New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

Posts

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#26

Every time I see the word passion...

david weaver

... it makes me think of the covers of the fiction novels you see near the checkout line. I lack that kind of passion for woodworking...it doesn't change my breathing pattern or anything.

I really don't know if derek's 90% is accurate, but if lloyds was taking bets, I'd bet 90% would be closer to right than 50%.

I just kind of wonder what it is that the people who are watching all of these basic videos (sharpening, saw sharpening, making some spoons, making a bench) are doing in their shops if they are not beginners. Part of the disinterest from some of us is that these things are kind of teach it to yourself stuff...the things you get better with based on hands on experience, and the things that you really don't get that great of a sense of by watching 10 other people do them.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#27

Re: Schtick

North of the Border

We actually should wish that Derek were right even though he doesn't have proof to support his claim. With so many followers of Sellers being "beginners", traditional woodworking is getting an unprecedented boast, thanks to this "snake-oil" salesperson, or Internet personality(?).

90%? Anyone with less than 10 years of hand tool experience should be considered a beginner.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#28

why do people always resort to extrapolating?

david weaver

I never understood the need to extrapolate something someone else says in order to try to bolster your point. If you need to do that, then what does it say about your own opinion of what your point is in the first place?

I didn't learn anything from this whole discussion, but I did learn that when you don't say up and up things about any given guru, folks come out of the woodwork, including folks you've never seen before and who don't seem to talk about much of the actual subject matter.

I hope someone has some posts about design or making something soon. We all might learn something other than what blogger we're supposed to read, or how long we're supposed to work on something before we're not beginners.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#29

That must be part of the reason why...

John in NM

The first couple paragraphs managed to turn my interest off immediately :D

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#30

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

wilbur

It is a mystery to me of why he sometimes engenders anger among some of his peers.

Maybe because he resorts to straw man arguments?

Again, I don’t doubt that he can get sharp edges. But the quote of his in your OP doesn’t hold water, in my experience.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#31

The mystery...

John in NM

He's certainly not the first to provoke such a reaction. I suspect it has a lot to do with many woodworkers being essentially self taught these days.

They've learned a multitude of methods, perhaps come up with their own as well, and know intuitively that there is more than one way to approach any problem.

Then any expert who implies that his way is best inevitably gets an argument out of the self taught guy who's alternative method works fine for his own purposes.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#32

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

Steve Voigt

It is a mystery to me of why he sometimes engenders anger among some of his peers.

Maybe because he resorts to straw man arguments?



Yeah, exactly.

The OP specifically said he wanted to hear from others; then, as soon as he got some negative opinions, he got defensive. This is what always happens with these Sellers threads; his followers have a cult-like intolerance for any criticism of the man. The comparisons to Dr. Oz are pretty perceptive as far as I'm concerned. Referring to him as a "leader" is more than a little creepy. And David, Derek, Warren, didn't express any anger; they were just skeptical and not very impressed. If you ask for opinions, you're going to get them, and not always on topic.

I think Sellers is a competent craftsman, but every piece of his I've seen looks like it came off the cover of Woodsmith magazine. It's furniture for woodworkers, not furniture with any profound design sense. What's striking about Sellers is his total certainty in his own methods and his intolerance for any other methods. But as David said, this is what helps him sell himself and his videos, courses, etc., so I'm sure it's all intentional.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#33

I never heard of him

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

But then I don't turn to the internet Blogs to learn woodworking. For my purposes the woodworking wisdom lies in shops producing furniture by people too busy making stuff to write about it. The techniques these people use are generally efficient and reliable, having stood the test of time. Much of what I practice comes from the wisdom imparted by the owners of a couple of shops that do antique repair along with furniture building. These places see what has worked, or not, and employ it in their work along with support techniques that are efficient and inexpensive.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#34

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

david weaver

design sense - exactly..

I have seen most of the stuff being made in videos, and it's got broadly rounded curves and is done fairly hastily with what looks like white pine.

When I first started, I liked stuff like that and I ran down to my shop and made test pieces and all of that stuff, but as time goes on, you start to say "can I make something that I will want to have, and that I'll look at with 10 more years of experience and not be offended by its form".

