New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Shellac Question

Posts

Shellac Question

#1

Shellac Question

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I bought some Woodcraft garnet shellac about 10 years ago, used some to finish 3 spice boxes and stored the rest dry in a desiccator. Since then I have gotten lazy and cheap and have only used Zinser shellac, which is cheaper than roll your own and instant, ready to use. I have used several gallons of it uneventfully. But it is blond, or at least light, and not garnet which looks nice on walnut.

Tried dissolving some of the garnet recently in various combinations of alcohols with marginal success. In all cases gels remain. So obviously something is amiss with this shellac, no the solvents.

Is it expected that shellac will go "bad" stored dry for 10 years?

Re: Shellac Question

#2

Re: Shellac Question

Denny

Bill,

I'm still using shellac I purchased in 2006, no problem. But in addition to storing the flakes dry I also kept them in a freezer. Maybe the trick is to keep them dry and cold.

Denny

Re: Shellac Question

#3

Re: Shellac Question

wilbur

Have you tried 190 proof Everclear as a solvent? That’s worked for me for old shellac flakes that wouldn’t dissolve in any other sort of alcohol.

Re: Shellac Question

#4

Re: Shellac Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I have experienced the same problem as you're having with 6-8-yr old dewaxed shellac, of good make, which dissolved quickly when fresh. After some years, it wouldn't dissolve fully in fresh denatured alcohol.

Incidentally, the best alcohol I find (other than Wilbur's Everclear) is Kleanstrip 'Green' Denatured Alcohol. I get it from Rockler. It's faster than Home Depot's or Ace Hardware's gallon jug (and more expensive).

A friend once told me that he used moonshine when he could get it, cause it was the very best thing. In your parts, you might find a Mason jar of it here or there :) .

Wiley

Re: Shellac Question

#5

Re: Ditto on the green klean strip..

david weaver

.. home depot here carries the green stuff, or at least they did last time I was buying.

It has a pretty favorable mix of stuff in it, and it costs the same as the blue can klean strip, which has a lot of methanol in it. at one point, they were carrying quarts in both types (green and blue) and they were the same price at that point, too.

My mixing has gone down, though, as bill described, I've been using the zinssers blonde for stuff that it's the final coat or just intended to be under wax (and I've been using the amber dewax from zinssers where it's going to get lacquer). I don't miss the mixing when blonde is fine (as it usually is with cherry).

I haven't dissolved shellac more than a couple of years old, though, but will be taking a shot at it soon.

Bill - the gelling that occurs, can you continue to agitate the mix and get it to disappear?

Re: Shellac Question

#6

Re: Shellac Question joel@tfww interesting article

Rum

I found this somewhat interesting in regards to shellac shelf life (recalled reading it a while back - google search for "site:toolsforworkingwood.com shellac" got me there again.

https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/blog/363/Shellac%20Shelf%20Life%20-The%20Followup

The previous one (linked from above): https://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/blog/235/How%20to%20Dissolve%20Shellac%20and%20Improve%20The%20Shelf%20Life%20of%20Dewaxed%20Shellac%20Flakes

indicates its probable that you might get the gell to dissolve with sufficient agitation and time. Would be interesting to see if that proves true for you.

Re: Shellac Question

#7

Re: Bloxygen

TomD

So bloxygen in a glass jar might be a solution. I have the bloxygen, but I also have argon for tig welding, which probably works pretty well. If you put the flakes in a glass jar, fill with bloxygen, then never tip the jar, use a ladle to extract the flakes you use. Might be a plan.

While if you have a big fridge and all the kids have moved out, then fridge might help, but it doesn't seem to be the core problem. If keeping epoxy, shellac, film, etc... drives you to a second fridge, or a larger one, then the cost of that is not going to be free. Plus they are energy hogs.

I keep some liquids this way. I mount an O-ring syringe in the lid, give the liquid a shot of bloxygen. When I extract the liquid I invert the bottle, and use the syringe. I don't even loose bloxygen, in theory. Another method is a bottom collection pump (like the mustard bottles at the fair, with a blivot of bloxygen over the liquid.

Re: Shellac Question

#8

Not surprised to find....

david weaver

Not surprised to hear that the eventual death of dissolvability is due to slow oxidation.

I'm sure that folks could find a less permeable storage solution that didn't involve putting shellac in the fridge (that gets my wife's hackles WAY up, she already doesn't like CA glue in the freezer).

Re: Shellac Question

#9

I seem to recall that it does....

John in NM

Moisture from the atmosphere if I remember correctly, though the claim was less than substantiated as I recall. Looking at Rum's link, Joel says it's oxygen rather than moisture. Seems reasonable.

