New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

My current thoughts on sharpening

Posts

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#26

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

TomD

I remember at one point pushing the point that the fastest way to sharpen wasn't the diamonds then being pushed, but to use a grinder. That one could go direct from grinder to green compound (I learned a lot here about how effective diamonds were, and now prefer that for stropping when i do). At the time there was widespread derision over the idea one could go direct from a grinder wheel to a buff, without seven steps of shapton, or some such. I don't care where the ideas come from, particularly since I was passing on Taig Frid's routine, and all this stuff exists only because other people have been doing this stuff for hundreds of years. Good to know people are getting results and not scared away by dry grinding any more.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#27

Re: tidy technique

TomD

I use a leather strop dry, and rarely replace the diamonds. There is very little in the way of anything black anywhere. I frankly don't know where it all goes. I strop frequently, depending on the tool so I rarely go to a messy stage. There must be some very minor rouding of edges, but it doesn't seem to affect results. I do have all the barrels of Japanese tools if I want to have perfect edges, though sometimes perfection is the enemy of the good.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#28

Re: Honing only

TomD

Why sharpen? Obviously we want keen edges, but when taking about going all the way back to grinding, that seems like a somewhat wasteful process. I have been doing a lot of leather work recently, and the traditional tools for that can be rather poor in edge holding, as with a fairly wide range of traditional tools, from Scythes to razors. There isn't any point in grinding these tools, unless you damage them. They work by frequent honing, often prior to every cut, though with diamonds one can wait till the tool speaks up, then hone it because the diamonds cut that much faster. I have noticed that this approach is polluting my tool use generally. Of course for woodworking, we need more edge holding, and sharpening prior to every cut is not practical. But there are some tools where honing works really well. With some of my planes I can get the blade in and out in a few seconds, plus the time to hone them. Certain categories of tools are not so explicit that the rounding of honing on leather will affect their performance. Most tools can be sharpened this way. The earlier prevalence of flat or convex bevels seems to suggest the prevalence of this technique in earlier times.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#29

It's not wasteful

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

In fact I do store my plate in a plastic bread wrapper. What I am wiping off is WD-40 and metal particles. Any diamonds that are doing any good got embedded long ago in the process and not wipeable. Any diamonds that are not embedded are a disadvantage to have around.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#30

Similarly

John in NM

I remember reading a memorium article about Tage Frid in FWW, written by Hank Gilpin, who was an early student and employee.

He described Frid's chisel sharpening technique as removing all nicks on the shop belt sander (probably followed by a quick strop that I've forgotten about).

Personally, I see nothing wrong with complicated honing regimes, and have indulged in them myself. But I do see them as an end unto themselves and not required as part of doing fine quality woodworking.

Sharp enough does the job - where "enough" lies is going to depend on the woodworker, time constraints, and goals. Some will not wish to waste a spare second sharpening, others will find themselves distracted and annoyed by a less than perfect edge and thus not able to enjoy their work.

Enjoying the work is the point, I think - whether one is a hobbyist or professional.

I think I've mentioned before, one of the best edges I can get is hollow grinding followed by a quick buff on a hand cranked hard felt wheel with some polish for stainless steel.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#31

Re: tidy technique

Lars Parrington

Thanks Bill. I also have moved away from diamond paste because of black fingers. I'll have to give it a shot again one of these days.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#32

Re: The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

Lars Parrington

Cool setup! I already have a ultra-fine spyderco and a fine eze-lap sitting around, so I'm halfway there.

I'll keep my eye out for a medium spyderco. The CBN wheel sounds awesome, but I'm not as bothered by the 3X dust as you (or maybe I just do less grinding).

I will be interested to hear your thoughts on the system after using for a year or two.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#33

Re: The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

Chuck Bjorgen

I tried out the medium and ultra-fine Spiderco stones a couple months ago and really like them. Just this morning I redid a vintage 2 3/8" plane iron from a 22" woody that was given to me. I reground this on the Tormek, which I've had for around 15 years, worked a micro bevel on a 1200 Ezy-lap stone and finished on the two Spidercos. Took maybe an hour with back flattening. Haven't cut any wood yet because I'm still re-gluing the handle on the plane.

David Weaver convinced me that the two-inch width on these stones is no problem because it's easy enough to run the irons off the edge of the stones while hand honing. The end result is there is no dishing or other uneven wear.

As with so many others here, I probably have a small fortune invested in sharpening equipment.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#34

Re: The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

David Weaver convinced me that the two-inch width on these stones is no problem because it's easy enough to run the irons off the edge of the stones while hand honing. The end result is there is no dishing or other uneven wear.

David and I were encouraged to try these stones by George Wilson. If they are good enough for George ... :)

I would prefer that the stones were 3x8" rather than 2x8" (the UF is available in 3x8" however it comes without a case). In any event, the 2" width is irrelevant is you do side sharping, which is my preference anyway.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#35

Re: The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

TomD

I have had spyderco stones and sticks for at least 30 years. My only gripe was that they were nowhere near flat when I bought them, and they are not easy to flatten though maybe loose diamonds would solve that problem. How is the flatness today?

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#36

Re: Similarly

TomD

Agreed, the buff is a great method. LV has been offering this method for a long time with their green compound. The only problem with hollow grinding is that it isn't appropriate for all methods, but then as you point out there is always flat belt sanding, the ultimate fast method. And with sandpaper you can hollow, flat, or convex grind.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#37

Re: The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Tom

Both my Medium and Ultra Fine stones needed flattening - not a lot, but they needed to be done before putting them to use.

Each required about 15 minutes combined on coarse (250 grit) and fine (600) Eze-lap diamond stones.

Will they remain flat? I did resurface the UF with the 600 last week and there was some wear. Not enough to consider flattening much (I was just curious), but there will be some flattening needed based on this.

Regards from Perth

Derek