New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

Posts

Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#1

Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Eighteen drawers times 4 equal 72 dovetail joints to mark, saw and remove waste. Nearing the end of this journey I would like to offer some insights as to the utility of making and using this thing.

I have little patience for making jigs and the like. I would rather be making furniture. That said, the time it took to make this device has been amply rewarded on this project.


Marking It is advertised as something to hold the pieces while marking. I found it quick to "load", and it held the pieces in the same plane, securely, while the pin lines were scribed. "Quick, secure, same plane" meets the requirements for successful marking. I never had any piece slip while marking. (Raise your hand if you never had a pin board slip while marking)

Delighted, but there are bonuses.......


Sawing After marking one can just loosen the vice, slide the pin board up and saw it. As an aside, sawing the pins was a problem. The thin saw wanted to drop into the scribe line. Sawed in this orientation the pin was not sloppy but too loose for my preference. It was difficult to get the saw to start on the edge of the scribe line and I was not always successful.


Waste removal The fastest way I found for removing the hundreds of pin waste pieces was to use the band saw like a power chisel and chisel away most of it(yet another technique learned in Headley shop), which leaves a corner. This corner was removed by remounting the pin board and sawing it out with a fret saw. I have never found sawing out all of the pin waste with a coping saw to be very quick, but that may be my lack of sawing skills.

Note my exuberant use of chalk to avoid misorienting pieces in this process.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#2

Can't take the credit.....

roger lance

Bill.....the maker of that jig is a UK woodworker.....and I believe I got to search out his site due to a discussion of chisels in which he was mentioned.....the guy made various tools for sale including this simple-to-make jig and I watched a video he had showing the jig and then made one.....if anyone can name the guy, please do and give credit where credit is due.

I'm glad you found it useful. I've made a lot of jigs over the years.....some successful and some not.....they are really tools in their own right.....and are generally worth the effort and time required to make them.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#3

Selling ice to Eskimos

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If one can sell two boards dovetailed together to someone for making dovetails I would call that exceptional marketing that may have a larger payoff in some other product line.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#4

Re: Can't take the credit..... *LINK*

Bob Entwisle in NJ

Roger,

I found this link to an article by David Barron.

Bob in NJ


Dovetail alignment jig

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#5

Re: Selling ice to Eskimos

William Duffield

If I understand it correctly, it's four boards, not two, right? Two of the boards are fences, and the vertical one must be thinner than the box stock. Precise layout and construction for squareness in three axes would be important.

Would a clamp attached to the horizontal face of the jig, to hold the tail board in place, b helpful? Would a stop block, that could be laid on top of the vise jaw to position the end of the tail board even with the front face of the pin board, be helpful?

I ask because I can't raise my hand in response to your rhetorical question. The only alignment methods I have used are the vise jaws and a bench plane laid on its side, and finger tip sensors. I need to find a better way.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#6

Re: Can't take the credit.....

William Duffield

Thanks, Bob. That provides techniques useful in answering the questios I asked Bill.

But, why bother mitering the fence joint? The two halves don't even need to meet, much less fit flush.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#7

Speed

TomD

The fastest way to remove waste is with a chisel, but you have to stick with it. You have to have a routine that is absolutely correct, and does not waste a motion. The one in Franz Klausz' tape is very good, you have to follow it exactly. There was a video from Hedley's Williamsburg shop that showed using a knife chisel. The exact method you use will depend on wood density, and the geometry of the parts/how large they are.

The reason to believe the chisel is fastest is because most methods use it for the finish cuts, so if you have a method that ads few cuts, or even employs fewer cuts than the finish paring method, you are going to be a long way ahead on time. Since most of the chisel methods are just as technically easy as the paring at the finish methods, or even easier, there is no reason not to use them. The only fly in the ointment is that you need to know the technique (one is in the most publicized video on dovetails ever, so not much excuse there), and you have to realize the magic is in the details, you need to do exactly what is there, not sorta. Though obviously you can modify as you prefer once you get the hang of it.

