New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Precision you can feel — woodworking perfected with Lee Valley

Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

Posts

Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#1

Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

david weaver

At the risk of ruining my reputation (not that I build anything nice, but that I build anything at all), my wife all of the sudden two weeks ago demanded a bookshelf, and the two options sucked - one was an unfinished house shaped bookshelf made of common pine (knots and all) for $250 with gaps all over the place. Just awful, it wouldn't even look good painted unless someone caulked it like house trim.

The other option is that she thought she'd go to the high end kids store here and get a solid finished bookshelf for $250. It's more likely at that store that they'd have one for $500+ made of pine.


It looks like there are dark gaps around the HBDT at the top, but those are pencil marks where I'd like to take a little material off of the pins. When I haven't done anything for a while, it always seems like things are a bit tight, and tough to get glued up quickly. They are still otherwise rougher than the picture would make them look.

I will put two shelves in the middle of it via dado and make a simple moulding on the top and make a base with a cove and rabbet (no clue what you'd call it), and trim on the front with a bead, similar to this one that I built for my daughter under similar duress. (never noticed the wax in that bed until the camera flashed it).



I could put a nicer moulding on it, but I doubt my son would apprecate it (he's 1)

The total cost to me is going to be $240, including enough stock to make a T&G back and for some shellac and wax.

Rockler sends out flyers here all the time (and they're only about 2 miles away), but when they have deal wood, it's just awful, and this is that. I hope it darkens enough to negate a lot of what you see on it. It's almost white. When they have pallets of low priced wood, they empty the racks of any good 4/4 wood (or it seems that way). and the good wood is only about 30% more. I asked the guy there where the good wood went, and they looked at me like I was talking greek (the good wood was supposedly on sale, too, but nowhere to be found. You don't want to look at the wood price list in that place if there isn't a sale).

I said "it's nice that this stuff is inexpensive, but it's pre-thicknessed and it looks like every piece of culled wood they couldn't do anything with at the mill, either due to staining or width"

When I said that, they looked like they were really unhappy with me!! Two years ago, I got a plano setup. That's such a nice device for this junk wood - you can take the cull pile wood and get the boards to line up perfectly on a glue up.

Posted at bill's request (to talk about stuff being built rather than fighting about whose dovetail method is good), I don't build much furniture or cabinetry and when I do I don't post about it, anyway. And I wouldn't post about something plain like this, but it does meet my minimum standards:

* proper joints at the corners

* no endgrain showing once done

* no plywood

I'd challenge anyone to find a decent solid bookshelf with long term use possibility for $250. I sure couldn't find anything already made.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#2

Memories as a Kid..

david weaver

When I was a kid, we either found stuff like a bookshelf at an auction, or my dad made one.

My dad had a circular saw, a jig saw, a 1/2 sheet sander and one of those old bulky low power black and decker homeowners drills........... and eventually a band saw (but he never used the band saw for furniture).

I remember everything he ever made was exactly the same. Pine (at least it was solid), wide boards bought from a local lumber yard. He'd cut the pieces, slab everything together and I guess they'd get glued at butt joints (and screwed and nailed).

Then he'd sand them and my mother would put stain on them and that'd be it.

As much as I can't bring myself to do something like that, I have to admit that everything that he's put together is still there. They even still have a wooden 2x12 bench sitting outside that he made over 30 years ago (though that got painted - white pine. ).

My parents went on to find and buy nice furniture that was made locally or mostly by hand somewhere, but a lot of the shelves that my dad made have been moved upstairs and they are all in good shape.

I guarantee we never checked any of them for square, we never used a clamp, etc. I never saw a clamp other than a C clamp and a pair of vise grips until I got into woodworking, but I'll bet in total, my dad has built more pieces of furniture than I have.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#3

Re: Memories as a Kid..

TomD

That is really nice.

I have to say the most functional shelf I built was based on my In-laws', who have immaculate taste. I always figure I will be moving, though we have been here for 20 years. So it is just plywood cases that where they meet are 1.5 inches, not too wide, quite tall. The shelves were made out of 2x stock with bevelled edges. The cases are butted and then the forward edges are covered with 1x pine. It is not fine woodworking, but I have made a few fine woodworking shelves and overall they never look that good in the room. The pieces are nice, but the overall effect with all the disparate volumes is not restful. The key to classing the books is to do it all by size. I want to class book by subject, but it ends up looking terrible. The overall result is it looks like a built in, but can be taken anywhere.

