Re: Leaders?
david weaver
I think you just asserted several things that I never said let alone implied.
I didn't say his videos are only for beginners, but I do believe that they are primarily for beginners. People who aren't beginners just don't buy much other than materials.
I have seen many of his videos on youtube, and the demos that he's done of his DVDs and he is a good skilled woodworker. I have seen things from world class craftsman that are otherworldly, people like George Wilson, Lynton Mackenzie, etc. I don't see anything like that from Paul. I'm sure Lynton did some teaching of some sort, and george had apprentices. This is an entirely different scale than selling videos and classes to amateurs. (to be clear, he is still far more accomplished than many amateurs who have put together videos and sold them to beginners - one of those being chris schwarz, whose materials I have never purchased despite insistence of dozens of people early on in my screwing around with wood telling me I *had* to have them. I never saw the reason they were such a need to have and still don't. I'd buy 10 paul DVDs before one Chris DVD).
When I made the comment about selling tickets, I was thinking more about getting people to come to woodworking school than to sell DVDs. I forgot that Paul sell DVDs and it wasn't part of that thought, it's getting arses in seats as they say in wrestling (as in getting people to travel and pay money to take classes).
Now, no I don't harbor any real animus. I think it's perfectly legitimate to express an opinion that is critical, that is my opinion, without the issue elevating to something I think about at night with the computer off. There's nobody in woodworking like that, though there are unskilled or little skilled bloggers who bother me a whole lot more than paul does. They do irritate me when I see them quoted online.
Frame all of this with my general thought that what most of us are lacking is experience, not the next guru. If I could have anything, it would be more time at the bench. Aside from some guidance in aesthetics (which these peddled classes from the gurus are really not about), what I really need is more work with the wood, and nothing teaches like tools in wood and a demand of yourself to get better and learn something on your own. I suspect that's true for a lot of people, but most folks would rather do fantasy camp than sit in a quiet area and think about something on their own. Frame also, I guess, I have a pretty narrow interest range. I'd rather build tools than cabinets, and after I'm done with the tool phase, I'd rather build a few guitars than cabinets...or clocks, or benches, etc. I have enough trouble finding anyone who could use a double iron plane properly, let alone anyone who could tell me how to make one.
Most beginners and novices are pretty ripe, though, and folks who are tending toward 5+ years of experience and a lot of shop time are less ripe.