New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Abingdon, VA – Tree Cutting & Portable Sawmill

My current thoughts on sharpening

Posts

My current thoughts on sharpening

#1

My current thoughts on sharpening

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.


My need for sharp blades

I mainly make shavings in order to adjust the size or shape of a piece of wood, that is, largely for fitting. I sand everything so surface finish is irrelevant. If wood goes away in a controlled fashion, tear-out free, I am satisfied.

Fitting tasks come in short spurts so I never plane anything close to dulling the blade in one planing session. Hence, when I grab a plane or chisel it is unlikely I will remember how much it was used when I last used it, for whatever. As a result dullness, as evidenced by lack of cutting, can come unexpectedly. These unexpected halts in the flow of work to sharpen are not a pleasant surprise for me. Hence, I want my steel to stay sharp as long as possible and sharpening to be quick.

Obviously my wood removal and sharpening is vastly different from someone settling in to flatten a table top. In this situation sharpening is to be expected during the course of the work and even become a welcome break from strenuous activity. Others have the discipline to sharpen before the tool stops cutting. Hence, you may find what follows irrelevant for your work.

My equipment and materials attributes

I have a bench grinder with a wheel suited to sharpening tool steels (that’s tool steel, not necessarily HSS), cast iron plates and an assortment of diamond paste, fixed diamond plates of various grits, strop and an assortment of other stones that I find to slow for further consideration.

The bench grinder is the fastest way to remove metal but it is risky removing metal to the edge for this fast removal may leave the edge not straight.

Diamonds on cast iron is the fastest way to remove metal at the edge whilst keeping the edge straight. But, diamonds embed in the tool and can be transferred to a subsequent finer diamond plate, if finer grits are employed.

Fixed diamond plates cut faster than many stones but not as fast as the charged cast iron. They do not transfer diamond particles in my experinece.

A strop is good for removing burrs and refining an edge.

The question becomes how to best use what I have in the most effective way. What follows is what I have been doing on the past few projects- chisles, planes and spoke shaves.

1. Hollow grind as needed to a point near the edge but without breeching the edge. This step removes bulk metal fast leaving little metal to be removed by the slower sharpening techniques to follow.

2. Sharpen edge on the cast iron plate with 15 micron paste. This set up cuts amazing fast and will sharpen a blade that is quite dull in a time that does not try my patience. The scratch pattern is similar to a “fine” fixed diamond stone but the cut is much quicker.

3. Refine edge on strop. Mr. Weaver suggests modest pressure on the tool and indeed this works well.

The picture shows the cast iron plate, syringe of paste(a lifetime supply), Strop, and a container of WD40 for the plate lubricant. It should be obvious that this equipment is cheap.

I find the result fine for what I do. Personally, I have been over sharpening, ending with 1 micron diamond in the past. A highly refined plane blade edge after a few feet of planing is duller than what my current procedure starts out so I see little use for my needs of sharpening beyond what is described above.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#2

Sounds Sensible, Bill.   


Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#3

PS and a thanks.....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

to Mr. Weaver for the inspiration to forgo the 1` micron diamond and jump directly from 15 micron paste to strop.

I can not over emphasize how aggressive the 15 micron diamond on cast iron cuts even abrasion resistant steel like CPM 3V. The plate actually "rings" from this cutting action.

As an additional benefit, aided by a dash of WD-40 lube, a hollow ground bevel sucks onto the surface of the plate which enables even those challenged by hand held sharpening to get good registration of the bevel on the abrasive surface. My son-in-law who had never sharpened anything before was able to hand hold a block plane blade for sharpening during a Thanksgiving visit.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#4

Two questions

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill,

This is good information to share. Thanks!

1. Is the strop charged with any compound? Is there something special about it, that needs to be replicated in order to get the fragments off and put some sort of hone on a 15-micron diamond edge?

2. Where'd you get the cast iron plate? Is it Blanchard-ground or surface ground--at what diamond mesh do you go from one to the other? Suggestions for others?

Wiley

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#5

Question on loose diamonds.

Chuck Nickerson

First: and excellent statement of your criteria for evaluation. Not the same as mine which makes the statement an important step.

