New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Tell me the difference...

Posts

Tell me the difference...

#1

Tell me the difference...

McKay

I fail to see the difference between an inexpensive drift punch and the fairly expensive draw bore tool from LV. I held off doing 21 draw bores until my new draw bore tool came. It came today, and I must say that I am disappointed. I have a drift punch that I handled and spent ..maybe 4$ on it. The LV draw bore is a beautiful tool, but does not function any better than the drift punch. I wish that I had spent the money on one of their other fine tools. So, is there a difference?

Re: Tell me the difference...

#2

Re: Tell me the difference...

BrianMonumentCO

I wonder what metals are involved.

That could be the major difference.

Of course you could have paid simply for a name.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#3

Re: well..

David weaver

At least you didn't get one of the really expensive ones that has an oval profile.

I have a couple of the lv pegs and haven't used them, so I'm not sure if they are anything other than circular.

I guess you could send them back if you're not happy with them.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#4

Re: Tell me the difference...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Mckay

What did you do before the LV pins came into your life? Did you draw bore at all?

I guess one needs to ask why does use draw bore pins since it is not necessary to push in a pin before wacking in the peg? I often do not bother. They are not one of life's vital tools. However, when so needed, what else is there to use?

My understanding - and approach - has been that I use them to test a fit or to hold a joint together in lieu of a clamp. To do so, the draw bore pin needs to be long and tapered. Short pins require a hammer and some force, which runs the risk of causing some damage.

I also find that I prefer to twist it in-and-out, since this offers more control. This means that the pin requires a handle. Twisting can place a great deal of strain on the fit between handle and shaft, so this needs to be more secure than just inserting the shaft into a hole in a handle.

For $29, I think the LV drawbore pins are pretty good value.


Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Tell me the difference...

#5

Several thoughts

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

You put the handle on it; when you spent your $4, it didn't have a handle, right? Cost of production of a drift punch would be pretty low, but adding a handle would add production cost.

The other element, of course, is that Lee Valley's tools are fairly low production runs compared to the number of drift punches made and sold worldwide by any given maker; unit cost of production generally goes down as units produced goes up.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#6

I used the drift punch..

McKay

I put a handle on the drift punch but I did not like that it was round instead of oval. I assumed that a draw bore pin from LV would be oval. That is what I get for assuming without checking. The pin is a nice piece of work. However, I will send it back and continue to use my drift punch until I can afford a proper pin. (and yes Derek I draw bore nearly everything I make. )

Re: Tell me the difference...

#7

A respectful question.....

roger lance

This is one of those tools/techniques that I question if it offers any advantage over the use of a clamp to bring a mortise/tenon joint tightly together. Is there an advantage ??

Re: Tell me the difference...

#8

craigd

Re: A respectful question.....

craigd

If you are building something like a joint stool, which is all angles, it makes clamping a whole lot easier. Plus, they are lots smaller and faster to pull the joint together (vs clamps). I made my pins so I could change the taper to work with blind holes.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#9

Re: A respectful question.....

McKay

I consider the draw pin as a clamp that is not removed as a clamp would be.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#10

Re: A respectful question.....

wilbur

If you drawbore a mortise and tenon joint, you give the joint added mechanical advantage for the day that the glue fails on you.

Also, during assembly, the drawbore pins pull the joint tight without the need for a clamp. This is a great advantage if you’re using a mortise and tenon joint for, say, a 6 foot long stretcher for a long table. It’s a lot easier than maneuvering a 7 foot long clamp.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#11

Re: A respectful question.....

TomD

I don't buy the glue fail answer, because it just makes it more difficult to reglue. It might make sense on a hanging bivouac, where if the joint goes without a warning you would tumble a few thousand feet to the ground. But with furniture and the right glue in there you can reglue in a few minutes and are good to go for another hundred years.

A properly cut tenon doesn't need to be clamped, though most of mine do. But they can be wedged, or tension fit. One certainly wouldn't need a 7 foot clamp, just clamp some cheeks to the stretcher with a crosspiece, drive a wedge or fit a veneer screw, and you can do any length you want.

I accept all your reason, even though I see workarounds, but I just don't actually believe that drilling holes in things that are offset, and then pounding in a dowel, is aesthetically pleasing, of structuraly superior. If it was better, not just one of the ways things can be done, it would make some sense. As far as not being better, I think that has a lot to do with the dimensions. Most of my concern is on the lighter structures, where the loads are significant. On work scaled like timber framing, the parts are tough, and the cheeks and tenons are wide, The dowel by itself is sufficient without glue. In that case, it works, but I didn't take this to be a discussion of that.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#12

Re: A respectful question.....

Larry Barrett

If the wood in what you are assembling still has substantial moisture in it then the draw bore joint will keep the joints tight as the wood settles to its equilibrium moisture content (EMC) point.

For example, a joint stool made from wood not long out of the log. Both post and rail will likely be above EMC when assembled. Think about the post mortise and the rail tenon joint. The rail will not change in length (not noticeably) but the post will shrink in cross-section and the tenon on the rail will also shrink in cross-section. The draw bore joint will keep the shoulder of the rail tenon tight against the post as the post dries.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#13

Re: A respectful question.....

wilbur

Agree on the workarounds for clamping, and everyone has their own opinion on the aesthetic value of pegs.