Sellers clearly has the ability to use his tools competently and at good pace, but the problems he's solving are not problems I have, and just as you say, when you get to a certain point, you don't need to see definitive statements about things that can be accomplished many ways at the same speed with the same result.

A beginner, however, is not going to be amenable with the explanation "well, you'll figure it out, that's not something that will be a problem for you if you just get a little bit more experience" or "it doesn't really matter what method you use, you just need to understand what result you want".

Those things are met by "TELL ME HOW TO DO IT RIGHT NOW, I DON'T HAVE THE PATIENCE TO FIGURE IT OUT. WHAT'S THE SECRET???". And the firestorm of reference purchases after that - "go get this ___" (DVD, video, book, whatever).

Inevitably, when most of us get to the point where our problems are design or obscure, that stuff is not interesting.

It's OK that it's not interesting to us (i never have much interest in adoption someone else's opinions) and it's OK that it's very interesting to some other people (I never have much interest in them adopting mine).

I have little enough interest in arguing with people with different opinions that I think this is probably the last thread that I'll do it.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#35

Re: The mystery...

North of the Border

Good point.

Of course, some are just very narrow-minded and insist that anyone who does teaching/blogging for a living is all about money. They live in a world that is either black or white.

Frank Klausz likes to say his is the right way, and like Paul Sellers, he is, of course, simply expressing his expert views that he believes in.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#36

Re: The mystery...

TomD

I think that is perceptive John. The online things tells you two things. It all works, and nobody believes anything you say. I have given seminars where you get that interpersonal thing happening, and I am no better than average at best in seminars, but you get no back-talk, and even some folks who call you up later to arrange courses or to become your pal. But online, you get to hear what is really in people heads, which is "what a load of ...". It's a good thing, I guess that is kinda what goes through my head, so why not others. You learn more with polite scepticism than with hero worship.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#37

Re: I never heard of him

TomD

You are not alone, his Wikipedia page is under the shadow of a "Notability Guideline". He did apprentice, whatever that involved in the period he did it, and in what actual speciality he apprenticed in. Since not everything involving wood is cabinetmaking.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#38

Re: Schtick

TomD

Ten year rule is probably at least two apprenticeships. I've been at it 50 or 35 years, depending on what one considers the relevant starting point. I have met people who had actual UK apprenticeships, and they couldn't sharpen a pencil, sorta. They could work in shops which for my lifetime have been mainly power tooled up. I learned some useful stuff about production though.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#39

Re: Every time I see the word passion...

TomD

I have no evidence of this, but I think there is a realy huge move from power to hand at the moment. So that is where are lot of the parless morons come from. And why there is a lot of basic ed out there. I do wonder what kind of slack jawed parchment presser makes it to adult life without knowing how to sharpen anything whatsoever. The As Seen on TV store has sharpeners for goodness sake.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#40

Re: a work...

TomD

Wow, I am starting to worry. Pro wrestling, what else will we learn about your expertise as time goes by. I have to confess I watched a little as a kid, but we only had a few channels...

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#41

Re: Game?

TomD

You may still be waiting for the rule book to arrive, but woodworking isn't a game in the sense of something you are on top of. It is a craft or work or whatever. You don't have a 5 years peak, get paid a ton of dough and then spend the rest of your life in dignified hasbeenry. Probably more apt is "those who can't do teach", in his case.

Woodworking is something that anyone who can stand at attention can learn in a few years, possibly today in a few months, or semesters. Even today the skill is so not rare that you can barely make a living at it. To regard people displaying bare skills as gods of the craft is just funny. If he was any good we would probably never have heard of him.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#42

Re: Leaders?

TomD

It is generally a bad sign when people rely on dictionaries to advance arguments because dictionaries reflect usage which includes stuff that is incorrect. The true meaning of words is generally not all that big a deal, but when you are arguing there have to be some meaningful norms or you can't communicate.

To take a craft example, it is pretty clear that a lot of old anvils were used to cold hammer with really large sledges or axes, or used for 4th of July over a charge of black powder. As much as these are uses, they tell us very little about blacksmithing. Same thing with words and dictionaries.