Have you found a technique/fluid/cloth that helps remove diamond from the blade, or is it just a matter or truly most sincerely diligently wiping?

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#6

answers

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

1. Is the strop charged with any compound? Now and then I rub some of that green stick on the leather with a bit of oil.

Is there something special about it. I doubt it.

2. Where'd you get the cast iron plate? Well, I have several. The one in the picture I got from a machine shop and it is surface ground. I have others. We ordered gray cast iron bar stock and they are Blanchard-ground .

Economy of scale is everything in cast iron plates. The material is very cheap, and grinding is cheap, if doing a bunch. Not cheap for 1 plate. I remain astonished that someone has not made a market for these plates. I suspect it is because most do not know how fast this arrangement removes metal......of any abrasion resistance.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#7

Re: Question on loose diamonds.

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The business of using diamond in cast iron was not my idea. In fact this format has been used for cutting the facets on diamond gems for as long as diamonds have been faceted. Looking in old machine shop manuals the technique is described as well as the problem of the loose particles embedding in the tool being ground. It is stated that these particles are tenaciously embedded can't be wiped off.

My assumption is that statements that there will be carryover of one grit to another is true (I have seen it also) and I have modified what I do to avoid using a smaller loose grit behind a coarser one. In the past I used 15 micron diamond fixed on a plate followed by 1 micron loose diamond. Loose 15 micron followed by strop is greatly faster.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#8

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

david weaver

Looks good to me!!

I've been bouncing back and forth between washita only and bare leather (something only for the hard core, I guess) and...

$20 chinese diamond plate on ebay filed by okudo suita (the latter is also only for the hard core). Coarser okudo suita will sharpen HSS, ....surprisingly sharp - no dangling wire edge piecefs, and actually cut it fast enough to make black swarf.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#9

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

Bruce, a MN Galoot

Most of my blades are old steel, Bergs, plus a few Hirsch, so they don't require anything special. However, my LV and LN A-2 plane blades don't sharpen easily on my King waterstones. I have a block of cast iron I've been using, but the coarsest diamond I've tried is only 3 micron. Thus the blades get sharp but it has taken time. Time to get some coarser 15 micron diamond and get that cast iron surface ground. Thanks for the discussion.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#10

The ultimate grinding/sharpening set up?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

By way of introduction, I work with hollow grinds. I believe that the way to the quickest, most efficiently created, and sharpest edge is via a hollow grind that leaves the minimum amount of steel to hone. Honing on a minimum amount of steel is also more friendly to the honing media - less effort is required as there is less surface area, and it is possible to use less sophisticated honing media.

A hollow grind is also economic of the steel. Minimal blade length is removed since the steel is wasted from the hollow - that is "inside out". As I shall demonstrate, there is the ability to create the ultimate micro bevel.

For the first time in some years I have reorganised my grinding/sharpening system. For the past 5 or 6 years I have been using a Tormek 2000 (10" wheel) and Shapton (1000 grit)/Sigma (6000 and 13000 grit) ceramic waterstones. The combination is excellent, but I wanted something that did not make as much mess with water - the paste created dries out my hands and I live with painful cracks.

I have also done the diamond paste thing. Done it for several years. It is also messy - stains hands and I would worry about contaminating the wood via touch. I am not interested in oilstones. I use steels like A2, D2, HSS, PM-V11, M4. Most of these are beyond oilstones.

I decided to base the system around my half-speed 8" dry grinder. This has been used in the past with 46 grit Norton 3X and 46 white wheels. I long ago stopped using the 3X as it sheds so much grit into the air, which I do not wish to breath in. The white wheel is nearly as bad.

What I wanted was a dry honing and dustless grinding set up that was fast and efficient. Not much to ask!

Several weeks ago I took possession of two ceramic Spyderco (2"x8" Medium and Ultra Fine).The Spydercos are hard and retain their flatness like oilstones, but are worked dry. Spyderco do not say what the grits are, but they are reputed to be 1500-2000 and 6000-8000, respectively (it would not surprise me if the Ultra Fine is about 10000 as it leaves a mirror finish). After a little flattening of the Spyderco stones on diamond plates, they will not need to be flattened again, just cleaned with a scrubbing brush occasionally. In many ways, the Syderco are a ceramic version of an oilstone.