My dad and mom were both profs, so there were a lot of books. My dad built a lot of shelves. I have a lot of books, probably more. If I had it to do all over again today, I wouldn't buy them. But given when I grew up a lifetime with books was inevitable.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#4

The "Prison shop"

Bob Hackett

Up here in Maine they still try to teach skills and find meaningful work for inmates. As a result we still have places the locals call "prison shops" where the work the inmates turn out can be bought by the public. The one closest to me offers solid oak book cases for less than $150, even less if you want unfinished. The work is better than imported furniture, the construction is bullet proof judging from the two that survived my two son`s teenage years and you can even custom order things like moldings and different finishes. All for less than $150 for a standard depth 5 foot tall 3 intermediate shelf bookcase. Plus you get to talk directly to the guys who do the work because they man the shop (with supervision from the MDC).

One of the other approaches I`ve used to appease impatient friends and family who don`t quite understand what it means to be in the middle of a rather complicated project and have someone close appear wanting to derail you is to drive them down to either the local second hand shops or the Habitat for Humanity "re-store" and help them pick out a solid wood piece that we can modify and refinish to get them up and running in a hurry (they`re ALWAYS in a hurry).The best part about this is that they get to participate in the modification and refinishing themselves ( I insist on it). The most repeated phrase during these projects is always, "I had no idea it was so involved/ difficult/ time consuming. Very few have undertaken these types of projects with me and come back wanting anything in a hurry. :D

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#5

The bottom line.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Was the "customer" pleased? The book cases look great to me.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#6

Lumber

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

You lumber report brings up two points.

Where to buy: Everywhere has local lumber sales to small shops. One just needs to find this source. Because sales are largely to a small number of shops these places may not be well known to the general public. They may not advertise or even be in the yellow pages. This source cuts out one "middle man" in the supply chain so that prices may be lower.

Quality: Packs of lumber (500-1000 bdft) are sold by grade. Within each grade there is a spread in desirability of the individual pieces with the best being clear, wide and sap-free and the worst just slightly better than the next lowest grade. If the seller allows the customer to sort and pick, the remains of these packs will by and large not look attractive. You wind up with what you see at Rockler. The first person to pick is delighted with their score and the last customers bemoans the poor quality of Rockler (fill in the blank) lumber.

In the case of Cherry Rockler is probably buying a Select and Better grade. Select allows narrow lumber, short lumber and other grading standards are loosened. Personally, I would rather buy #1 Common as better value. After a Sel&Btr pack is sorted through the remains will be less useful than average #1 Common.

We never allowed customer to pick. It annoyed some tiny volume customers but these customers didn't generate significant profit. It benefited the average customer because they reliably got average lumber for the grade they were buying.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#7

Re: Local Sawyers

david weaver

Far and away the best place to get lumber here is local sawyers, but you have to have some lead time to get from them, or be willing to make a trip.

My other quick option supplied the wood that the other bookshelf is made of, and it, too, is substandard (and costs more). The color is bad, but I understand that the color of cherry is no longer part of the grading. It also looks like a lot of it was sawn with the pith off center. I've seen the sorting mills that operate like coin sorters, and I'd assume it comes from a mill like that because all of the boards are approximately the same width.

Most of the wood for my kitchen came from mike digity, a local sawyer, but he retired, so I have to go looking again. Mike's wood is KD, has much better color and a lot fewer defects. It's also less expensive than retail lumber, and he dropped it off at my door.

I agree with what you're saying, at least with cherry (I don't know enough about the rest), select and better isn't that great any longer and I need to go locate a replacement for mike and just keep a couple of hundred feet in my shop since it is my go to wood. though this is pre thicknessed, I've been doing the rest of the work by hand, as even in compressed time, there isn't a great deal of time difference on a project like this one (especially with pre-thicknessed lumber). the plano set with a couple of additional clamps has all of the boards close enough that two smoother passes makes them even.

My biggest problem is that I have storage for about 500 bf, but that's it, and I have a bunch of stuff that I have around that takes up about half of that (specialty things like beech and fruitwoods), but that doesn't get turned over fast.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#8

Re: My Thomaston Cutting Board

david weaver

I've been in the Thomaston store, and the wife and I bought a cutting board (we were on the road and not looking for furniture). I told her that there was no way I was leaving without it because it was cheaper than it would've cost me for the wood.

The guy who rang me out had two guards standing behind him with shotguns :)

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#9

Re: I was the first picker...

david weaver

Btw., I got there when they opened this pallet, so I got to be the first picker. The picture I showed doesn't do justice how crappy the rest of the wood was. I went through the whole pallet and got the stuff shown off of it.

