New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

A technique for chopping to a baseline

Posts

A technique for chopping to a baseline

#1

A technique for chopping to a baseline

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Buddy Floyd stopped by for dinner and some woodworking chat. Buddy studied Period Furniture under Robert Emmett (Fine Woodworking #22 page 32). Buddy makes Period Furniture, does antique restoration, traditional barn construction, and contributes regularly to our local woodworking club. Buddy made a joke early on that reflects the state of Period Furniture now days. “You know what is the hardest part about making Period Furniture? (I thought carving) Finding someone to buy it!”

Buddy showed a different way to chop to a base line. I have been trying it and I like it.

Task: establish a crisp shoulder at a base line like for a tenon or dovetail. Problem to be avoided is bruising the baseline by the chisel being forced back into it during chopping.

PIC 1



To begin, I have previously been shown and practiced holding the chisel vertical in the scribe line, making a gentle tap and then removing a small chip to establish the initial shoulder. In addition to bruising, the risk is not getting the chisel seated accurately in the shallow scribe line.

PIC 2,3




Buddy is a carver and what he did looked like what I have seen carvers do with a chisel. Holding it more or less as illustrated (I don’t carve so this hand position is from memory, but about right) he raises a small chip with a gentle tap on the chisel. This operation establishes a crisp shoulder that is trivial to locate for the next step. The shoulder is robust enough to resist the chisel bruising even for a modest whack in the next step.

PIC 4


Now holding the chisel vertical against the shoulder, whack it to deepen the cut that begins the waste removal.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#3

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline *LINK*

JDK

Paul Sellers has been an evangelist for this technique for many years:


Chopping to the Knife Wall

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#4

Don't quite understand

Kees

Does he first score the baseline rather deep with a knife and then lightly chop at an angle towards this knifeline?

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#5

Not the same, and comments

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You will note that Buddy uses the chisel bevel down, like in carving, to control the depth of the cut, which is very shallow. And, the scribe line does not have to be deeply scored. Finally, the shaving is removed (probably must be removed) from the face of the wood not the end as shown in your pictures. Removing from the face, bevel down, with a carving position for the hand enables a very fine shaving to be raised against the shallow scribe line. Yet the resulting vertical wall at the shoulder is strong enough to support a modest whack for the first vertical cut. Study my pictures and you can see the differences.

The advantage I am finding is that there is virtually no chance of the vertical cut drifting off the baseline due to inaccurate chisel positioning. When I lost concentration I occasionally did not get the chisel accurately registered in a shallow scribe line. The result is a shoulder with a defect. Additionally, because there is a shoulder established for the first vertical cut, one can whack the chisel harder on this first vertical cut. The result is a quicker job of chopping out the waste, at least in my hands.

As far as invention, Buddy likely learned this approach from Emmett and I would not be surprised if it has been used for hundreds of years by some. If indeed it has merit it most assuredly has been used forever by some.

Does anyone here use it, tried it and rejected, whatever?

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#6

Scribe line is shallow, chip is thin

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With chisel bevel down, hand supported more or less as shown, one can control the chisel to lift a very fine shaving that runs up to the baseline and fractures, leaving a vertical shoulder. While I failed to ask Buddy explicitly, I think he was using the chisel just as he would use a carving chisel to make an accurately controlled cut. As far as I could tell he was holding the chisel as I have seen people like Mary May or folks in the Headley shop carve. I found it quick to learn to get an optimum shaving thickness and I could proceed rapidly across the scribe line to raise these chips.

With a vertical shoulder now established it was very quick and reliable to accurately locate the chisel for the first vertical cut.

I can not control the shaving depth if I come in from the end of the board. The shaving must be lifted from the face of the board to control its thickness.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#7

clarification

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

My hand is resting on the bench in Picture 2, and the bevel of the chisel is down on the face of the board. The idea is to achieve a hand position that provides for precise pivoting of the chisel off its bevel to raise an optimally thin shaving, quickly, with a gentle tap of a mallet and then be able to reposition the chisel for the next shaving.

