Tenon sawing question- Is it practical?
Bill Tindall, E.Tn.
Background to the question:
I agree that this is an essential joint to master for furniture building by what ever means it is executed.
This joint is also most demanding for accuracy and strength. The joint is typically used where maximum strength is required. A dovetailed box will have several individual joining surfaces. If one, or even a few, are not perfect the rest will take up the load. But in the case of the M&T joint there is no redundancy to compensate for lack of accuracy of the fit.
A loose fit degrades the joint strength. Any glue formulated with water will be poor at gap filling and that includes hide glue. When the water goes away holes remain and the glue becomes a foam rather than a coherent tough film.
For various reasons I have measured tenons I have made and concluded that the tolerance for a good joint is one where the tenon is in the range of 0 to 0.005" thinner than the mortise. One may quibble with this exact number but the conclusion is that the difference between a joint that is difficult/impossible to assemble and one that is too loose is a small number of inches, something on the order of a scribe line width or less.
Hence, the challenge of sawing a mortise is to make two saw cuts with sufficient accuracy to yield a tenon that is accurate to some small number of inches ( about 0.005"). And, if you are going to claim that hand sawing is practical this tolerance needs to be achieved without post adjusting of the thickness by plane or chisel.
Now the question: For someone that builds a piece or two of furniture a year that requires M&T joints, is it reasonable to expect that this person can reliably saw a M&T joint?
On a personal note, I do saw dovetails, typically about twice a year for furniture pieces. And a chest of drawers involves a lot of dovetail sawing. So, I do get a lot of practice over a short period of time, with months of gaps in between the need. Yet, when I start a new piece, after maybe several months of not sawing dovetails, some of the first few pins are not up to the accuracy required for a strong M&T joint. Nor do they need to be for this redundantly locked joint. Hence, hand sawing dovetails remains practical for me.
The task of learning and maintaining the skill to hand saw tenons seems too daunting to attempt. Many seem to have come to the same conclusion for I know of no one that routinely saws this joint. If driven to, they expect to adjust thickness after sawing to get the perfect fit.
I am skeptical that hand sawing a M&T joint is practical for the typical furniture builder. Agree, disagree, whatever?