If I'd have arrived later in the day, I wouldn't have been able to get anything that would make even a passable looking bookshelf. In contrast, the stuff they normally stock before it "goes on sale" is perfectly acceptable, and 3/4ths of the boards in the rack are fine. I'm going to assume that when they sell this stuff for $4 a foot, that they are making more money on it than they do with the regular stuff at $5.50 (that's the "sale" price, with the stuff normally being about $7.50 a foot - a price that I wouldn't buy at in the first place). I'm sure there is plenty of room in their 4/4 stock to price it at $5.50, but they're not in the business there to put much lumber through, they're in the business to sell low cost imported gadgets and jigs (at least that's my opinion from going through there).

Working wood with hand tools gives an extra amount of information to your brain about just how bad the wood is, and this wood's definitely dud stuff, chippy with unusual off center grain at the corners of boards, etc.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#10

Re: It's easy to get good wood...

TomD

If you aren't species specific. Most areas have woods available cheaply in great quality, but you have to be willing to take what you can get. I really don't much like red oak. But it grows on my NB farm. And a lot of it blew over last summer. Of course in Tennessee, I guess local is a dreamy collection of stuff. And availability doesn't change all the other issues you mention. But I am willing to be limited to beech maple, cherry, and red oak. I wish walnut fell across my path more often...

Here is about 1-9K of wood when it was originally knocked over. Just across the road from me. A trunk about 20 feet long and 3 feet in diameter, and perfect hard rock maple. That is one of the original cottages down here by the lake. Just outside Toronto. I could have sawn it up, but these tree removal services hit like a surprise attack, and you get no warning to talk to your neighbours, how many full width benches were in that baby.


Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#11

Re: It's easy to get good wood...

TomD

Actually on the hoof that tree is probably worth more than the house behind, which is a tear down, and will get a huge suburban home dumped on it shortly.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#12

Re:  I hear you on locating free wood..

david weaver

...I have no ability to accommodate it. There's often free wood here, but it's of the "had a tree cut down, it's free if you haul it away", and it's already be bucked by the tree service. I have never seen a beech tree in that situation, but if I did, I would probably go and hope for a couple of long rounds to make planes.

I think that folks see lumber in the store, and then they see what they can get for a log (which is often nothing if it's suburban) and they figure it's worth at least something to burn.

There's red oak here out the wazoo. I don't mind it if it's QS, but I don't like it otherwise. That's no bold statement on a woodworking board, but where I grew up, 2/3rds of anything I saw made in hardwood back then was red oak. It still is, I guess...there's a lot of amish builders there. We burned a lot of red oak as a kid, it's absolutely ideal as a firewood. Low ash, burns clean, good heat value and easy to split. Easy to find it standing in big trees, too.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#13

Re: Some more..

david weaver

..






Made decent progress this weekend. Cut the dadoes, rabbeted the insides of the back to take T&G for the back, cut the shelves, did the glue up, and did all of the tongue and groove. I did use a thickness planer for the T&G stock to get it down to 1/2", the size of my T&G plane. If this thing was something I wanted to build, I'd probably have thicknessed it by hand (I don't mind routine hand work, I consider it an exercise program, which I could use in the first place).

I hate glue ups, there's no way around it. I'm by myself with somewhat limited space and I never get square. I need some warmth for the hide glue and have to move into the basement, which is partially taken up by the cabinets I'm building for the kitchen.

I realize if anyone is paying attention in the picture, you'd wonder why there's TBIII in the picture. It was 0 with a high in the low teens the day I glued the sides together, temp in the basement was high 50s. Just no good options for hide glue.

HBDTs are the bang it out kind you make when you're covering things with a moulding, warren used the term "not perth, but handsome". They're not measured or anything, just guess at the spacing. I don't mind cutting dovetails, but I hate cutting show dovetails, because I don't want them to show in the first place, and there's no room for error.

While gluing together, I got frustrated and was briskly striking the outside of the case to get the shelves to seat, and for some reason I missed a little bit and given that this wood doesn't run straight up and down with the grain, I blew a huge amount of it out in shards with the mallet and had to track it down and put it back together like a puzzle. This wood is full of so many stains, I don't know if anyone will notice the hide glue (which I glued in the cold basement for that spot by focusing a lamp on the area). Actually, nobody will because that side will be facing the corner. It was a dumb conclusion to losing my temper!!

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#14

Quickie Bookshelf, Fin

david weaver

Hopefully this will work, I put the image on one of the free hosting/posting sites. I'm sure it won't stay there forever.

We always talk about how it's OK to post mediocre work, so I'm doing that.



