New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

Posts

Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#1

Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

JDK

His logic seems unassailable. Love to hear from some of our local experts.

Paul Sellers on the flat stone question:

"Is it obsessional or compulsive activity to spend more time flattening than sharpening and more time doing both than actually working wood? "


Paul Sellers on the Flat Stone Question

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#2

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

wilbur

I use water stones, and I keep them flat. I think Paul Sellers might have a point if it was true that [1] I spent more time flattening than sharpening, and [2] I spent more time sharpening than working wood.

To be clear, I'm not saying that he can't achieve a sharp edge with his method.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#3

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I have been obsessive about sharpening since 1962. I rarely flatten any stones. For coarse grinding on plane irons and wide chisels I use a King 800 stone, which is soft. I am on my fourth stone, having worn three too thin. I flatten these stones occasionally, maybe after 500 or 1000 sharpenings. I am sure that if I flattened every time I would have used at least twice as many stones.

The reason they don't need flattening very often is that I manage the wear by using the entire stone. If you concentrate the wear in the center of the stone all the rest of the grit is wasted, and you also waste time flattening the stone. I have seen videos of experts who spend more time abrading stones than abrading steel. None of my stones have ever looked like the one Sellers shows. In order to get a stone like that, one has to neglect both ends of the stone.

I don't think much of Sellers' sharpening. If you look at a video of him sharpening he sharpens the tip of the bevel at about 45 degrees. I guess it might help avoid chipping and bending for some, but I would not want to work that way. These pictures of his chisels also suggests an extreme honing angle at the edge.


Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#4

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

david weaver

That post suggests that every old stone is dished along its length like that, but that's not the case.

I've bought probably 50 old stones, oilstones mostly. Some are dished like that, but at least half are not.

I stopped flattening my stones when I went from waterstones to oilstones, and with the waterstones, I flattened them mostly because they were shaptons and shaptons cut better with a fresh surface and burnish without one.

When I get a very dished vintage stone, I still do flatten those once.

the half of the stones that I've gotten that were flat (i don't mean starrett flat, but very flat nonetheless for something kept flat by hand), and they were deliberately kept flat and not just stones that were used little. Maybe the most interesting of the whole lot was a stone that had vs cut into one side of it (by a veiner), the one *edge* of the stone had a lot of sway in it from who knows what, and the top surface of the stone was very deliberately flat. The stone had a lot of wear. It is in an nice box and a letter is inserted into the top of the box explaining that it was the stone of a professional chair and cabinet maker who worked in a production shop in indiana around 1900.

All of this stuff, lobbing one salvo after another, apparently at beginners, is over the top. Eventually everyone will learn to keep sharp tools or they will not continue to work wood. How everyone does it will be slightly different, but innate laziness should drive all of us to do as good of a job as possible with as little effort as possible.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#5

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

David Charlesworth

I enjoyed his essay on hollow oilstones, but what does he choose today?

Three diamond stones and a strop.

???

David

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#6

What David said!

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

"but innate laziness should drive all of us to do as good of a job as possible with as little effort as possible."

(I would change "possible" to "necessary")

Apparently he decided there was a better use of diamond plates than for flattening other sharpening media. A fine diamond plate is about equivalent to 15 micron loose grits. Interesting that we wound up the same place for the final steps- fine plate to strop vs. 15 micron grit to strop.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#7

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

TomD

I think one should sharpen on flat media, but how much flattening of stones that requires is another mater. I thought the whole Shapton episode was midly ridiculous, and said so here. I have often asked why if people are so worried about flatness they only sharpen in the center of the stones. But you can't seem to get much traction on that subject.

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Every spot starts with an idea, maybe something you would like to convey. Then you think how you would craft the message for the likely audience who are people of some certain type. Then you do your best with it, and experts nit pick with no consensus your every thought. It's kinda like trying to keep your stone flat, to worry about that either.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#8

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question

JDK

He gets his edge tools sharp, and he's a great craftsman of the old school.

It is a mystery to me of why he sometimes engenders anger among some of his peers.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#9

Schtick

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Paul Sellers is an interesting fellow. There is no doubt that he is an excellent woodworker. I read his blog and watch his videos. I tend to learn something most times.