I once watched Phil Lowe carve a tray table edge . It was astonishing how quick the chisel could be positioned and an accurate shaving taken. It think it is this ability that enables an initial shoulder to be established quickly in this case if the chisel and hand are properly positioned. It takes just a few seconds to raise the shavings across a 4" scribe line and then you are off to the races with the vertical blows.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#8

Re: clarification

Hank Knight

That's a classic carver's hand position. Once mastered, it provides a solid anchor for delicate control. Mary May maintains that a good carver needs to have ambidextrous mastery of this grip. I wish ...

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#9

Re: Scribe line is shallow, chip is thin

Kees

Ok, understand it better now. Something to try the next time.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#10

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Steve Voigt

It looks fine to me, but I have to say I don't really see that bevel up vs. down is of much consequence here. I use chisels bevel down (probably like most other people do) primarily to have greater control over the cut, especially when it (the cut I mean) is longer than a few inches. For the 3/4" or less length of cut on the tails, I can't see that it matters much.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#11

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

With the bevel up you will need to have the chisel nearly horizontal to the board surface to take a thin shaving. I don't find this situation favorable. I don't see how one can have any control of the shaving thickness without riding the bevel.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#12

Re: FK all the way

TomD

That isn't so much a method, as the method. It is for instance the method used in that video FK did on dovetails, which remains very good (no reason why it wouldn't). I advise people to look at that video, not generally, but specifically to every single tap. If you copy exactly what he does and don't insist on introducing seventy things from 35 different places, you will have an excellent method. Every tap leads to the next move, mixing in stuff may undermine the next thing he is moving towards. The main thing I am referring to is his chisel work, it is the part he is blistering at with no loss of quality. The layout method is mostly for rougher, work, but his chisel work, I don't see it has been exceeded. His power tools are another example of something one could easily vary without loss, but the chisel work is pretty connected.

A bit more of a reach is the Krenov described method in which he simply takes a fence and clamps it over the line. Same principle, but a kludge. However in context of something like a pearwood side, you might well prefer to eliminate even the rare chance of an accident. Part of doing really fine work (my best personal experience of this is guitar making), is protecting the work every step of the way. You get 100 hours into a guitar and you realize you only have to place it gentry over a piece of dust to scratch the surface, and there may be little you can do about it. You will do something, but it may not be what you wanted to do having set everything up and been about to spray.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#13

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Warren in Lancaster, PA

There is no problem taking fine cuts with the bevel up. In carving we use a gouge bevel up on convex surfaces and bevel down on concave surfaces.

Concerning the above technique. A chisel is both a cutting edge and a wedge. Because it is a wedge, it will spread the tissue in both directions if you cut right on the line. However if we relieve one side of the cut we can cause the wedge to push stuff in that direction. For instance on dovetails we can saw with a coping saw to near the line, then use the chisel right in the scribed line because the waste will be pushed toward the thin waste side. Or we can take our first chisel cut some small distance from the scribed line and then cut right on the line and have the movement to the waste side.

If we are making tenons we can saw a shoulder a small distance from the scribe line and then cut to the line with the chisel. Or better yet we can saw right on the line to save even more time. I think all four of the techniques I mentioned would be faster than what you describe.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#14

point by point/bevels

TomD

That method as you describe it is basically identical to FK's. He uses the scribe, light chop; He takes the wedge out bevel down, not from the end. Partly because it is the smallest movement you can do to achieve the result, but also to set up the flip side. If he takes it from the end now, when he powers up from the other side, end grain will tear out. While if he leaves enough in place that it lies on the table, he will get a more penetrating cut. But on the second side he varies it, and takes out the waste from the end, because that produces the best result in that case, and is also related to how he gets out the waste relative to the shapes he is dealing with, which are not finger joints. Etc...

