New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Mujingfang plough plane

Posts

Mujingfang plough plane

#1

Mujingfang plough plane

Joe shelton

I'm weighing the merits of this plane, and would like to hear comments from anyone who's used one.

Seems like it might be fun to run a few grooves for drawer bottoms. Do you reckon?

Mjoe

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#2

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Joe,

Have no experience with the plane. I suggest a couple of things before buying.

Their bench plane blades come in HSS, as I understand it. Woodcraft's ad for the plough says 'high carbon steel'. You might want to check with the vendor or other owners whether 'high carbon steel' means HSS or something more akin to O1, a clean steel in other words--if it matters to you.

I see that the fence is on the right side of the blade, with the plane cutting away from you. That is opposite to the convention for western ploughs. So, if you're doing drawer bottoms, if you want the groove to be on the near side of the board you're planing, you would either have to be pushing from left to right, with the left hand being dominant, or else pull the plane. Only you know if you care about this :) . If it were me using this plane, I would pull it.

2 cents.

Wiley

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#3

Re: Bouvet Plane

david weaver

Warren showed an open mortise design of plane that I recall him calling a Bouvet grooving or plow plane or something.

I think that's preferable for cutting drawer grooves if you want to do it on the cheap (and it will cut drawer grooves better than a plane with a metal skate, anyway).

I put up a thread earlier this year on sawmill creek showing the making of one (or a couple?) of them, but you really don't need to refer to that if you can just look at a picture and visualize things.

IIRC, it took about an hour each to make a plane like that.

I haven't got any thoughts on the muji plane because I haven't used it. I hear it's small, though.

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#4

Wiley, Dave - Thankd


Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#5

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

Lars Parrington

While high speed steels (HSS) may have high amounts of carbon, it has been my experience that when a manufacturer advertises "high carbon steel", they specifically do NOT mean HSS.

HSS do not lose their temper until they gets almost red hot. So they are preferable for tools like drill bits which can get quite hot in use. Generally they are also more abrasion resistant, making them useful for things like jointer and planer blades, but less useful for hand tool blades because they are harder to sharpen.

It is pretty unlikely that mujinfang would be supplying HSS blades. It would be unnecessarily more expensive or difficult for them to make, and they might get a lot of complaints from users who find their oil stones won't abrade the blades.

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#6

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

david weaver

Mujingfang makes most of their chisels and plane blades out of a high speed steel similar to the T series steels.

It's chinese made HSS and probably much easier to harden and temper reliably (as in without warping or cracking) than a plain carbon steel would be.

It's quite good. You can't really rely on their descriptions, though, because when someone like JWW describes mujingfang stuff, they often use meaningless descriptions.

For some time (and maybe still), they called the bench plane irons A2 steel, but they are instead some type of HSS. I'm supposing they are T series steel because I believe I read that somewhere and they take quite a good edge for HSS and even on a natural japanese stone (though such a stone doesn't remove much of their metal).

For what it's worth, a T series HSS would be far superior for hand tools compared to M2. The chisels that muji makes are wonderful. It's too bad nobody sells them over here. They're tapered along their length which is really nice for some things.

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#7

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Lars,

Yeah, I understand all that, just as you do. However, I wouldn't trust the ad blurb. It's not specific--who knows what 'high carbon' means to an ad copy writer. There's a language barrier to jump, and Mujingfang is known to use HSS on numerous other irons.

It's worth a check with someone who knows, IMO, if one cares. Someone who has standardized on Arkansas stones would care.

Wiley

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#8

Re: Bouvet Plane

Gary B.

Hello, do you have a link showing the planes you describe making? I'd be interested in learning more!

Thanks and Merry Christmas!

Gary

Re: Mujingfang plough plane

#9

Re: Bouvet Plane

david weaver

go to sawmill creek and type this in search:

"Time-to-build-two-quickie-drawer-grooving-planes"

I don't know if linking to other forums is allowed, but there's no great need to do it.

You can build them much nicer looking than I did, I just wanted the planes.