So for instance in the FK method he cuts in with his gage a certain depth, or scores the line to a certain depth; this sets up the undercut; that sets up the power cut without backing off the line. The way he wastes the material, is critical to how you get the second side power cut. It isn't difficult, it is specific, but a lot of people seem to just look at it and they don't see the specifics, or assume because it works you have to be a wizard.

Another thing about his method is that a lot of people see the no line layout. There is nothing in that method that is difficult, but it is separate from the specifics of the cutting. If the no line layout freaks you out, it is a separate technique, that I don't use on fine work anyway. I think it is fun and great for practice, but irrelevant for fine furniture, don't let it bog you down.

When it comes to sawing out, you can get good results right off the saw from a precision fret saw. It will cut right to the line. I have occasionally done this, the specific situation is where I am doing a power tool version of a drawer cut out of an apron. I use the fret saw to release the drawer from, and since I have the saw un-earthed, I will use it to chop the tails, it won't easily cut the pins though one could make a jig.

I have an even sicker method for getting out the joints with a power saw, but I have been holding onto it for about 20 years, planing on writing it up for FWW, or something... :) Like all these methods it has it's limitations, but it is super fun to do, and blistering fast.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#8

Re: I wondered the same thing

Bob Entwisle in NJ

William,

I wondered the same thing. Mitering the fence joint seemed like an unnecessary bit of fussiness.

Am I missing something?

Bob in NJ (who's shop jigs are often mistaken for firewood)

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#9

Re: Selling ice to Eskimos

TomD

In your case it is a productivity tool for someone who can cut dovetails. Somewhere, someone like FK is asking themselves why you are "so beginner" you can't eyeball straight and square. His words not mine.

But there are also a lot of hand-holding tools for people who never have made dovetails, and for them there might be some upside. Though they could biscuit it together, but then you have to look at all the how to make a sled threads. Some people have problems with the basics. Some people buy shooting boards, which is funny because a plane does all the stuff a shooting board does, more accurately to start with, shooting boards just allow you to listen more carefully to NPR while you are doing that stuff.

As a shooter, and woodworker, I am sure you can eyeball square. That is my background also. I have to confess I like to learn how to do stuff without the assists, then I like to make the jigs and stuff also. It is consumerism, and in that vein there are also people of whatever skill who will buy anything. The beauty of the American consumer is that his wants are so far past needs that there is no end to the potential economic expansion.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#10

It is marketing

CJ in MPLS

No reason to miter those corners as noted. But then he needn't have used mahogany either. It takes but a moment to miter the corners but in the end it looks nicer and for folks that are interested in buying such stuff, wouldn't you rather buy it from the guy that makes things look good?

I think that the same thing applies to the jigs one sees in Fine Woodworking articles. Granted most of of this are from commercial shops that will make a piece over and over again, but most of the jigs look brand new and fancy to me. My jigs are made out of whatever leftover junk I have around. Most prevalent these days is some mdf beadboard that I had put up in my basement a few years ago. I had about 2/3 of a sheet left over and that stuff is used in every project it seems.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#11

Yes Bob.....that's the fellow.....

roger lance

for those interested, go YouTube and do a search on David Barron and you will find his video on making a dovetail alignment board. I tried to make a link but was unsuccessful.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#12

Re: Yes Bob.....that's the fellow.....  *LINK*


David Barron dovetail alignment jig video

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#13

reply, not to Eskimos

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

If I understand it correctly, it's four boards, not two, right?.........yes to all questions. Don't make the "fence" very tall or it will be constrained to get marking knife into pin hole next to fence. 1/4" is plenty high.

Would a clamp attached to the horizontal face of the jig, to hold the tail board in place, be helpful? No, it is trivial to securely hold the tail board in place.

Would a stop block, that could be laid on top of the vise jaw to position the end of the tail board even with the front face of the pin board, be helpful?....No, I tried it and rejected same. I diddle with overhang, sometimes just perceptible amount over to pull the joint together. In any case, again, it is trivial to do this alignment.

