point by point/bevels
TomD
That method as you describe it is basically identical to FK's. He uses the scribe, light chop; He takes the wedge out bevel down, not from the end. Partly because it is the smallest movement you can do to achieve the result, but also to set up the flip side. If he takes it from the end now, when he powers up from the other side, end grain will tear out. While if he leaves enough in place that it lies on the table, he will get a more penetrating cut. But on the second side he varies it, and takes out the waste from the end, because that produces the best result in that case, and is also related to how he gets out the waste relative to the shapes he is dealing with, which are not finger joints. Etc...
What you say about carvers is trueish since with gouges the shape one paid big bucks for is most commonly summoned from the bevel down side, there are many exceptions but it is true to a significant extent. However, it is just our loss of context that leads us to believe this is not a carpenter thing. This was one thing I picked up from Japanese carpenters (no interrupted tradition to wonder about), how much they worked off the bevel. Somewhat additionally odd, given how fancy the backs of the chisels are - must be where the action is, right? I came away and started using my chisels off the bevel almost all the time, as an exercise, now I don't think about it, and just use what makes sense.
Brief commercial interlude: for chisels with double bevels centred geometry. Very useful tools in many cases (western version I am talking about).
This also gets into all the stuff about how one should grind a bevel. There will certainly be some difference if you have rounded, hollow, micro, or flat.
Speaking of which the Krenov specialized chisels - through to the Hedley shop ones have shapes you could describe as micro bevelled, and tapered, so that the have very acute bodies and penetrate with very little set back. The setback force is however multiplied, so one has to watch that. (Thin wedge requires less space to power through, but exerts more force). One can also break the chisel.
There is also a detail in the way Japanese chisels are set up (and before people explode, you could do this with a western chisel). They are set up so that the bevel can be flat to the work for surface paring, and the handle does not interfere. But a detail of this is that if you hold the back vertical and hit with the handle angle which is pitched forward, you get the double bevel centred effect to some degree, and you get less set back on your line, which is in part there because you are driving into the bevel and forcing the chisel back. It isn't just the geometry of the chisel, it is the vector of the force. Since the pounding is a cross body deal, you can make this a very natural motion.
As regards that, should the set up place the dovetail end board parallel or perpendicular to the shoulders, which gets into jigs and all that. I think the natural way is with the board end perp to the shoulder line, and that flows with the other stuff we have been talking about. It seems when people want to jig up they often do it from a face to end perspective, where part of what they are fighting may be the mechanics. It is at least a thought.
Chisel design is affected by al this in many ways, stuff like should the transition be aesthetic or built like a fire plug. How long, where should you hold it. A lot of these things come up as individual issues, but there is an organic whole to the thing.
This is advanced stuff (very easy to do), that I have brought up many times before here, and have been teaching for 15 years. It would be nice if I could somehow actually get it across.