We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
So this morning I was surfing the blogs when I was implored,no make that begged,if I had never tried the notched batten,to stop what I was doing turn off the laptop,go to the shop and try it. So I did,and it worked good,much better than I thought it would. When I had first come across a Nicholson bench I questioned how it would be used. I now understand how the benches without vices, just holes for the holdfast ,crochet and associated appliances can be useful.
I am disseminating information gleaned from his blog, His further immersion into the writings of Roubo has brought to light the appliances that are of use on workbenches sans the screw vice. One very interesting tidbit of note is that the French translation for the notched batten is doe's foot.
The point is made that one leg of the notch serves to act as a lever preventing movement. What I am curious to know - since I have not tried this out, and no one has mentioned it ... neither Richard not Chris Schwarz - is what happens when the end of the board is not 90 degrees? Does the notched batten still work?
The exact angle doesn't matter whether it's the notch's or the workpiece's. No need for a perfect fit in the notch for the method to work. The critical thing that two sides/edges are somewhat cradled.
All that is required is that one of the edges register firmly and completely in the notch, just like it would on a wide planing stop.
A single point of support in the other direction is nearly as effective as having the entire opposite side of the notch support it provided that single point is as far away from the apex as possible.
This is based on my own experience with metal fabrication involving hold downs and plattens. The forces involved there were several orders of magnitude more than any WWing process I`ve encountered and involved both deformation/reconfiguation of the material by hydraulic pressure as well as impact (sledge hammers applied to hot steel, aluminum and bronze)
In this case, less truly is more (better).
BTW- Making the notched piece out of plywood scrap and relieving the stress riser at the apex by cutting the angle into a drilled hole there will help keep it from splitting like a solid wood piece will when heavy forces (especially those involving sudden impact) are applied