But I find it hard to believe that the drawbore doesn’t give a mortise and tenon joint an added mechanical advantage.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#14

Re: A respectful question.....

Warren in Lancaster, PA

I've made thousands of mortise and tenon joints. You don't need clamps and you certainly don't need draw bore pins. If you use a peg that is tapered the full length, like we see in historical examples, and offset the holes the peg itself pulls the joint tight.

Drawbore pins do not show up in the 1000+ tools the Dominy family used from 1750-1820, or their account books of the period. Surviving Dominy furniture shows the use of pinned mortise and tenon joints.Drawbore pins do not show up in the 200+ tools surviving in the Seaton chest or the 1797 inventory of those tools. Seaton had 11 different mortise chisels.

Jay Gaynor illustrates an old Birmingham drawbore pin and dates it as late 18th century or early 19th century based on style. The earliest reference I have seen to drawbore pins occurs in Nicholson (1812). Some 18th century inventories are quite extensive, but do not seem to include these tools. If someone has an 18th century reference to drawbore pins, I would very interested in seeing it.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#15

The world is a very big place.

Bob Hackett

Why try to contain it in only a few cabinet maker`s tool chests.

You see drawbore pins at work in both timber framing and wooden boat building to good effect. Why not take what works in other trades and apply it to furniture work. I suspect that`s how these things appear once we advance and work our way through the evolution of skills and craft.

There also has been some extensive WWing going on outside of Europe that use pins and pegs much more extensively than the metal hardware we find more celebrated (at least celebrated here) craftsmen using.

There is both life, history and efficient techniques being practiced beyond what we tend to discuss as " the documented history of furniture making" here.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#16

Re: A respectful question.....

roger lance

Although I make a mortise/tenon joint that can be closed with hand pressure, I've often experience a joint that I'm unable to close by hand once the glue has been applied due to swelling of the mortise/tenon. A clamp saved me in those situations.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#17

Re: A respectful question.....

BrianMonumentCO

This part of the thread brings me back to the last time I watched my VHS tape of Jim Kingshott doing Mortice and Tenon work. He showed a peg allegedly from HMS Victory. And he made good sense about using the peg or Trennel (he claims it was derived from the words "tree nail") to hold a joint together.

BUt as he drilled the mortice board and then the corresponding hole in the tenon board it was clear that he was using the trennel (I cannot claim I have the correct spelling) to help hold the joint together.

But he was VERY adamant that the trennel MUST be riven and not just a turned dowel. It needs to be straight grained and then driven through a dowel plate.

Aside from JK's tutorial on M&T construction, I just plain like the looks of the trennel/peg.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#18

Re: A respectful question.....

Sgian Dubh

"I cannot claim I have the correct spelling"

Trunnel is more common Brian, but apart from that the rest of your post is pretty sound, although not all trunnels are, or were, driven through dowel plates prior to use, e.g., those used in large beam framing joints for construction of barns, houses and the like. They were (are) usually fitted straight off the chisel or hatchet that formed them, a bit fatter than the hole, and therefore roughly square in profile. The sharp corners had a role in locking the joint through their ability to distort the grain as they were driven into place. They could do this relatively easily because the wood used is, or was, relatively wet or green.

I've used the same form and technique of trunnel for draw-boring in smaller scale outdoor furniture, it too generally made with a durable wood species, e.g., English oak, air dried to no lower than about 20% MC, therefore soft enough for the trunnels to distort the grain. Slainte.

Re: Tell me the difference...

#19

Re: A respectful question.....

TomD

Now that could be a separate question. You give up a certain minuscule glue area, and somewhat trash various aspects of the structure, but you do have the "nail" in there. I guess I sorta covered that in my speculations that in some ultimate death scenario you might get more capacity out of the draw bore, though if the cheeks and tenon are thin enough, my sense is probably not. But the question is whether that peak load scenario is the likely failure mode, and whether the violence the DB does is worth it.

I remember reading this article about failure in wooden boat structure. The test they use is something like a 10% 80%. They load the element to 10% breaking strain, and then something like 80% breaking strain. The interesting thing is the 10% cycling has an affect, it builds up over time and eventually the structures fail. An example is when masts fall down at the yacht club, it isn't a hurricane that does it on a calm day, it is the gentle working back and forth in gentle waves over millions of cycles.

However, when woodworking mags test joints they get a giant clamp, or hammer, and blow the thing up, and then say "look" it failed around the glue joint, the joint was stronger. Or maybe the nail hold up, and it is victory or the nail. With stuff that is nicely made, the proud owners, don't tear it apart in a 20 ton press, they carefully open and close the piece, and keep an eagle eye on any kids that are around. Then 30 years down the road the thing comes apart after 300 000 cycles. I don't think nails help with that. I think a well cut repairable joint is a better bet. But it is just a guess.

There are a lot of imponderables. Does the guy who uses the nail cut the joint as carefully as the guy who only relies on glue, for instance.

But basically I agree with you, there has to be some failure mode we are dealing with, and the peg might be better for some of them. I don't use the method much, so maybe I am doing things in a way that favours the glue.