There is also a morbid fascination since I know that he will say or write something that I will strongly disagree with. I remind myself that he is writing to a selected audience, and that I am not a member of this. The audience comprise 90% beginners, new to woodworking. He attempts to simply skills, at which he is very effective. He is a good teacher. What is there not to like about this?

The problem for more experienced woodworkers is that he sells His Way. And to do this he puts other methods down (and, by association, the supporters of those methods). That is not polite. Woodworkers are passionate people and easily roused. He also makes statements that are incorrect, and does so with pseudo science that will convince his followers and thus may prevent them from learning alternate views. For example, his view that micro bevels weaken an edge, and that the chipbreaker only serves to support a thin blade. There are many others.

This is his schtick. He is preaching to the converted. He is selling his courses. He is doing a good job of being newsworthy - just look how many react.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#10

Re: Schtick

JDK

In his writings I agree he is opinionated and is sometimes, although I believe not often, abrasive and contentious. But, I suspect, each of us sometimes share these failings, and others besides.

In his videos, however, he is not. Like you, I almost always learn something from him. His videos are invariably entertaining. The projects are designed to impart basic techniques, yes, but many of them produce beautiful pieces of furniture. His simple love of woodworking is so transparent and genuine that I have no difficulty overlooking his faults.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#11

It's the preachy...

david weaver

..it's the preachy kind of stuff that comes out between the lifestyle posts. It's just a little offputting. that's my opinion, but I don't have much against the guy other than the delivery, he's not out shilling gadgets and doodads.

There's always a bit of an urge to exaggerate, too. Take the statement:

>>but no one as yet has ever been convincing enough to cause me to give up what gives me topnotch surgically-sharp edges freehand in no more than a minute<<

And compare it to what goes on between minutes 1 and 3 in this video.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vvTcReENk9g

Granted, there's probably 15 seconds or so of paused talk time in that span, it's more than a minute of process, and.....it looks like exertion. That doesn't include time to take a plane iron apart and reset the cap iron when done. Hardly "no more than a minute".

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#12

Re: a work...

david weaver

..this stuff is called a work in professional wrestling (made up conflict or made up assertion). I'm convinced that most of it is a work. the reason for works in professional wrestling are to create tension and sell tickets.

The bits about microbevels creating a weak edge are one of the most often peddled bits of stuff by multitudes who have never had an edge with a microbevel fail because it was microbeveled.

Brings me to another pro wrestling term...drawing heat. Getting the old ladies angry so that they buy tickets so they can swing a purse at you. There's some of that here...it's part of the work.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#13

Re: Schtick

North of the Border

I suppose you and some others look at Sellers' writings with a filter that (a) he is targeting at beginners, and (b) he writes to sell something or with a commercial motive.

His blog is read by thousands and they consist of both beginners and non-beginners. Who he is targeting at is irrelevant as long as he contributes something and he does, like a dead flat stone is not necessary. To suggest that he is selling his courses through his blog is fine, but to say that he has to be controversial to sell his courses is a bit belittling. So only those bloggers who don't sell things or teach are worth the salt? I don't think so. Of course, highly commercialized bloggers exist (and I don't even visit them or skip those posts that are obviously commercial (like the recent ones by Chris Schwarz)); Sellers' doesn't fall into that category.

(Effective) leaders are often controversial (and sometimes wrong) and I suspect Sellers is doing something right when some skilled woodworkers are unhappy with him.

As to why Sellers is using diamond stones? Why not, when it is fast, maintenance free, long lasting and it works. I have used oil stones, water stones, diamond stones, sandpapers and lapping films. I have used grinders/hollow grind, micro bevels, no secondary bevels and Sellers'. I have used honing jigs and freehand to sharpen, The point? It is fun to be varied in how we work, including sharpening. We shouldn't be too serious and lose sight the purpose of woodworking.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#14

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

Who is he leading?

Discussing effective leaders is usually something reserved for a professional cause, or a leader of an organized group.

One of the things that is true about "gurus" in the true sense of the word gurus, is that if anyone expresses displeasure about any of the works a guru is putting out, some of the faithful appear to do the dirty work.

It's not that he has to try to draw heat to sell courses, it's that he needs to do it to sell more courses.

