Re: A respectful question.....
TomD
Now that could be a separate question. You give up a certain minuscule glue area, and somewhat trash various aspects of the structure, but you do have the "nail" in there. I guess I sorta covered that in my speculations that in some ultimate death scenario you might get more capacity out of the draw bore, though if the cheeks and tenon are thin enough, my sense is probably not. But the question is whether that peak load scenario is the likely failure mode, and whether the violence the DB does is worth it.
I remember reading this article about failure in wooden boat structure. The test they use is something like a 10% 80%. They load the element to 10% breaking strain, and then something like 80% breaking strain. The interesting thing is the 10% cycling has an affect, it builds up over time and eventually the structures fail. An example is when masts fall down at the yacht club, it isn't a hurricane that does it on a calm day, it is the gentle working back and forth in gentle waves over millions of cycles.
However, when woodworking mags test joints they get a giant clamp, or hammer, and blow the thing up, and then say "look" it failed around the glue joint, the joint was stronger. Or maybe the nail hold up, and it is victory or the nail. With stuff that is nicely made, the proud owners, don't tear it apart in a 20 ton press, they carefully open and close the piece, and keep an eagle eye on any kids that are around. Then 30 years down the road the thing comes apart after 300 000 cycles. I don't think nails help with that. I think a well cut repairable joint is a better bet. But it is just a guess.
There are a lot of imponderables. Does the guy who uses the nail cut the joint as carefully as the guy who only relies on glue, for instance.
But basically I agree with you, there has to be some failure mode we are dealing with, and the peg might be better for some of them. I don't use the method much, so maybe I am doing things in a way that favours the glue.