four wheels)

* oilstones are too slow to sharpen or oilstones don't make a fine edge, the norton chart says they are only equivalent to ___

* older tools are inferior and poorly designed, they'd have used our tools if they had them available

* you can't use dovetails or mortise and tenon on everything or you'll never get anything done

* it takes too long to rip by hand, it's not practical

* we can improve on whatever is out there just by taking an engineering approach (usually said by someone who doesn't understand why certain tools are the way they are)

* you can't get an edge like mine without a jig (implication that freehanded tools have angles all over the place and there is a minefield of unworkable tools as a result)

Add your irks, even if you're not an old complaining pa german like me.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#2

Oh...two more..

david weaver

* you can't grind steel without ruining the temper

* the hollow (on a hollow ground chisel or plane iron) will make the edge fail

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#3

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

roger lance

In woodworking, the phrase or idea that "you can't show end-grain or dovetails on your case work" is a concept with which I'm not on board.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#5

Re: some people just have no modesty

roger lance

Guilty.... :(

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#6

Re: Hey...

david weaver

that one's mine!!

You can do whatever you'd like, of course. that one's just an opinion, whereas the ones I posted are often stated as "fact".

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#7

Re: Hey...

roger lance

was that yours ??!!..... :D

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#8

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

TomD

One thing about the internet is that when it comes down to it, I am really leery about saying anything "can't be done that way", or the reverse. And the same goes for this list of opinions, they are probably both true and false depending on what the point someone is trying to make is. And further, if it is the internet, "nobody" will agree with what may very well be a perfectly reasonable statement in context.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#9

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

TomD

* a plane is just a jig for a chisel (yeah, OK, and a car is just a bicycle with four wheels)

I don't thing that is a convincing analogy. There is so much wrong with the idea that a car is just a bicycle with four wheels. While a plane really is a jigged blade. Lee Valley even sold one that was designed to hold you chisel, though I made an )1 blade for it.

I think the problem with this saying is twofold: "Just" sounds insulting, if you can insult an object. And the comparison really doesn't add much of use, unless you have are stupid and in desperate need of McGyvering a plane out of chisels and stuff.

* oilstones are too slow to sharpen or oilstones don't make a fine edge, the norton chart says they are only equivalent to ___

I think the real issue isn't that they are bad, it is more that the commonly offered man made versions don't stand up well in comparison to man water stones, or that was the perception that became reality when they hit the market here. There are a whole other range of issue with oil stone, and few pros,

* older tools are inferior and poorly designed, they'd have used our tools if they had them available

Something like axes, in the main, new versions (other than artisinal copies) suck. Modern tools like bandsaw are a lot better and certainly would have been picked up the moment they had hit the market, as in fact they were. Of course modern tools can encompass the whole range of everything. Are you making modern planes or ancient planes? So the win will go to the modern tools on logic.

* you can't use dovetails or mortise and tenon on everything or you'll never get anything done

You would certainly get a lot of DTs and MTs done. The market doesn't care. The useful place in the argument is to avoid fanciful arguments in favour of whatever joinery is under discussion. And don't be embarrassed that something isn't practical. Very little in life, particularly the stuff that makes it fun, is actually practical.

There is something that happens when dudes get involved in woodworking, there is a collision between statements of practicality and the fact that they are engaged in a namby activity that could not be less practical if they did it under water

* we can improve on whatever is out there just by taking an engineering approach (usually said by someone who doesn't understand why certain tools are the way they are)

Engineering is key in many fields but it is not the same thing as design. It is fun to see the mess that happens when engineers set out to explain something seemingly simple, like an Atlat. Given that the whole point of science is that we don't know stuff, but have a process to explain stuff, you would think there might be more humility about the first part.

* you can't get an edge like mine without a jig (implication that freehanded tools have angles all over the place and there is a minefield of unworkable tools as a result)

It is probably true. I was pretty crestfallen when I first heard that Japanese carpenters use jigs and microscopes to prepare their race planes. And most people suck at sharpening at some point. But one can learn to be good at freehand sharpening and it doesn't happen from hiding behind jigs.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#10

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

TomD

"...Not on board with"

Or seemingly most of the makers of fine furniture since the 70s. What separates the men form the boys is whether when showing DTs they orient the parts for the best "look", or the best structure.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#11

Re: Oh...two more..

