Re: Sayings You've Often Heard..
TomD
* a plane is just a jig for a chisel (yeah, OK, and a car is just a bicycle with four wheels)
I don't thing that is a convincing analogy. There is so much wrong with the idea that a car is just a bicycle with four wheels. While a plane really is a jigged blade. Lee Valley even sold one that was designed to hold you chisel, though I made an )1 blade for it.
I think the problem with this saying is twofold: "Just" sounds insulting, if you can insult an object. And the comparison really doesn't add much of use, unless you have are stupid and in desperate need of McGyvering a plane out of chisels and stuff.
* oilstones are too slow to sharpen or oilstones don't make a fine edge, the norton chart says they are only equivalent to ___
I think the real issue isn't that they are bad, it is more that the commonly offered man made versions don't stand up well in comparison to man water stones, or that was the perception that became reality when they hit the market here. There are a whole other range of issue with oil stone, and few pros,
* older tools are inferior and poorly designed, they'd have used our tools if they had them available
Something like axes, in the main, new versions (other than artisinal copies) suck. Modern tools like bandsaw are a lot better and certainly would have been picked up the moment they had hit the market, as in fact they were. Of course modern tools can encompass the whole range of everything. Are you making modern planes or ancient planes? So the win will go to the modern tools on logic.
* you can't use dovetails or mortise and tenon on everything or you'll never get anything done
You would certainly get a lot of DTs and MTs done. The market doesn't care. The useful place in the argument is to avoid fanciful arguments in favour of whatever joinery is under discussion. And don't be embarrassed that something isn't practical. Very little in life, particularly the stuff that makes it fun, is actually practical.
There is something that happens when dudes get involved in woodworking, there is a collision between statements of practicality and the fact that they are engaged in a namby activity that could not be less practical if they did it under water
* we can improve on whatever is out there just by taking an engineering approach (usually said by someone who doesn't understand why certain tools are the way they are)
Engineering is key in many fields but it is not the same thing as design. It is fun to see the mess that happens when engineers set out to explain something seemingly simple, like an Atlat. Given that the whole point of science is that we don't know stuff, but have a process to explain stuff, you would think there might be more humility about the first part.
* you can't get an edge like mine without a jig (implication that freehanded tools have angles all over the place and there is a minefield of unworkable tools as a result)
It is probably true. I was pretty crestfallen when I first heard that Japanese carpenters use jigs and microscopes to prepare their race planes. And most people suck at sharpening at some point. But one can learn to be good at freehand sharpening and it doesn't happen from hiding behind jigs.