I wonder if the oxidation is reversible? I have a vacuum chamber at work, might be interesting to stick some in it for an hour or so.

Re: Shellac Question

#10

Re: I seem to recall that it does....

Rum

There was a comment at the bottom of one of the articles by someone who sounded knowledgeable (for whatever that's worth) that claimed that water also had some effect, although its substantially slower than oxygen.

He also made a good point (assuming that water the vapor effect is true; assuming it is does no harm I suppose since the risk is lower than assuming otherwise :D) that if you freeze/refrigerate the shellac to let it warm up before opening so that you don't get condensation on the shellac when you open the jar.

Practically speaking it seems that if you're excluding oxygen you're excluding water (ignoring the less probable ways that that wouldn't be true) so I think it would be hard to really know unless you did a long term anaerobic high moisture test.

Re: Shellac Question

#11

Very Doubtfull

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

The "oxidation" is a chemical reaction creating a new compound of the shellac resin. Once the resin has changed there's no going back (according to what I've read over the years).

Re: Shellac Question

#12

Second Question

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Bill, you can tint shellac with Homestead TransTint concentrate very easily. I use it all the time when I need to push the finish color on a piece to match up with other items or just establish a tone. Application is by spray (with a mini-gun) so that I can dial it back and bring up the tone gradually with no lap marks. Nice thing is if I decide I don't like it, it rinses off with DNA and I get to call " do-over!"

Re: Shellac Question

#13

Ah well, too bad

John in NM

Some reactions with moisture are reversible, so the mind was running that way.

Can't think of an oxidation reaction that would be though, now that I try to do so.

Re: Shellac Question

#14

seedlac..

david weaver

Just as a side comment, I remember George saying that he suggested seedlac as far as getting something that will keep its shine in the long term.

I wonder if the shine loss is from oxidation on the surface, and if so, I wonder if that would make seedlac impervious to oxidation in storage.

Not that most people could tolerate its dark color.

Re: Shellac Question

#15

Re: Second Question

david weaver

How colorfast is transtint...like long term color fast?

Re: Shellac Question

#16

answer

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"Bill - the gelling that occurs, can you continue to agitate the mix and get it to disappear? ".....no

Re: Shellac Question

#17

fading

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I think it is a premetallized dye which sets the bar for lightfast. I got essentially no loss of color in an accelerated weathering test on mahogany where as chromate and lye faded substantially under the same conditions. I was impressed with the result.

Re: Shellac Question

#18

Re: Second Question

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi David and all,

Will have to wait some years to find out about the lightfastness--I'll take Bill Tindall's word for it though.

One thing I like about it--alcohol doesn't smear it or have any other effect on it. So if you like shellac, which I do, you can apply the shellac over the dyed wood and not get any running, smearing, or weird effects.

Wiley

Re: Shellac Question

#19

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Looks like I can filter the goo out and use the rest.

Re: Shellac Question

#20

Very

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

stable.

I used to buy several grades of dewaxed. I found that the super or ultra blond grade seemed to store the best, to I quit the garnet and dark grades and now tint the mix to the exact color I want to complement the wood and my finish routine. Because I top coat with waterbornes, I don't keep mixed shellac more than 4 months and try to mix only as much as I need for the job at hand.

Re: Shellac Question

#21

'Shine

Mark Mandell - Gone Round In New Jersey

Great Idea. What you don't use on the piece you can have on the rocks!!

Re: Shellac Question

#22

Re: Bloxygen = Argon

TomD

I buy that stuff by the 4 foot cylinder, so I guess I don't need to buy the expensive little bottles also.

http://www.bloxygen.com/

There is something also sold at wine stores that might come to hand more easily for some.

Re: Shellac Question

#23

Re: I seem to recall that it does....

TomD

Was he referring to water absorbed into the alcohol. That wreaks the mix, and of course is often part of the alcohol. for a head start.

Re: Shellac Question

#24

No, not really...

John in NM

I was talking about pulling a vacuum on the flakes before mixing with alcohol.

If moisture were adsorbed onto the shellac, pulling a vacuum on it - like a 10^-4 Torr vacuum - would probably take care of it, the moisture would evaporate.

If the problem is due to the oxidation of shellac, then it is not likely to be reversible. I was reading Joel's article while writing the reply so my thinking got muddled (it was also a short walk to muddled, as usual :D )

Pulling a vacuum on alcohol would just give you less alcohol and a higher concentration of water in it - because the alcohol boils first. Also wouldn't do the vacuum pump oil much good if done for extended periods.