New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Sold my Jointer

Posts

Sold my Jointer

#1

Sold my Jointer

CJ in MPLS

I suppose it was just coincidence that a very mild blister that I formed during my last hand planing session a few weeks ago peeled away this afternoon. I'm committed to truing up my wood using hand planes now in any event. I will still cheat on the thicknessing however.

CJ

Re: Sold my Jointer

#2

Re: Sold my Jointer

BrianMonumentCO

I am assuming that you sold your electric jointer.

For thickness planing a scrub plane is useful and essential.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#3

Re: Sold my Jointer

John in NM

Congratulations to you, and enjoy a bit more floorspace :D

I can't do without one myself, but that's the way it goes. In the next month or so I'm getting a second one - 12", more or less free for some driving :D

Re: Sold my Jointer

#4

I wish I had the same

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I find that face jointing is hard on knives. Ideally one needs a wide one for face flattening and another with keen edges for edge jointing. That said I usually begin the flattening of a severely twisted board by nipping the corners with a scrub plane ( a cheap #5 with a cambered blade. Can't see why buying an authentic scrub is desirable or necessary.)

Re: Sold my Jointer

#5

Re: Sold my Jointer

CJ in MPLS

Brian:

Yes, the jointer in question was an 8" Delta Crescent. A #7 Diamond Edge is now the sole mechanism with this function in the garage.

And while I do understand the scrubbing process, I'm not keen on using it overmuch. ;)

CJ

Re: Sold my Jointer

#6

Re: Sold my Jointer

TomD

Used to be some one on this board who argued that scrubs are not historically correct. I now forget what their evolution was supposed to have been for.

I wouldn't buy a scrub plane mainly because I can't see any reason why the type profits from being made of metal. Possibly the lower stance, but that is hardly an important advantage. In wood one can knock one out in an hour, so why not have a "real" one. Biggest advantage to a scrub over as Jack is that they are easy for weak people to push, or to cut endgrain. A lot of this kind of work today is done by people at the opposite end of the age spectrum from the apprentices or kids who might have done it in an earlier age. Or they lack the lifetime of experience an old hand might have had. On the archery boards where the demographic is seemingly 60 and over, the second childhood Shakespeare spoke of is much in evidence as draw weights fall into the toy department range again, as people are ageing. At some point a tool that takes a decent bite but is easy to push may shine, for now it cuts endgrain maple easily.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#7

Re: Sold my Jointer

david weaver

These have all become "white collar sports", I suppose as a crisis to actually make something that is permanent other than a printout of whatever we do at work.

I profile my jacks very aggressively because I'm lazy and they are easier to use that way. Not quite to scrub profile, but more aggressive than the average jack user.

I might be one of the people who said a scrub is not a necessary hand tool to have, but mostly because if you want a really aggressive profile, you can just get it out of a jack plane or an old continental jack and have what is essentially a better plane to use.

I tried both versions of premium metal scrubs and they are both left in the dust by various wooden planes with a rank set on the iron (cheap japanese planes with the irons ground drastically, english style jack planes, and continental...I've tried them all).

Re: Sold my Jointer

#8

Scrub planes

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

David, Tom, and all,

Two theories about scrubs.

Theory 1 by Chris Schwarz. It's a ripping tool, to be used by carpenters when hand saw ripping would be less practical:

http://www.popularwoodworking.com/woodworking-blogs/chris-schwarz-blog/scrub-planes-a-curious-animal

Theory 2. In Continental Europe, board preparation began with the scrub, rather than the fore plane, as in Great Britain. So about the turn of the century (ca. 1900), Stanley saw a marketing opportunity to the numerous European craftsmen coming into the US at that time:

https://literaryworkshop.wordpress.com/2012/11/08/the-origin-of-the-stanley-40-scrub-plane-a-hypothesis/

Personally, I like the British approach--17-20" jack/fore planes. Get it flat while you're knocking down the high places. But do the rough cross-cutting first.

Wiley

Re: Sold my Jointer

#9

Re: Scrub planes

david weaver

I'm not sure which is correct, I've noticed that even with a jack or something, if I have a quarter to remove from the edge of a board, it's quicker to set the try plane rank and do it. The benefit being (it's easy to do a hundredth at a time or a little more), that there isn't much tearout and the board is still flat and square when the mark is hit.

I am guessing that when I use my jack on a lazy shaving, one that offers not fighting back, that the volume of wood is similar to a heavy shaving of the try plane. The thickness is greater, but the chip is tapered. Don't know for sure, though. It doesn't get me through the edge quicker.

The continental idea is one I can get on with, though. There's a definite line between scrub and jack plane at a cursory glance before you get into the hobby, but other than the planes that are literally designated as scrubs (like the stanley, and some of the older single iron continental planes with narrow irons), functionally the rank set jacks do the same thing. Personally, I like a wider jack with the same set as a scrub anyway, as you alluded to, why have the board any less flat than it needs to be? Narrow planes for anything other than thicknessing work just provide an opportunity to have a valley somewhere.

(I think my thoughts about using the try plane to plane a board to width are probably not similar to most folks using jointer planes, etc and taking light cuts. Just another area where a try plane and the will to use it with some vummer is a great option over a plane that is set usually or only to take light cuts - and without the resistance of a long metal plane).