I don't know too much about most peoples' blogs and I don't read paul's generally, unless someone brings this stuff up. There's too much on his blog about old hags tooth routers out of 2x4s and promotion of his classes. I do like the content he offers a whole lot better than that of the WIA club, who turns into the church of scientoology as soon as any of the members are publicly criticized. Paul draws heat, works on me, I'll admit - but it doesn't sell tickets. You can't sell everyone, but I'm glad he posts what he posts. I just wouldn't confuse his advice for someone like George Wilson's....(in terms of both who George is but also in the type of advice George gives....oh, and you'd never see george do whatever it was that paul did to that saw handle on the poor downtrodden carpenter's saw).

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#15

Re: Leaders?

JDK

Well, David, you must admit that you harbor animus toward Sellers, and I, for one, don't understand it. You claim Sellers is making money selling his videos. Well, sure. He's out their teaching his skills to thousands of people, skills in *hand-tool woodworking*. Those customers must feel they are getting their money's worth. And then you suggest his teaching is designed to appeal to only beginning woodworkers. This lends me to believe you haven't watched many of his videos. For the most part they are damn impressive displays of high skill practiced by a master craftsman at the top of his game, and like others have said here, even the most experienced woodworker will find therein both useful information and thought-provoking material on a regular basis.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#16

Re: Leaders?

North of the Border

leader (ˈliːdə Pronunciation for leader )

Definitions

noun

a person who rules, guides, or inspires others; head

Sellers has inspired countless number of woodworkers and is a leader. He may not be your leader or mine or many others', but he is a leader in his own right. Leaders share many traits and inspiring others is one of them.

To many of his students, he is a leader. But, a person doesn't necessarily have to be physically leading or belonging to a group to be a leader. That's an outdated way of thinking and a narrow sense of interpretation.

I love this:

You have enemies? Good.

That means you've stood up for something,

sometime in your life.

- Winston Churchill

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#17

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

I think you just asserted several things that I never said let alone implied.

I didn't say his videos are only for beginners, but I do believe that they are primarily for beginners. People who aren't beginners just don't buy much other than materials.

I have seen many of his videos on youtube, and the demos that he's done of his DVDs and he is a good skilled woodworker. I have seen things from world class craftsman that are otherworldly, people like George Wilson, Lynton Mackenzie, etc. I don't see anything like that from Paul. I'm sure Lynton did some teaching of some sort, and george had apprentices. This is an entirely different scale than selling videos and classes to amateurs. (to be clear, he is still far more accomplished than many amateurs who have put together videos and sold them to beginners - one of those being chris schwarz, whose materials I have never purchased despite insistence of dozens of people early on in my screwing around with wood telling me I *had* to have them. I never saw the reason they were such a need to have and still don't. I'd buy 10 paul DVDs before one Chris DVD).

When I made the comment about selling tickets, I was thinking more about getting people to come to woodworking school than to sell DVDs. I forgot that Paul sell DVDs and it wasn't part of that thought, it's getting arses in seats as they say in wrestling (as in getting people to travel and pay money to take classes).

Now, no I don't harbor any real animus. I think it's perfectly legitimate to express an opinion that is critical, that is my opinion, without the issue elevating to something I think about at night with the computer off. There's nobody in woodworking like that, though there are unskilled or little skilled bloggers who bother me a whole lot more than paul does. They do irritate me when I see them quoted online.

Frame all of this with my general thought that what most of us are lacking is experience, not the next guru. If I could have anything, it would be more time at the bench. Aside from some guidance in aesthetics (which these peddled classes from the gurus are really not about), what I really need is more work with the wood, and nothing teaches like tools in wood and a demand of yourself to get better and learn something on your own. I suspect that's true for a lot of people, but most folks would rather do fantasy camp than sit in a quiet area and think about something on their own. Frame also, I guess, I have a pretty narrow interest range. I'd rather build tools than cabinets, and after I'm done with the tool phase, I'd rather build a few guitars than cabinets...or clocks, or benches, etc. I have enough trouble finding anyone who could use a double iron plane properly, let alone anyone who could tell me how to make one.

Most beginners and novices are pretty ripe, though, and folks who are tending toward 5+ years of experience and a lot of shop time are less ripe.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#18

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

Bit of an overgeneralization to me to start including internet personalities as such, but if you see him as a "leader", that is up to you.