I ask because I can't raise my hand ....... both my hands are in my pockets.

I need to find a better way. ...for me this was it! Where has this idea been hiding?!? This way is so very much faster than the what I always thought silly technique of cutting a rabbit on the end of the tail board.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#14

I bestow Credit to Roger

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

This jig may have been first used in 1720 for all I know. Credit goes to who ever "moves the needle". In this case your posted picture moved me to make it, use it, like it.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#15

Jig making......

roger lance

CJ......I agree about getting the stock for making a jig from scrap.....I actually take a little measure of pride in using scrap to make such things.....I've been using baltic birch ply in jigs but those parts (mostly) are from cut offs.

Turners are the ones who love making things from scrap or the burn pile more than us flat workers.....its a good lesson to learn though.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#16

Rabbit?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

"This way is so very much faster than the what I always thought silly technique of cutting a rabbit on the end of the tail board."

Not to mention getting all that rabbit fur all over your work. Now, a rabbet on the end of the tail board...

This little jig does look like one of those simple devices that it took a genius to imagine. Definitely going on the list to make.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#17

Roger, what other handy jigs are......

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

....in your collection? Fess up. Lay them out on your bench and take a picture.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#18

Two very good jigs......but.....

roger lance

they are made to be used with power tools......namely a plunge router.....and we know how popular that can be here......basically a form of heresy......I'd have to look the shop over to find jigs for hand tool use only.....don't think there are many as jigs are mainly made to assist a power tool technique to make it more accurate, safer, repeatable, etc.

But if you are a mixed tool woodworker, these two jigs are excellent and well worth making if you are into case work.....


These jigs should be credited to Norm Abram and Mark Spagnuolo.

The jig on the left came from The New Yankee Workshop and is used to drill/position holes for shelf supports. This jig was fashioned after a commercially made jig that was made in aluminum.....MEG jig (I believe). Norm has since improved the jig with a fence system to reference it against your work piece. It works really well.

The jig on the right came from The Wood Whisperer (Mark Spagnuolo) and is featured on his site as the #139 video/project. It is an "exact-width dado jig" and can also be found on YouTube. Very accurate and very handy. I took the liberty to make some mods to fit my situation.....but it is basically the same jig.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#19

A William Duffield  vice jig......

roger lance

For hand tool woodworkers, William Duffield's movable vice jaw for working on tapers is extremely handy and effective.....



I'm glad he posted this.....he even has one that also tilts in an additional direction....but I've found this to be very desirable as is.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#20

There is also the usual assortment of.....

roger lance

tablesaw sleds, bandsaw sleds, taper jigs, and finger joint jigs.....all basics for those power tool users.


Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#21

There are also jigs that test the maker.....

roger lance

this is a jig for making compound angled tenons in chairs.....it is based on an expensive commercially made jig, an article in FWW, and some innovation on my part.....


A thing like this will challenge the mind and give you something to think about as you go nighty night.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#22

Re: A William Duffield  vice jig......

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

It's not mine. I got the idea from Steve Latta, along with his auxiliary bench. The one that rotates the other way was inspired by the aux. jaw on the Emmert patternmaker's vise.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#23

A Latta/Duffield vice jig......

roger lance

I believe it is important to give proper recognition to the people who have designed/made a product.....but, I'm finding that there can be a long trail to find the real originator of an idea.....Steve Latta may have also got onto this with something he saw or read.....at any rate, its a good idea and I'm grateful that you showed it.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#24

Re: Two very good jigs......but.....

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

IIRC, the shelf pin jig on the left in your pic used to be commercially available, in either birch or aluminum, by a small company called mag industries.

Re: Experience with R. Lance dovetail marking holder

#25

Re: Two very good jigs......but.....

roger lance

Yup, I wrote about that under the picture.....but it's MEG Products of NJ and those jigs are still available.