Re: Scrub planes
david weaver
I'm not sure which is correct, I've noticed that even with a jack or something, if I have a quarter to remove from the edge of a board, it's quicker to set the try plane rank and do it. The benefit being (it's easy to do a hundredth at a time or a little more), that there isn't much tearout and the board is still flat and square when the mark is hit.
I am guessing that when I use my jack on a lazy shaving, one that offers not fighting back, that the volume of wood is similar to a heavy shaving of the try plane. The thickness is greater, but the chip is tapered. Don't know for sure, though. It doesn't get me through the edge quicker.
The continental idea is one I can get on with, though. There's a definite line between scrub and jack plane at a cursory glance before you get into the hobby, but other than the planes that are literally designated as scrubs (like the stanley, and some of the older single iron continental planes with narrow irons), functionally the rank set jacks do the same thing. Personally, I like a wider jack with the same set as a scrub anyway, as you alluded to, why have the board any less flat than it needs to be? Narrow planes for anything other than thicknessing work just provide an opportunity to have a valley somewhere.
(I think my thoughts about using the try plane to plane a board to width are probably not similar to most folks using jointer planes, etc and taking light cuts. Just another area where a try plane and the will to use it with some vummer is a great option over a plane that is set usually or only to take light cuts - and without the resistance of a long metal plane).