What you say about carvers is trueish since with gouges the shape one paid big bucks for is most commonly summoned from the bevel down side, there are many exceptions but it is true to a significant extent. However, it is just our loss of context that leads us to believe this is not a carpenter thing. This was one thing I picked up from Japanese carpenters (no interrupted tradition to wonder about), how much they worked off the bevel. Somewhat additionally odd, given how fancy the backs of the chisels are - must be where the action is, right? I came away and started using my chisels off the bevel almost all the time, as an exercise, now I don't think about it, and just use what makes sense.

Brief commercial interlude: for chisels with double bevels centred geometry. Very useful tools in many cases (western version I am talking about).

This also gets into all the stuff about how one should grind a bevel. There will certainly be some difference if you have rounded, hollow, micro, or flat.

Speaking of which the Krenov specialized chisels - through to the Hedley shop ones have shapes you could describe as micro bevelled, and tapered, so that the have very acute bodies and penetrate with very little set back. The setback force is however multiplied, so one has to watch that. (Thin wedge requires less space to power through, but exerts more force). One can also break the chisel.

There is also a detail in the way Japanese chisels are set up (and before people explode, you could do this with a western chisel). They are set up so that the bevel can be flat to the work for surface paring, and the handle does not interfere. But a detail of this is that if you hold the back vertical and hit with the handle angle which is pitched forward, you get the double bevel centred effect to some degree, and you get less set back on your line, which is in part there because you are driving into the bevel and forcing the chisel back. It isn't just the geometry of the chisel, it is the vector of the force. Since the pounding is a cross body deal, you can make this a very natural motion.

As regards that, should the set up place the dovetail end board parallel or perpendicular to the shoulders, which gets into jigs and all that. I think the natural way is with the board end perp to the shoulder line, and that flows with the other stuff we have been talking about. It seems when people want to jig up they often do it from a face to end perspective, where part of what they are fighting may be the mechanics. It is at least a thought.

Chisel design is affected by al this in many ways, stuff like should the transition be aesthetic or built like a fire plug. How long, where should you hold it. A lot of these things come up as individual issues, but there is an organic whole to the thing.

This is advanced stuff (very easy to do), that I have brought up many times before here, and have been teaching for 15 years. It would be nice if I could somehow actually get it across.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#15

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

TomD

Actually, on the clock, the method Bill has the first rung of is the race winner in the hands of FK. It is generally faster to chop than to saw. There are some stunning examples of sawing being faster. I have one proprietary method I should really write up though it is a mixed method, and probably not what people want to hear about. But all that said, most of the sawing methods involve twice the work, which is fine for beginners, and special situations, but if there was a way to chop and not loose speed or quality,in that step, it would be faster overall. There are at least two methods.

People generally know FK is very fast, but for the most part his methods are not seriously discussed. Woodworkers seem to think he is magic. But some of the things he does are easily adopted by anyone regardless of skill.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#16

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I saw a video of Frank dovetailing; he hits the chisel right on the line with two or three substantial hits then hits at an angle with likewise several substantial hits. Then he turns the piece over and does the same and he is done. This is very different from Bill's one gentle tap at an angle to raise a small chip.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#17

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Ironically, PS uses his chisel BU to create a "knife wall".

While watching the video on Youtube, I noticed another, which is on inlay dovetails. This demonstrates a different method of creating the knife wall ...

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=YeTKRcnuWPI

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#18

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

JDK

Not impressed with the "inlay dovetails."

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#19

Follow up thoughts on many paths to an end

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Something remarkable about woodworking is the variety of paths employed to a common result, be it "pins or tails", how to establish a crisp shoulder on a M&T or whatever. The fact that woodworkers have not settled on one "best" way to do these tasks can not be dismissed as ignorance, lack of skill or lack of experience. The novice or amateur woodworker might not have found "the best" way from lack of experience or changing skill level. But we see a diversity of approaches to common woodworking tasks among people that have made and sold hundreds of pieces of furniture. I would not presume these people have not found the best way for them, even if this way is different from our notion of the "best" way.

