New WoodChat!
Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

Sawing a perfect tenon

Posts

Sawing a perfect tenon

#1

Sawing a perfect tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

I designed this guide about 4 or 5 years ago and offered it to Lee Valley, who looked into producing it. In the end, however, LV decided that they could not find a way to manufacture it cheaply enough as a commercial proposition. So finally I now have the design back and I am passing to the public to build for private use. I just hate to see a great design not get used.


Link: http://www.inthewoodshop.com/ShopMadeTools/TenonGuide.html

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#2

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

Lars Parrington

Nice idea. A couple questions:

1. Do you find that your saws become magnetized after using them with this jig? If so, do you find that to be an issue at all. Mainly, I'm imagining it might make saw filing more difficult.

2. Do you find the bottom edge of the fence gets abraded by the set of the saw? I'm talking about the same edge that you line up with your knife lines when cutting the cheeks.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#3

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon *LINK*

Peter Evans

Nice one Derek. another application is to cut the slot in a saw handle (and to start the back mortise), and I was putting a jig togther for that purpose that mirrors your concept (the inspiration was the horizontal saw blade jig made vertical). Then I joined the NSW Woodworkers who were giving away the remaining stock of the AngleMag with a membership subscription. That works well, so I did not make the jig. Details on the AngleMag (no longer commercially available unfortunately) in the link below.

However your jig is superior for the specific purpose, so I think one needs to go on the list.

Cheers


http://www.toolsforworkingwood.com/store/more/anglemag1.html

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#4

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

1. Do you find that your saws become magnetized after using them with this jig? If so, do you find that to be an issue at all. Mainly, I'm imagining it might make saw filing more difficult.

2. Do you find the bottom edge of the fence gets abraded by the set of the saw? I'm talking about the same edge that you line up with your knife lines when cutting the cheeks.

Hi Lars

I have not found any of my saws becoming magnetized. I have a few other guides with magnets, such as for sliding dovetails and dados. Collectively, these have had minimal to none influence.

The bottom of the fence has a few scratches where the set marked the fence. I have not used the guide that much to know how much wear this would cause. I doubt that it would be much since the set is tiny, and it is restricted to this section once only (think of how a shooting board is run in).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#5

Jack Guzman from Maine

Article

Jack Guzman from Maine

Derek,

Is your jig being submitted as a Woodcentral article? If not already I would heartily recommend it is.I'm not in a position at the moment to build one but I would like to in the future.Here it would be easier to find. Is this doable? Thanks for sharing this.---Jack

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#7

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

JDK

Derek...

I must say I'm a bit "conflicted" about your jig. On the one hand, it will reduce the risk of cutting tenons that are out of alignment, but on the other hand, it will prevent someone from learning how to cut tenons the old-fashioned way, using the eye-and-hand coordination acquired only via practice.

I'm afraid I'm one of those who believes a few poorly cut tenons is a reasonable price to pay for mastering a technique that once learned is never lost.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#8

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

Hi David

I am not advocating that one use this guide rather than learn hand skills. If you know me then you will be aware of how highly I value hand skills.

The mortice-and-tenon joint is used in all furniture. It may be the most frequently used joint. It is also a deceptively difficult joint to make, and has consequently spawned a range of alternatives: biscuits, dowels, pocket holes, loose tenons, and domino.

This guide is intended for those that, for whatever reason - physical or confidence - cannot control a handsaw, or who want some help in learning to do so. I do believe that hand memory can be developed using a jig such as this since it replicates the hand movements involved.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#9

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

JDK

Fair enough, Derek. I am well aware of how highly you value hand tools and their mastery, and I did not mean to imply otherwise.

As you know, learning to cut a tenon (and mortise) by hand is very rewarding, and except in cases of illness (I'll dissent from your other caveat, "confidence"), I urge aspiring hand-tool users to use simple trial-and-error to gain this fundamental skill.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#10

Stuff comes around

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

This is an interesting variation of a jig I saw in an early 20th century Popular Mechanics "Shopnotes." That one was designed for use with a regular handsaw, though, and didn't have magnets, but rather a slot to guide the saw.

That issue of "Shopnotes" is currently boxed up, waiting for the current remodel to get done, so we'll have the bookshelves in that room back; so I can't show it.

Rediscovery/reinvention isn't a bad thing, though; Derek's iteration is a good use of current technology to make a nifty jig.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#11

Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Background to the question:

I agree that this is an essential joint to master for furniture building by what ever means it is executed.