The search then was on for a new grinding wheel. About 2 months ago I took possession of a 180 grit 1 1/2" wide CBN (Cubic Boron Nitride) wheel with 1/4" side radii.

There were two wheel grits at the time (there are finer grits now available - up to 350 grit, but I do not see these as relevant to anyone but a turner). The 80 grit is indicated for heavy work. From what I could determine, the 180 grit is nearly as fast and provides a smoother finish.

I got mine from D-way in the USA. I liked their presentation and reputation, and Dave Schweitzer answered all my emails promptly and thoroughly. You can find a few of his videos on Youtube. I went for the radius edge as I thought it may be more useful, not only for lathe chisels (as they demonstrate), but also for entering and exiting on straight edges. I have since used the radius edges for grinding in-channel gouges, and they did a fantastic job.

David assured me that the CBN wheel will grind all hard steels, not just HSS (and he is correct). With regard laminated blades where there is soft steel, he mentioned that a second grind on hard steel will remove any loading, if this occurs.

The beauty of the CBN wheel is that they last a long, long time, possibly forever - unlike diamond wheels which are unsuited to grinding carbon steel (diamond is absorbed by the carbon in the steel). The CBN wheels remain flat, require no upkeep, and this means that settings do not change. They grind relatively cool and can do so to the edge of a blade, just like the Tormek. Less steel to hone means a quicker hone. A straighter hollow means less work to do, which - of course - means faster sharpening. Sounds good.

Installing the wheel is a simple affair. D-way sell a beautifully machined bushing that slipped over the 5/8" arbor on my half-speed grinder. The grinder has a 1 h.p. motor, so is powerful enough to easily push this heavy wheel. It is so well balanced, however, that I imagine a less powerful machine may need a manual spin to start it along.

The CBN wheel replaced the 3X wheel. The guards were removed - the CBN wheel is solid steel and is not going to blow up! I use the Tormek BGM-100 set up, which is identical to that used on the Tormek wet grinder. A huge advantage of this is that one can set up precise angles - which makes for easy repeating of grind angles. For more info, go here: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/WoodworkTechniques/GrindingNirvana.html



Is it cost effective? Does it cost too much? Decide for yourself what you can afford. There are lots of ways to spend money on sharpening systems, some of them in my opinion are a waste of time and money, and some of mine are no doubt for others a waste of time and money!

On average I can grind a blade and hone it in just a few minutes. It probably takes me less time to grind and hone than most take to grind alone. More importantly, re-sharpening takes under one minute.

Step #1 - CBN wheel for grinding - to the edge of the blade. It is warmer than a Tormek, but cool enough to hold in the hand, and much much faster in the grind. The final hollow is slightly deeper (8" radius vs 10" radius), and the upside of this is that a honing will last slightly longer. It is very important that the edge is smooth and the hollow grind is straight. This means much less work to do in terms of preparing the edge with a coarse stone. The CBN result is in a totally different class - universe - to that off a white wheel.

Step #2 - I freehand on the hollow and, after the CBN, shape in a camber on a broken-in Eze-lap Fine grit. I've had this stone over 10 years now. Magic! This is followed by the Medium Spyderco, which raises a very fine microbevel in about 8 strokes. On a PM-Vll blade it is so small that one must look carefully to see it. Five strokes on a Ultra Fine Spyderco, and I could call it done. A few strokes on either Veritas green compound on planed hardwood or, my preference, the 0.5 micron diamond mesh (from LV), and the blade is very, very sharp.

No water. No mess. I can focus on the important part of woodworking - working the wood.

The irony is that the CBN wheel creates a perfect hollow and the Spydercos remove so little steel that the hollow looks like it will last a long time ... and grinding will be done so infrequently!

Here are images of the edges created on a 1" PM-Vll chisel blade. Firstly off the 180 grit CBN wheel ...


You can see the wire here. It is not typically ragged like that off the Tormek. It may be that the CBN wheel is new and still wearing in. It may also be (more likely) that I ground a little further than I would usually as the wheel on the dry grinder is set up fractionally off the line of the Tormek, and it was necessary to grind fractionally further to square the edge, plus the PM-Vll steel holds the wire a little more tenaciously.

