New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

200+ woodworking book reviews

Sold my Jointer

Posts

Re: Sold my Jointer

#26

Chris Scholz

What do you mean by "not historically correct"? *LINK*

Chris Scholz

... who argued that scrubs are not historically correct. I now forget what their evolution was supposed to have been for.

Curious to understand that. Wolfgang Jordan shows an industrially manufactured scrub plane that he dates back to 1860 (depending where in the world you are that may or may not be considered "historic"). My naive reasoning would be that these type of plane many have been around a long time in one form or another before the became a manufactured product.


Austrian (not Australian) Scrub Plane from 1860

Re: Sold my Jointer

#27

Re: What do you mean by "not historically correct"

BrianMonumentCO

I wonder what the irons look like.

The planes in the pix have bodies that look like a jack.

What makes them scrub planes?

In view that we cannot see the irons.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#28

Re: 1860..

david weaver

..is pretty late in the spectrum to introduce a plane that would be for coarse work.

As stanley introduced theirs late, after machine planing (and jointing, or "buzz planing") was already common, who knows what the usefulness was?

I don't from any of these, but I second the notion from Brian that the line between jack and "scrub" isn't necessarily that clear.

Even in discussions here, there are a lot of people describing the use of a rank set jack plane, and not a purpose made scrub.

No clue what the continental euros were doing, and whether or not a plane like that would've been more popular if they were working wet wood instead of dry. It's a lot easier to scrub wet wood than it is dry wood. It could've been the role of those planes to clean up riven wood.

Maybe kees can tell us.

I do like the continental smoother design, though, it allows two forceful hands for coarse work, which is useful all the way up to coarse smoothing.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#29

Greber traces scrub plane at least to 1570

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Chris and all,

I am fortunate and very appreciative to have been given copies of Josef Greber's 'The History of the Woodworking Plane', by a European friend. Both the English language copy published by the Early American Industries Association (text, no plates), and the German copy, which has plates in it.

Here is a photo from Greber of two planes with provenance back to 1570, a smooth plane (upper) and a scrub plane (lower), both shorter than we are presently accustomed to:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/15972827793/in/photostream/

These planes were formerly located in the Dresden Historical Museum, but were destroyed in WWII. It is stated in the text--referring to the Late Middle Ages--that roughing planes had standard angles of 45 degrees, with planes intended for finer shavings bedded steeper at 48, 50, or 52, and even up to 60-65 for the finest shavings.

There were iron planes also of this era. Here is a photo from Greber of an iron scrub plane, 5 inches long with 1-5/8" iron, which is still extant in Dresden. The plane is from the same 1570 provenance as those above:

https://www.flickr.com/photos/78661951@N07/15973386593/in/album-72157650940844105/lightbox/

There is a table in the book which lists prices on various irons during the 1600's, from Stuttgart and Goppingen. The Goppingen prices, from 1669, are said to reflect the sizes of the irons, with the scrub iron at 6 Kreuzer, compared to a jointer iron at 10-12 Kreuzer.

Wiley

Re: Sold my Jointer

#30

Re:Or what makes scrub planes

TomD

Or what makes scrub planes scrub planes, vs Jacks? The first one I made was very curved edge, almost semi circular, and the mouth was gaping, but in use or configuration what justifies the name.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#31

Re: Greber traces scrub plane at least to 1570

TomD

Wiley, how do we know they are scrub planes? I don't read german, so I can't tell if they use some word for scrub in their other than gestrüpp.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#32

Re: Greber traces scrub plane at least to 1570

david weaver

Those planes are exceptionally ornate and crisp.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#33

Re: Greber traces scrub plane at least to 1570

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Tom and all,

The 'scrub plane' originated in Germany, and there has been continuity and documentation of German language and dialect, as well as the physical planes, over the centuries. Greber presents this history and evidence, so ultimately what we know is from Greber, and of course I can add nothing to his evidence. But I can quote a few things which relate to your question:

Greber states, p. 103 in the EAIA translation,

"The Scherfhobel, or Schurfhobel as it is called in the Dresden inventory (Fig. 81, bottom), was the predecessor of the present-day scrub plane (Schropphobel), whose name and form come from 19th-century plane factories. There are at least nine different names for the plane in German, varying according to locality. All the names have the same meaning--a tool used for coarse work, cutting, scratching. Hubner writes [NB: Hubner was a German technical encyclopedist published in Leipzig, 1712]:

"It is the first and so-to-say the preliminary hand plane, with which a rough surface is worked up. Its sole is flat, but the iron, set at a half right angle (i.e., 45 degree pitch) must be sharpened more or less in an arc so that it cuts into the stuff deeper and more easily."

Greber had access to historical inventories. The Dresden collection made by the Elector August I of Saxony, who ruled from 1553-86, had several inventories over time. The earliest inventory, ordered by Christian I immediately after the death of August I, was made in 1587 by toolmaker Balthasar Hacker. Hacker's inventory lists 301 planes, including 44 scrub planes.

By 1945, there were 1,280 items left of August I's Dresden collection These were taken at the time by the Soviet army. However, they were carefully stored and returned in 1958, and several of the tools were included in the 'Splendor of Dresden' exhibit which toured the US in 1978-79 (quoting liberally from Greber, pp. 91 et seq.). The wooden scrub in Fig. 81 and shown in my Flickr link was lost in WWII, however, the iron scrub in Fig. 2, also linked, still survives.

Ultimately, I think we should credit Greber as knowing his stuff, and being a careful historian. He was born in Trier, his father being a chief engineer engaged in building railroad bridges. Josef has a lengthy curriculum vitae, but a few short sentences will give the flavor: He apprenticed as a cabinetmaker, went on to become a journeyman, and then completed education at the vocational teachers' college of Univ. of Cologne, taught at various trade schools, became headmaster of a training college for vocational instructors in 1957. He has numerous publications on tradecraft and trade history. His surviving notes, working papers, and manuscripts (there was some dislocation during WWII) were at Winterthur Museum at the time of publication of the books referenced here.

If I can provide anything further that would help, will be glad to try!

Wiley

Re: Sold my Jointer

#34

Re: Greber traces scrub plane at least to 1570

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

One thing to bear in mind: The Elector of Hanover was a powerful personage. The Holy Roman Empire was carved up into 7 Electorates--the Electors elected the HR Emperor. They were like kings. So when he decided to have a Museum, and sent out for objects, the toolmakers made real nice ones!

Wiley