This joint is also most demanding for accuracy and strength. The joint is typically used where maximum strength is required. A dovetailed box will have several individual joining surfaces. If one, or even a few, are not perfect the rest will take up the load. But in the case of the M&T joint there is no redundancy to compensate for lack of accuracy of the fit.

A loose fit degrades the joint strength. Any glue formulated with water will be poor at gap filling and that includes hide glue. When the water goes away holes remain and the glue becomes a foam rather than a coherent tough film.

For various reasons I have measured tenons I have made and concluded that the tolerance for a good joint is one where the tenon is in the range of 0 to 0.005" thinner than the mortise. One may quibble with this exact number but the conclusion is that the difference between a joint that is difficult/impossible to assemble and one that is too loose is a small number of inches, something on the order of a scribe line width or less.

Hence, the challenge of sawing a mortise is to make two saw cuts with sufficient accuracy to yield a tenon that is accurate to some small number of inches ( about 0.005"). And, if you are going to claim that hand sawing is practical this tolerance needs to be achieved without post adjusting of the thickness by plane or chisel.

Now the question: For someone that builds a piece or two of furniture a year that requires M&T joints, is it reasonable to expect that this person can reliably saw a M&T joint?

On a personal note, I do saw dovetails, typically about twice a year for furniture pieces. And a chest of drawers involves a lot of dovetail sawing. So, I do get a lot of practice over a short period of time, with months of gaps in between the need. Yet, when I start a new piece, after maybe several months of not sawing dovetails, some of the first few pins are not up to the accuracy required for a strong M&T joint. Nor do they need to be for this redundantly locked joint. Hence, hand sawing dovetails remains practical for me.

The task of learning and maintaining the skill to hand saw tenons seems too daunting to attempt. Many seem to have come to the same conclusion for I know of no one that routinely saws this joint. If driven to, they expect to adjust thickness after sawing to get the perfect fit.

I am skeptical that hand sawing a M&T joint is practical for the typical furniture builder. Agree, disagree, whatever?

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#12

Re: Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Patrick Gibbon

Why is adjustment with a chisel a negative to hand sawing? I hand saw every one of my M&T joints. If it needs adjustment, no big deal. If I overadjust than there's always cyanoacrylate glue to attach a piece and re saw. Not proud of that but once the joint is together no one will ever know by looking at it. How is a powered alternative any more accurate?

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#13

Pussyfooting

Warren in Lancaster, PA

Sometime around 1979 I decided to stop pussyfooting around and saw right to the line for making tenons. When you take responsibility for getting it right the first time your sawing can improve quickly.

If a fellow is always looking for an excuse to avoid sawing by hand, then it is hard to develop these skills. But if one saws fretwork and scrollwork and does ripping and crosscutting and joinery all by hand, these skills build on each other.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#14

clarifying my posting objective

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Derek posted an aid to hand sawing a tenon. The anonymous JDK dismissed this aid and in turn advocated that one should just learn to saw them without such an aid. I do not question that JDK's advice is sound for the woodworker that is challenged, and primarily motivated, to learn hand tool skills. Making a place to store socks is not as important to these woodworkers. In contrast, the universe of woodworkers I am considering are those whose primary motivation is to build stuff. What are reasonable expectations for these people?

Given the strength and accuracy demands of the typical M&T joint I questioned whether hand sawing was a proficiency that could be readily learned and maintained by the average person building a piece or two of furniture a year. If not, it does not serve these woodworkers to encourage them to spend time on a fruitless skill building journey. I recognize that the primary motivation of some is to learn a skill and that practically applying that skill is secondary. These people may be more willing to devote time to perfecting a skill than others.

You post supports the position that many(most?) should have a more reliable "go-to" way of accurately making this joint, or expect to need to adjust hand sawed joints.

I am occasionally driven to hand saw a tenon. And somethings I am pleasantly surprised at my result. But, I expect to fiddle with it some afterwards. BTW, cyanoacrylate adhesive is not permanent. Use something else.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#15

Well said

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Its all about acquiring and then maintaining proficiency through either practice or use. Some have more tolerance for practice than others. I recently finished cutting a bunch of dovetail joints. Some of the first few pins were a bit too loose or a bit too tight, but fortunately for this redundant joint it doesn't matter. Toward the end they all were just right. In 6 months when I need to do it again, I will repeat the experience- too tight, too loose, eventually just right. I have my expectations understood and can live with them.