Secondly, the Medium Spyderco ...


Then the Ultra Fine Spyderco ...


Finally, a few strokes on a 0.5 diamond mesh to add a final polish and ensure the wire edge is gone. And demonstrating that edge on soft Radiata Pine ...


The stones: Medium, Ultra Fine Spydercos, Diamond mesh (on perspex on hardwood), and Fine Eze-lap.


P.S I am currently installing an 80 grit CBN wheel, which will be used for heavier grinding. I would call this system "done".

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#11

Clint Searl

This should be archived!


Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#12

While we are on the subject of grit size....

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I don't find that the coarsest diamond grits embed well on cast iron. You can feel the rocks rolling around on the plate. However, they embed dandy on a hard plastic like acrylic or polycarbonate. Some sort of viscous water based lubricant completes the recipe. I use glycol in water. Specifically the glycol is 1,2-propane diol that I used to rescue sheep from ketosis, but I suspect a solution of glycerin would do as well.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#13

Part of "ultimate" review lacking

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Review of the "ultimate" sharpening system should include the price of all the parts.

The grinding wheels you describe are available from any of the machine shop supply stores here in the US, and I suppose elsewhere. Turners here that have deep pocket budgets have been using dry wheels as you describe for some time.

I do think one statement in your review is misleading. I don't have black fingers when I used diamond on cast iron. If you do you are using too much lubricant. A few drops are plenty. After sharpening I wipe the plate with an absorbent paper towel and the lubricant and tiny metal particles are absorbed away.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#14

Added info as requested

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi Bill

Costs:

180 grit 8" wheel from D-Way was $220. The 1" wide wheel is $175.

http://www.d-waytools.com/tools-diamond-grinding-wheels.html

Spyderco 2"x8" Medium plate is $45

Spyderco 2"x8" Ultra fine plate is $58

http://www.knifecenter.com/kc_new/store_store.html?brand=234&a=sharpen

Keep in mind that these should last many, many years. They have all been around for a long time. This is not new technology.

Overall, the costs here are low - about the same as a new smoother from LN or LV.

Regarding the diamond paste, one of my cast iron plates for use with diamond paste (ex-plane sole) ..


It is unavoidable to get paste residue on fingers when lapping or freehand honing.

Bill, I am not arguing that paste is a non-starter - I used it for a few years. It works very well. It is cheap. I would never tell someone to use the system I do. I put it out there for others to evaluate, and measure against their own. Everyone has a different set of priorities. Mine are to do it quick and clean. My hands and fingers crack easily. I dislike sharpening with a passion. I just want it out of the way so that I can get back to working wood. However, I love what a sharp blade can do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#15

Diamond wear *LINK*

John in NM

This is going to sound like nit-picking, perhaps it is too as it doesn't much change your preference for CBN wheels :D

You have the diamond wear question with ferrous grinding all backwards.

Diamond is not dissolved by carbon. The heat, pressure, and shearing actions of dry grinding with diamond can cause a phase change to graphite. Diamond is particularly susceptable to this because it is a metastable crystal and graphite (stable) is a stacked hexagonal crystal (that's where the shearing comes in).

The dissolving part comes in due to carbon's affinity for iron. The graphite formed in dry diamond grinding is dissolved by the iron, not the carbon. For this reason, low carbon steels wear diamond faster than do high carbon - hows that for irony? :D

However, I doubt this is much of a problem with low speed wet grinding. CBN wheels may still be a great choice due to the quality of the abrasive more than the wear mechanism. Unless one is sourcing high quality, monocrystaline diamond wheels for wet grinding, the CBN will probably still last longer.

I've included a link to the Nature article that I saved years ago when I was cutting lots of stones and curious about this.


Diamond wear

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#16

Agree on the mess...

John in NM

Too much paste, too much lube.

Additionally, one could use a soft metal like copper as a permanently charged plate for fine honing - less mess that way, no paste and can be used dry. Harder to make it flat for the super picky amongst us, but over the distance of a bevel for a hollow grind, machine shop dead flat shouldn't be necessary. Contamination of grits should be less of a problem using a copper plate, but with a hollow grind regime one can easily use a single grit for acceptable results. The big downside is, of course, the price of copper! :D

As with my other post, this isn't really intended as a critique so much as adding information for those who may wish to experiment. As always, I enjoy Derek's thorough write ups a lot.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#17

Re: Agree on the mess...