It's clear from the comments in his videos there are tons of followers. Reminds me of dr. oz...

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#19

Re: Leaders?

JDK

Referring to Sellers as a "Guru" belies your claim that you lack animus. And David, some of us have been hand-tool woodworkers considerably longer than five years, and I suspect most of Paul's readers and viewers are of similar experience.

Your claim his appeal is primarily to beginners is simply unsupportable, and is nothing but an assertion made out of whole cloth.

You don't like the guy? Fine. But it's unseemly to bluster your anger with unsupported assertions and banal insults.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#20

Re: Leaders?

North of the Border

Reminds me of dr. oz...

and that must include:

Tage Frid

James Krenov

Sam Maloof, and

George Nakashima

who had had tons of followers.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#21

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

You're again in the weeds with the anger stuff, I just don't care enough for it to ever rise to that. I wouldn't buy Paul's stuff, but I will watch a few of his youtube videos now and again out of a morbid fascination with delivery of stuff that I already know and have known for quite a while.

I hope you realize there are more definitions to guru than the one you are leaning on:

: a teacher or guide that you trust

: a person who has a lot of experience in or knowledge about a particular subject

a : a teacher and especially intellectual guide in matters of fundamental concern

b : one who is an acknowledged leader or chief proponent

c : a person with knowledge or expertise : expert

I would call mehmet oz a guru, too, and he surely doesn't lack qualifications.

A lot of why I chose the word guru has more to do with the people following paul and their rush to defense of anyone who even has a neutral thought. Gurus tend to attact that kind of crowd.

You'll see me defending george wilson when someone gets upset that they don't think he's perfectly nice to people who make ridiculous comments about him. I guess george is my guru. Of course, George offers his advice for free and my questions to him have less to do with how to sharpen and more to do with how things look.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#22

Re: Leaders?

JDK

He's not listening. I'm done.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#23

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

I suppose. I would call Bill Gates a leader, and folks like that. I wouldn't call any of the people you described "leaders", what are they leading?

I'm not so much into chairs, the nakashima stuff i don't get at all, and I've been beaten over the head with quotes of tage frid more than any of those you listed. None of them talk much about the stuff I'm interested. Krenov had opinions about planes (and i'm uber interested in planes) but I don't think too much of his opinions about them....others are perfectly free to disagree. The big knock about the planes that I like the most is that they're not cost effective to produce.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#24

Re: Leaders?

david weaver

If I'm not, I'm not the only one. I don't see what the buzz is about (re: sellers), and if that's "not listening", that's fine. No guru reaches 100% of the audience.

Re: Paul Sellers and the Flat Stone Question *LINK*

#25

Re: Schtick

FrankB

Paul Sellers is an interesting fellow. There is no doubt that he is an excellent woodworker. I read his blog and watch his videos. I tend to learn something most times.

There is also a morbid fascination since I know that he will say or write something that I will strongly disagree with. I remind myself that he is writing to a selected audience, and that I am not a member of this. The audience comprise 90% beginners, new to woodworking. He attempts to simply skills, at which he is very effective. He is a good teacher. What is there not to like about this?

The problem for more experienced woodworkers is that he sells His Way. And to do this he puts other methods down (and, by association, the supporters of those methods). That is not polite. Woodworkers are passionate people and easily roused. He also makes statements that are incorrect, and does so with pseudo science that will convince his followers and thus may prevent them from learning alternate views. For example, his view that micro bevels weaken an edge, and that the chipbreaker only serves to support a thin blade. There are many others.

This is his schtick. He is preaching to the converted. He is selling his courses. He is doing a good job of being newsworthy - just look how many react.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Derek,not every woodworker feels the need to over psychoanalyze other woowdworkers. Could you tell me where you come up with accurate figure of "90%'of his audience" are beginners or is this just a made up statistic. To quote "Woodworkers are passionate people and easily roused" I understand the passion of woodwork but by no means does my passion make me easily roused. My passion gives me an understanding of others ways and methods.

To Quote" and does so with pseudo science that will convince his followers and thus may prevent them from learning alternative views" I don't know how you could make such a misleading statement.

Frank.