What is unclear, and interesting, are the factors that make one approach best for one furniture maker and a different approach best for another. As amateur or novice woodworkers it is unclear what this fact means for how we should find our best way. Should we pick something that works for a successful furniture maker and master it? Or should we learn of and experiment with various approaches advocated by mentors, passionate teaches and/or writers to discover what is best for us?

Personally, I am an experimenter. I will probably never settle on "the" way and reject trying something else. Since I am not making a living at it I have the luxury of wasting time trying stuff, and having fun doing so. Something I do consider though is reliability. In the end I want to make stuff so what I try must have a good chance of working well.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#20

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"There is no problem taking fine cuts with the bevel up. In carving we use a gouge bevel up on convex surfaces and bevel down on concave surfaces."

I the case at hand we are creating a concave surface by scooping out a fine shaving from a flat surface. I would not presume that someone that can earn a living doing the carving on 18th century furniture in a competitive market like Charlestown would not know the best way to hold the chisel for the task at hand. If anyone wishes to try the approach described don't reject it before trying it bevel down.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#21

Re: Follow up thoughts on many paths to an end

Michael Brady

I learned from this exchange: the meaning and pronunciation of "kludge", which coincidentally is directed to the method I use to avoid crossing the baseline, and that there so far has been no use of blue masking tape, unless I read too hastily.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#22

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

Warren in Lancaster, PA



"There is no problem taking fine cuts with the bevel up. In carving we use a gouge bevel up on convex surfaces and bevel down on concave surfaces."

I the case at hand we are creating a concave surface by scooping out a fine shaving from a flat surface. I would not presume that someone that can earn a living doing the carving on 18th century furniture in a competitive market like Charlestown would not know the best way to hold the chisel for the task at hand. If anyone wishes to try the approach described don't reject it before trying it bevel down.

I don't think you have any idea what you are talking about. A gouge makes a concave surface or a convex surface depending on how it is postioned. A chisel cuts a flat surface. I mentioned the carving to emphasize that we are able to make fine cuts either bevel up or bevel down. With a chisel, we sometimes use one or the other in the flow of work just to avoid changing grips and wasting time. The idea that we cannot control a chisel with the bevel up is preposterous.

Concerning carving: if you can't carve with or without a mallet, bevel up or bevel down, away from yourself, towards yourself, to the left or the right, with a great variety grips and a great variety of stances, you are not much of a carver. We have to cut in three dimensions. There just is not time to reposition the work piece every time you need to make a different cut. Best way to hold a chisel???

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#23

How did we get on carving....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

a topic I indeed no nothing about.

Getting back on track......for anyone wishing to try the technique that Buddy uses do try raising the shaving with the bevel down as illustrated .......and any other way that suites your curiosity. Or dismiss the idea entirely. In the end do what works best to be judged by the user making stuff.

I implemented the technique illustrated 16 times yesterday and so far still think it better than what I was doing, however flawed what I was doing might be. The bottom line is that it is getting nice crisp baselines accomplished.

Re: A technique for chopping to a baseline

#24

Re: Follow up thoughts on many paths to an end

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Bill,

I appreciate this post. Here's why. It is always helpful to see how professionals perform certain operations. For this same reason, I thought Warren's contribution--that you don't actually have to lift up and clear the chip, simply cutting through the supporting grain is sufficient--is highly appreciated.

The professional is up against something I knew in my work life, but never in my hobby life: To do high quality work on time and on budget, and that the customer will be happy with. And do it reliably, so as to build a positive reputation for delivering the goods. This is a stern test, hence, any long term professional who is cutting it against the odds is to be listened to attentively.

I love these accounts of how pro's do things, no matter if it leads to competing methods. All the better.

Wiley