New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Trouble with the curve

Posts

Trouble with the curve

#1

Trouble with the curve

Joe shelton

Pardon my attempt at being literary, but this question is about bending wood. I have recently bent the stocks of two shotguns. The first effort was reasonably good, achieving the bend I wanted but darkening the pistol grip area by overheating. The second try was completely successful.

Both these guns were new, so I had good reason to believe the wood was sound. As I move to older guns, and to guns owned by others, I worry about Bob Smalser's warning (see his Article on this site) that glued repairs will fail when heated for this manipulation.

So, how do I evaluate wooden stocks for the possibility that they have been broken and glued back together? Visual inspection seems the only means, but even my poor skills have yielded some invisible glue lines. And old stocks often have layers of finish and changes in character that can hide defects.

Any ideas?

Re: Trouble with the curve

#2

Bent?  Why?

John in NM

I've never heard of doing that - usually the profile is fully carved after letting in the steel bits.

Usually you can spot repairs on old stocks fairly easily. Often they are pinned with a dowel in addition to being glued. Even when unpinned, you can usually see the repair, truly invisible repairs are only possible on very small cracks.

If the finish is old and very dirty you might miss a repair. First thing to do would be to strip the stock and inspect it.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#3

Re: Bent?  Why?

Joe shelton

John, I bent them to change the cast. They both came with cast off, more or less, to fit a right hand shooter. That's typical for shotguns, or at least common.

I shoot long guns from the left shoulder, so I changed these to cast on.

Thanks for your comments on glued repairs. If I recall, you make stocks, right?

Re: Trouble with the curve

#4

Neat

John in NM

If it works well enough, sure saves the trouble of making a new stock!

I had forgotten that shotgun stocks often have a cast to them, at least the higher end ones. For some reason I was imagining bending it for the curve of the grip :D

Yes I make a few, but nothing like shotgun work.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#5

Re: Trouble with the curve

BrianMonumentCO

The concept of bending a stock is an old one.

As a gunsmith, I would strip the stock so that I could perform a thorough examination of the wood.

BUT THE MOST important reason to strip the stock is to permit the warmth and humidity to enter the wood.

This is critical to get a good bend.

Bending is done to create CAST on/off or CAST right/left.

The on/off definition is the older usage of the term.

And the purpose is to move the majority of the buttstock so that it is in a comfortable place for shooting. This depends upon whether the shooter is right or left handed.

Sad for the left handers in the world, but MOST guns are right handed.

Just 2 cents worth from a gunsmith.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#6

Re: Neat

Joe shelton

Well, stay tuned. If I mess up too bad, I may be sending you two pieces to use as a template for a new one...

Re: Trouble with the curve

#7

Re: Trouble with the curve

Joe shelton

Thanks, Brian, I've thought that stripping might be necessary, especially for an old gun, but it doesn't sound like fun.

For clarification, cast on is to the left. And in my case, at least, cast is used to accommodate eye dominance, not handedness. Being right handed but left eye dominant gives me fits with my handsaws, too.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#8

Re: Trouble with the curve

BrianMonumentCO

IIRC from gunsmith school, the interesting part in the terminology of cast on vs cast off is that it is dependent upon whether the gun is used as a left handed or right handed gun.

That is why I prefer the terminology cast left or cast right, as it has no bias.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#9

Re: Trouble with the curve

BrianMonumentCO

looks like I didn't recall that correctly.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#10

I don't know...

Joe shelton

I couldn't tell for sure, but like you I prefer to be explicit about it. I just adopted the terms used by a fitter who measured my gun and translated the impact point on a patterning board to stock dimensions.

Apparently the same kind of confusion happens with pitch, with US conventions opposite continental usage.

Anywho, I'm having fun both with stock adjustments and learning to hit a few clays.

Thanks for your comments.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#11

I thought you did recall it correctly...

John in NM

Cast on is the butt bent towards you, cast off is the butt bent away from you. The hand of the shooter would determine which way on and off were in an absolute sense.

I had to go look it up, but fortunately I have a reprint of Al Linden up here at work. He gets me chuckling every time :D

Re: Trouble with the curve

#12

Re: I thought you did recall it correctly...

BrianMonumentCO

John, That is what I recalled. But I went on line to find a reference and they all said cast off was for righties and cast on was for lefties. But I thought it was directional away from the person.

I just wanted to find a reference.

When I didn't I guessed that I was wrong.... But how....

Lacking proof, I retracted my IIRC.....

I want to find proof either way..

But so many writings today are not correct.

Re: Trouble with the curve

#13

Go with Linden...

John in NM

Two advantages, first, he agrees with your original definition and is a pretty old and respected reference, and second, I have a distinct liking for his pithy style :D

I like your cast left and cast right definition best though, no explanation needed to go with it, which is always a plus.