Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question
david weaver
design sense - exactly..
I have seen most of the stuff being made in videos, and it's got broadly rounded curves and is done fairly hastily with what looks like white pine.
When I first started, I liked stuff like that and I ran down to my shop and made test pieces and all of that stuff, but as time goes on, you start to say "can I make something that I will want to have, and that I'll look at with 10 more years of experience and not be offended by its form".
Sellers clearly has the ability to use his tools competently and at good pace, but the problems he's solving are not problems I have, and just as you say, when you get to a certain point, you don't need to see definitive statements about things that can be accomplished many ways at the same speed with the same result.
A beginner, however, is not going to be amenable with the explanation "well, you'll figure it out, that's not something that will be a problem for you if you just get a little bit more experience" or "it doesn't really matter what method you use, you just need to understand what result you want".
Those things are met by "TELL ME HOW TO DO IT RIGHT NOW, I DON'T HAVE THE PATIENCE TO FIGURE IT OUT. WHAT'S THE SECRET???". And the firestorm of reference purchases after that - "go get this ___" (DVD, video, book, whatever).
Inevitably, when most of us get to the point where our problems are design or obscure, that stuff is not interesting.
It's OK that it's not interesting to us (i never have much interest in adoption someone else's opinions) and it's OK that it's very interesting to some other people (I never have much interest in them adopting mine).
I have little enough interest in arguing with people with different opinions that I think this is probably the last thread that I'll do it.