Re: P T's suck also... & the ashcan of credibility
TomD
"But in the case of the M&T joint there is no redundancy to compensate for lack of accuracy of the fit."
Leaving aside multi tenon joints, or depending on definition, finger joints... However, there certainly is plenty of redundancy in the joint. People whale on those things for centuries, and they hold up. It really doesn't mater what is the source of the overbuild, whether it is multiples or size, etc...
"A loose fit degrades the joint strength. Any glue formulated with water will be poor at gap filling and that includes hide glue. When the water goes away holes remain and the glue becomes a foam rather than a coherent tough film."
Of course wood is also a foam, when the water goes away, by your definition, and in many cases it is less strong, at least along the grain lines, than glues, so this may be one of those ideas that sound well thought out, only at first glance.
"For various reasons I have measured tenons I have made and concluded that the tolerance for a good joint is one where the tenon is in the range of 0 to 0.005" thinner than the mortise. One may quibble with this exact number but the conclusion is that the difference between a joint that is difficult/impossible to assemble and one that is too loose is a small number of inches, something on the order of a scribe line width or less."
I would probably describe it pretty much as you do, and yet for hundreds of years people have been making it work. Something we are not accounting for is at work, and i have to say, a lot of the fits on stuff like the NYW are way too loose for me, but somehow the work gets done between that and a few thou. I think your 5 thou claim probably wouldn't hold up in testing, because it rarely does in machine work either. Machine work can go to 11, as the saying goes, but it is actually pretty tough to measure south of 1thou without some really fancy gear, which power tools aren't.
"Hence, the challenge of sawing a mortise is to make two saw cuts with sufficient accuracy to yield a tenon that is accurate to some small number of inches ( about 0.005"). And, if you are going to claim that hand sawing is practical this tolerance needs to be achieved without post adjusting of the thickness by plane or chisel."
I think you are right that it would help if the joinery could come off the saw, however, if it required some fitting, it is still practical so long as the fitting is as efficient as other alternatives. Rarely is power cut stuff right the first time either. It can be set up to do repeats, but one-off work is rarely of that type. This is why we have biscuits and dominos, the power tools suck at this also
"Now the question: For someone that builds a piece or two of furniture a year that requires M&T joints, is it reasonable to expect that this person can reliably saw a M&T joint?"
At the low end of that, no. If they are five years in the craft and have never practised a lick, and have only made several small pieces, ten total. But I am not expecting that much from them no mater how you slice it. If they did ten highboys, or guitars and really worked at it, why not. Can you learn to play the guitar in five years?
"Yet, when I start a new piece, after maybe several months of not sawing dovetails, some of the first few pins are not up to the accuracy required for a strong M&T joint."
I think this can be relieved a lot by simply doing some practice cutting, even just a half dozen kerfs, first.
I also think this analysis fails because it seems to imply there is dovetail sawing, and tenon sawing. Not really. Sure you can learn on only one thing, and only be good at that. But then you don't know how to saw. When you know how to saw, it is all pretty much the same, so you should be able to do the tenons also. I remember watching Norm do some hand sawing. Normally his hand work was terribly amateur, but when it came to sawing, he looked like a pro. When he started hand saws were still in use on the jobsites I know. So maybe hacking away a 2X with a hand saw made him a good sawyer, in general, worked for me.
Now do people want to learn to saw? Judging by the tool catalogs they seem to want to. And to boot, a few newbies went successfully into making saws, the filing of which is very much like hand sawing, and some of these guys had very low hours in the air, and turned out great products
"The task of learning and maintaining the skill to hand saw tenons seems too daunting to attempt. Many seem to have come to the same conclusion for I know of no one that routinely saws this joint. If driven to, they expect to adjust thickness after sawing to get the perfect fit."
Got me there. I routinely saw some, but on furniture, a small piece often after counting reveals say, 36 M&Ts. I reach for the fastest method I can find.
"I am skeptical that hand sawing a M&T joint is practical for the typical furniture builder. Agree, disagree, whatever?"
"Practical" as usual just means you don't think so, which is why I knew you weren't a bowhunter, and in particular a stickbow guy. The sale of bows would indicate otherwise, and in this case maybe the sale of saws. Better get practising, because if DTs are anything to go by... I was a hero in the 90s, and now my DT skills are just run of the mill. I'm probably better than I was... Get sawing or prepare for the ashcan of woodworking credibility. I'm OK with the ashcan, but I know it is coming.