That said, if one is going to advocate free hand sawing tenons, it is well to clarify expectations for what is involved in learning and maintaining the ability.

Sawing tenons was part of a Will Neptune class I took. We were expected to need to do adjustments at this stage of our experience. It was comforting to know that fact.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#16

Re: Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Sgian Dubh

"I am skeptical that hand sawing a M&T joint is practical for the typical furniture builder. Agree, disagree, whatever?"

I both agree, and disagree. But my answer depends upon the definition of "typical furniture builder". I think that if your typical type falls into the category you place yourself, then I tend to agree, although there will be people within that category who can execute a hand cut M&T first time pretty much every time - they will have probably spent a fair amount of time honing the skill, so going back to the task after a significant absence isn't really an impediment.

I fall into a different category of "typical furniture builder", i.e., a trained professional of, if you like, the old school, i.e., trained in the 70s towards the end of the time when furniture makers were routinely introduced to the basic hand skills, supplemented by machine woodworking training. Nowadays it's not uncommon to see trainees in the field focus primarily on machine woodworking such as chop saws, nail guns, five siders, AutoCAD, AlphaCam, CNC, etc, and to rarely touch a hand saw or hand plane. In any case, I'll go extended periods without needing to execute hand cut joints, but faced with a one-off M&T I'll frequently choose, because it's often quicker, to simply mark it out and cut it with hand tools rather than set up machines to do the job. I also expect to get it right first time.

In my case I think that old training embedded the technique so thoroughly that it usually just switches on in an instant when required. I can certainly understand that for others the ability to sort of zone in on exactly what needs to be done may be more difficult, or perhaps even impossible without some refreshing practice. Incidentally, I see advantages in Derek's jig for those that find the task challenging. Slainte.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#17

Re: Well said

Patrick Gibbon

Bill, I still don't understand your reasoning. Sawing this joint, even with mistakes, is easily done with a hand saw. A power tool is going to have the same opportunity to miss the mark. If one wants, a joint can be pinned or wedged to insure a stronger mechanical fit. Despite my lack of skill, I have yet to have a M&T joint fail. Maybe in another 20 or 30 years. I'll be gone by then and my furniture will be in a second hand store or a landfill. (I hope not) I guess if this basic joint is that tough to execute right I need to shop at IKEA more.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#18

Re: Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

For what it is worth, my personal preference is to just lay out the lines and saw to them. By eye and hand, no jigs. But that is me, and perhaps that is you, however there are many, many woodworkers who are totally intimidated by the thought of making this joint this way. Hell, I recall a time when I was as well. As Bill argues, it takes a special kind of motivation to overcome this fear. And as Warren notes, a go-for-it attitude helps in this regard. I'd like to believe that I am that way. And all this only counts if you have the coordination to go with the attitude.

The irony is that I have been critical about magazine articles that demonstrate cutting dovetails away from the line, and then paring to it. I argue that this safety-first approach can introduce more errors than it attempts to prevent. What I - we here - ignore is that there are many would-be go-for-it woodworkers who benefit from first getting their toes wet. I have received many emails from forum readers thanking me for the post (here and on a couple of other forums). It is evident that there are many who want to use it.

Those that do not need it, do not see the value of it. Those that need it, do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#19

Re: Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Lars Parrington

"... And, if you are going to claim that hand sawing is practical this tolerance needs to be achieved without post adjusting of the thickness by plane or chisel.

Now the question: For someone that builds a piece or two of furniture a year that requires M&T joints, is it reasonable to expect that this person can reliably saw a M&T joint?"

If you're only making one or two pieces a year, that's not very many M&T joints. So, why is it impractical to have to adjust some of them?

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#20

Re: Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?

Curt Putnam

I agree. Having only learned to handsaw well enough to even attempt a dovetail in the last couple years (long story) I find that I am not one of those "stars" who can "just do it" without considerable warmup/practise. The analogy I would use is shooting baskets. Don't do it for a year and most guys need some time to get their groove back. A few pro caliber guys can just grab the ball and get nothing but net. Some guys can't do it no matter hard they try. We all have different gifts

Most weekend warriors will benefit from the use of a jig. The real question should be: Why is there the sense of cheating when one uses a jig? I submit it is a bit of real men don't ... and the fact that we are all exposed to those who just grab any old saw, walk up to a board and split the lines. We feel diminished. Well, compared to them, we weekend warriors are diminished. Get over it. Use the jig or keep gluing shims on.