As far as Churchill is concerned, he was probably trying to reach people who might be wiling to expose themselves to the risk of a bullet, not just a

- bullet point.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#43

Re: a work...

david weaver

I'm by no means a pro wrestler, but I was a big fan as a kid. Even though I knew it was fake, they could still irritate me to no end with the heels (which of course got me to watch).

As an adult, I don't watch it, but I do find the exposure of the inner workings of the business back then as interesting, because the toughness of some of the guys was a lot more real than most folks would believe, and the psychology of selling the matches and getting people into the seats is something you find in so many non-pro wrestling places that it's incredible.

One of the personalities on when I was a kid was Brother Love, who got his gimmick by imitating televangelists, and he said he traveled to tent revivals to see how they drew in the suckers, and at the same time, the people who were running the tent revivals were going to to house matches to see if they could glean anything about drawing in paying customers from the way the wrestling promoters operated.

To much examination of that stuff makes me a bit of a conspiracy theorist about everyone intentionally peddling a work, vs. just providing an honest opinion, but I do think the psychology of drawing people in has a lot of similarities to the way pro wrestling promoters worked, it's just not quite on the same level of showmanship as wrestling promoters would do. The idea of a view being a view whether it's brought in by heel work (making people irritated) or face work (bring them in with warm fuzzy feelings) is still there.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#44

Re: Leaders?

North of the Border

You sound like someone who knows everything, including what Churchill was probably trying to reach! Of course, a dictionary is of no use to you and when one uses it, it is a bad sign.

We have so many "experts" here (in almost everything) and no wonder Paul Sellers is viewed in such a way by some who are very good at belittling him.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#45

Re: straw men...

david weaver

..I'd assume like paul, you're arguing against straw men or constructing a composite person combined with a little bit of extrapolation. The description of "some" you're providing doesn't really match anyone here, and the straw assertions you make on others' behalf don't match anything anyone said.

I do agree with Tom that if paul were on the level of someone like George Wilson, you'd hear of him after he retired, as with George (we started to hear from george as he retired, but before that he didn't have time for any of this stuff). And we are extremely luck to be able to hear from George, because he will address things that we cannot get a qualified opinion on elsewhere.

Having discretion of useful discrimination is not the same as being closed minded.

I still really don't have much of anything against paul, indifference is a different thing. He's entitled to make income any way he'd like, he's clearly a good woodworker and offers a lot for free. Someone with a bit more exposure would be waiting to see what makes him world class, maybe he's just not showing us. I know he likes to trumpet making something for a president, but that is not as exclusive of a class as one would be led to believe.

The OP posted a post that said something like "hard to refute", but as George often said when he first migrated to the online community, "why does everyone want to talk about sharpening all the time, who cares?" (eventually people extracted what george does from him, though).

Take my advice, if you have a true woodworking issue to deal with, especially if it's design related, ask george. the quality of advice you get from him is truly rare, and it is 100% entirely free.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#46

Re: straw men...

North of the Border

Unlike you, I am not interested in any arguments. Paul Sellers is way up there and he needs no one to argue for him at all.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#47

Re: straw men...

david weaver

>>I am not interested in any arguments.<<

That doesn't seem to be the case. Nobody is going to try to change your opinions, just as long as you don't try to present them as fact.

Most of us (here at least, not in the world of beginners) see work like this as being "way up there".

http://www.cybozone.com/fg/wilson1.html

Everything paul has shown is, including the piece that was made for the president (who is local to him, and that seems more likely to be the connection than it is a matter of elite work), is not close to this level.

There are many like George, not thousands maybe, but many. I have not seen folks like george throw barbs at rudimentary methods because they don't care about basic blocking and tackling, they care about design and aesthetics. Basic tidy nuts and bolts type work is assumed doable by any moderately trained apprentice.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#48

Referee waves arms, blows whistle

Wood Central doesn't have a lot of rules, but it does have one great big central one: we are expected to be civil to one another. Connected with that, we should discuss, even argue about, ideas, not about each other.

This conversation's wandering away from civility; please, folks, settle down.