Re: Sold my Jointer

#10

Scrubs for machine woodworkers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

A 3rd philosophy for "scrubs". Even those that employ jointers and planers have use for a scrub plane function. The two situations where I use mine the most are trimming applied edge molding where the application is wider than what it is applied to and it needs to be leveled, and, nipping the corners off twisted lumber prior to running it across the jointer to flatten. Both needs require the plane to take an aggressive shaving. Any heavy plane with a cambered blade and open mouth works fine for these tasks. I use a Stanley #5. It is the tool I reach for when wood needs to go away in a hurry, but still have control of what is going away. The planes called "scrub planes" are too light weight for my taste and needs and I don't do enough of any what I will call coarse planing to justify an expensive plane.

I prefer the repurposed #5 with its highly cambered blade to just setting a typical #5 to take a coarse cut for several reasons. Foremost is that the highly cambered blade cuts even when it dull. In fact I hardly ever sharpen it. It is easy to push, and for narrow planing like trimming an edge band the depth of cut can be adjusted by moving the position of the plane side to side.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#11

An experienced hand...

Bob Hackett

with a good eye and sharp axe, hatchet or adze can do the work a scrub plane would do with less time and effort. Look at Peter Follansbee`s videos so see what I mean.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#12

Re: An experienced hand...

david weaver

It depends on what you're working. If you're using properly sized and decent quality lumber, an axe or a hatchet should be a fairly rare thing. I keep a broad hatchet over my bench, but I only use it when I have something odd on a piece of lumber (like ends where a mill left part of the end high on a board).

It is nice to have at least one sharp 2 pound hatchet around, though.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#13

That needs to go on a T-Shirt

CJ in MPLS

Like so:


Re: Sold my Jointer

#14

Re: That needs to go on a T-Shirt

david weaver

I think you could probably sell that :)

Re: Sold my Jointer

#15

White collar

Warren in Lancaster, PA


White collar woodworkers, 1813. Almost as many clamps as as BT; almost as many hones as DW.; almost as may braces as BH. almost as many bench planes as ...

Re: Sold my Jointer

#16

Jack Guzman from Maine

Scrub

Jack Guzman from Maine

I got tired of the valuable shop space my jointer took up and was real happy when I sold it. Never regretted it. I joint board edges with a #7 stanley.

Scrub planes--Boy,these guys really have it in for this useful little thing. Mine is a european style wooden one with a horn on the front. I use alot of local air dried hardwoods bought in the rough.I needed to make a threshhold. I found a good sized piece of white oak but it had a twist on one end. Out with the scrub and the winding sticks. A few minutes work then run it through the planer and I had my board. I keep it around just for such work. It's not an essential tool,probably not historically correct but it is a useful tool.I have used it many times. ---Jack

Re: Sold my Jointer

#17

Jack Guzman from Maine

Nice picture

Jack Guzman from Maine

I like that picture. What is the source for it? I think I'd like that for wallpaper on my pc monitor. thanks---Jack

Re: Sold my Jointer

#18

Re: That needs to go on a T-Shirt

TomD

Not with that plane on it, but yeah, great shirt! What is more one could probably print from that graphic.

Though might be better on a golf shirt, you know, it has a collar. :)

Re: Sold my Jointer

#19

Re: Scrubs for machine woodworkers

TomD

That is how I use it too, but my primary, a tool I love, has a German blade in it, and it can get hit or miss at times when the furoughs cover so much space it is hard to find the surface, and nothing left to cut below it, which is possibly where the idea that the tool has a different purpose in some version. I just grab a different plane if that happens, and the same cut that creates problems is great on endgrain.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#20

Re: Nice picture -  image source  *LINK*


https://dblaney.files.wordpress.com/2014/02/john-hill-carpenters-shop-1813.jpg

Re: Sold my Jointer

#21

Re: Nice picture

Warren in Lancaster, PA

The painting is called Interior of the carpenter shop at Forty Hill by John Hill. You can find it by searching "Forty Hill" "John Hill". There are some detail pictures of the fellow on the left.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#22

Jack Guzman from Maine

thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Sold my Jointer

#23

Jack Guzman from Maine

that works-thanks


Re: Sold my Jointer

#24

I like my scrub plane

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

I have a Stanley 40, and find it quite useful. I like the narrow furrows it makes, and, used cross-grain (directly across or at a strong angle across the grain), it makes quick work of reducing stock when needed.

I do have a postwar Stanley No. 5 with a Handyman cutting iron that I plan to sharpen with a strong camber, so I can find out whether I've been missing something that y'all who use a jack as a thickness-reducing plane know about. But until I get the needed round tuit, the scrub gets the job done.

Maybe it's a matter of the stock being worked. Since I've been in carpentry mode for several years, the wood I work tends to be Douglas fir, pine, redwood, woods like that, rather than furniture-grade hardwoods.

Scrub planes are like drawknives: for stock reduction, the optimum stroke is short and choppy. I even grunt, like a TV karate guy, sometimes when I make the strokes.

Re: Sold my Jointer

#25

I wish I had all those windows...

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Well not today. It is below zero and being near a window is cool.