There is also the question of the balance between productivity and skill building. I choose to acquire the basic hand tool skills but I have to balance the time against actually getting things built. This is especially so for those of who have to race against the ravages of time and bodily degradation.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#21

What is missing...

John in NM

Power tool setups can be more accurate and repeatable. They are not automatically, but they can be set up to be so with some forethought.

The advantage I see to hand sawing everything one can is the speed and flexibility that a practiced eye and confident hand gives you.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#22

Re: clarifying my posting objective

JDK

The anonymous JDK

David Katz here (note the email address), from Long Island, NY. Longtime WoodCentral member, and amateur woodworker for 30 years.

Given the strength and accuracy demands of the typical M&T joint I questioned whether hand sawing was a proficiency that could be readily learned and maintained by the average person building a piece or two of furniture a year

We're in the Hand Tools forum here, and Derek wrote a post about his device to assist a (presumably) novice woodworker in using a saw to cut a tenon. I assume that someone building only a piece or two of furniture a year would be far better off using a table saw and a tenon jig to cut tenons. My point was that if a person wants to cut tenons by hand, he should acquire the skill via trial and error rather than use Derek's device.

...it does not serve these woodworkers to encourage them to spend time on a fruitless skill building journey

I agree. They should use a table saw (or band saw) and a tenon jig, as i wrote above.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#23

Quantitative note on breaking strength

Wiley Horne--So. Calif.

Hi Bill and all,

I wouldn't argue for a second about your 5 thousandths tolerance for an excellent M&T joint. However, I have always been struck by some actual data, published here:

http://www.oldbrownglue.com/images/articles/HowStrongisYourGlue_FWW.pdf

In breaking tests done at Case Western U., different glues were tested against different woods, and the tightness of the fit was also varied, from 'loose' to 'snug' to 'tight'. Loose was 1/64" play (15-16 thousandths); snug was hand-pressure join; tight was light hammering together.

Data are shown in the article. Many different combinations of wood, glue, and tightness, but in most cases (excepting epoxy and polyurethane glues), the loose joint was within 10% of the strength of the snug joint.

Just for info....

Wiley

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#24

This data is simalar to some other

Bill Tindall, E.Tn.

Reference: Hill and Eckelman, Furniture Design and Manufacturing, December 1973. In this case M&T joints were tested.

They found a progressive loss in strength as the joint got looser (range of data was 0 to 0.008". They similarly found that the hide glues were the least strong in this joint. Joints with hide glue had 80% the strength of PVA.

Indeed in the FWW data for oak and maple we see a substantial loss of strength for the loose joint. If I could become satisfied with 1/64" gap I would become a hand sawed tenon convert for I think I can saw at least this well.

I don't understand the IPE data from several perspectives. It seems inconsistent. I was unsuccessful gluing the piece of IPE I have with PVA glue. If you can glue it into a Kronov style plane it is wickedly stable and abrasion resistant.

The biggest bang for the buck is tenon length. There is roughly a linear increase in strength with tenon length. In the range that we normally make them another 1/4" of tenon length will largely compensate for a loose joint.

Re: Sawing a perfect tenon

#25

Might just as well use the tablesaw.

Kees

Let me first day that this is strictly my personal opinion, and I understand that other people have different views about their woodworking.

With that said, what is the advantage of using a handsaw when you are going to jig it? You might just as well use the table saw with a tenoning jig. To make Dereks jig I guess most woodworkers would have to use a tablesaw anyway, because they seem to lack some handsawing skills. You could save yourself some time and money if you forgo the use of a handsaw to make tenons alltogether.

I see people often describing their use of powertools to take the donkey work out of wood preparation and then they start using their handtools in the more enjoyable part of the job, the joinery. That's how I work often too. It is very liberating to leave the jigged world of the powertools behind. Using jigs to guide your saws and chisels is kind of a step back again, as far as I am concerned.

About the strength of the M&T joint, there is also the concept of strong enough. Antiques in the 17th century often had pretty sloppy standards in this regard. And to give a modern example. Overhere the official norm for M&T joints in window and door making is max 1 mm play, and the joint has to be glued with a D3 or D4 glue. That's very sloppy compared to your example, Bill!