TomD

* you can't grind steel without ruining the temper

Dry grinding with a 3600 rpm 6" is not going to necessarily draw the temper, but you better have a plan. It wasn't till I got into metalworking that I thought I saw the situation those grinders were designed to handle. Grinding HSS tool bits. Lathes and such used to cut with often square sections of very resistant to wear HSS that are often freehanded into rather elegant finger nail shapes. You need to burn through that stuff. The bits are usually honed on oil stones after the grind, or used straight from the wheel. The nasty stones those grinder come with actually work on this stuff.

* the hollow (on a hollow ground chisel or plane iron) will make the edge fail

The real question is whether some degree of hollow grind will actually make the edge more vulnerable in use than the same point to point angle in a flat grind. Obviously in some cases yes.

The next question would be whether there is any advantage in use to a hollow grind (not just honing), there clearly is in certain cases with knives.

The third question would be would you bother to use a hollow grind if you had to do it by hand, or; given you are doing it with power are there any tools that will give a flat or convex grind with power. Obviously yes on the power end of that, and probably no on the hand.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#12

Re: Let's assume...

david weaver

..these sayings are coming from hobby woodworkers (because that's where they're coming from).

So the idea of stuff like not being able to make joints timely is not in reference to making something for pay.

I made for pay cabinets in a factory setting when I was younger, there are a couple of parts that are identical to making kitchen cabinets now, and MANY that were modified to bring the assembly line to the point that components could come in and we could put together more than one cabinet per minute (10 to 13 per line, depending on what kind of cabinet was made on it).

Far as the jig or no jig goes, I guess you could get into that stuff for contests, but that's about it. Someone with untrained hands can get a good straight across edge with a jig, too, but I haven't seen much practical difference between the two except that when I use a jig, I'm always searching for a screwdriver or cleaning off jig wheels or trying to find jigs, etc.

As far as the right way or wrong way, we're probably all guilty of thinking "that's stupid" when we see something, I'm sure I am. I'll bet that the people who watch my plane videos could find a million things to criticize, top of the list being that I'm too lazy to build a nice bench.

I try to remember what I think when someone tells me how to do something, which is usually "we all moved away from our mothers for a reason". Or my grandfather's (an independent man if I ever saw one) response...."hey, I don't have to take that ___ from you!" If the results are good and you're happy, it's a good method. If the results are bad and you're happy, it's a good method for you, maybe not for everyone else.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#13

Re: Oh...two more..

david weaver

I'd use a hollow grind no matter what. Or probably would (actually, I have a flat belt grinder, so I can make that statement without much question).

I've never drawn temper seriously on any edge (or even remotely close in the last half decade), and grinding carbon steel is miles different than HSS (which itself will grade a wheel and drive up temperatures). Refreshing a hollow on a chisel leaves nothing hotter than what I can drag across my palm to cool it (except for muji HSS tools, of course - they still do get warm, but they can).

That's not a first grind for a newbie, but it's a good target.

CBN's heat transfer properties (the abrasive transfers heat much more efficiently) have pretty much eliminated the skill of getting touch on the heat end of things, though. You can just place an edge on the wheel and unless you really grind a whole lot, it won't get very warm.

As far as the hollow goes, I've never seen anyone break an edge up into the hollow. Most people would be shocked to see the hand tools used by professional craftsmen when they chased the primary bevel very shallow and a secondary bevel much steeper (something that I've gotten commonly on NOS and lightly used double plane irons). I can only guess they did that because it made it easy to sharpen an iron on site with a single stone or two.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#14

Sharpening tools

Chris

Kongzi (aka. Confucius) said: "A craftsman who wants to improve his work first sharpens his tools."

Usually quoted in context of meditation, yoga, "mindfulness" or "self-cultivation". Way above my head, I prefer to take this literally.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#15

Don't play with that . . .