(my son is glimpsing in after noticing the flash of a prior picture - he's in the middle of a diaper change)

Base is, I guess, a scotia with rebates at the top and the bottom. The top is just a lazy man's moulding. I'm not wild about it, it's too steep, but it's clearly the kind of thing you can cut with one pair of planes (the same pair as used for the scotia), which means fast.

Back is 1/2" T&G (cut by hand, of course). Finish is shellac and wax, very light two coats of padded shellac. It's not quite as bad as the camera flash makes it look. You can get a glimpse of reflectivity on the top of the shelves. The virtue of using planed wood instead of sanded, but still using a very small amount of finish and wax.

It could've been more interesting, but it's a bookshelf, and the biggest consideration was cost. Rockler's sale wood (which has to be mill culls, even though they don't like it when I say that) is covered with stuff I don't see anywhere else, but not covered with pinkish cherry color. At any rate, I can't find anything in a bookshelf that's respectable (when I look in the stores around here), so the opportunity to do something plain presents itself.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#15

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, Fin

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

May be quick, but it's nice work. Bookshelves don't have to be works of art.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#17

Re: That's rather good, David. You should do more!

Brian Holcombe

Nice work David! That is not mediocre.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#18

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, Fin

roger lance

Theres nothing "mediocre" about a young man trying to provide for his family by making functional furniture that happens to be well made.....even if it is not museum quality.....and there is nothing wrong with posting photos of that level of work either.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#19

I would like to know more

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I have little idea how molding is made by hand tools. A description in a separate post would be of interest to many I think.

Could you provide more details on how the top molding and top all came together to make a finished top? I am thinking that it was not easy getting the top as nice as it looks.

How are the shelves installed?

The wood: Nothing shabby about the cherry. It looks to be northern cherry with good color and not excessive pitch pockets. We would have been satisfied purchasing a bundle of the same.

"Rockler's sale wood (which has to be mill culls"....... There is no such thing as mill culls. At some point in the manufacturing the lumber is graded and then sold by grade. It has become common for the best packs of cherry to be put up as "Selects and Better". Selects is the 4th grade down from the top grade. The big question when buying a pack for resale is how much of the "better" is included in the Sel&Btr. If a pack of Sel&Btr gets picked over after the "better" is taken what is left will be narrow, short and/or have defects. In any case you wound up with some nice looking wood for the shelves. If one buys the "best" for $6/bdft and has a 20% cutting waste they are still ahead buying lower grade at $3/bdft and suffering a 50% cutting loss, with maybe some cut-offs to be used elsewhere.

"covered with stuff I don't see anywhere else, but not covered with pinkish cherry color"......? I don't understand what are you saying here?

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#20

Re: I would like to know more

david weaver

As far as the wood quality goes, take a look at the top picture of the bookshelf. The brightness of the flash hides a lot of the strange things on the wood, but one of the issues is the brown streaks on the top of the bookshelf - the flash makes them look washed out a little bit, but the wood has strange brown streaks on it, as if someone took a piece of brown rubber and rubbed it on the wood - the whole board is like that. It's not like mineral pockets which are more drastic, but there was some mineral streaked wood that I put in the back with the T&G. Every board on the pallet had some sort of issue, but the only boards with any width were like the ones here with all of the brown streaks on them. It was $4 a foot and 2 miles away from me, so that won. I can get cherry cheaper here, and better, but I have to make a long drive and schedule it.

The moulding at the top and the wood for the base were just from an 8/4 stock piece off of the rack (not sale wood). They are proud of that there.

What I'm used to seeing there is large boards in the racks, but at an exorbitant price. I'd say it has great color, but that hasn't been the case lately, but it does have even color even though it's more white than pink.

Mike digity used to deliver lumber around here (he was responsible for a lot of the planemakers' beech in circulation), and he always brought me beautiful wood, clear and even from the same tree or from several trees and with a deep pink color. I understand that the pink used to be part of the grade, but due to a decline in quality, it's not part of the grading now.

I'll make a post about the moulding later today. There are probably people striking them in videos on youtube, it's a very intuitive process.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#21

Looks very nice!


Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#22

Re: I would like to know more

Steve Voigt

"I have little idea how molding is made by hand tools. A description in a separate post would be of interest to many I think. "

Some good places to start:

- Matt Bickford's book, mouldings in practice.

- Larry and Don have two videos on making mouldings.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#23

I like it a lot!

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

What could be a more solid and useful piece of furniture! It will be in use from now on.

What I like specifically:

1. The cherry, which will take on patina over time, and just get richer.

2. The mouldings, which seem exactly right to these eyes. Just right, not too steep or too anything. Like Bill, I'd like to see more of how they were done and applied, if it's not too much trouble.