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Additionally, one could use a soft metal like copper as a permanently charged plate for fine honing - less mess that way, no paste and can be used dry. Harder to make it flat for the super picky amongst us, but over the distance of a bevel for a hollow grind, machine shop dead flat shouldn't be necessary.

Thanks John.

Just a comment on the above. What you write is fine for when honing a bevel. However, there is also the back of the blade to consider, either when flattening it or, more commonly, when honing/removing the wire edge. The surface needs to be flat for that.

Incidentally, I have been using oil-based diamond paste. You?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#18

copper substrate for diamond particles

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

The problem with copper is that it is sticky. Steel on cast iron is like skates on ice. It makes registration of bevel on surface easy even for those challenged by such tasks, such as myself. Steel on copper is not as bad as steel on rubber.

As far as cost, copper clad circuit boards are a very cheap copper substrate, sufficiently flat for my work.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#19

thanks

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I am fetching the full length article from the library. Looks to be an interesting read.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#20

Circuit boards...

John in NM

I forgot about those!

Copper is not as good as cast iron for honing steel, as you point out (in lapidary work its actually better).

It's just somewhat easier to acquire in a readily useable chunk. Most of the cast iron we see around is in pieces weighing a hundred pounds or more, and often still in use.

Broken hand planes are a great source, but people rarely seem to save those.

I too am amazed that LN or Lee Valley have not marketed cast honing plates. On the scale of thousands of parts, it becomes quite reasonable in price.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#21

Re: Agree on the mess...

John in NM

Yep, the back can be more problematic, but then you've probably figured out already that I'm not especially fussy about it.

I have some diamond paste around, but mostly I use loose grit in oil when I need it - that is more useful when stone cutting so it's what I have around.

Most of my chisels and blades are O-1, which I'm happy to sharpen using anything short of sandpaper. I had a copper plate I used before stropping for a while, but then fell out of the habit and recycled it. Lately I've been using oil stones, though once I replace my cracked #5 plane I will probably go back to diamond.

I may try another copper for really coarse grit if I ever need to really flatten a sole or chisel back. To date I've just not found it to be worth the effort required.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#22

Re: Diamond wear

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi John

I knew it was something like that. :)

I wonder how many purchased diamond wheels expecting them to be the bees knees? I suspect that CBN is even cheaper.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#23

Cheaper over time, yes...

John in NM

Nickel plated diamond wheels are about half the cost of CBN though, which is why they are still preferred for wet applications like lapidary work. Most of the cost of those is the wheel, so with permanently bonded wheels abrasive life becomes an important factor.

The bees knees for that is actually a sintered diamond wheel, though I suspect that CBN would outlast it due to the way diamond wears.

If I were still doing much lapidary work, I would be very interested to try CBN in place of diamond. For cutting anything up to sapphire, I suspect it would last longer, though it would not be cheaper than loose diamond grit.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#24

tidy technique

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

I could have mentioned that beginners to diamond on cast iron sharpening typically use way too much lub and paste. A couple of mm long "worm" of paste is enough for a 3 x 12" plate. The paste only has to be applied every few sharpening sessions. Reduce viscosity with a few drops of WD-40.

One may have a date with someone not a woodworker just after chopping dovetails and need to avoid black fingers for dinner. Nitrile gloves would work, but there is no need to get black fingers in the first place.

PIC 1


If you pull the tool across the plate the top edge will stay mess-free.

For those that push (personally I see no difference) a puddle of WD-40 laden with black steel particles accumulates at the edge. Note that the plate is damp with WD-40 not puddled.

PIC 2


After a few strokes turn the chisel over and wipe it back on the plate. Smear it around with the back of the chisel and carry on.

PIC 3


When done wipe plate with paper towel. Have a great date.

Re: My current thoughts on sharpening

#25

why wipe off?

Jerry Gibbs

Couldn't one store the plate with paste in a plastic bag and save?