New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Discussion topic: case innards

Posts

Discussion topic: case innards

#1

Discussion topic:  case innards

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi all,

I'm curious what you folks think about a particular aspect of case internals--how to terminate drawer runners. Or more particularly, where to terminate them.

I generally tenon the runners into a mortise in the rear blade, which is itself part of a web frame. However, in Jeffrey Greene's book 'American Furniture of the 18th Century', he shows highly-regarded historical examples where the runners are mortised directly into the back of the case, so that the case innards contain the minimum number of sticks needed to do the job of restraining the drawer. Functionally, you don't require a rear blade to hold the drawer--it's there to receive the runners. Greene shows other period examples where there are rear blades receiving the runners, so practice varied.

To be honest, I use the rear blade to receive the runners because it's what occurs to me when I think about how the case will be assembled. I can't quite understand how on person will put the case together, if the runners terminate in a mortise in the case back. On the other hand, I know that any extra stick added to the minimum required to guide the drawer, will add another constraint to be satisfied in fitting the drawer.

So. Where do you folks terminate the drawer runners, and why? Does anyone tenon them into mortises in the case back, and why?

Thanks,

Wiley

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#2

page references?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Historically they were often just nailed to the sides of the case (desk pg 268 for example). Personally I mortise them into a back blade or nail them into a dado on the case side. Why not. It is trivial to do.

I only found one example in the Greene book with the runner mortised into the case back and it was more a situation where the back was an apron of a table like affair, not the back of a chest of drawers. There is no mention of attaching to the case back in the drawer section page143.

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#3

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

There rear divider is there to keep the case back the same size as the case front in spite of the comings and goings of the wood over time.


I am unsure what you mean by web frame. The drawer runners are not glued into the drawer dividers except maybe in front, but there is no reason to glue them in front. There is no frame about it in the sense that this assembly is fastened together.

(Note: in this unusual piece the drawers are graduated from large on top to smaller on the bottom :) )

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#4

Re: Discussion topic:  case innards

Roger Myers

The attached picture is a view of the drawer runners for the center drawer on a low chest by noted 18th century CT maker E. Chapin. The case is one over three drawers and the drawer runners for the center drawer are fit to the case back. The side runners are mounted to the case sides using the 18th century version of pocket screws. This is an exceptionally well made piece with great attention to both what showed as well as interior construction. The piece is on display at the CT Historical Society where I measured it.

Unless I am doing a reproduction piece, I generally tenon runners into a front and back rail, glued both front and back, and this frame is then set in dados on the case side and glued only in the front.


Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#5

Re: Discussion topic:  case innards

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have seen cases where the drawer runners were tenoned to the back of the case. Some have the side runners attached to sides of the case, while runners between side by side drawers are attached to the back boards. There is a lot of variety in the inner structure of chests of drawers. Some have the dividers and runners slide in from the front; some have them slide in from the back. I don't recall a case where some parts were set in from the front while others were from the back.

When making reproductions, some people copy the inner structure from the original and some do whatever they are used to.

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#6

Re: Discussion topic:  case innards

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Thanks to you all! On further study, prompted by Roger's post, I think I may have found a clue.

There is a one-over-three drawer dressing table shown in J. Greene's book, pp. 239-240 (Boston, 1735-50, Israel Sack Coll.), with internal runners tenoned straight into the back. Then, on the pages 232-37 preceding, there is a bonnet-top high chest and a flat-top high chest whose lower tiers are similar to the one-over-three design, and whose interior runners are tenoned into the back.

In these three examples, the lower front rail is not of blade form. It is vertically oriented with ornate curves and finials, and does not lend itself to web frame construction, physically or from the standpoint of assembly. I couldn't see enough of the Eliphalet Chapin one-over-three to know if its front lower rail is similarly vertically oriented and sculpted, but likely it is judging from E. Chapin examples I googled.

Thanks to you all for a good discussion!

Wiley

P. S. I would post the relevant photos, but am worried about copyright w/r/t Jeffrey Greene's book. However, here is a good example of E. Chapin's one-over-three construction:

http://connecticuthistory.org/connecticut-valley-style-eliphalet-chapin-inspires-a-tradition-of-craft/

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#7

comments, disagreements

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In the examples quoted the center rail is tenoned into the back. However, it looks to me like the side rails are nailed to the sides as would be typical. In fact there seems to be a nail indicated on page 240 and there is no indication of a tenon on the back of the side rails.


However, if the side of the case is offset then it is just easiest to mortise all the rails into the back as shown in the coffee table I recently made.

The examples quoted are very special cases. The "back" is a one piece solid member like on a table, which provides a stable location for a possible mortise. A chest of drawers which typically would have an applied back, ship lapped for example, offers a poor place to locate a mortise. In this case something else needs to be back there to accept a mortise. In such a case there will be a divider to hold the back of the case together.