3. The little ornament lines on the case frame verticals--they add interest and look right.

Overall, it looks like Home.

Wiley

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#24

Re: Cutting the Mouldings

david weaver

(Here is a picture without flash, taken during the day today. You can get a better idea of the color of the wood and the random brown marks I mentioned).

Sorry I don't have more pictures of the process, but I'm not sure they're needed.

I square (sometimes something other than square is necessary) a piece of stock long enough for the entire moulding, and then use a sticking board (mine is pretty ugly, made from SYP scrap and MDF with a few screws in the end to retain the stock, but otherwise no other fixturing.

Draw a pattern that the mouldings will have on each end of the board (they are just a suggestion, at least to me, it's more important that the various parts are even than for the final cut to be perfectly to the mark). I use card stock or something I can hold in place for a pattern.

Remove excess stock on the waste side of the profile (if you're a power tool user, you can blast it off with a router or TS it off), I usually jack the stock off of the piece, but you can rip it off with a handsaw if there is enough excess for it.

Cut with rabbet, jack, plow and smoother, depending on which is convenient, to get close to the mark and then use the moulding planes to finish the profile. I don't mind using the round a fair amount, but I try to limit what I do with the hollow because it's a nuisance to sharpen. Fortunately, what it cuts can usually be brought close to shape by other planes.

Cut the moulding (to 45 degrees) and plane the ends and fit it after.

I did a no-no on this bookshelf top, which I have done on others and gotten away with so far, and that is to glue it all the way along its length of the mouldings capping the end and then screw it after the glue dries. Ideally, one would place the pieces on one at a time with hot hide glue and just hold them for a minute or two, but I usually use liquid hide and then just lightly clamp everything so that the competing clamps hold the miters tight and the mouldings to the edge. Anything is fair game (tape especially to get things in place before clamping and tapping into place with a small mallet).

Anyway, hot hide glue would be smarter because its open time is so short. I always attach mouldings with liquid hide glue because it's what I have handy. The fit is never perfect, so I don't finish smooth the top until after the mouldings are in place, and I just plane with a stanley 4 at 45 degrees so that I can plane the bits and pieces flush but not have evidence of anything.

If I liked what I was making, I would learn what to do for longevity with the mouldings so that I wasn't using screws to force it to stay in place in the case the glue line would let go. I figure a nice idea would be a sliding dovetail in the back. I have no clue what is historically accurate.


I'd have a better fit if I were using hot hide and placing things by hand, even with the clamps, things move around a little bit.

Also, it wouldn't take much extra time to cut a much more complex profile than this moulding, and maybe next time I will. I need to build a few more of the smaller sizes of H&Rs, and I really (like I've been talking about for almost 2 years now) need to finish my kitchen cabinets, they're about 2/3rds done.

This picture gives a good impression of how bright the top is even though it's just got a few thin padded shellac coats and inexpensive johnson wax. I think in the balance of time, the fact that I can plane something like this after attaching the mouldings, and plane out imperfections in fit....this kind of stuff would've driven me nuts when I first started woodworking. I actually don't know of a faster way to do it than to plane it afterward, and it just happens so that doing such a thing provides a fine finish. I only finish smooth all of those parts (the top, the moulding, etc) one time.

If I get into a situation where I have to scrape something, i'm mindful of wanting it to match the planed surface, and thus use a card scraper with a burr, then a completely dull side of the scraper and then burnish with plane shavings so that it's close to matching.

I did do some sanding on these mouldings, but only because I didn't have the right scraper shape around at the time and was in a hurry, it hurt their final finish a little bit, they're dull. I'd have to build some finish up a bit more to hide that, but I don't want a built up finish on this, I want something I can refresh and repair easily.

Re: Quickie Bookshelf, at Bill's Request

#25

Re: I would like to know more

david weaver

Shelves dadoed in. Sorry, I forgot to answer that question. Sometimes I'm only good for one per post before I go off and answer questions nobody asked.

Dadoed in about 1/4" (done by hand, of course). I'm sure I could've made this thing, save the HBDT and the mouldings - with power tools much faster than I made this. The lumber as it came from rockler was about 85 hundredths thick and I used it as is other than surfacing it by hand (so nothing is identically thick). The shelves, IIRC, I planed to a constant thickness so as not to have trouble with the dadoes, but the dadoes are cut by hand and marked off of the shelves, so it wouldn't have mattered what size they were or if they were even thickness front to back, I'd have just cut to the mark.