CJ in MPLS

I've heard this one a time or two. I wonder who came up with that one. He must have been famous, because I've heard it quoted by many people.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#16

Re: Don't play with that . . .

david weaver

"Don't let that plane sit on its iron or it'll be dull the next time you use it"

(sitting on wood)

Some of these things I see on comments on youtube, though I've heard that one a lot and one of the things the guy who got me into woodworking made a big deal about was letting the iron only touch free open air while sitting on the bench waiting for use.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#17

Re: Don't play with that . . .

Dan Rode

I want my planes sitting iron down on the bench. If it's sitting on it's side, there's a 100% chance I'll cut myself reaching for something.

At the same time, I used to always worry that I'd move the iron by setting it down on the bench. So I was very careful and often set them to the to was on a scrap or into the tool tray.

After a while I figured out the iron will be fine as long as I don't slam it down.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#18

Re: Two more

david weaver

* A really sharp edge is fragile

* natural stones make a sharper longer lasting edge than synthetics (I always see that in advertisements for $300+ natural stones)

The second one I see mentioned often other places than just catalogs, but I've never seen any proof of it.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#19

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

William Duffield

"If it ain't broke, don't fix it." >(

How are we supposed to make improvements to marginally designed and manufactured tools that work, but not well, if we can't tune, and even experiment? OTOH, the observation that "all tools are kits" is generally true, with very, very few exceptions. At least final honing is needed on every edge tool we acquire. Possible exceptions might be the infill square and a few other tools made by Chris Vesper. What do you think: are there some other tools you have used, or know of that aren't kits?

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#20

Re: In my opinion..

david weaver

Experimentation with how the tools work is the best way to understand them.

It's sort of like saying, what's the best way to understand how an old wooden plane should be made so that it adjusts well and doesn't clog (I know that many folks have bought old wooden planes that look nice only to be vexed by having to take them apart repeatedly or having them adjust unpredictably).

Well, I guess I never had a good handle on it until building planes.

Not touching anything reminds me of Dovo, who still makes straight razors and does a mediocre job honing them, especially if the cutler leaves a little bit of warp. If you hone the razor yourself (or anyone outside of dovo does), then the warranty on the razor is void.

Anyone who has ever shaved with a straight razor will get a kick out of that.

That said, I have received premium planes from people who fettled them by sanding the soles, etc, before ever using the planes. I guess they had read the internet and heard that you should keep the soles in nic with wet and dry paper, so they did it to a new plane right away.

These days, I would take a premium plane and put it on a lap so as to make it convex a few thousandths. That's a bias in favor of the plane user, and a reduction in surface friction from what can be very resistive planes (the perfectly flat ground premium planes that act like a brake once the wax wears off - and when the plane sole is perfectly flat, that is every dozen or two strokes that the effect of the wax is gone), but I wouldn't do that to any plane I expected to sell.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#21

Unless you are an expert...

Bruce McCrory

* "Unless you are a confirmed expert, say nothing."

Typical statement from political acolytes who proliferate fomented prejudice in order to stifle rational thought. Very common in all walks of life.

Example: "Don't be stupid. Everyone knows that your unborn grandchildren will adore you for buying every Veritas tool produced." I had to laugh. Some blogger was selling an LN smoother he had tweaked and gave up on in favor of an historical hand plane, Stanley, I presume.

One can also be made for the straight razor from Grandpa Honker's enamel plated bath cabinet.

Presumption of expertise is always with those who author the above noted subject quote.

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#22

I cut the board again, and it's still too short.


Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#23

Re: Here's one that's true...

david weaver

.. you can't cut laminate flooring with a miter box...I tried twice

(that's what my dad said when he handed me a dull miter box saw)

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#24

Our favorite at work...

John in NM

"What could possibly go wrong?" Spoken in the tone of bravado of one who assumes nothing ever goes wrong :D

A classic courtesy of Mystery Science Theater 3000

Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..

#25

Re: Our favorite at work...

Doug Trembath

Oh, ye of little faith... Would that we were all young and dumb again... Wouldn't it be fun... How I long for those days...

Doug Trembath