It all comes down to what is easiest for the case at hand. What ever is back there that can accept a mortise is fair game. I think you are overthinking this issue.

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#8

PS

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

What is the concern that prompted the question?

I worry about engineering to hold the case or table together. The engineering to hold a drawer is a minor consideration and an afterthought following the decisions of how to construct the case. Given that anything will hold up a drawer what ever convenient options result from the main engineering of the case or table are fair game.

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#9

Re: comments, disagreements

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Sorry I couldn't continue sooner. I have a couple questions...

In the picture shown in your post, how did you assemble the coffee table? What I mean is, is the back both tenoned into the leg posts, and receiving tenons from the drawer runners? If so, what was the order of assembly?

Also, in the picture, are there sticks attached yet, which are outside the runners and flush to the inside leg faces, to keep the drawer running within channels? Or are these to be added later.

And are there kickers (I think that's the term--I mean 'upper' drawer runners) yet to be installed above the drawers, so the drawers can't tilt upward when pulled more than halfway out?

I ask because I think you have done something simpler than I did on my satinwood table, which was to use full web frames, below and above the drawers, with the web frames sitting in rebates cut into the solid sides and solid back, and screwed down. The upper and lower drawer runners were tenoned into the rear blades of the web frames. I may well prefer your way, once I understand it.

Wiley

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#10

Re: PS

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

Two things prompted my inquiry.

First, hand tool joinery had reached its zenith, it's fully mature state after many centuries, in the 18th century. Therefore, the leading cabinet makers of that era had come up with the most efficient and effective designs, given the technology of the times (no electric jointers, thickness planers, etc). So, I notice that this ultimate distillation of hand tool methods led to tenoning drawer runners straight into the back in certain cases. I'm curious, and it wasn't obvious to me why it was so. I wondered if they were leaving themselves a little latitude for fine adjustment in place, for example.

Second, I don't find constraining three drawers to run in channels, constrained from below, from besides, and from above, a trivial exercise. I feel I am using more sticks than strictly necessary in making web frames above and below, and rebating these into solid sides and backs. Works fine. But I like to compare how it was done back in the day, by folks to whom time was of the essence.

Wiley

Re: Discussion topic: case innards

#11

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"In the picture shown in your post, how did you assemble the coffee table? "

It is built with standard construction for something like this coffee table with a drawer as learned in Headley Shop.

I never know what to call parts in these discussions. Lets call the boards connecting the legs "apron boards" like in a table. The apron boards are M&T into the legs like a table, sides and back. The top "drawer divider/blade" is dovetailed into front leg. The bottom drawer divider/blade is double M&T into the front leg. Done, this arrangement holds the table together, just like a table with no drawers.

Now to provide for supporting and constraining the drawers. What ever is easiest works for me. The engineering that holds the thing together determines what is available to fasten drawer runners and guides to The runners are M&T loosely into front blade and back apron board. I never glue them. Some small gap fore and aft provides a place for trash to fall so it doesn't wear the drawer. The side constraints are not yet added in the picture, as you noted. I just nail a filler strip between the runner and side apron board. Segmented kickers are nailed to the table top if that works out or M&T as the runners are when it doesn't work out. If the top is narrow kickers are not needed as the blades suffice.

The vertical middle divider is dovetailed into the top and bottom blades. Its back has a slot that the tongue of the spacer between drawers slips into after the table is glued together. The thing I am calling "spacer" constrains the drawer sides in the middle. You will note that there is no fitting of all this stuff. If the drawer fits in the front opening it will fit within.

Now how to assemble. It is assembled with front down on the bench.

Assemble dovetail and double M&T blades into the front legs and lay flat on bench face down.

Assemble back apron to back legs and set aside.

Add the side rails to face down front section.

Install runners into their loose mortises. (not ridiculously loose but loose enough that they slip in easily)

Pick up back leg assembly and add it to apron side boards. The runner M&T are shorter than the apron M&T so one can get the apron M&T stated and then align the runner tenons as the back assembly is tapped home.

Set upright, clamp the joints to snug them up. Check for square and let glue dry,

Slide in the dovetailed vertical divider with a slot in its back that sticks out past the top blade. Screw on a back block with a slot. Drop in the center vertical divider.

"Also, in the picture, are there sticks attached yet, which are outside the runners and flush to the inside leg faces, to keep the drawer running within channels? Or are these to be added later. " Not shown. Added later

"And are there kickers (I think that's the term--I mean 'upper' drawer runners) yet to be installed above the drawers, so the drawers can't tilt upward when pulled more than halfway out? " In this case segmented and nailed to table top.

"I ask because I think you have done something simpler than I did on my satinwood table." Indeed! But you had fun arranging it.

Pictures below are of the desk with similar but not identical construction necessitated by "frame and panel" apron board construction.